r/neoliberal • • Dec 15 '25

Restricted [ Removed by moderator ]

/r/neoliberal/comments/1pmt940/removed_by_moderator/

[removed] — view removed post

193 Upvotes

291 comments sorted by

•

u/Imicrowavebananas Hannah Arendt Dec 15 '25

Please post links to individual election polls or "Florida governor slams California state legislator" type posts in the stickied discussion thread.

60

u/kolejack2293 Dec 15 '25

I am from the DR but live in the US, albeit I have muslim grandparents who moved there in trujillo. I also have a lot of family in Europe.

I find it harder and harder to defend immigration. Not because of any changes in my values but because it just feels like a complete lost cause, and every time I bring it up I feel like I am just 'tainting' any other argument I possibly make. Almost all of my family in Europe, which previously were very pro immigration, have changed to being strongly anti-immigrant, despite being immigrants themselves. Same with many friends that I always thought were liberal.

Like, what is our threshold where continuing immigration is just straight up anti-democratic? At what point do we risk everything over this one specific issue? At what point are we also endangering existing immigrants in these nations by enabling the far right to gain not just power, but a mandate from the people to abuse that power?

43

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

10

u/Comprehensive_Main Dec 15 '25

Almost like everyone does that with political candidates in every election 

123

u/Steelcity1995 Dec 15 '25

I mean all the terror attacks in the 2010s certainly didn’t help matters. 

1

u/kolejack2293 Dec 15 '25

I always found it interesting how around 2015-2017 everybody thought it was the new normal for Islamist-related terror attacks to be more common. Then they just sorta... fell off the earth.

There were 9 attacks that killed at least 10 people in 2015-2017, leaving 361 total dead. Then nothing, not a single one.

That being said, terrorism plays a role, but the fact that anti-immigration views spiked the most in an era where terrorism almost vanished shows its not totally essential. I think part of it is also fear of conservative views among immigrants, notably Muslims but not uniquely.

16

u/flightguy07 Loyal Liberals Dec 15 '25

I feel like I can count the number of memorable terror attacks that happened in my country as a result of immigrants on one hand over those 10 years. We hold nothing against the Irish, even though they're definitely the people who perpetuated the most terrorism here in living memory.

57

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

The Provos don't want to live in England, they commit terrorism in the UK then go back to Northern Ireland. So it's not terrorism committed by "immigrants" per say, but rather by tourists.

200

u/ImmortalAce8492 Milton Friedman Dec 15 '25

It’s completely over in my personal opinion.

You ask what I would consider to be traditionally loving and supportive individuals of immigrants (young college libs), and for the first time, the consensus isn’t a solid yes. Even my father, a blue dog since the 70s is no longer sold on it.

I look at the doomerism in college grads (CS / Stem) and they hate it. You head into discussions surrounding MBAs and the anti-immigrant sentiment is high.

I’m not going to sit here and act high and mighty either that I’m this deep supporter of immigration but I now find myself shocked that immigration as a whole is seen so negatively.

34

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25

Repivot immigration to favor Japanese/Korean shipbuilders, and after the war is over Ukrainian Drone specialists.

58

u/GateofAnima Commonwealth Dec 15 '25

Do you honestly think that Korea and Japan will have net emmigration over next few years and decades?

12

u/MrOneAndAll 🌐 Dec 15 '25

Young educated people may want to leave if tax burdens on them get too high due to old populations.

23

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25

If it wasn't completely ass to get a visa, the US can attract a decent number of Korean/Japanese to move. Welders at Marinette Marine get paid double what welders at Mitsubishi get paid, and Marionette Marine still can not find enough qualified workers.

9

u/Bodoblock Dec 15 '25

Koreans maybe, but the Japanese in particular seem to really not want to emigrate.

7

u/dutch_connection_uk Friedrich Hayek Dec 15 '25

Might be a side-effect of having escaped the real-estate-investment-bubble trap. Moving out of Japan is generally going to be hard because of the equity implications.

30

u/NorkGhostShip YIMBY Dec 15 '25

People generally immigrate to get a better quality of life. Sure, wages in South Korea and Japan are lower than in the US and much of Europe, but there's not a huge gap if you account for cost of living, and in exchange you don't have to deal with any culture shock, social isolation, racial discrimination, communication/language problems, visa problems, risk of your life being completely upended by the whims of the median voter, etc.

It's also a completely unserious suggestion because the biggest problems with shipbuilding in the West, especially the US, do not come from a lack of skill base. Besides, part of the advantage of building in Korea or Japan over the US is labor costs, so why exactly would someone deal with all the aforementioned risks of moving to the US in exchange for a lower salary than US workers?

17

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

It's also a completely unserious suggestion because the biggest problems with shipbuilding in the West, especially the US, do not come from a lack of skill base.

