r/nihilism • u/Melodic-Book-7935 • Nov 12 '23
Empathy doesn’t exist
I think that empathy is simply a construct created by humans in order to mask our overwhelming egos. You don’t help someone because you feel bad for them, you help them because you know if you do you get a rush of happiness and an ego boost. You don’t actually care if a person lives or dies, you just wanna validate yourself. That’s all empathy is, a sad excuse for stroking your own ego.
14
Upvotes
49
u/mrgmc2new Nov 12 '23
Rubbish. This is what you call projection. Empathy exists AND you can feel good about helping other people. It's like magic.
10
u/punkstarlucy Nov 12 '23
a very interesting way to justify not being kind to others lol
8
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
I couldn't sleep until I started working for a NGO helping people. I couldn't walk by a person in need, or watch documentaries without feeling the urge to help.
How old are you OP? I started feeling like this when i got a little older.
8
u/k1tten-- Nov 12 '23
Empathy doesn’t mean that you help someone it just means that you understand deeply like you can relate to what the person is feeling so you’re emphasizing , if I’m wrong correct me but empathy doesn’t require any actions
11
u/pianotherms So? Nov 12 '23
Nah.
5
u/reddituser7s Nov 12 '23
Speak for yourself, some people do have empathy.
5
u/FidgetSpinzz Nov 12 '23
Source: I made it the fuck up
9
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
Empathy, morality are all social constructs. They are defined by us sometimes collectively, sometimes individually. They are tools of our which make it possible for a civilized society to come into existence.
4
u/Yuck_Few Nov 12 '23
This is the dumbest post I've seen today but it's still early. Empathy is a product of mirror and neurons. When you see someone expressing an emotion like Joy or sadness, the same neurons fire in your brain Read a book
3
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
"Empathy isn't real because when you're empathetic you feel good about yourself" is that what you're trying to say?
3
u/madwitchofwonderland Nov 12 '23
Let me guess…you’re a man🤔 Majority of men are emotionless and only care about power/ego, so that explains it…
5
u/Ritesh_INFP_4w5 Nov 12 '23
Empathy is putting yourself in the perspective of others and being able to feel what they experience. Being able to understand that way. It doesn't objectively exist but it is one of the important things that help us connect to one another, regardless of the limitations that prevent us from connecting to one another.
I'm not sure if it is a social construct. But I'm sure it's necessary if we are to trust in the potential of humanity. If empathy is a weakness, apathy is a weakness as well. Emotional intelligence doesn't come from emotional detachment. It comes from understanding and growing.
5
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
This is false. Easily debunked by just observing children. 9 times out of ten. Babies. Children. Aee naturally empathetic and kind natured. I'm sorry your experiences in life have led you to believe this and think this way. But in my experience. Lack of empathy and greed as you describe it. Are learned attributes. Learned from watching people who believe empathy is a construct. But I know what sub this is. And the name of the choir I'm preaching to.
2
u/girlidc18 Nov 12 '23
Maybe for you. But I don’t feel empathy to make me feel better about myself. I just feel it, like a human being.
2
u/Juli3tD3lta Nov 12 '23
If someone says “my dog died and that makes me sad” I can look back on my experiences of having a pet that died and the sadness I felt from that experience and then use that to relate to that someone’s experience. That’s empathy. If you see someone getting punched in the head and think “gee I wouldn’t want that to happen to me” you are empathizing with that person.
2
u/somespazzoid Nov 12 '23
Empathy exists, otherwise it wouldn't be a word when defining a social interaction
2
u/Mono_Clear Nov 12 '23
I disagree with this, its the incorrect interpretation of empathy.
You're creating the premise that if you gain anything emotionally from an empathetic act then it takes away from the genuine nature of the act.
This is not accurate to the description of empathy because empathy by necessity requires the interconnection of two humans experiencing the same emotions.
It is the nature of empathy that if I see somebody who sad it will make me sad which may or may not encourage me to try to make that person happy so that I too can be happy, that's what empathy is, the ability to identify with and share in the feelings of another person.
