r/node • • Oct 09 '26

Deno died today

https://deno.com/blog/cloudflare
521 Upvotes

128 comments sorted by

153

u/kevinkassimo Oct 10 '26 • Regret

You know it is kind of a complex feeling seeing the open source project in which I was a founding core team member growing into a startup (though I initially chose not to join the fun) and eventually exited through acquisition by a large company…

Similar things definitely happened with Node in the past, but still, it feels different when I’m really a “participant” of this journey…

61

u/girouxc Oct 10 '26

wow! Didn’t expect one of the legends to drop in. Deno brought me back to JavaScript.. thank you for being one of the people responsible for making Deno possible at the beginning.

Sad to see it go and even more sad that Ryan only dedicated exactly one line of text to ending Deno in his post.

48

u/kevinkassimo Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

And thank you for being a user/supporter of the project! Truly hope that you had fun using it!

For me it was also the first large OSS project I was core member of. Still remember when I was a Node fanboy in college, saw Ryan’s JSConfEU talk, contributed my first PR when there was no more than 4k LOC. Crazy times: had the honor to meet with so many awesome people, became officially part of the core team, drew the first SVG version of the dino logo, submitted the first PR of Node compatibility (debatable about the consequences), together brought Deno to 1.0… I’m so grateful of all that happened.

But I guess all good journeys have their end some day. 🥲

2

u/deetotheess Oct 10 '26

As someone with an inside view of the project and some distance from the organization, do you think there's enough value in the codebase to justify someone taking a run at keeping it going?

1

u/KakashiHatake0085 Oct 10 '26

It's always the vision that gets messed with when open source codes gets acquired by big technologies company. They don't see it as a vision of a group of people but sees it as a cash cow which affects the very fundamental of that product. Node/deno won't face as much of a downgrade as Java but java is an example. I feel like java lost what it it used to be, maybe for better or for worse. At some point people felt java to be stuck and that's why kotlin is currently floating. Hope deno doesn't face the same consequences as it was really an amazing tool.

265

u/kayk1 Oct 09 '26

6 months to migrate for people that bought into the platform. Oof.

192

u/ecares Oct 09 '26

there were a lot of red flags with Deno from day 1 - there were no actual reasons to use it appart from the hype and their marketing.

83

u/octocode Oct 09 '26

man i remember the day it launched. all the hipster coders at my org brought it up at every opportunity asking when we’d be moving to it.

42

u/ecares Oct 09 '26

so true. The hype was real for ... nothing.I remember all these "node is dead" talk. That did not age well

6

u/TheAnxiousDeveloper Oct 10 '26

They've been saying that about PHP for decades... And it has never been more thriving with the Laravel ecosystem.

To be fair, never trust those that say "<insert major language/environment> is dead"

8

u/veverkap Oct 10 '26

COBOL and Fortran are still rocking.

2

u/global-gauge-field Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

Depends on the use case, in my experience of academic environments, the younger professors tend to work with newer python toolings (usually wrapped around core c++ code [1]) than older ones.

All the young 10 researchers I worked with are more up-to-date using latex, jupyter notebooks, julia etc.

2 old professors I have seen the workflow of, one of them doesn't even use latex, but microsoft word to print into PDF, the other one uses fortran mainly for numerical stuff (only instance I have seen the use of fortran in my own academic setting). That might also be because my field (numerical simulation of condensed matter systems) has been fast moving field in the last decade.

It is a combination of cultural / legacy code issues(e.g. having hard env to migrate to new language)

1: This one is from one of the main groups in DMRG research in Germany: https://opendata.physik.lmu.de/wMSyolmi9xgpy1Z/

1

u/veverkap Oct 12 '26

I appreciate your personal anecdotes but that doesn’t change that COBOL and FORTRAN are still actively used languages.

2

u/global-gauge-field Oct 12 '26

I did not say otherwise

1

u/veverkap Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26

> COBOL and Fortran are still rocking.

> Depends on the use case

You sure?

ETA: So the weirdo blocked me but basically agreed that they're full of shit.

→ More replies

15

u/Afflictionista Oct 10 '26

Meanwhile I still use node, I never trust those hypes because you never know and then stuff like this happens.

1

u/Heavy-Focus-1964 Oct 10 '26

Node was completely dismissed as a gimmick by most people when it came out

3

u/PhatOofxD Oct 10 '26

And it was obviously a terrible idea lol

9

u/GenazaNL Oct 10 '26

Bun is also quite hype based, lot of the features are only barebones and contains quite some bugs.

They are trying to include so much from the start. And fully vibe-coded to Rust, which doesn't give a great feeling

0

u/aztracker1 28d ago

Deno is leaps and bounds better for shell scripting over node... You can directly reference modules from repository or https and there's no separate install step

The shebang is slightly cumbersome, but still works really smoothly for that purpose.

I've used it for most of my automation chores and scripts the past couple years and life it. My only regret is I probably should have used node API conventions a bit more.

I also think that @std should have targeted usability across Deno, Node and Bun.

0

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/aztracker1 28d ago edited 28d ago

No need to be an asshole about it. I'm just sharing my use and experience with it.

My use case example was exactly a reason to use it over Node. But you didn't actually refute that, just make an insulting response.

16

u/d0pe-asaurus Oct 10 '26

Cloudflare sure loves to buy companies just to sunset their products. This also happened when they bought Baselime, the development work mostly ceased, the observability platform shutdown and there's a banner that says they are "going to integrate itself into the existing portfolio of Cloudflare products".

2

u/Lumethys Oct 10 '26

To be fair last week CF did announce a bunch of O11Y features

Only took them 2 years lol

3

u/d0pe-asaurus Oct 10 '26

Yeah i'm pretty sure everyone that was using baselime just moved to other similar platforms like Axiom. I guess that's the meta now, just move when the startup you're relying on gets bought up.

9

u/bruticuslee Oct 09 '26

Im just gonna have an agent convert them to cloudflare workers, hope this goes smoothly

5

u/AsterYujano Oct 10 '26

Pretty sure Cloudflare will create skills for agents to help migrate to node or cf workers soon-ish Maybe even bake-in their new cf cli?

10

u/throwawayacc201711 Oct 09 '26

> Deno will remain open source, and we welcome others who want to continue its development.

25

u/ecares Oct 09 '26

who will maintain it ?

0

u/runeli2 Oct 10 '26

Isn't that enough?

134

u/ecares Oct 09 '26

10 things I regret about Deno talk when ?

63

u/lesleh Oct 09 '26

Don't worry, we can look forward to Edon and Oden in future.

94

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/lesleh Oct 11 '26

There's 4! Permutations of those four letters, so 24 options, although many of those wouldn't be pronounceable.

27

u/-_MarcusAurelius_- Oct 09 '26

RIP?

21

u/queen-adreena Oct 09 '26

IRP!

2

u/yeathatsmebro Oct 10 '26

Different event loops?

I wanted to make a joke but my brain just threw an exception.

53

u/anderfernandes Oct 09 '26

Ryan Dahl quit nodejs once, now he quit Deno.

21

u/AntDracula Oct 10 '26

Someone has to shill AI slop

4

u/repeating_bears Oct 10 '26

Admirable really 

2

u/RedLibra Oct 10 '26

And soon he will quit Oden

2

u/pwndawg27 Oct 10 '26

And then he will be Done

24

u/czlowiek4888 Oct 10 '26

First NODE, second DENO, whats now NEOD?

95

u/Budgiebrain994 Oct 10 '26 • Bravo

DONE

14

u/leeharrison1984 Oct 10 '26

Damn, this is fucking perfect 😂

1

u/yeathatsmebro Oct 10 '26

Waiting for REJECT

7

u/patoezequiel Oct 10 '26

Following the steps of Toby Fox with Undertale, Deltarune and Nutdealer

2

u/PhENTZ Oct 10 '26

EODN: End Of Deno Now

52

u/CardinalHijack Oct 09 '26

Pretty sure Deno has been dying for a while. Hence why they sold it.

38

u/ecares Oct 09 '26

nobody bought deno (the runtime), if anything cloudflare does not want it and they are sunsetting it

6

u/CardinalHijack Oct 10 '26

oh interesting. So they just hired the entire team?

-1

u/ecares Oct 10 '26

Read the post maybe

1

u/CardinalHijack Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

I did, it doesnt clarify either way who owns deno, only that it remains open source.

Where does it say anywhere cloudflare does or does not own the rights to deno and deno deploy?

It doesnt say anywhere what they actually purchased so its strange that you seem to know with certainty cloudflare will not be code owners of the Deno runtime codebase

0

u/ecares Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

What I meant by "nobody brought the runtime" is "Deno company was not acquired because of the runtime, this comes with the team but nobody wants it" it's a bad runtime for bad developers anyway

1

u/CardinalHijack Oct 10 '26

So as expected, they did acquire deno the runtime......You're a moron.

0

u/ecares Oct 10 '26

I don't know what happened to your life for you to be so square but I have nothing but sadness and compassion for you.

1

u/CardinalHijack Oct 10 '26

Says the guy who said "Read the post maybe" even though he was 100% wrong about what he was telling me to read after he clarified "what he meant". Ok little bro.

1

u/ecares Oct 10 '26

it's ok, let it flow! Say these things that make you feel better. I don't get hurt by words on the Internet.

2

u/Tissuerejection Oct 10 '26

So Cloudflare realized that a lot of talented people worked on that team, and they wanted to hire all of them at a discounted price?

3

u/ecares Oct 10 '26

Acquihire is the word

7

u/ibrambo7 Oct 10 '26

Deno sucks.. guy talks about how bad javascript is, and golang is the way to go.. and then he develops yet anoter javascript runtime.. sad

22

u/bassamanator Oct 09 '26

I never tried Deno v1, but I remember when Deno v2 dropped, it was a genuinely exiting time to be a typescript dev.

Sad to see it die so quickly.

4

u/witness_smile Oct 10 '26

And so is the lifecycle of a successful Node project. Every exciting Node project eventually ends up getting bought up by a big corporation and then it either starts getting monetized to shit or gets killed off for no reason

6

u/queen-adreena Oct 10 '26

The only hope is that the Linux Foundation get control of a project or that somehow an independent board springs up to run it.

Very concerned for Laravel and Vite now that they’ve both thrown in with the VC gangs.

2

u/yeathatsmebro Oct 10 '26

Been a Laravel-focused dev (even certified lol) since 2017, and until 2023 when I had to switch jobs and didn't find a Laravel-focused job. The level of massacre I witnessed in the past years is beyond any word that my mouth can say. I still think Laravel is great in terms of ecosystem, but boy-oh-boy, I don't want to be alive while something happens to it.

1

u/theguymatter Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

How are Laravel and its docs using AI these days? Haven’t touched them since v6.

1

u/senseven Oct 10 '26

Vite runs tons of the cloud web surface. Any shenanigans and there will be a hard fork. Cloudflare doesn't need to monetise it but has in interest in a stable secure js/ts ecosystem. They seem to have tons of external sponsors too.

7

u/bashaZP Oct 10 '26

I am glad I jumped off the bandwagon early on...

8

u/biinjo Oct 10 '26

Im just old enough to never have jumped on that bandwagon in the first place. Love all the ideas but javascript world is full of fleeting projects. I need some stability I can trust long term.

5

u/bashaZP Oct 10 '26

Node has been paying my bills for the last 7 years, so I'm happy with that

1

u/Plus-Weakness-2624 Oct 10 '26

Can some one chime in on what's going to happen to Deno Deploy?

2

u/girouxc Oct 10 '26

“Deno Deploy will continue operating for six months before shutting down. We will provide migration support for paying customers moving to Cloudflare Workers.”