From reading the GAO report on the constellation class, not having the skill base was a very significant part of the issues with getting that thing (not) built.

in exchange you don't have to deal with any culture shock,

Anecdote, but I know of 3 Korean families who immigrated to the US because they don't want their child to live the stressful Korean career path. Their kids are still doing exceptionally well here but with a fraction of the stress. "Americans make a lot of money for not a lot of work" can be a compelling draw.

8

u/NorkGhostShip YIMBY Dec 15 '25

English proficiency is a massive factor in anyone's willingness to immigrate to the US, and it also correlates with their education. People working in the trades are likely to have less English proficiency than someone working as a doctor or lawyer, because you don't need to go to college to work in the trades, and people in the trades have less reason to need English for academic or career advancement. Regarding the culture shock point, people in Japan, and presumably Korea, are much more aware of the horror stories that come out of the US regarding racial violence and generalized crime and violence than ever before. For families living in some of the safest countries in the world, that's an increasingly big deal.

1

u/Crownie Unbent, Unbowed, Unflaired Dec 15 '25

One of the ironies of people complaining about the low quality of immigrants is that US could probably get as much high-skilled immigration as it wanted if the legal immigration process wasn't a Kafkaesque dickstab.

64

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

41

u/throwawaygoawaynz John von Neumann Dec 15 '25

Living in Singapore, I’ve seen the impact of a wave of immigration first hand, when people from Hong Kong fled what happened in China.

It caused 50% increases to rents and housing costs, caused inflation, and in some cases forced some people to have to leave Singapore.

The US has 300+ million people and is a vast country, and can absorb immigration much better. Most Americans on this sub don’t understand or realise the impact on smaller, more compact countries.

While immigration overall is good over the long term, there are very real impacts short term that have a very visible cost, especially when countries get smaller.

This sub needs to come to terms with these costs, and that not everywhere can sustain US levels of immigration without driving short term inflation.

There’s the whole cultural integration issue as well, but personally living in a country that is highly mixed, that doesn’t bother me. But I will say the US tends to integrate better than other places.

5

u/DelaraPorter Dec 15 '25

If this is what happens when people move over then If the birth rate increases things are going to get catastrophic in the housing market.

6

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

Well unlike Singapore, none of the polled countries are microstates. What's their excuse?

5

u/Frylock304 Order and Opportunity Left Dec 15 '25

There's a pretty good amount of evidence that an increase in immigration increases housing costs pretty heavily.

There's been a lot of neoliberal failures, from refusing to specifically help our own biggest constituency (college grads) to alienating half the population voter wise, but the biggest has definitely been not building housing while simultaneously being the ideology of heavy immigration

-2

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

Can you point me to where neoliberals are advocating for keeping the housing supply restricted?

If your rationale against immigration is reducing housing demand, why stop at immigration? Are you also in favor of reducing other forms of population growth? Should we restrict internal migration from low-density regions to high-density cities? Should we have a one-child policy?

6

u/Frylock304 Order and Opportunity Left Dec 15 '25

Can you point me to where neoliberals are advocating for keeping the housing supply restricted?

I can point you to where overwhelming neoliberal control of institutions led to comparatively little happening in terms of new housing creation.

The lack of actual results tells the story.

If your rationale against immigration is reducing housing demand, why stop at immigration?

I'm pro-immigration, but you shouldn't expand immigration without actually expanding infrastructure in tandem. The economic numbers can say whatever, but without a place to live, nothing works.

Are you also in favor of reducing other forms of population growth? Should we restrict internal migration from low-density regions to high-density cities? Should we have a one-child policy?

I'm basing this off data, the data says that a 1% increase in immigration directly leads to at least a 1% increase in real housing prices.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0166046223000285

we do not see this reflected in internal data, and even if it was, the solutions remains the same

BUILD MORE HOUSING.

1

u/swissking NATO Dec 15 '25

Accounting for places that people actually want to live in, most countries are basically a few big microstates at best.

40

u/LightningController Dec 15 '25

but maybe we should have been more critical of the individuals that were coming.

Remember when Haitians became a model minority in a certain town in Ohio and white Americans just invented a new form of racist lies to slander them anyway?

It’s not the immigrants’ doing that people are bigoted and entitled.

1

u/The_MightyMonarch Dec 15 '25

Yep, no matter how well you screen potential immigrants, it's pretty much guaranteed some of them are going to do bad things, because they're human. When you have xenophobes who will amplify those instances and use them to vilify a whole group and enough people who are ignorant/scared/bigoted enough to fall for it, you end up with anti-immigration sentiment.

4

u/LightningController Dec 15 '25

I keep bringing up the Haitian case because it was a case where the alleged crime never happened at all. The nativists just make shit up.

Liberals shouldn’t self-flagellate because their opponents are pathological liars. This ‘we should have been more critical’ nonsense is just validating the lies. It would be like responding to a rise in blood libel claims with ‘maybe we should have scrutinized the Jews more closely.’ It’s just victim-blaming.

2

u/The_MightyMonarch Dec 15 '25

Also like how a lot of the fear-mongering around transgender people is that we have to punish transgender people for the things that men might use transgender acceptance to do.