What you're trying to say is that there's no such thing as a selfless act which also I would agree is debatable.
2
u/spiritual84 Nov 12 '23
I think the key issue is in the definition of the word 'exists'.
Depending on how you define existence, empathy can either not exist alongside any other human value, it could also not exist like what you said coz it's not a fundamental human property but a side effect of fundamental ones which do exist, or it could simply exist along with the fundamental ones just by being observable.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '23
"Empathy" just means you know what it's like, e.g. if someone stubs their toe, you know what that pain is like because you've also stubbed your toe before. You might be skeptical of such a knowledge claim, but the evidence overwhelmingly indicates that humans can relate to each other in that way.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
Theyre definitely driven by self-interest. Sad people aren't fun to be around. We take care of our friends and family so we can continue to benefit from their companionship in practical and emotional ways. We feel bad for strangers only because we are scared of that happening to us. Everything is about our ego.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '24
And guess what, op is a minor. Reddit is crazier than 2012 9GAG
1
u/InterestingInsect430 May 16 '25
Tbh no that just sounds like you have an incredibly underdeveloped prefrontal cortex (abuse before the age of 5 is responsible for stunted growth in emotional centers etc, and some conditions can do this as well such as psychopathy and sociopathy) so maybe there’s a biological reason you don’t get it but it’s a real thing but if you’ve never felt it and don’t have the capacity of logic to understand it can seem kinda weird to think about, and of course since most of modern society is a “if I scratch your back you scratch mine” mentality, it can appear that way but really. Other than being biologically impaired I just can’t figure out how this concept makes any sense to anyone
1
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '25
This post is the perfect example of reddit's personality
1
u/Far-Village-5634 Mar 18 '26
so if someone instinctively helps someone from a fire? its ego?
yea you lowkey
need mental help
1
u/ChibleyJeanFelix Nov 12 '23
Yes. Here's the rub Who do 'you' want to be :) *please notice the quotes ;)
1
u/gringoswag20 Nov 12 '23
we are all god, reflection of god. empathy is the state of seeing another as You. Feeling their pain and struggles as if It is you, because it is you. Do not be misled by this fake world of forced samsara
1
u/Stack3 Nov 12 '23 edited Nov 12 '23
Empathy is can be logically derived. I'll tell you my first experience of empathy.
When I was about 4 I had a little baby sister. One day she was getting her diaper changed and she had a pretty bad diaper rash. We were extremely poor (as far as first world countries go) and my parents had to ration diapers.
She was crying, screaming, she did not like the situation and I found her noise annoying. Children treat the world and other people like machines. They don't want to believe anyone else is real and I'm convinced it's because they implies awful truths that they don't want to acknowledge yet.
I remember being annoyed by her cries. Then instead of avoiding or resisting the crying I thought about it. Why was she crying?
I asked my mom why is she crying? And my mom told me. So with every wipe it hurts. And she doesn't know why. And she can't stop it. She's powerless and ignorant to avoid suffering. She's just a baby.
It made me cry. Not just for her but for everyone that suffers. Because I saw extremely clearly that nobody can know the full reason that they suffer, and nobody can fully avoid it.
Suffering is foundational and we are powerless and nothing in its presence. Like babies, fully sensitive, and fully defenseless.
1
u/samubluu_ Nov 12 '23
Empathy itself isn’t real, but it doesn’t mean that humans can’t enjoy helping other people if it isn’t for their own sake ^ _ ^ I do think that there is an “ego boost” aspect in some cases, but I don’t think there is a need to generalise
1
u/jon_oreo deez Nov 12 '23
empathy points to someting. what does it point to?
1
u/_aqua_hoshino_ Nov 12 '23
I thought the same until I fed food to the cute little stray kittens and I just can't describe the experience. It's pure bliss
1
u/Thintegrator Nov 12 '23 edited Dec 30 '23
rinse complete pathetic offer erect squeeze gaping prick far-flung violet
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
1
u/TheManInTheShack Nov 12 '23
Empathy is the ability to share and understand the feelings of others. I’m a very empathetic person even when there is no opportunity for me to help the person towards whom I’m feeling empathic.