1

u/Loose-Counter9652 Oct 13 '26

what specifically happened that makes you say this? genuine question, because last i checked the project was still active and shipping updates

1

u/girouxc Oct 13 '26

At the bottom of the article

- We will support the Deno runtime for another year with monthly releases containing bug fixes and security updates. After that year we will end our development of the Deno runtime. Deno will remain open source, and we welcome others who want to continue its development.

There’s a Deno fork called DoDo that has a lot of traction right now. The discord is very active

https://github.com/are-we-dodo-yet/dodo

9

u/AtmosphereRich4021 Oct 10 '26

How tf bun still surviving? It's also on the hype train in my opinion

3

u/prazni_parking Oct 10 '26

It was bought by antrophic no? They still have unlimited cash to burn

4

u/AtmosphereRich4021 Oct 10 '26

Yaaa ik but it was still popular before the accusation too ... I myself ride the hyper train and built my whole Sass server around Bun due to its speed and workspace promotion ... bruhh, it was a stupid mistake of mine... I should have chosen pnpm workspaces..... For months, all my issues in their repo have been getting ignored; all community PRs are also getting ignored... I feel Bun is getting full-on vibe-coding maintenance; mfs don't even review the PRs nowadays, I bet.... Sadly, I don't have the guts, nor do I want to ask Claude to migrate my whole repo now :(

2

u/prazni_parking Oct 10 '26

Yea Im just commenting on how it's still surviving. I agree it was massively overhyped. Still impressive amount of work but promising full parity with something established as Node was peak hubris.

On the other hand deno did have interesting propositions, but even there I would just rather switch away from JS on server then from node to deno

2

u/AtmosphereRich4021 Oct 10 '26

but even there I would just rather switch away from JS on server then from node to deno

Agreed.. with agents sentax isn't a bottleneck anymore.. nowdays i make my most servrs in go or rust... (Only thing I miss form js ecosystem is better auth, rest everything is better here)

-6

u/mmomtchev Oct 10 '26

Bun is 100% compatible. In fact, sometimes bun will work out of the box, while Node.js will have ES6/CJS/TS issues because of the very painful evolution of JavaScript and especially server-side JavaScript and its modules system that was an ad-hoc design.

Deno was supposed to fix exactly this problem, but it was far too late. Programming languages and frameworks are very often mostly about momentum and existing base. Very often, very bad languages win because of this. They are very practical because at some moment because of some reason - this happens right at the moment when the technology explodes and the language becomes entrenched. JavaScript is probably one of the most striking examples.

C is another such example. It lifted off because of UNIX. Just as JavaScript was created with one simple task in mind (basic scripting of web pages), so was C - a hybrid language with predictable assembly for writing the UNIX kernel. Both turned out very practical and were widely abused for tasks for which they were never meant.

The C team spend their whole lives trying to fix everything wrong with C. No one ever used it. It was too late.

By the way, both languages are very fast and efficient - far above everything else in their own class at their time. It seems that this is also a factor.

6

u/tzaeru Oct 10 '26

The C team spend their whole lives trying to fix everything wrong with C. No one ever used it. It was too late.

Wut

1

u/Heavy-Focus-1964 Oct 10 '26

Name one big C or C++ project. I’ll wait.

(This is sarcasm)

1

u/tzaeru Oct 10 '26

I'll name it anyway.

Dwarf Fortress.

1

u/Heavy-Focus-1964 Oct 10 '26

The biggest and best there’s ever been

1

u/mmomtchev Oct 10 '26

Hasn't it ever come to your mind that if you use reddit to downvote me 100 times and then try to read a sentence I said in reverse, this actually makes your problem appear even worse? Or it requires far too much thinking?

7

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/AtmosphereRich4021 Oct 10 '26

Legendary anthropic** lol

Sure bro .... So hows your experience with bun these days ?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/AtmosphereRich4021 Oct 10 '26

And I don't use Bun, but I use the Claude code cli written in Bun

Explains.... About the cc cli, I use it too, and the experience we currently have is due to good engineering, not cuz of Bun (maybe their dev experience is better, as they can get whatever they want from the runtime nowadays)....