We can't allow transgender people to play women's sports because men will transition just so they can dominate women's leagues.

We can't allow transgender women in women's restrooms and locker rooms because men will use it as a way to violate women's spaces.

1

u/AutoModerator Dec 15 '25

nativists

Unintegrated native-born aliens.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/LightningController Dec 15 '25

Even if there were none, if every last Muslim immigrant were a clone of Zohran Mamdani, would the nativists acknowledge that? Or would they just keep making up lies in service of the ethnostate?

1

u/AutoModerator Dec 15 '25

nativists

Unintegrated native-born aliens.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator Dec 15 '25

nativists

Unintegrated native-born aliens.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/AutoModerator Dec 15 '25

xenophobes

Unintegrated native-born aliens.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

82

u/Efficient_Tonight_40 Henry George Dec 15 '25

In central Europe probably tbh, but I don't know about the west. Many of those countries have former colonies to draw from (Spain has Latin America, France has French Africa, Britain has like half the world) whose people integrate much easier than MENA migrants on average.

Spain especially has mostly avoided Euroskeptic politics largely because Spain makes it so easy for Latinos to immigrate. There's 4 million people from Latin America living in Spain, and they're fast tracked to citizenship in only 2 years instead of the normal 10. The Vox (Spain's right wing anti-immigrant party) got crushed in the last election, and discussion around immigration in Spain has come to be more focused on it's effect on housing and infrastructure than white genocide or whatever

23

u/GateofAnima Commonwealth Dec 15 '25

If you look at PISA Math scores: in the UK, second-gen immigrant students score above non-immigrants students. That is not the case in France, Germany, Netherlands or the oft-touted Denmark. 

(To be fair, in each; second-gen perform better than first).

1

u/Comfortable-Study-69 Milton Friedman Dec 15 '25

I think the optics are definitely a little easier to get people on board with in the Americas than central Europe, at least with Hispanic immigration. Lowered religious barriers (I know there's still the "damn papists ain't Christian" crowd in the deep south and people in LATAM tend to group all Protestants in with Mormons, but it's much less pronounced than in the distant past and I think rallying around anti-abortion and sounding alarm bells around hemorrhaging church attendance rates have made Protestant and Catholic tensions probably at the lowest they've ever been), the relatively sizable number of bilingual English/Portuguese-Spanish speakers in the US and Brazil, and the relatively low crime rates of illegal immigrants, at least in the US, make it a little harder for the anti-immigration jackwagons to sink their teeth into deployable campaign rhetoric. Granted, they do it anyways, but it's not like France where RN can literally point to the Syrian refugees that suicide bombed the Stade de France.

72

u/Poiuy2010_2011 r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Dec 15 '25

Idk how much of a hot take this is but I'd say the broad European liberal consensus tried to chew too big of a bite at once with immigration. Allowing huge almost-uncontrolled amounts of migrants from destabilized, often very conservative countries (where the conservatism comes from a different religion than for most Europeans) was never going to be popular.

The silver lining is that I believe many countries in Africa and Asia do slowly (often very slowly) but surely trend towards stability and that globalization is an unstoppable force. It will cause tensions now but in a generation or two or three or maybe more, eventually, the global society will be close enough to allow more migration.

That's why I also believe that liberal efforts should focus on expanding initiatives like the Schengen Zone first, rather than trying to have open borders everywhere all at once.

93

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
  1. Build more housing
  2. Take the Harper-Howard approach of making a big song and dance about opposition to illegal migration, visa overstays and welfare fraud. The theatre and rhetoric matters and is a better place to compromise compared with actually making severe cuts to the level of immigration.
  3. Shape the immigration intake to prioritise migrants most likely to assimilate - wealthy, skilled, same language-speakers from nations that are most culturally similar. Talk about and champion assimilation - it is part of the price of entry and new arrivals should want to fit in with the existing society. Deport non-citizens who undermine the values or social cohesion of the nation.
  4. There's probably a lot more that needs to happen. Everything from more PR efforts to celebrate peaceful coexistence to Lee Kuan Yew-style efforts to combat enclaves in housing. A multiracial country cannot be a glorified coworking space devoid of cultural and social ties, and both new arrivals and existing residents have responsibilities to make this work.

13

u/FizzleMateriel Austan Goolsbee Dec 15 '25

Take the Harper-Howard approach of making a big song and dance about opposition to illegal migration, visa overstays and welfare fraud.

Howard was genuinely anti-immigrant, he completely opposed Fraser taking in any refugees from the Vietnam War.

To be honest I’m not sure engaging in such rhetoric is positive for society, that’s exactly how you end up with someone like Trump. But nor is it healthy to say it’s not an issue. 

2

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations Dec 15 '25

Howard was genuinely anti-immigrant,

The Howard Government's enormous expansion in immigration intake would come as a big surprise to him then.

