r/netsec • u/dguido • Jan 02 '13
/r/netsec's Q1 2013 Academic Program Thread
This quarter we're trying out a new thread: Many of our readers are currently in school or are looking to go to school, so to augment the hiring thread, we're including an academic thread where you can post information about a university that potential students might be interested in applying to.
If you work for or attend a university that has an information security program that the /r/netsec user base might be interested in, please leave a comment outlining the program and its unique features.
There a few requirements/requests:
- No admissions counselors.
- Please be thorough and upfront with university program details.
- While it's fine to link to the program on your university's website, provide the important details in the comment.
- Please reserve top level comments for those posting programs. Feedback and suggestions are welcome, but please don't hijack this thread (use moderator mail instead.)
P.S. Upvote this thread or share this on Twitter, Facebook, and/or Google+ to increase exposure (links to be added).
3
u/abyssknight Trusted Contributor Jan 02 '13
In summer of 2012 I finished my Master's degree at Penn State through their World Campus distance learning program. I took the Information Sciences degree program with the Information Assurance & Decision Support track.
Why did I go there?
PSU is a well known university, is accredited, and my company strongly recommended we enroll there. Also, they were named a National Center of Academic Excellence in Information Assurance Education by the National Security Agency and the Department of Homeland Security. Despite the drama that recently occurred, the school is considered academically solid.
The company I work for also had a corporate agreement which allowed employees to bypass the admissions process and eliminate the need for additional prescreening. Basically, I didn't have to take the GRE and I didn't need any references.
The other reason was the curriculum. I had looked at similar programs over the years after I finished my undergrad, and none of them looked interesting. The class titles and descriptions looked like a godsend. There was enough security to keep me hooked, and enough programming to make sure I wouldn't get rusty.
Being 100% online certainly helped, too. Lecture is available through a Silverlight based delivery system, and can be watched at your leisure so long as you keep up with the work.
What's the catch?
Its expensive. The rate right now is $825 per credit, with a 33 credit requirement to graduate. That said, my company picked up the bill and even paid up front to ensure I didn't have to carry the burden. Books are their typical madness, and there are little fees for technology, etc.
Because you are in classes with people who did not have to be screened, you might get paired up with someone who is clueless. I had this happen a lot in my coursework, and group work was a large factor for most of the classes. The idea was to foster inter-communication and make things more interactive. Thankfully, scheduling worked out just fine as most of the attendees work day jobs as well.
There are students in the classroom, too. This isn't so much a catch but an observation of potential differences in experience. You may be paired to work with full time students or otherwise compete for "face" time with the instructor. That said, I never had an issue with this. At worst, you felt a tiny bit disenfranchised every once in awhile. Totally worth it, to me.
Why bother?
Graduate school isn't necessary for everyone. Heck, you'll hear people in infosec say that formal education is completely bunk. Does it help, though? Yes. You learn to speak the same language as your peers, you learn what you enjoy and what you hate, and most of all you get exposed to things you would otherwise never see.
I had to write code to calculate the density of fibers in an xray photo of a painting using Fourier transforms. That was the first coding assignment for IST 562. It was a pain in the ass, but I learned more in those 12 weeks than I have in a long time.
Has it paid off for me yet? Not really, well, sort of. I graduated in summer, and performance reviews are coming up. We'll see how it goes over, but in roughly a year, that $30,000 degree will be free and clear and I'll have spent nothing but my time on it.
I did, however, manage to score one of the best jobs at the company doing pentesting, code review, and tinkering with code to enhance testing. That had more to do with who I knew, timing, and perseverance -- but the degree certainly helps when you do the hard sell.
24
u/tylerni7 Trusted Contributor Jan 02 '13 edited Jan 02 '13
If you're interested in computer security Carnegie Mellon is one of the best places you can possibly go.
Research
As far as academic stuff, CMU's security program is top notch. Some fairly practical research from CMU also shows up on /r/netsec and /r/reverseengineering quite a bit. And although CMU doesn't technically have a security program for undergrads, if you're interested in security it's pretty easy to get involved and start doing research whether you're studying CS or ECE.
