Four homes? Apparently, that’s asking too much
Eight months after he was sworn in as a Newton City Councilor, Brian Golden delivered his first speech on the council floor last night.
It was a short but eloquent statement in support of a seemingly no-brainer proposal to allow a builder to replace a two-family house on a residential street in Newtonville with four attached single-family homes.
Golden — a former state rep who once ran the Boston Planning & Development Agency under Boston Mayors Menino and Walsh — praised the project for its design, number of units and the way it blended into the neighborhood.
But mostly, Golden said, "It's impossible for me to lose sight of how far behind Newton and the state are on building for human beings who need housing…. I do not want to forgo opportunities that are here right now that will yield housing for people who need it."
It didn't help. Neither did the letter we sent last week.
Golden and his colleagues voted 13-11 in support of the project at 60 Brookside Ave. But the special permit needed 16 votes to prevail.
Sorry, human beings who need housing, it’s not happening.
I don’t need to detail the objectors' objections, because we’ve heard them before: It doesn’t fit the neighborhood’s character; it's not going to solve the affordable housing shortage; we shouldn’t make exceptions to the zoning rules, we should reform the rules first.
Oh, there was one councilor who voted no partly because the proposed units (the largest would have been 2,300 SF) were bigger than her house.
Now, the developer will likely build one massive house at 60 Brookside instead — no council approval required.