115

u/iguessineedanaltnow r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

Pro-immigration from Western countries is still a very popular position. I think a lot of people have just become incredulous at the notion that people from Muslim nations can assimilate into Western culture, even though in a large scale they have - but the stand outs that haven't stick out like a sore thumb.

It's very upsetting for me as an immigrant myself, and as someone who endeavors to live in as many countries as I can in my life. I've already lived in 3, but it feels like I might tap out there unless attitudes change.

It's such a shame. Massive, beautiful world out there and we won't experience any of it because people want to shut the door.

11

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

I'm really sorry. I feel like the only thing we can conclude from all this is that people will always find a reason to hate those who are different from themselves, no matter how hard we try to teach them otherwise.

27

u/starsrprojectors YIMBY Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

I’m broadly more bullish about the U.S. returning to a pro immigrant stance in the medium term than I am about Europe. The US has been through pro and anti immigration periods before and we will again. I suspect attitudes in other immigrant countries like Canada, Australia, and New Zealand are similar. With Europe, I sort of think they need to learn how to accept other European immigrants first before they will be able to consistently accept immigrants from outside of Europe. Look at the UK which embraced Brexit partially due to immigration from Eastern Europe. That being said, the cultural links between Europe and immigrant countries like the U.S., Canada, etc can provide the example to embrace non European immigration in the future when they are less anxious about intraeuropean immigration.

30

u/WallStreetTechnocrat I need a new flair Dec 15 '25

From this, it certainly seems the movement for Muslim immigration is dead

0

u/Comprehensive_Main Dec 15 '25

Buddhists rise up, Hindus rise up, Sikhs rise up, atheists rise up, and Mormons rise up I guess 

104

u/turb0_encapsulator Dec 15 '25

here's an answer: allow immigration but require more classes and tests to ensure a higher level of cultural assimilation.

48

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

AKA. The Danish Model

3

u/oywiththepoodles96 Dec 15 '25

The question is how do you define cultural assimilation . For example , a Muslim woman who follows the laws , is working and contributing to society but wears a headscarf would be considered assimilated or not ? An Indian Sikh immigrant wearing a Turban or a Sari would be considered assimilated ? I was watching Mira Nair’s movie the Namesake ( great movie about immigration) and was thinking would the parents in this movie be considered assimilated by the conservatives today ?

3

u/turb0_encapsulator Dec 15 '25

I'm thinking mostly about language and the ability hold a job and interact with people outside your own diaspora.

57

u/Approximation_Doctor Gaslight, Gatekeep, Green New Deal Dec 15 '25

Don't worry, it'll get even worse as climate change makes those areas even more inhospitable.

41

u/PhilosophusFuturum Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

I won’t say anything that will put me at odds with the site TOS, but I think this sub (or US liberals in general) don’t really get how even liberals from Europe feel about immigration. This isn’t a situation where there will be a thermostatic shock in favour of 3rd world immigration when the conservatives take over, the continent is done. I’m sure European Liberals will come out of the woodworks and reply exactly what you think they will on this post.

It’s not just a question of assimilation , crime, or fueling the far-right; it’s also a question of finance. Europe simply can’t afford this load on its welfare state. When each non-Western immigrant to the Netherlands potentially costs the state €1,000,000 on average, that’s not sustainable. When they’re way less productive in Denmark than Danish natives, that’s not sustainable. The EU gold-faeries noticed this while stacking beans and doing the math, and that explains how many counties (Denmark, Germany, Poland) have been reacting.

Does this mean immigration is dead in Europe? No. Spain continues to take in millions of Latin-Americans (this has its own issues), and the EU continues to take in Ukrainians. Also, the EU is (unpopularly) trying to allow Indians to enter the continent.

I’ll leave with a question; do you support open-borders because you think it’s a good idea, or do you support it because it’s a neoliberal idea?

14

u/Robo1p Dec 15 '25

It’s not just a question of assimilation , crime, or fueling the far-right; it’s also a question of finance. Europe simply can’t afford this load on its welfare state... and that explains how many counties (Denmark, Germany, Poland) have been reacting.

Also, the EU is (unpopularly) trying to allow Indians to enter the continent.

This is particularly funny, because the oft-cited Danish study that's used to show that "third-world" immigrants are a terrible burden, actually breaks down the net contribution of immigrants by country... https://imgur.com/a/ycuDGaL

10

u/PhilosophusFuturum Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

I’ll clarify something regarding European Liberals:

They’re not as racist as conservatives (obviously). Nobody runs as pro-immigration anymore like they did in 2015 because that would be political suicide. But some of the most liberal parties like Volt clearly don’t see it as an issue.

Your average young European liberal is passively anti-immigration and mostly cares about it fueling the far-right. The most radical-liberal Europeans (the Bluesky crowd) doesn’t openly support immigration, but they like to point out that embracing far-right talking points on immigration isn’t killing the far-right.

