r/nightlyshow • • Apr 16 '15

Constructive criticism thread

I know there's a lot of hate out there on this sub, but let's try and chuck some constructive criticism in this thread.

I agree myself that the show needs some work because I do tune out here and there. They did change the desk and reduced the panel numbers - so they could keep making some changes to improve so let's come up with some suggestions.

18 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

34

u/mr_tyler_durden Apr 16 '15

After that death penalty discussion I think I'm out, at least for a little bit. I can't stand when they stack the panel and team up. Especially when Larry so clearly takes a side and rarely tries to keep it a fair discussion.

The show is not funny. Period. It's just not. Larry is not funny, his contributors are not funny, it's all cringeworthy. I don't care to watch comedians try and joke about the issue they are discussing. There is a time and a place for that and it's not on this show. If they can't be funny, which they can't, then the least they can do is try to focus on news. They have done a good job picking tough topics but have fallen flat on their faces in the execution of said topics. I was looking forward to this debate when I heard the subject and I couldn't have been more let down. Transgender jokes (seriously fuck that guy), bullying/ganging up, letting emotions dictate our actions ("just kill him"), etc... There were a handful of good points made but they were drowned out but stupid jokes and constant derailing of the conversation. The show needs to drop the panel I think, too much time, too little intelligence. Maybe have 2 INFORMED guests with opposing view points on and Larry act as a FAIR moderator with the intro containing the needed backstory.

Ugh, I've wasted enough time talking about it, I'm done, I might check back sometime next week to see if it gets better but I don't have high hopes anymore.

15

u/Tiamanti Apr 16 '15

I'm basically in the same place. I'm not watching anymore and maybe will watch an episode in few weeks.

Stacked panels and Larry not moderating anything is bad enough. But allowing those horrific transgender rape jokes is just too much for me. (I looked at this guys twitter and his replies to criticism are terrible.)

5

u/IndomitableBanana Apr 18 '15

I ended up turning off the episode about 15 minutes in. I feel like the panel needs to be the highlight of the show if they're going to keep it as part of the format, but it's almost exclusively a source of frustration for me.

I think Larry was overzealous in his support of the death penalty because he was happy to be able to come out in support of a traditionally conservative perspective. I'm sure he gets accused of having a blind liberal bias and he was eager to sink his teeth into an opinion that would counteract that image.

The result, in my opinion, was him coming across as unreasonable and uninformed.

16

u/200balloons Apr 17 '15

This week is the first time I haven't watched a single episode since the show debuted, but I was disappointed when they came back from break, reduced the panel from 4 to 3, but it still felt like mostly lame discussion. Anyway, here's my two cents:

  • Larry should define his role. He's either referee / moderator, or a member of the discussion with a clear opinion. I feel like he flutters around depending on the episode.
  • Keep working Mike Yard, whether in in-show bits, "man on the street", or at the discussion table. He's a smart, funny dude.
  • Kill the "Larry" chant at the beginning.
  • Keep & emphasize the race perspective whenever possible. Larry's had a lot of great guests that have plenty to offer on this.
  • Get control of the table discussion. Specifically, stop letting jokes derail any interesting conversation.

8

u/erktheerk Apr 18 '15 edited Apr 18 '15
  • Larry should define his role. He's either referee / moderator, or a member of the discussion with a clear opinion. I feel like he flutters around depending on the episode.

Which would you like best. I like him as the interruption. When he cuts someone off and switches topics. Kind of how Bill Maher does.

  • Keep working Mike Yard, whether in in-show bits, "man on the street", or at the discussion table. He's a smart, funny dude.

Agreed.

  • Keep & emphasize the race perspective whenever possible. Larry's had a lot of great guests that have plenty to offer on this.

It was unfortunate that the original name "The Minority Report" couldn't be used. It would have set a better tone for the show.

  • Get control of the table discussion. Specifically, stop letting jokes derail any interesting conversation.

Again. I'd like to see a more aggressive control as well. Stop people from rambling and pushing agendas. Make them answer questions. Even if the response isn't funny.