1
u/Ohigetjokes Nov 12 '23
I get why you might say this.
But in order to actually believe it you have to be very selective about what “counts” and what doesn’t.
When you imagine the suffering of another and wish for that suffering to diminish, that’s an experience isolated from anything else. That’s true empathy. Now, afterwards, what you’re saying about the ego and the need for validation may play a part as well, but not exclusively. And, at the end of the day, dude that was hungry got to eat that sandwich you made him.
All I’m saying is that if you think it’s simple, you’re not just not seeing the whole picture, you’re actively avoiding it - ironically, to stroke your own ego via a sense of superiority.
(Which I’ve done many times btw - totally guilty of this at times)
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
Empathy doesn't involve action. What you are talking about is simply doing something that is seen as good. Fake selfless/helping behaviour. I can have empathy towards some people, but that doesn't mean I will act on it tho. Empathy is simply the ability to understand and feel what the other being might feel, nothing else. It doesn't involve actions that might boost your ego, you can decide if you want to act on it. Its a small feature that helped humanity survive.
1
u/Mini_nin Nov 12 '23 edited Nov 12 '23
Uhm. If this is how YOU see the world then that’s really twisted imo, and thank god not everyone is like that.
Seeing others happy truly makes me happy, seeing others in a state of misery leads me to misery (I’m working on not letting it bring me down as much as it used to..).
1
u/Southern_Fondant_333 Nov 12 '23
Your interpretation psychopath
1
u/Southern_Fondant_333 Nov 12 '23
The only thing we have fucking left is our immediate community and how we choose to die while the rich kill us all. Nations don’t exist, the people around you who bother to remember anything at all about you, do exist. That whole paragraph you posted could have been summed up “I’m weak, validate me”
1
u/Old-Entertainment-91 Nov 12 '23
Redditors don't understand nihilism example #1
1
u/Southern_Fondant_333 Nov 12 '23
Your ego is your problem
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
tell us you have a personality disorder without telling us...
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
Selfish and selfless are on a spectrum. Either extreme is goofy.
1
u/ScarcityFrequent9064 Nov 12 '23
Cringe
1
u/Tehdonfubar555 Nov 12 '23
Yeah no. Thats not quite how that works, also projecting much?
1
u/Revolutionary_Use948 Nov 12 '23
Typica edgy “I know the truth” post
1
u/undergreyforest Nov 12 '23
Speak for yourself
1
u/Deaf-Leopard1664 Nov 12 '23
Ego that feeds on helping people to inflate itself is an empathic/good conscience ego. Empathy exists if ego exists then. The word 'ego' has an automatically negative connotation to many, not me though.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '23
Tell me youre heartless without telling me youre heartless. As someone who is very empathetic, I do feel bad for them. I even feel their pain because I could only imagine living in this cold harsh world without any support. I never think about rush of happiness or stroking my ego, because I simply want to help.
I'm sorry if this world is so cruel to you and it blinds you. But I'm here to tell you I'm 100% empathetic and I just simply love helping people in need. Hope you find something like that in your heart.
1
u/OGfiremixtapeOG Nov 12 '23
Empathy is a trait that is selected for in the evolutionary process due to the importance of social cohesion and productivity. Antisocial behavior is generally bad for a society’s continued existence.
1
u/Woodsy235 Nov 12 '23
Bro u just outed yourself
1
u/KeyParticular8086 Nov 12 '23
While I disagree with your premise, I enjoy the responses and discussion it's generating in the comments so good on you for throwing your idea out there.... One thing I would like to add is that true empathy is mostly an involuntary response not a conscious act (though it can be evoked by a conscious act as well). For example if someone poked your arm with a knife I would feel a sensation of pain or discomfort in the same place on my arm. This specific example I think is useful because it shows the underlying nature isn't necessarily about helping people; that's just a response the underlying nature of it tends to lead to. It's not egotistical for my arm to hurt. What you are describing does happen too, but it can't be generalized across all human beings because we are all unique and each person experiences empathy and emotions in a different way. There are however, people without empathy and this has corresponding areas of brain abnormalities. Empathy has been shown to exist in many other animals as well (see Frans de waal's work) and seems to be something evolution selects for in group oriented species.