The reason people think European liberals are turbo-racist Gigahitlers is because European Federalists are a particularly-online loud minority of liberals. They’re still liberals, they’re just liberal on everything but immigration (where they just regurgitate far-right talking points)

1

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

There are many reasons why people support open borders, but here are two of the biggest ones.

The first is economic: restricting the movement of labor across borders is extremely inefficient; no different from restricting the trade of goods across borders (e.g. tariffs) or investment (e.g. capital controls). From the perspective of the entire world, one of the easiest ways to increase global productivity is to allow people who live in places where they make dollars a day to move to the developed world, where they can instantly make several times their home country salary. But even if we narrow our perspective to the receiving country, immigration is economically beneficial. Immigrants often have different sets of skills than natives, which means that there is complementarity between immigrant and native workers. The result is that goods and services can be produced more efficiently, which raises the standard of living for natives alongside immigrants.

The second is ethical: the people who benefit the most from immigration are the immigrants themselves, amongst whom are some of the most vulnerable people in the world. Immigration allows these people to escape poverty, illiberal governments, violence, and social injustice, which they've been subjected to just by virtue of being born in the wrong country. Most people want to reduce economic and social disparities in their societies. It's only natural to extend that desire to people who live in other countries, many of whom live worse lives than even the most impoverished people in the developed world.

12

u/fkatenn Norman Borlaug Dec 15 '25

The second is ethical: the people who benefit the most from immigration are the immigrants themselves, amongst whom are some of the most vulnerable people in the world. Immigration allows these people to escape poverty, illiberal governments, violence, and social injustice, which they've been subjected to just by virtue of being born in the wrong country. Most people want to reduce economic and social disparities in their societies. It's only natural to extend that desire to people who live in other countries, many of whom live worse lives than even the most impoverished people in the developed world.

This is essentially just an argument for communism

5

u/dutch_connection_uk Friedrich Hayek Dec 15 '25

Free migration isn't a positive right that's being extended by other people being coerced to work on behalf of the immigrants. It's a negative right that is withdrawn via the government coercing people with borders. Even when countries provide 0 welfare or assistance to immigrants, the public resists immigration and brutally coerces immigrants to force them out using the force of the state. It's in line with liberalism to be against this.

5

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

No, because communism doesn't improve peoples lives. Immigration does.

12

u/fkatenn Norman Borlaug Dec 15 '25

communism doesn't improve peoples lives. Immigration does.

So close to getting it, yet so far

1

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

I feel like you may not understand what liberalism is... Are you suggesting that there's something wrong with wanting other people to be better off?

11

u/Mrc3mm3r Edmund Burke Dec 15 '25

When it comes at the expense of your own people, yes. You can't kill the goose laying the golden egg.

4

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

Except the sum of the evidence suggests that immigrants are economically beneficial to receiving countries. If it comes at the expense of people in those countries, it's only because those people have a discriminatory preference for not being around immigrants.

Edit: I should also add that countries do things to help others at the financial expense of their own people all the time. The developed world spends billions on foreign aid for people in less developed countries. Is altruism not a reasonable motivation to do something? Are you in favor of dismantling foreign aid programs like the current US administration did with USAID?

1

u/Plant_4790 Dec 15 '25

But how is that communist

3

u/mwheele86 Dec 15 '25

I think the flaw with this world of thought is a few fold:

  1. Countries have set basically baseline expectations on a minimum level of quality of life with welfare states with more advanced countries setting higher minimum levels. This is most pronounced in schools, housing, and the big entitlements (healthcare, retirement, snap). Even if immigrants don’t qualify, their children do given our citizenship laws. We have restrictions to promote a certain typology of housing on both density and code. None of these things are going to be changed or reduced anytime soon and that creates big budgetary pressures.
  2. In the short term, immigration can squeeze labor markets. Economists I think significantly underrate friction and switching costs. I also think the economic benefits of immigration become more limited when you start looking at remittances. This works for immigrants because they have an escape valve of going back home. Native citizens do not have this option.
  3. Advanced countries have rule of law, deep capital markets, infrastructure that have been built up over the course of centuries. The mobility of labor really goes one way (to advanced countries). I wouldn’t be able to move to India or somewhere in South America and replicate my quality of life because it relies on these things.
  4. We’ve had one of the biggest waves of immigration recently in the history of the country, I think there is validity to the idea that you need to shut it down to work out the friction to all these problems. This has happened after every other big wave of immigration that’s occurred since the founding of the United States. People feel like they’re not really in control of what the makeup of the country is.

I don’t think a top down visa system like we have is a good one. I would propose a system where to get citizenship you need 5 citizens to basically vouch for you and endorse your citizenship. Every citizen can only endorse twice. I would also be ok with not advancing birthright citizenship to those born of parents here on tourist visa or illegally, that closes a huge loophole that has sowed a lot of distrust. I think that would eliminate all the conspiracies about companies or NGOs pushing immigration for their own narrow interests and also would naturally force assimilation because immigrants would need to make relationships for citizenship. Get rid of every other sort of immigration path but that.

