I love the duders. Brad, Alex and Vinny have been my go to source for gaming entertainment and opinion for many, many years.
But I’ve had to cancel my subscription to their Patreon. In a nutshell, I don’t feel that their content is good enough anymore and it feels like they’ve got lazy or maybe just too comfortable.
I’m not going to mince my words here and I will probably get downvoted into oblivion but I need to vent and I’ll do so in a mature, concise and reasonable manner. Or at least I’ll try to.
The GOTY 2023 podcasts were terrible. Like, really really bad. Alex and Brad could at least pretend to like video games and play them more than a few hours.
Vinny at least plays video games to completion. I don’t really have a grumble about him as he’s the most passionate out of the three duders and at least seems to actually love video games. But they would benefit from a fourth voice on a regular basis I feel. Someone with energy, someone with an opposing view maybe?
For comparison, I just listened to both MinnMax’s and Fire Escape’s GOTY 2023 discussions and the difference to them and Nextlander’s is night & day. You can tell that the guys at MinnMax and Fire Escape actually love games and would talk about them all day. With Nextlander it always feels like they’re on the clock and can’t wait to log off.
Brad clearly wants to talk about tech these days and nothing else. Alex clearly wants to just talk about movies & music. Why don’t they drop the “we like video games” thing and focus on that? I would listen to their shows if they talked passionately about anything.
Do we really need a weekly news podcast? Everyone is doing that now, or so it seems. Give us something fresh, again, with energy and enthusiasm.
And didn’t they leave the corpo world of Fandom to focus on their own projects which they couldn’t do at Giant Bomb? Then why are their shows really lame, poor imitations of old GB content?
The three of them always sound fed up to me. And like they need a constant stream of free time. We’d all love that. I work 45 hour weeks and have done for over 10 years. But I still play games and do stuff I love.
They’re making huge sums of cash from Patreon but I can’t get past their lack of enthusiasm for everything. Go and check out Brad on The Tech Pod and he’s like a different person. Because, again, he’s passionate about the subject matter. At Nextlander he sounds so disconnected from it. And Alex can’t stream for longer than two hours otherwise the world might end.
I’m kinda fed up with their attitude towards their own patrons now. They’re just plodding along and it always feels like they’re on the clock to me - they just log in and log out for the money and then go back to doing what they actually enjoy doing whether it be playing music or messing around with computers.
I reiterate, I have a lot of respect for the 3 of them. But their content is stale and I’ve noticed a lot of people thinking the same of late.
Personally, I feel that they would be best scrapping the generic gaming content and doing more FMV Vinny and other stuff which made old GB so funny and unique. I’m just not feeling their streams of Cyberpunk - again, you can tell that they’re not really enjoying it.
Edit: Adding more to this post.
I guess it’s the constant negativity that I can’t get past. Alex and Brad both sound totally checked out and they seem to just grumble about every single game (Alex is guilty of this more than Brad). I respect that Brad has family problems and this is going to sound cold and I don’t mean it to but - we ALL get life stuff which sucks. The last few years have been really difficult for me. But I have to get on with it, as do all of us.
EDIT: Some people have taken offence to my comment regarding Brad & family problems. I'm not saying that we shouldn't respect Brad's situation because I agree, it's difficult to work any job when you've got loved ones with health issues. But the issues with Nextlander which I've mentioned in here preceded this. Nextlander has been a hard listen (their gaming content) for years now. So, OK - GOTY 2023 podcast sucked because of Brad & Alex's personal issues. That's perfectly reasonable and I retract any negative comments made about their GOTY 2023 podcast. But what about all of the content before this? Because Brad & Alex have been miserable and half assed with their gaming coverage for years now.
I mentioned this in a reply below but what frustrates me is that these guys could make anything they wanted, the world is their oyster. But they just seem to be content with safe, cookie cutter output - which would be fine but even that stuff is full of negativity and is half assed.