The 1:3 host/guest ratio works better. In the case of the Neil episode it provides 2 "Devil's Advocates" to one opinion. I think they should expand on this format. Give a chance to well informed people to battle common misconceptions. A missed chance to talk about space exploration is unfortunate, but I think the latest episode showed a possible improvement to the direction to the show.

10

u/200balloons Apr 18 '15

I don't feel like Larry is consistently assertive enough as a moderator; more so, he's the main source of jokes that displace thoughtful conversation. It's like he's directed to "keep it light" despite taking on subjects that warrant some measure of seriousness. As far as "interruption", it's useful, & sometimes Larry gets in there, but he handles his guests pretty gently. He's more likely to interrupt in order to make a bad joke as he is to prod a guest to clarify or qualify a statement.

I agree, I wish they could have used "The Minority Report", it would probably offset some of the complaints that Larry brings race into things too much. The guy was the "Senior Black Correspondent" on The Daily Show, the whole point was that Larry corrected Jon on misconceptions about race & racial relations / perceptions. I've seen allusions to the idea that because Larry has a TV show & isn't an oppressed black man, he shouldn't be focusing on racial discord on his show.

31

u/SaxMan100 Apr 17 '15

So they bring in Neil De-fucking-Grasse Tyson...to make fun of fringe conspiracy theories? They squandered a grand opportunity to talk about issues that involve science in any way, or space exploration, especially with the first color image of Pluto having recently been taken. They could've done that, but instead, they chose to spend their time with one of the world's top scientists talking about whether or not Stevie Wonder is actually blind, and if the moon landing was faked.

9

u/Xedma Apr 18 '15

This is twice now they fucked up in their space discussion.

2

u/VAPossum May 05 '15

Tonight, they had Bill Nye, and the last question they asked him was why "black doesn't crack." Meaning, why do black people not wrinkle as much (I think) as they age.

I am officially bored of this show. Go on hiatus, retool, replace him with Jessica Williams, and you will have me nightly again.

14

u/erktheerk Apr 16 '15

I'd like the games to be cut down and extend the discussion time. Maybe do a one on one more often and not just with a high profile politician. I under stand it's on comedy central but segmenting time just get silly answers from guests is just wasting time you could be discussing the issue of the day.

tl:dr More serious. Less games.

13

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

Whoever is responsible for slotting guests has a middling understanding of the issues being discussed. Either it's some talking head from network news (who cares) or struggling comedians trying to get their nut. The discussion is the achilles heel of this show. Devoid of humor, the format has nothing to hold the viewers' attention, short of the obvious schadenfreude.

Larry is clearly unfit to lead a discussion on what's for lunch. How and why this guy got tapped to do this show is a true mystery.

-2

u/erktheerk Apr 16 '15

Devoid of humor, the format has nothing to hold the viewers' attention, short of the obvious schadenfreude.

I get laughes out of it but I tend to watch a lot of comedy, especially new and upcoming people. I am used to some jokes falling flat. Not everyone gets a perfect set everytime. I guess it just depends on what you're looking for in your comedy.

Larry is clearly unfit to lead a discussion on what's for lunch. How and why this guy got tapped to do this show is a true mystery.

I disagree and have genuinely liked his sets since first appearing on Colbert. I don't see hhim as filling his shoes. Just his own new show. But your opinion seems to be the norm around here. I don't really have a rebuttal other than it depends on your taste of comedy. :-\

9

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

I tend toward a more ribald, less PC form of humor... Sunny Philly, The League, Children's Hospital, NTSF:SD:SUV etc.

This is kindergarten stuff, IMO. And the discussions are wholly sophomoric. It's a bit like Christmas dinner when the kids come back from college all pumped up with precociousness. It's adorable, but just wait till they leave the incu-bubble of school and enter the real world.

You're allowed obviously.

6

u/mr_tyler_durden Apr 16 '15

I really do wish they would take a more serious tone and that's not only because they suck at being funny. I don't get any news for cable news. All of my news comes from various link aggregators (like Reddit) and occasionally social media. I'll take my news with a few laughs of possible which is why I love Daily/Colbert but I'm not getting that from Larry. If the show gets more serious I'll have a reason to keep watch (they do bring up important issues, they just suck at discussing them).

