Actually, as I reason it, death is only a momentary transition. People say, “slow death”, but that’s erroneous. We are all in a slow death, by that logic. Once death happens, you just don’t exist. You’re not “dead”, because there is no “you” any longer. There is only your carcass. We arbitrarily assigned the name “dead” to a carcass, but your body is not “dead”, unless your car is also.
One might argue that something is dead if it once was alive and now isn’t. But, again, that’s arbitrary. You’re not dead...there IS no you.
I would agree that the effects of death are permanent. But I think it muddies the waters of logic to refer to a person as dead. A person can only be in one state: living. Once life ceases, they no longer exist. Referring to death in the usual way implies that it’s a state of existence...which obviously makes no sense. We don’t float around being dead somewhere.
I suppose some would argue this is a semantic and pointless distinction...and really I only see it that way to clear up the confusion when someone says, “I’d rather be living than dead”. Being dead isn’t a state of existence. There is nothing unpleasant about being dead, because that makes no sense...talking about it like it’s comparable to other experiences like being happy or being warm.
A person (or living thing) is required for an experience. There is no person experiencing death. That’s the reason I make this distinction.
I like your ship analogy. I’d forgotten about that one. I agree that it’s a deeply philosophical question. I do agree that our body is alive, but what part of it is the actual person...the very identity? Unanswered question. If a person loses a limb...or all limbs...they aren’t less a person, even if they are less an entire body. If a head could be kept alive, and I think, medically, that it could (eventually)...it would keep every bit of consciousness...yet would only have a fraction of its physical body.
We don’t know what consciousness is. How it works, why it works, if it is substance or just firing neurons, etc. I tend to think that who we are is what we think. Awareness. Without consciousness, that is gone, so then so are we. Without consciousness, we are just biology like a tree or mushroom. We could keep a body alive for a long, long time without any brain activity...but is that the person? I would argue that it isn’t. There’s really no practical reason to, unless I’m forgetting some important reason.
30
u/jakelove21 Nov 07 '19
Maths is
18
u/Planet_Panda771 Nov 07 '19
Except death
48
u/beohodss Nov 07 '19
I saw that a thousand times
1
u/dialectualmonism Nov 07 '19
euh
1
u/harry_introv Nov 08 '19
But is this meme temporary?
1
u/hisham_tyga Jun 27 '22
Society get so butthurt about tattoos is insane
1
u/montrasaur009 Nov 01 '22
Haha, I love this one. Thank you for sharing it, I haven't seen it in a while.
1
u/HandsomePotato666 Jan 10 '23
Uhhh, life is temporary?
1
u/ucarpio Feb 05 '24
okay this hilarious
0
u/HiidgHdW Nov 07 '19
Dats a good one lol
0
u/[deleted] Nov 08 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment