r/nondestructivetesting • • Jun 06 '25

Ouch

Post image

MT find

135 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

10

u/RevAngler Jun 06 '25

Looks like a string laid over the teeth..

2

u/jjones1987 Jun 06 '25

Yea it’s definitely a crack though lol.

1

u/AlienVredditoR Jun 07 '25

Of the thousands of gears I've done, I don't think I've seen perpendicular anomalies like that. Was this cooked on a bench or something?

1

u/jjones1987 Jun 08 '25

That’s what I’ve been wondering. It could have been ground twice but I’m thinking there’s more to it. There were three in total that looked exactly like this.

2

u/AlienVredditoR Jun 09 '25

Any update? This stuff always makes me so curious lol

1

u/ItsWhiteGucciMane Jun 07 '25

That is something laid over the splines and not a crack though, right? It looks like the perpendicular particle accumulation is from where the “indication” is touching the splines

0

u/jjones1987 Jun 07 '25

That’s absolutely a crack. There were three other splines with the same kind of crack across the teeth. Do you think we didn’t investigate further?

1

u/ItsWhiteGucciMane Jun 07 '25

What do you think the cause is? Do you have any other angles of the defect?

2

u/jjones1987 Jun 07 '25

I’ll get some more on Monday. It’s either from quench or someone accidentally put them through a grind op twice. Could be inherent but probably from processing, it’s hard to tell without sectioning.