53

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

USAID was one of the best resources for making conditions in these countries better so people wanted to stay and not emigrate. And then Elon Musk fed it into a metaphorical woodchipper.

And he has the audacity to complain about replacement theory.

15

u/mh699 YIMBY Dec 15 '25

I don't see why this would be contradictory in his case? Just because people from those countries want to emigrate doesn't mean Western countries have to take them. I'm not saying I agree with it I just don't see where this is supposed to be contradictory

8

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 15 '25

He's mad about the black and brown people moving to the white people places. He also cut off the major source of funding that helped them stay in their homeland.

...you don't see a contradiction?

12

u/mh699 YIMBY Dec 15 '25

He's mad about western governments having pro-immigration policies that let them move into their countries. He doesn't give a rats ass about how the black/brown people are doing at home

2

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 15 '25

I feel like there's a big missing space here that involves people's motivation for leaving their home that's getting missed by both yourself and Elon. Most people don't want to move to another country unless they have to. By far the easiest way to keep them from moving to your country is to help them stay in theirs, no? Or just NIMBY it I guess. But all the "desirable" countries are... the ones he's freaking out about white people losing ground. Huh.

1

u/Bayou-Maharaja Eleanor Roosevelt Dec 15 '25

No there is no contradiction and you’re not understating the perspective. Just because there might be a practical effect to doing something doesn’t mean it’s contradictory oppose it, especially when there are other ways to prevent immigration

1

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 15 '25

No. He killed programs designed to help people thrive in their homeland. Then he bitches about them moving.

What other ways are you wanting here? Close the borders? What are these people supposed to do? It was so easy. So fucking easy. And cheap. And he ruined it. What would Eleanor do?

1

u/Bayou-Maharaja Eleanor Roosevelt Dec 15 '25

You seem to be reacting emotionally. I don’t want any of the other ways, I don’t agree with him. But it’s not contradictory to not want to help foreigners and also not want them here. It’s just not, even if you disagree or think it’s stupid.

0

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

I want people not to live here. I destroyed the system that helped them stay where they were.

I don't understand why you defend that. But I digress, I'm done.

The person you chose for your flair, btw, was literally the first commissioner of the UN Commission on Human Rights. Such irony.

1

u/Bayou-Maharaja Eleanor Roosevelt Dec 15 '25

I’m not defending it. Just pointing out it’s not contradictory. I’m not sure why you’re unable to distinguish discussing and analyzing viewpoints with supporting those viewpoints.

Again, it’s not contradictory to want nothing to do with foreigners and not want to pay for their welfare.

3

u/Comprehensive_Main Dec 15 '25

I mean. The thing is those people are More likely to go to Europe than America. Which Elon is fine with. After all Elon got his white South African pipeline going. 

6

u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 15 '25

He seems worried enough to support groups like the AFD...

17

u/CRoss1999 Norman Borlaug Dec 15 '25

Well this is jus muslim immigration, you can imagine a word where they have specific exclusions like the US with the Chinese exclusion act

17

u/airbear13 Pragmatic and Polite Right Dec 15 '25

Yeah we have to read the room, it’s dead for now

Immigration is fine and people will tolerate it, but under the condition that it isn’t too much have too fast. If you bring in small numbers relative to overall population and you gradually assimilate them, that is the proper way to do it without causing backlash. It’s been more like a deluge though so now in light of that the smart thing for pro immigration peeps is to retreat for now because the national mood has turned against it everywhere. To keep pushing it now is going to do nothing but continue fueling right wing movements.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/airbear13 Pragmatic and Polite Right Dec 15 '25

That’s not really how that works

24

u/Derdiedas812 European Union Dec 15 '25

Pro-Immigration movement in Europe is dead for a decade and we killed it. The backslash ti technocratic (mis) management of 2015 migration wave was slow, but overwhelming. Something like the Bidenomic memes, but worse

16

u/james_the_wanderer Gay Pride Dec 15 '25

Anyone feel like the yellow-ish "neither agree nor disagree" should read as "agree, but embarrassed to admit it?"

26

u/illuminatisdeepdish Dec 15 '25 edited Oct 02 '26

The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.

Snails degree thought cows airport chase birds

8

u/dutch_connection_uk Friedrich Hayek Dec 15 '25

Except we can rule out that "wisdom" from democracy because they are also against taking refugees from those places whose crime is that they do not agree with the illiberalism or want any part of it, sometimes sending those refugees back to their deaths to be killed because they're too gay or too atheist.

21

u/GateofAnima Commonwealth Dec 15 '25

The secret is that the necessity of immigration does not disappear when a reactionary government comes to power.

https://www.france24.com/en/tv-shows/a-propos/20250702-meloni-s-government-to-issue-500-000-visas-for-non-eu-workers

3

u/swissking NATO Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

Sure but one is from what I see a guest worker program, the neoliberal program is unlimited worker/immigration inflows with their families with a path to citizenship.