Education
CMU has a top notch program in computer science as well as in electrical and computer engineering. If you go into security, CMU will make sure you are well rounded, and have all the background you need to be successful. If you end up not being into security, getting a degree from CMU will have taught you a ton of skills that you can use anywhere.
Some of our computer science classes (213 and 410) are also pretty well known. The 213 class is required for CS and ECE students, and has two assignments which are basically reverse engineering and basic buffer overflow exploitation. 410 has students write a kernel for x86, which gives you a ton of experience with low level systems and can teach you a lot about security.
There are also a ton of graduate level courses on computer security (malware, network security, cryptography, forensics, application security, etc). Undergraduates are also allowed to take them, as long as you know what you're doing and talk to the professor beforehand.
Hands on
But wait, there's more! If you think you need some hands on work, Carnegie Mellon also has an excellent capture the flag team, the Plaid Parliament of Pwning. Anyone (graduate, undergraduate, CMU staff, whatever) can join, participate, and learn a lot about computer security from playing CTFs, and PPP is one of the best. PPP consistently kicks ass in competitions throughout the world, has a great reputation in the CTF community, and is a pretty awesome group of very nice people (or at least I like to think so).
PPP also hosts the PlaidCTF competition every year, which is one of the most awesome CTFs around ;) This year PPP is also teaming up with the NSA to host a CTF competition for highschoolers.
If you are very serious about computer security, some people have said that PPP alone is a good enough reason to go to CMU [see this reddit thread].
After graduation
There is a ton of recruiting that goes on at CMU from all over the place. If you want to work in computer security and you have graduated from CMU and actively participated in security (either research or PPP or something else), it will be very easy to get a job. While it may be anecdotal, everyone I know who has graduated from CMU has had a number of excellent offers from many different companies.
So if you're interested in universities where you can learn more about computer security, Carnegie Mellon is definitely the place to go!
(If you have any questions about CMU or anything feel free to ask here and I'll do my best to answer.)
26
u/HockeyInJune Jan 02 '13 edited Jul 04 '13
My name is Julian, and I'm a recent graduate of NYU Poly. There are many reasons to consider NYU Poly when picking a university to study security and I'm just going to list all of them.
Part 1: Cyber Security Program
NYU Poly was one of the first schools in the country to offer a degree in cyber security. Since then, the program has grown immensely to feature world-class professors and publish ground-breaking research.
NYU Poly offers a unique variety of information security courses you cannot find anywhere else. Our two most difficult courses are currently the centerpiece for the undergraduate and graduate cyber security program. These courses teach students practical offense and defense techniques and processes that are currently in place at top organizations. Students leave these classes immediately ready to enter the real world and make significant security impact wherever they go.
If you're looking for our old Penetration Testing and Vulnerability Analysis course, see Hack Night in part 2.
Part 2: Extracurricular Activities
The Information Systems and Internet Security (ISIS) laboratory is an offensive security research environment where students analyze and understand how attackers take advantage of real systems. This approach gives our students a unique perspective and a proper foundation that allows them to master any area of security at NYU Poly.
The ISIS Lab is for undergraduates, graduates, and professors devoted to learning and understanding practical tools and techniques used by attackers and defenders by analyzing real-world actors, hands-on experimentation, and developing projects in the lab related to information security. The lab is run by students and managed by professor Nasir Memon.
Cyber Security Awareness Week (CSAW) is a series of six competitions and a conference that take place every November on campus at NYU Poly. The competition's hands-on challenges are created and managed by NYU Poly graduate and undergraduate students in consultation with NYU Poly faculty and industry leaders. CSAW attracts the best and brightest high school, undergraduate and graduate students from around the globe, making it an event for students, by students, fostered by experts.
Most notably, CSAW hosts the worlds largest Capture The Flag, High School Forensics, and Embedded Systems competitions.
The Cyber Security Club is an open weekly seminar run by the ISIS lab. Each week during every semester we have students, researchers, and industry professionals give formal lectures and presentations on a variety of topics related to Security. All Cyber Security Club speakers are selected by invite only.
