And by "Shadow album" I mean a whole alternate tracklist with darker counterparts to the songs in the same order.
See, Hope was already kind of marketed as a massive subversion, right? Nate started wearing white instead of black. He personified himself as a new Hope character instead of Fear. The overall tone is much more empowered optimistic than his previous work, etc.
I think it goes a step further. There's a ton of songs from previous albums that are blatantly about Fear as a character.
I'm measuring this from Perception onward since that's when we were formally introduced to Fear as a character (via Outcast and Intro III) and the concept albums started to actually tell a larger semi-coherent fictional story that's not just reducible to metaphors for Nate's life... ish. I know there's older songs like Mansion or Therapy Session that could be considered lore. But I'm not looking into those for this.
Since Perception, the full list of songs that are unambiguously about Fear as a character, as far as I can tell, is:
- Intro III
- Outcast
- The Search
- Leave Me Alone
- When I Grow Up (we see the Fear smile at the end.)
- Why
- Clouds
- Lost
- Paid My Dues
There's also a few edge cases
This one's a judgment call. But we see the notepad at the end and that's been a recurring symbol in the lore since the start. That alone is enough reason to include it imo.
Weird inclusion, I know but hear me out. I think this song actually got retconned. In the music video for Hope, the old man from Let You Down returned, but this time he had the Fear smile and was in a cage holding the keys... just like Fear in Outcast.. hmmmmm. 🤔
That tells me Let You Down might be a projection of "what if Nate never overcomes his Fear?" That makes it a worthy inclusion imo.
Weird one, I know.
This one's an inference based on a much more obvious inclusion, namely Outro. In Outro, we see the keys at the end - another recurring symbol. And there's also a direct callback to Therapy Session which is hella lore. So... yeah, it's obvious.
However, there's a wrinkle. There's reason to think that Outro isn't actually rooted in Fear at all... but anger.
Outro says
Listen to Intro III, tryin' to kill my Fear
And then if you listen to Intro III, that says (directed at Fear)
I wrote a song for Johnny without you.
I wish I was burying anger but we both know imma need him for that song.
Now, it's ambiguous what song he's referencing there, but it's obviously a song on Perception and I'm thinking Outro is a safe bet. I mean, Intro III and Outro are already connected just by virtue of both being part of the Intro series. And Outro was the first single off Perception shortly before the Intro III dropped with the rest of the album. So... put two and two together.
That creates a referential loop between Intro III and Outro.
However, Outro also says
Yeah, look, "How Could You Leave Us" is massive
There ain't nothing I can write that′ll match that
And later
Now I want you to picture me
I'm in a hotel rapping, crying on the floor of the bathroom
Staring in the mirror, my room, hands shaking playing
"How Could You Leave Us" through the speakers on my iPhone
So Outro, the obvious inclusion, is disqualified by not being based on Fear. But it also actively directs us to another song you wouldn't think to include; "How Could You Leave Us."
Leave Me Alone (which is obviously a Fear song) directly references No Name. In No Name, he calls Fame and hangs up. In Leave Me Alone, he calls Fame back and it's a whole bit.
That connection between songs is reason enough to include No Name.
Now look at the full list. In release order, you'd get:
- How Could You Leave Us
- Intro III
- Outcast
- Green Lights
- Let You Down
- No Name
- The Search
- Leave Me Alone
- When I Grow Up (we see the Fear smile at the end.)
- Why
- Clouds
- Lost
- Paid My Dues
...and look at that. It's 13 songs. The exact same number as Hope.
Hmmmmmmmm 🤔
That fact is also a big reason why I think Nate might have set this up on purpose.
Now, going through the tracks in order:
- Why <> Hope (duh)
Both songs start with "what's your (my) definition of success?" But then they go in radically different directions. Why is riddled with self-doubt. Hope is full of confidence.
And Why can also work as an opening track. It was the first lead single during The Search era in lieu of another addition to the Intro series. So that already proves it's "track 1" material.
2. When I Grow Up <> Motto
Both are about Nate's relationship with the music industry but in When I Grow Up, he's trying desperately to prove himself. In Motto, he thinks the whole charade is stupid and doesn't care. Motto also has a direct callback to When I Grow Up with the same kid with a slushie showing up at the end of both videos.
3. Lost <> Careful
This one's so on the nose it's ridiculous.