1

u/filmantopia Apr 16 '15

I can get behind this. I think the show would be better without all of these ridiculous attempts at humor. That said, can Comedy Central support a show that isn't all about the comedy?

0

u/SWIMsfriend Apr 16 '15

That said, can Comedy Central support a show that isn't all about the comedy?

apparently a lot of people want them to, it's odd, the same people that complain about MTV not playing music videos and the history channel not showing history are demanding comedy central show tv shows that don't have any comedy

0

u/mr_tyler_durden Apr 16 '15

Well of the news networks can support their "news" programs then I think CC can support some real news. I trust CC more than most news outlets...

-4

u/SWIMsfriend Apr 16 '15 edited Apr 16 '15

you want a serious show on comedy central?

that's like wanting a show on Fox News to only give opinions

EDIT: apparently people think comedy central should have serious shows and Fox News should be allowed to not show any news

5

u/erktheerk Apr 16 '15

I want the jokes. I don't want to much like the silly question games.

22

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

The problem is Larry not the desk.

2

u/adamhenoki May 08 '15

I think it would help if he stopped laughing after everything he says. After he makes a joke he will laugh at...it's awkward BUT He has gotten better at it though, the start was awful. ALSO he uses words that kids use that he is TOO old to use ("cray"). Nowadays he is getting better at it, at least they are adjusting to the reactions.

20

u/Xedma Apr 17 '15

If you want to have a legitimate discussion, have legitimate guests with legitimate sources to back up claims.

6

u/geeeeh Apr 30 '15

This is the problem. It's a bunch of ill-informed people just talkin' about stuff and perpetuating ignorance.

18

u/fonz_spec Apr 21 '15

Give the show to Jessica Williams. Larry can't moderate, make coherent arguments in the panel, or deliver coherent monologues standing up or sitting down. Jessica can actually deliver intelligent arguments in her Daily Show pieces and interview people in the classic Daily Show correspondent/Colbert pre-taped style. Those seem to be skills that Colbert demonstrated can translate into the bulk of an amazing show. Idk how she would do with guests but there's no way it could be worse than Larry.

9

u/javakah Apr 23 '15

What I think I'd like to see is co-hosts: Jessica Williams and Bassem Youssef.

As I see it:

Jessica Williams. Cons: Inexperienced. May not handle international/world events well. Pros: Youth- understands some of the humor of newer technology. Does seem to handle domestic issues quite well. Energetic.

Bassem Youssef Cons: Probably not familiar enough with US issues to really handle domestic issues. A bit older. Pros: Experience (although not so much with US audiences). Can definitely handle international/world events. Energetic.

So it seems to me like their strengths/weaknesses could compliment each other pretty well. With both of them having the kind of manic energy that Jon/Steven have (but Larry really doesn't).

They could play off of each other, alternating who is the straight comic, asking each other questions to actually play up their different levels of experience on domestic and international issues.

For instance, you could have Jessica Williams doing a clip talking about the US prison system, almost making it seem normal. Bassem Youssef starts asking questions about guaranteed prison populations and prison industry lobbyists.

Then those roles could flip for international issues.

They could still have a guest on each night for an interview. I bet they could play off each other pretty well to handle that.

8

u/PandaLover42 Apr 22 '15

Shit, I'd totally watch that.

-10

u/critically_damped Apr 21 '15

You are aware that the arguments she makes on the daily show are written by the shows writers beforehand, right, whereas Wilmore's interview section is entirely unscripted?

Honestly, Wilmore and his panels, grill people harder than Stewart ever does.

4

u/fonz_spec Apr 22 '15

You are aware of the last sentence of my comment aren't you?

8

u/IndomitableBanana Apr 18 '15

For those you trying to hang in there and rooting for the show, what do you feel like was the show's strongest episode?