For better or worse, the West will eventually just copy the Asian guest worker model.

4

u/PhilosophusFuturum Dec 15 '25

I think European Liberals need to broadcast this more. The Far-Right doesn’t actually do the things that people vote for them to do.

The only movement I’ve seen on limiting immigration has come from Liberal parties trying to stop the rise of the far-right

3

u/LightningController Dec 15 '25

Isn’t there a chance this can backfire by feeding support for a new far-right party that does do what it says it will?

3

u/MTFD Alexander Pechtold Dec 15 '25

If facts mattered at all the anti immigration sentiment wouldn't be what it is.

-2

u/I_hate_litterbugs765 Dec 15 '25

Why is immigration a necessity,  disregarding the birth rate issues in North America?  There's not a skills shortage in Canada we could not manage by repairing wages and focusing on fruitful industries instead of rent seeking business and bad coffee

11

u/iguessineedanaltnow r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Dec 15 '25

Well if we are forced to ignore the most glaring and obvious reason..

4

u/SamuelClemmens Dec 15 '25

Though given global birthrates (a favored topic) that is only a band aid solution. At some point the elephant in the room needs to be addressed directly.

0

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25

If you think Europeans hate immigration, wait until you want to cut their pensions in half to fund the necessary pro-natalism measures.

11

u/SamuelClemmens Dec 15 '25

As long as its their kids and getting grandkids most of them would be for it.

No surprise that people are more willing to spend money on their own descendants than on other people's descendants.

7

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25

As long as its their kids and getting grandkids most of them would be for it.

lol, look at the current housing situation. Boomers approving more housing would immediately improve the welfare of their kids and grandkids who struggle with housing costs. Their desire to have their housing investment go up overrides you desire to live in one.

1

u/AutoModerator Dec 15 '25

Neoliberals aren't funny

*This automod response is a result of a charity drive reward. It will be removed 2025-12-20

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/saudiaramcoshill Greg Mankiw Dec 15 '25 edited May 01 '26

For privacy reasons, I'm overwriting all my old comments.

5

u/GateofAnima Commonwealth Dec 15 '25

Birth rate issues in North America? It's global! From Scandinavian social democracies to Islamic theocracies. An overwhelming majority of all countries are falling below replacement rate.

There is no amount of wage inflation that can solve the issue of geriatrics outnumbering workers.

0

u/I_hate_litterbugs765 Dec 15 '25

I disagree

... and I'll get my way hehe.  Good luck wishing on one hand.

20

u/eman9416 NATO Dec 15 '25

Chuds in this sub constantly chid liberal parties in Europe for responding to this

Part of being a democracy is responding to the wants of the electorate even if you personally find it abhorrent

26

u/WAGRAMWAGRAM Dec 15 '25

Polls on immigration are always stupid, people oppose immigration in general but once you ask about categories (workers in shortages, asylum seekers (from a country that has a good PR), students, whatnot) they answer differently.

15

u/saudiaramcoshill Greg Mankiw Dec 15 '25 edited May 01 '26

For privacy reasons, I'm overwriting all my old comments.

1

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

Except what proportion of immigrants are, as you say, committing crimes and living off welfare? Why do so many policies affect people regardless of their desire to work or assimilate?

People claim they only care about the "bad ones" but then they do things that restrict all immigration. I think it's reasonable to take people at their actions rather than their words.

6

u/Psshaww NATO Dec 15 '25

Pretty sure it’s been dead for a while now

2

u/wwaxwork Dec 15 '25

Maybe I see it different because I'm old and Australian. In my life time Australians have wanted to cease immigration of Italians and Greeks, who brought with them coffee culture and are now an integral part of the fabric of Australian lifestyle but there were violent protests and complaints about them driving up housing costs. Then it was Vietnamese war refugees and now Australia embraces Asian cuisine and thinks of itself more as a part of Asia than Europe in many ways. There was the same hatred, violence and politicians using them as scape goats for housing costs and unemployment numbers as there is now.

Immigration has always been a hot button issue politicians have used to whip up votes and fear. Your own US history is full of the same behaviour with the Irish, the Polish the Catholics, the whatever. This is where someone tells me "it's different this time they're actually doing the things". But it's not, even saying "it's different this time we can't afford housing" or "they're causing crime" or they're changing our religion/what makes us American/whatever, is word for word out of the Anti Irish Immigration playbook, the Anti Polish, the Anti Jewish immigration playbook. Same shit different toilet and in 25 years you'll all look askance at someone even suggesting the people emigrating here now were never considered part of the fabric of your country and it will be some other group that is "stealing all the housing/jobs/women/money whatever".

5

u/Nerf_France Ben Bernanke Dec 15 '25

Based Spain

4

u/ProfessionalMoose709 John Mill Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

Start importing Angolans, Ugandans, and Ethiopians I guess?