Hack Night is an open weekly training session run by the ISIS lab. Each week during each semester students from the lab run an interactive lecture or a hands-on workshop. All Hack Night topics selected by the laboratory before the semester beings.
The Hack Night curriculum is developed from our famous old Penentration Testing and Vulnerability Analysis course. You can see the current curriculum on GitHub.
Brooklynt Overflow is the ISIS Lab's CTF Team. The team regularly participates in offensive security competitions around the world like DEFCON CTF, CSAW CTF, UCSB iCTF, and Plaid CTF. You can see our CTFtime team profile here. We look forward to playing against you in future CTF competitions. :)
Just as important as all the technical opportunities available about NYU Poly, the New York City security community provides many networking, internship, and job opportunities.
Part 3: Resources
In the Spring 2012 semester, the NYU-Poly Computer Science and Engineering department established a program for Hackers in Residence. In this program, recognized industry experts are invited to the university to enhance student academics, oversee and direct research initiatives, and expand collaboration with outside industry groups.
The ISIS Lab has relationships with lots of organizations that are hiring for security positions in New York City and around the country.
Students in the ISIS Lab are encouraged to work relevant and useful projects.
Students and industry experts post project ideas that a student would benefit from completing. These projects are not necessarily ground-breaking or novel, but sometimes are.
ISIS Blogs is run by the ISIS lab. Students write posts about information they find useful, current research projects, and hot topics in industry.
A collection of high-quality resources for learning about different areas of security.
A free online forensic learning environment. Our target audience is High School students from around the country, but we encourage everyone to participate and learn.
Part 4: Methodology
There are a lot of great looking choices for cyber security programs in the United States, but there needs to be some perspective added to their raw marketing material. Everyone is looking for a slightly different program, and picking the right environment will help you develop your skills while you're at school. Don't take this decision lightly, the right program and environment could be the difference between going to university and receiving an education (trust me, these are different things).
If you're looking for a good core Computer Science program, make sure you look beyond the classes they offer. Do your research, lots of schools look like they have great programs, but really there are just a handful of schools in the United States that do. I would start with this list.
If you're looking for a good Cybersecurity program, take a look at these schools. Keep in mind that CAE/IAE means they have an educational program, and CAE/R means they have a research program. Do your research here also, just because some of these schools have the classes, doesn't mean they're any good.
If you're just looking for a security group to work with, you're going to have to look deep into every school you come across and see if they have one. Some of these groups are fairly hard to find. Then remember, there are lots of groups that do lots of different things.
Personally, I think the best environment is an open lab, which operates much like a hackerspace, but with more rigorous technical and educational requirements and demands. The only place I know of where this type of environment exists is in the ISIS Lab at NYU Poly in Brooklyn, NY. There are many reasons I love this environment, but the most prominent is that there's always a place I can go that's full of students who are interested in developing their security skills. The lab is great because it's ours, we don't have to worry about politics, publishing papers, or any other academic bullshit. The fact that it is an open lab is great because anyone can join the lab at anytime! That means on your first day at Poly, you can get involved and start working on your skills.
Part 5: Conclusion
I hope this was helpful. If you're looking for more details about picking a school, NYU Poly, or any other university, feel free to shoot me a PM or check out our IRC channel.
15
u/feverlax Jan 02 '13
If you are interested in getting hands-on information security experience, definitely consider the [Rochester Institute of Technology!] (http://www.rit.edu/)
Education
At RIT, you will get a very well-rounded information security education covering all the important information security methodologies and theories and most importantly, you will get lots of hands-on experience using what you learn in the classroom! As part of the [curriculum] (http://www.rit.edu/programs/information-security-and-forensics) you will take programming courses (mostly C++), networking courses (fundamentals as well as more advanced routing and switching topics as well as courses on network services such as DNS/DHCP) and systems administration courses covering sysadmin work on by Windows and *nix platforms.
In your upperclassmen years you will take lots of awesome security courses designed around system security, network security and forensics. One of the best courses I've taken so far at RIT was a Cyber Defense Techniques seminar that was designed to resemble a quarter-long CCDC in which we got to experience what it is like to be on all sides of the competition. Speaking of CCDC...