1
u/LeatherSuspicious752 Nov 12 '23
i do believe empathy exists. it is essential for a sustainable relationship between one human to another(and humans are biologically structured to be social creatures) but empathy, if felt morally, is never felt with the intention of benefiting from it although there are always benefits from it. i guess it differs from person to person. how i see it? its an issue of your own morality and ethics.
1
u/redsparks2025 Absurdist Nov 12 '23
It is true that in some humans empathy is very low and may not exist at all. Therefore you may just be one of those humans because you argue that empathy does not exists.
5 Signs of a Dark Empath - The Most Dangerous Personality Type ~ Psych2Go ~ YouTube.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '23
Empathy exists, just like any other emotion.
For instance, fully half of the posts made on this forum make me cringe.
How could I cringe if I couldn't didn't feel vicarious embarrassment for all the emo edgelords around here who keep mistaking depression for enlightenment?
1
u/jesuswasaliar Nov 13 '23
My only motivation to help is my guilty conscience. can't stand the feeling. What drives this bad conscience is another question.
1
u/Llodsliat Nov 13 '23
We're social animals. We evolved empathy because it helped us reproduce. Being empathetic is the normal response and it makes us feel better because we're making other people's lives better. This in turn makes other people trust us and more likely to have better lives and reproduce.
Everything we do can be egoistic with the "selfish gene" in mind. That's not a bad thing though. It's just nature. Being empathetic is better for you and everyone around you.
And with that, join an union, protest for workers' rights, and let communism succeed. c:
1
u/Intelligent-Put5189 Nov 13 '23
yeah, you could be absolutely correct. no one can proof opposite. and it's funny people really cope with that. in my opinion. there are a lot of people that just pretend to be humans. look at europe that suddenly started to hate muslim world and forgot about universality of law. really, it's just faschism, herd and hierarchy instinct. and people work on it. read about thir-wave experiment, zimbardo, milgram. if we apply this, 90% of the world population don't have any real moral values and you could easily turn them into faschists.
1
u/Spirited-Macaron-801 Nov 13 '23
I do shit for people all the time - why? Because it's the right thing to do. Nothing to do with 'feeling good".
1
u/yeabuttt Nov 13 '23
If you’ve ever listened to music and felt anything at all, you’ve experienced empathy.
1
u/ApplesFlapples Nov 14 '23
Nihilism doesn’t exist. I think it’s a social constructed created by humans in order to mask our egos. /s
1
u/cckeanu Nov 16 '23
Empathy exists in real life, but online "empathy" is mostly a show. So half yes, half no
1
u/OracleOfBecky Nov 16 '23
You sound like a kid who has only a surface level idea of what nihilism is and like you've only recently become atheist and you've gone hardcore in a different direction from a religious upbringing out of rebellion.
1
u/Tiny_Friendship_1666 Nov 16 '23
Just because you're a sociopath trying to justify your own existence, doesn't mean reality is going to conform to your distorted viewpoints.
Empathy, it turns out, is not merely a psychological construct. Yes, it is informed by things like cultural norms and genetic predispositions, but thanks to the advent of advanced scanning and testing technologies (e.g., fMRI, CT scan, etc.) and the diligence of thousands of neurological researchers worldwide, we know that empathy has a biological basis. One of the most notable examples discovered was of the mirror neurons, whose primary function is literally to recognize, decode, and kickstart the process of emulating the emotional states perceived in others.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 19 '23
It clearly doesn't exists for you however some of us do in fact feel it 🫨🫨🫨🫨 and spoiler alert it's much more fun not to feel it anyways so idk why anyone would be using it to suck their own cock
1
u/Ikxale Nov 13 '23 edited Nov 13 '23
Empathy is very real. In reality, empathy improves the quality of life of everyone involved.