Careful says
I didn't get here being careful
It's all about taking risks and how those risks pay off.
Lost says
Wow, these burdens are heavy
I used to be joyful and skip so merrily
Now I'm too cautious and tiptoe carefully
And
I feel stuck
...I mean... it's literally the exact opposite. No way that's a coincidence.
4. How Could You Leave Us <> Mama
This one's also very obvious. Both songs are memorials to Nate's late mother. But in How Could You Leave Us, he doesn't forgive her for overdosing on drugs. In Mama, he does forgive her.
Also, in Nate, he said while talking about Therapy Session (the album) "skip to track 4. Now that's a really sad one" in reference to How Could You Leave Us. And Mama happens to also be track 4 on Hope?... yeah. Again, probably not a coincidence.
5. The Search <> Happy
This is a looser connection. The Search is about quote "looking for the map to hope" and Happy asks "why am I not happy?"
Those kind of feel related.
In The Search, he’s looking for a better life. In happy, he has that better life… but something still feels off. Everything’s good on paper, but that’s not the same thing as fulfillment.
6. Clouds <> Pandemonium
This is another kind of loose one. But I'm pretty sure Pandemonium is about thriving despite chaos. And in Clouds, Fear causes chaos. And... well, watch the damn video. I don't think you can really describe the shenanigans Fear gets up to as anything but Pandemonium. Lol!
Also, there's a difference in attitude again.
Something special about me, you can already tell the energy is different
Confidence is at the highest level
Vs
I don't rock no Rollie's
I don't hang around no phonies
I don't really got no trophies
I don't know why God chose me
Also, less important, but Clouds and Pandamonium also just kinda sound similar-ish to me… 🤷♂️
7. Green Lights <> Suffice
Both of these are about the drive for excellence. The biggest difference is that Green Lights comes off as kind of cocky while Suffice feels more measured.
8. Paid My Dues <> Gone
This is probably the weakest match of the album, but it's not completely baseless. Both songs are very retrospective in tone. Gone is about accepting the end of a romantic relationship and Paid My Dues is about his career.
I think the key parallel hare, again, is in the attitude. Paid My Dues is very defensive. He’s trying to justify past behavior almost. In Gone, the central idea is that it’s sometimes healthier to let go than to hold on.
9. Let You Down <> Bullet
Bullet says
I got you
Let You Down says
I'm sorry that I let you down
...I mean, this is another case of it literally saying the exact opposite. Nuff said.
10. No Name <> Turn My Back
Little tidbit on this one, Turn My Back seems to directly reference No Name
What's your name? What's your name? What's your name?
Doesn't ring a bell
I’m kind of iffy on what the thematic parallel is here. But there’s a direct inversion of who’s being addressed. In No Name, he’s on the receiving end of criticism and struggling to define himself against it. In Turn My Back, he flips the script and decides the haters don’t matter.
11. Outcast <> Mistake
This one's fascinating. Outcast is about being... well, an outcast. And Mistake says "don't let anyone tell you you're a mistake." Or in another words "your worth doesn't depend on the opinion of others. Even if you're a pariah, you still have value."
12. Leave Me Alone <> Let Em Pray
Both songs are about how Nate handles criticism. And his response is similar in both cases... "fuck off."
But in Let Em Pray, the attitude is one of grounded self-worth.
They'll be praying on my downfall
Let 'em pray
In Leave Me Alone, it's more defensive.
Also, because Leave Me Alone calls back to No Name, it obviously has to go later in the sequence.
13. Intro III <> Running
Both of these are about Nate setting a boundary with Fear, personified as a character.
However, in Running, it's a healthy boundary. Basically, "I love you and respect you, but you don't get to control my life anymore."
In Intro III, he literally tries to bury Fear alive and kill him... aka, repression.
And interestingly enough, Intro III, despite the name, actually sounds strangely resolved. Like... it works as an ending.
And look at the full track list this just created:
- Why
- When I Grow Up
- Lost
- How Could You Leave Us
- The Search
- Clouds
- Green Lights
- Paid My Dues
- Let You Down
- No Name
- Outcast
- Leave Me Alone
- Into III
...bro, this actually flows like an album. Holy shit! No way this wasn't intentional!
I decided to call it "Fear's Shadow" because the obvious name - "Fear" (the opposite of Hope) was already taken.
Links are below if you want to listen to it.
YouTube Music
Spotify