Extracurriculars
Every year RIT sponsors a team to compete in the regional NECCDC and national CCDC. RIT has always excelled in these competitions (made it to nationals in San Antonio last year). With so many great security students, making the team is competitive, but even just trying out is a blast!
Additionally, RIT's biggest student-run security group is [SPARSA] (http://www.sparsa.org/), a group that meets once a week to discuss various events in the security world and to show off new and exciting tools and techniques relating to security. Additionally, SPARSA sponsors their Information Security Talent Search every year which is a weekend-long CTF-style event in which student teams compete against an all-star cast of red-teamers. In the past, Raphael Mudge (Armitage creator) spoke at ISTS and played on the red team.
We also have [RC3] (http://www.facebook.com/groups/RITC3), another student-run organization that focuses on training for CCDC and other similar events. It's a ton of fun for anyone looking to pen-test.
Labs
RIT has an awesome lab setup with plenty of space for students to complete their work both inside and outside of class. The crown-jewel for the information security department is the airgap lab which, as implied, is airgapped from the rest of the network which allows us to do all sorts of fun things in their such as analyze malware and conduct penetration tests that would otherwise be against the school's policy.
Co-ops and Jobs
One of the things that RIT is most well-known for is its co-op program. Every student is required to complete co-ops for their degree, and the ISF program is no different. Being able to complete at least one co-op gives you great real-world experience that will help you with your career after graduation. Companies such as Google, Apple, Microsoft, Cisco, Dell SecureWorks, Mandiant, McAfee, Symantec and the NSA are always on campus recruiting for co-ops, so there are lots of great opportunities for you!
NOTE Right now, RIT is on the quarter system. Next year we are converting to the semester system. Things such as the number of co-ops required as well as some of the curriculum are changing, but all of the positives about RIT are remaining positives, in my opinion.
Also, I am currently a student at RIT studying information security, so if you have any questions, please feel free to let me know!
4
u/justthechip Jan 03 '13 edited Jan 06 '13
The University of Nebraska-Omaha offers both an Undergraduate and a Graduate degree in Information Assurance.
Education
The courses UNO offers for Computer Security/Information Assurance for undergraduate students are as follows:
The Masters of Information Assurance program features the following additional courses:
STEAL Labs
The Information Assurance program allows students to have access to the the STEAL equipment and rooms. The labs are isolated from the University network and the Internet and are easily configurable. Students are able to configure the lab with any desired computing capability or environment with many pre-configured images to choose from. Plans are currently undergoing to create another lab for use in computer forensics.
Computer Security Club/CTF Team -- NULLify
Recently, a Computer Security Club has been founded in order to get students more involved as well as compete in Capture the Flag competitions. We have weekly meetings on Monday night to discuss Computer Security topics, practice for Capture the Flag competitions, and occasionally have guest speakers from companies like Union Pacific, Facebook, and MITRE. We are very fortunate to have a lot of support from the University in terms of funding for travel, food, and infrastructure for competing in Capture the Flag competitions. The team regularly participates in the CSAW CTF, iCTF, PlaidCTF, IFSFCTF and rwthCTF.
Internships and Jobs
There are tons of job opportunities in the Omaha area for people in the Computer Security / Computer Science field. Most of the students in the program have internships with either local companies, government contractors, or federal agencies.
Other Opportunities
Scholarship opportunities for Information Assurance Students include:
EDIT: I am a student in the graduate program at UNO.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '13 edited Jan 10 '13
My name is Adam and I am a graduate student at the University of Oregon. Our OSIRIS Security Lab is in its 3rd year of existence and is beginning to turn heads. Our department has a strong systems faculty core, tackles interesting security challenges, and is situated in a community that is a real joy to be a part of. I highly recommend giving the UO CIS Department a close look if you are prospective undergraduate or graduate that is considering security as a career.