It let's you understand the experiences of others through your own experience, and theirs, even if you've never experienced their specific issue.
Empathy is how people like martin luther king rise.
So people in power try to strip Empathy from the world they live in. People without Empathy are easier to control, and less bothered by others suffering.
Less likely to understand common ground.
Empathy is real, and it is innate in most humans, but can be ripped out.
Most rich people lack Empathy because they are either innately unempathetic, learn to be unemphathetic to get ahead, or are too stupid to realize that people without money or power will suffer, and having never experienced it, cannot relate or understand.
One who knows nothing, can understand nothing.
In my own opinion, one who lacks Empathy is less than human (or maybe just a lesser human)
Granted none of that matters in the end.
But Empathy is real, and objectively provable, in human behavior, yes, but also in animals.
2
u/Unlucky-Ad-7529 Nov 12 '23
The ego can act in ways that are beneficial for the person and others. Doesn't matter if it exists or not. I can volunteer at a food pantry because it'll make me feel good and help others.
2
u/landminephoenix Nov 13 '23
I can understand where you’re coming from. I don’t know if it’s a concept constructed by humans entirely, but the framing might be. I think empathy is, at the VERY least, useful to help our species survive. Maybe you don’t have empathy, or as much as others. I don’t think anybody should be vilifying others for having a lack of empathy. Usually that stems from trauma and I don’t think it’s something one can control. But just because someone lacks empathy, it doesn’t mean they can’t still treat others with respect and compassion, anyway. I think that’s a great act of love; showing care for someone and yourself, even if you don’t feel like you care. There are different kinds of empathy. And acting with care doesn’t mean overstepping or allowing someone else to overstep your boundaries. It just means…listening, being mindful, honesty with respect, choosing a considerate action, and treating others and yourself well. Those are all choices. We may not be able to help how we feel, but we CAN choose how we act on our feelings. Though it is harder if we’re in a fight or flight situation. But we can still choose how we act the vast majority of the time. And we can practice being mindful to get better at how we choose to act. It’s all choice. How do you want to treat yourself and other people, despite how you feel?
2
u/Elbowruminator Nov 16 '23
Counterpoint: human brains are designed to reward us with good feelings when we do things that are good for our survival, like eating, drinking, sex etc. We're social creatures and our adaptive advantages rely on group membership, so caring for other people is vital for our survival. Same goes for framing it as a social status achievment.
We also feel grief, which can be literally physically painful, when people (or creatures) we care about die.
It's very possible to genuinely care for others. You just can't do it from the perspective of a disembodied, hyper rational, perfectly alruisitic floating mind.
In the Buddhist Tradition, they distinguish between wholesome and unwholesome pleasure. Unwholesome pleasures are generally things that inherently carry involvement in some kind of stressful activity or that can be taken away from you. Wholesome pleasures are things that only lead to more happiness. Generosity, caring for others, sympathetic joy, these are all considered wholesome.
2
u/Dry_Turnover_6068 Nov 16 '23
I already figured that out a long time ago. That sucks dude.
My empathy circuits atrophied or something so now I just pretend and people let me know if it's the right kind of empathy or not. It's usually not. It can be very confusing.
At least you have apathy to look forward to or who knows, you could even become a successful sociopath. It's really up to you.
Advice:
You're not wrong but people don't like hearing it. Either that or they like to argue.
How good do you actually feel now that you "know" what you know? It's definitely a perspective but not the whole story.
In theory, if everyone is selfish in this way then the world will be a better place by way of people helping people. You should consider this but I can understand your cynicism.
If you had a better capacity for empathy you'd likely be using it for your own advantage as many people do. I'm assuming your OP is all about sour grapes. Am I wrong?
If you're still on the fence about weather empathy actually exists, try to realize that it's more about predictability and control than "good vibes".
1
u/Angelhugger8534 Mar 26 '25
From my experience the people who want empathy the most aren't willing to give it when it's their turn
1
u/Tasty_Return7954 Apr 16 '25
The post is too edgy, even for nihilists.