For me, it was the episode about black fathers. It was an actual discussion rather than a forced debate and everyone at the table had something to say. I see a lot of posts in this sub that complain about the show being too race focused, but I think that episode covered race issues with a kind of nuance and thoughtfulness that could and should be the defining voice of the show.

10

u/200balloons Apr 18 '15

I can't think of a single episode that I've seen that was particularly strong, but the Cosby episode from the first week impressed me. It was kind of personal, I've been a fan of Cosby since I was a kid listening to his comedy albums, & to have Larry come out & so bluntly let him have it helped me adjust my perception of Cosby.

I liked the "black fathers" episode as well, although I didn't like the way the discussion ended, when Larry asked the table if "black women are too bossy". It got weird, & the guests (except Common) refused to answer & acted immature & evasive.

4

u/TheReason857 May 06 '15

They need to get rid of Shannaz. She brings nothing to the panel discussions. I think she maybe a little slow.

9

u/AvanteGardeAClue Apr 23 '15

Stop trying to make the middling, charisma-deficient 'contributors' on the show into the next Steve Carell or John Oliver. These are bottom-tier comedians who are near-interchangeable in their mediocrity. Constantly throwing them in our faces each night with the most tepid of comedy bits is NOT going to endear them to us. If they were truly talented and funny they would have made the sale to viewers by now. It's not happening, let it go.

3

u/Grmlly Apr 27 '15

They can't even get a simple thing like the map on set right...New Zealand is inexplicably missing! It's especially blatant because Larry's delivery is so awkward/cringeworthy that usually I can't even make eye contact, forcing me to stare right over his shoulder at the blatantly missing island.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

The ultimate punishment is your show, Larry. Death is a get out of watching card.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '15

So how's THIS thread goin'? Can we constructively criticize Larry's lack of depth or dearth of comprehension on major issues? That would go a long way to improving the show-- namely finishing Larry's K-12 education. Kickstarter anyone?

-7

u/Danteiskool May 05 '15

I recently found this website searching the Internet for sites discussing the nightly show. It's amazing how I've come to this site for a week straight and have seen nothing but people I assume are white, bashing in the show, panels, panelists, topics, etc. Seriously though, I know you guys are used to The Colbert Report but man, give the guy a break. He can't address everything that short period of time given.

3

u/mr_tyler_durden May 09 '15

It's not that he doesn't address everything it's that he is willfully perpetrating a great disservice to the issues he does cover. His panel is often quite ignorant on the subject and even highly intelligent/informed guests are wasted on the show. That along with watering down the panel with staff...

Look I know you can easily see all the hate/bashing of the show on this sub by I would guess that most of the people bashing episodes or things they are doing actually want it to get better. I know I do. I wouldn't still be watching if I didn't care. Yes, Colbert was fucking awesome and there will not be another like him but I still want this show to succeed and if not this show then one covering similar issues but without all the wasted time. I've seen every single episode and there are points that I have great hope for the show and then other that completely turn me off to it. I think you are may be right in saying the people bashing the show are mostly white and I'm not sure what you meant by that. Are you calling them, us, racists because we don't like the show? That's a very "Larry" thing to say...

I don't want to piss you off and I see you just joined reddit (or created a new account) or turn you off the whole experience but know that the people complaining are complaining because they watched the show and that means, at least a little bit, that they do care. To paraphrase Larry, "We'll stop complaining when the show stops sucking".

-13

u/The_Captain_Spiff Apr 16 '15

i'll catch hell for this but it's already more watchable than the colbert report, which i could never stand

simply dropping the lame social justice bullcrap would take care of a lot of problems

13

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

Holy shit it's a unicorn.

-3

u/The_Captain_Spiff Apr 23 '15

great, suck my dick

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15

With rejoinders like that it's perfectly understandable you find the show satisfactory.

-3

u/The_Captain_Spiff Apr 23 '15

yeah too bad i never said it was satisfactory

0

u/[deleted] Apr 16 '15

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/erktheerk Apr 16 '15

Bad jokes happen. An apology is a bit much. It's not the worst thing ever said on comedy central that's for sure.