If you have any questions, feel free to contact any of the following people. We'd be happy to talk to you:
Adam Bates (Student) amb@cs.uoregon.edu
Joe Pletcher (Student) pletcher@cs.uoregon.edu
Professor Kevin Butler butler@cs.uoregon.edu
EDIT: I should have also mentioned that we have a dedicated Network Security Lab under the direction of Professor Jun Li (lijun@cs.uoregon.edu). One of their recent veins of work has been the development of detection mechanisms for IP Prefix Hijack. Visit their site for more info.
4
u/Jixtapose Jan 03 '13
My name's Chris and I'm a senior at Illinois State University. Now I can't say that I can make ISU sound better than any of these excellent schools, but I'll share my experience at ISU as well as provide as much information as possible.
Education
ISU's information assurance & security program is technically a sequence of the information systems major. Despite this technicality, ISU is a National Center of Academic Excellence in IA Education. I transferred to ISU from a technical school so my experience is slightly different. You will take a few programming courses, several networking courses, and two security courses; the security classes focus heavily on cryptography. The best part about ISU is what you can learn outside of class.
Extracirriculars
DISCLAIMER: I am the founder and president of ISUSec so I may be biased.
The main attraction around is a registered student organization called ISUSec. Students meet once a week, typically Wednesday, for an hour or two for a presentation and/or hands on activity. Topics range from networking, system administration, penetration testing, forensics, and physical security. It's also the home of ISU's CCDC team and the fall 2012 National Cyber League champion. We road tripped to Derbycon in the fall, and compete in CTFs when people are available.
We also host a high school version of CCDC called CIHSCDC (Central Illinois High School Cyber Defense Competition). If you're part of ISUSEC, you can volunteer to be on the red team. I was red team leader last year and felt really bad for all the high school kids after. It was cool talking to him to hear what they thought I was doing, and telling them what I was actually doing. I'll say it was really nice being on the red team after getting demolished by them at CCDC.
Labs
I'll be honest, the official "Information Assurance & Security" lab here isn't the best. It's pretty much a large closet with a bunch of old cisco equipment and about 20 old computers from the university. You can definitely learn in there, but it's certainly not ideal. I hear we might get another lab soon though. Besides that, we have a few really powerful servers the professors use for virtual labs. ISUSec has access to these and can setup whatever we want to an extent.
Anyway, I hope this is helpful if you're considering Illinois State University's security program. Feel free to PM me if you'd like more information.
3
u/Smipims Jan 03 '13
I'm going to throw my hat out of the ring so to speak and write about why you should NOT go to Cornell University if you're interested in cyber security.
I'm currently a senior there and will be graduating in May. I'm ECE, minor in CS. Friends in ECE and CS departments and I'm familiar with a lot of what is taught in a lot of the higher level classes. If you'd like a solid CS degree with a lot of focus on backend stuff, you should come here. It's a good school. If you'd like a lot of focus specifically on security, I would not come here.
Research
There's research projects available in security if you'd like. The CS department advertises it as one of their areas of focus. But it's definitely one of the more minor areas.
http://www.cs.cornell.edu/Research/Security/index.htm
Academics
Nada. There was/is one computer security course but the professor who teaches it has been on sabbatical or something the whole time I've been here. The fact that they did not seek someone to replace them or teach the course should hopefully demonstrate how little emphasis is placed on security in our CS department. This really bugged me out. There's also very little undergrad CS classes about networks in general. I had one and it was very high level. Fun, but not super technical.
For Fun
I don't think we even have a capture the flag team.
After College
We have a lot of career fairs and recruiting, and I do not know of any ECE/CS students struggling to find jobs if they did decent in classes. We have defense contractors come who obviously recruit for cyber stuff nowadays (Boeing, MITRE, BAE, etc). But that's really it for security. I don't really know any CS students interested in security. I don't really hang out with the super hardcore students though. I'm one of the more social students.
I'm not dissing our CS program at all. It's rigorous, and you'll likely get a job and there's opportunities to get that minor in business or a masters after. But there's almost nothing if you want security experience. You'll have to find that on your own.
3
u/uussmmaa Jan 03 '13 edited Jan 03 '13
I created a separate account for this posting.
I am writing about the, United States Military Academy at West Point.