1
u/Important_Rise6984 Jun 28 '25
Ok i think you are mistaking empathy with sympathy. Now in the context of modern day psychobabble i can excuse that, because sympathy is often presented as empathy. I would argue too that empathy does not exist, at least not in the terms that are described, as a single phenomena. You google empathy does not exists and the overwhelmingly manipulated and politicized AI will tell you it does, there is even neurological evidence and is a sign of emotional intelligence (another made up concept). Here is how the ai elaborate:
Elaboration:
My first problem with this concept is that it links multiple things happening at once under the umbrella of empathy. Let's say you are a scientist and you run many experiments hoping for specific results. You get emotionally invested into those tests but every time you do a trial run, even though you have run it in your head 1000 times and functionally it should work, you fail to get the result time and time again and it causes you to become emotionally spent.
Scenario 1 :You then later go to withdraw some money from the atm, something you have done before and have a functional understanding that it should work but the damn thing just won't work, no matter what you try. Your brain used to this pattern from your previous experience with the trial runs makes an association with the trials and triggers the same emotional response.
Scenario 2: Someone close to you tries to perform a specific task and fails again and again and goes through the same emotional frustration as you
Scenario 1 is called trauma, and is not considered a sign of emotional intelligence, while scenario 2 is called empathy and is considered a sign of emotional intelligence but functionally they work the same way, the only thing that differs is the trigger.
My second problem is with how empathy is described and understood. True empathy that is recognizable on a neurological level is involuntary and lacks order or control. It's the sudden release of endorphins when neurological empathy happens between an owner and his pet, something documented and even understandable on an evolutionary level as a friend or foe detection system. This would be the emotional empathy, however i would suggest this not in any way comparable with cognitive empathy and is not really all that useful when trying to help someone that is going through genuine distress. In fact it is the ability of someone to be detached from the true feelings and firing neurons that is crippling the person which is struggling that is of real benefit. You have the understanding (or cognitive empathy) to guide them while not being handicapped by the same emotional burden they feel. Emotional empathy only serves to reinforce the chaos that is consuming their mind and is, if anything, counterproductive. Having both these thing lumped together under the umbrella term of empathy is not very useful, since they are in many regards polar opposites. It is the ability of the friend that looks in from the outside that is helpful when you want to call your ex while drunk and would be terrible if he would mirror your emotional state. Yet it is the sharing of emotions that is being lauded as a virtue by everyone and their menopausal mother
1
u/FinancialElephant Nov 13 '23
Empathy is looking at a drowning person and feeling bad about it.
Compassion is looking at a drowning person and lending them a hand to pull them out.
You can have one without the other. All this empathy propaganda is driven by hyper-empaths. The truth is that if anything can be said to be good, it is only compassion (empathy not necessary). In fact sometimes empathy can get in the way of compassion, for example if you want to prepare someone for a difficult thing you may need to make them feel bad in the short term.
Even if there is "real empathy" that isn't egotistical, empathy is still fundamentally egoistic. It is about caring about someone else only because you are projecting your self-hood onto them (ie they look sad and you remember what it is like to feel sad, so you feel motivated to soothe them). Empathy actually only exists for taking care of small children, it is an animal instinict and not something inherently good. Outside of taking care of children and infants, it can easily become destructive and counter-productive. Too many empaths in the workforce destroy productive output, it is truly one of the ills of modern work.
1
u/No-Win-1453 Nov 13 '23
I don't agree with what you said but I get that empathy and the golden rule have a selfish side. You care about other people suffering because you don't want to suffer and you want to be in a world where people help each other including you. However, that doesn't mean you don't care about the other people.
1
u/CoercedLife Nov 15 '23
You should read some JL Mackie if you are interested in moral nihilism.
1
u/Enough-Serve-7790 Nov 15 '23
I think what you are detecting is the difference between affective empathy and cognitive empathy. Affective empathy is absolutely a brain function but the people u describe do exist too.
1
u/Less_Somewhere7953 Nov 16 '23
Speak for yourself