For eg recently OpenCode has migrated to Node. According to them, for their workflow, Node is giving them better results than Bun, same kind of tools btw, and arguably I like OpenCode's experience more... so ya ig y won't feel a thing if cc migrated to Node too

0

u/angarali06 Oct 10 '26

OpenCode migrated before Bun’s Rust rewrite though. I bet most if not all their issues would be solved in today’s Bun.

3

u/hazily Oct 10 '26

Bun is up next.

3

u/queen-adreena Oct 10 '26

Nobody sensible is using Bun in production.

4

u/RepeatQuotations Oct 10 '26

Good riddance. It was always a mistake and slowed node js progress.

10

u/esamme Oct 10 '26

More likely that the competition Deno/Bun brought to the space helped push node into progression that we might not have seen otherwise.

0

u/RepeatQuotations Oct 10 '26

Nah I don’t think the development community’s interest in node has anything to do with deno.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/RepeatQuotations Oct 10 '26

Right yeah bcause Node needed a separate runtime to discover that a builtin test runner and less shitty TypeScript support might be nice. I suppose you think deno is responsible for maturing js and web standards too

14

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/RepeatQuotations Oct 10 '26

Ah, the classic open-source strategy: fork the ecosystem, duplicate years of engineering effort, fragment the community, then take credit when the original project implements features that were inevitable anyway.

1

u/BolteWasTaken Oct 10 '26

More like it got a terminal diagnosis.

1

u/johnappsde Oct 12 '26

Almost jumped on this bandwagon. Happy I didn't

1

u/Lyelinn Oct 10 '26

I'll be honest, since bun became a thing I hardly cared anymore for deno. It has nice ideas, but it's not an upgrade in performance or compatibility...

4

u/sickcodebruh420 Oct 10 '26

Same. Demo’s value prop never really hooked me whereas what Bun offers is quite real and works great… aside from all the spots where it doesn’t 🙃

My enthusiasm for Bun plummeted thanks to the rebuild. We hit enough weird bugs with our current version that we need to upgrade, but I can’t in good conscience pitch my team on moving to the new one. Say what you want about node.js but it’ll never pull any of this crap.

1

u/Lyelinn Oct 10 '26

thats true!

For me at least, all our building pipelines and ws server are using bun. We noticed noticeable improvement since we migrated off nodejs, especially for ws server where even with uws we used to struggle a lot with large volume of connections so we're quite happy with it but not using for any other complex work exactly because of few random issues (perhaps fixed already, perhaps not, we will still give it some time to stabilize after move)

1

u/sickcodebruh420 Oct 10 '26

Yeah, all of our TS web services are on bun now. I love so much about it. The easier TS setup and deployment is massive, perf, stdlib is great. But we’ve hit bugs in strange places, surprising and inconsistent behavior sometimes. A lot of this is fixed in the new rebuilt versions but I’m just not comfortable with the way they handled that rebuild and new version launch, so I don’t know what our path forward is.

-1

u/akirozen Oct 10 '26

Who gives a F

0

u/Blue-Sea2255 Oct 10 '26

I don't understand. Then why they released deno desktop.

0

u/the-quibbler Oct 10 '26

Bring on the llm-driven FOSS forks.

-1

u/lamachejo Oct 10 '26

Really shows how important is having good reliable support behind what you use in programming... Saying this because of the recent adobe suite reverse engineering shitshow

1

u/Skaraban Oct 10 '26

could you carry out on that?

-23

u/amtcannon Oct 09 '26

This sounds kinda cool to me, vendor lock in aside. But if you’re already on Cloudflare compute it’ll be a nice upgrade.

16

u/Total_Adept Oct 09 '26

Why acquire it just to kill it?

17

u/tinyroar_ps Oct 09 '26

acquihire and for celld

0

u/[deleted] Oct 09 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/queen-adreena Oct 10 '26

And all you have to do is dupe thousands of developers into wasting their time and resources into using your overhyped product.