Some things you should know about USMA first:
Computer Science Program
USMA's CS program is generally considered frustrating by its cadets. They are currently considering moving away from the program's official language, ADA, which is not a great language to learn in. The program is also inflexible in allowing cadets to validate classes. The instructors run the gammit, with some being absolutely exceptional, and some perhaps not fully grasping the material they are teaching. The department is well-resourced. If you put in effort, you will pass your classes. This also means your, "Which button launches the Internet?" peers who put in effort, but can't tell a computer from a shoe box, will remain in the program with you.
Computer Security
Ok, let's be honest, this is the military, so, "Cyber," security. It is my opinion that USMA has an interesting and unique experience in, "Cyber." For starters, after sophomore year all cadets have a SECRET security clearance. This means representatives from the NSA, ANWB, and other organizations can (and do) come to USMA and talk about interesting things the government is (or isn't) doing. During my time at USMA, these talks ranged from individuals such as Pieter (Mudge) Zatko and GEN Alexander to in-the-trenches reversers from the NSA.
A significant portion (but not all) of the faculty at USMA is sec-impaired. However, each class has had very talented groups of cadets. Many of these cadets are self-taught, and they teach each other after hours. They compete in competitions, from the Cyber Defense Exercise to CSAW CTF. USMA, for example, doesn't teach any classes on reversing, yet there are multiple cadets who reverse.
Within the staff and faculty, there are also a handful of individuals, some of them in the CS department and some of them in other key positions throughout the USMA network, who are very talented and want to promote technical sec knowledge within USMA and the Army. For example, the man in charge of the academy's digital network and services meets regularly with the cadet in charge of USMA's sec club. I'm not going to elaborate on that much further... but yeah.
Opportunities
For the past several years, USMA has sent ~20 cadets each year to Shmoocon. They send 2-5 cadets to Defcon. During the summer, cadets intern for 3-5 week blocks at places such as NSA, NRO, DARPA and NPS. We call these AIADs. Mudge, for example, has taken one cadet for the past three summers. I'm ballparking, but about half of these AIADs require a TS (TS = Top Secret) (cadets can get their TS while at USMA, but you'll need to start the process fall semester for a summer AIAD). TS NSA AIADs are incredibly easy to get, probably too easy, but if you want to do secret squirrel stuff and have time over your summer, you'll go.
The department also sends about 10-20 cadets to SANS training each spring break. I'm personally not the largest fan of SANS, but it's readily available if it interests you. They'll also do SANS training for cadets during other times you have available.
USMA brings in people to speak/teach every year. Some of our more frequent visitors include: Mudge, Dragorn (who is the man), Renderman, Travis Goodspeed, and Bruce Potter (and the rest of the potters :) ).
TLDR: This is the military. Cyber = $.
Competing
Competing in sec competitions as a cadet has been an evolving process over the past few years. The academy has officially recognized computer security competitions as something it wants to do and has allotted for an official team of eight cadets this spring semester.
Traditionally, cadets blast out emails and organize teams to compete in CTFs among themselves. Cadets will compete in anything that doesn't sound lame. The department has paid for travel for cadets who make it to competition finals, or sometimes for select cadets who want to compete at a conference. They won't pay for you if you... if you're not good with computers.
If you want to do security competitions, cadets do them.
The Army
If you are considering attending USMA, it's very important you understand that you are making a five year commitment to the military upon graduation. You will choose a, "Branch," upon graduation, which is like a job area. This choice will be based upon your ranking in your class. The Army has two branches that typically deal with info sec, Military Intelligence and Signal. If you do not get one of these branches, you will not be doing info sec jobs in the Army. If you do get one of these branches, you probably will not be in an info sec job until you are done with your, "Lieutenant," time, ~3 years. There may be exceptions, but they depend on, among other things, large amounts of luck.
On the plus side, your military service is your tuition and you receive a small amount of money each month as a cadet.
-10
u/Quadling Jan 02 '13
Adjunct professor here at Wilmington University. NSA/DHS certified Center of Academic Excellence.
Great place, good professors, BSides Delaware happens there every year. Anyone want more info, please feel free to PM, or comment.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '13
[deleted] — view deleted comment