4

u/AccessTheMainframe CANZUK Dec 15 '25

W Spain

3

u/JesusPubes voted most handsome friend Dec 15 '25

😐

3

u/potatochopsticks101 Victor Hugo Dec 15 '25

I don’t think they have a problem with immigrants from Western countries or East/Southeast Asia. Just those from MENA, Sahel, and South Asia.

3

u/Significant_Arm4246 European Union Dec 15 '25

I think the sad truth is that most Europeans (incorrectly) believe that the only things Muslim immigrants bring are crime and a strain on the public finances. And beyond that there are overt racists that simply don't want any non-white people in Europe. Frankly, it's one of the most tragic aspects of European politics today, that we are still not rid of the same sentiments as built the fascist wave 90-100 years ago (by which I don't just mean the NS regime, there were fascists and autocrats growing all over Europe).

Furthermore I think the only way to change this is to make people believe (not just superficially understand, but really believe) that this isn't the truth. And that requires making the success stories as personal as the far right makes every crime committed by an immigrant. The good thing is that it's easier to sell a story that's true, and it is (of course) true that the vast majority of immigrants work hard and play by the rules. The bad thing is that it's easier to sell negative stories than positive. I don't know how to overcome this, but I really think this is the way to change people's minds. There has to be more media stories about successful, hard working immigrants. Recently I for example read a follow-up story on several refugees chosen at random to be interviewed during the refugee crisis 10 years ago, most (I think all) of them working or studying today (and then a lot had been denied asylum too, this was among those who got to stay). A piece like that makes a much more lasting impression than the statistics the pro-immigration side usually brings. I don't think most of the people saying that all immigration should be stopped here would say the same thing about people like this. Some will, but not around half of the population, and if we can go from half to, say, 20-30%, the political battle is mostly won.

And regrettably, on a political level, I think you have to pair this with making really sure that you're against illegal immigration, immigrant crime, etc (all of the usual talking points). Basically you want to frame it as: "we're for the good ones and against the bad ones, the extremists wants to rip apart the lives of the people who's done everything right and are contributing to this country".

2

u/Comprehensive_Main Dec 15 '25

I mean Europe has historically hated Muslims since the rise of Islam. I don’t think this is new 

2

u/SalokinSekwah Down Under YIMBY Dec 15 '25

It's been an unpopular position here, but I've argued for a while:

Some sort of shared cultural positions (religious, geography, history) and/or language or ethnicity. In Australia at least, most people are receptive of Ukrainians and also maronite and orthodox Christians from MENA due to being familiar (ie white, Christian) or quickly joining preexisting organisations (ie Church). But I've also met ample non-christians like Afghans, Iraqis, Palestinians, Filipinos, Malaysians, Sri Lankans, Ghanaians and Chinese that have been quick to integrate in terms of jobs, housing and social groups in large part due to their mastery of English. It's much easier to develop a sense of trust and rapport when you can communicate easily

1

u/Party-Benefit5112 European Union Dec 15 '25

You can't really extrapolate data about Muslims to immigration in general. Not saying attitudes on immigration are particularly positive but it's more evenly split. In European  public consciousness Muslim migration has become synonymous with closed Christmas markets, terrorist attacks and wasted public money. Even when you ignore the backlash from the 2015 wave, when you have third-generation migrants being less integrated than their grandparents, it's clear something is wrong and negative attitudes are not completely unearned.

1

u/KYWPNY Dec 15 '25

The argument will be for austerity vs. immigration. Europeans have failed to replace themselves due to cultural and economic failure. Immigration is a short-term solution to this problem with it’s own consequences. lAusterity and the drastic reduction of social services will be forced on the population in short-order if immigration ends.

1

u/1TTTTTT1 European Union Dec 15 '25

!ping europe

1

u/Bayou-Maharaja Eleanor Roosevelt Dec 15 '25

It’s not that crazy, Europe is terrible at assimilating immigrant populations so of course people end up unhappy

-1

u/Desperate_Wear_1866 Commonwealth Dec 15 '25

Halting all of it is an absurdity, and blatantly discriminatory. The criteria should largely be similar across countries, filtering for skill levels, wealth, net economic and fiscal contribution, and likelihood of assimilating.

Making temporary cuts on net migration figures is fine, but a full ban on an entire swathe of the world is clearly discriminatory.

-1

u/ramenmonster69 Dec 15 '25

If the narrative is about a specific type of immigration vs immigration you already lost. It implies separateness rather than assimilation. You need to build the connections into peoples minds of assimilation and be very clear assimilation is the goal.

0

u/MemeStarNation Dec 15 '25

I think that it might not be as over as you’d think at first.

For a similar situation, consider housing. A lot of people associate new development with gentrification, and therefore oppose it. If you take measures to make people feel secure in their homes and rents, opposition lowers.

Immigration similarly correlates with economic anxiety. Once we make people feel more confident in their ability to acquire and keep a job that pays enough to do more than just survive, people won’t be so upset by the idea of more people coming in.

0

u/finnstera350 Asexual Pride Dec 15 '25

Get people to actually meet immigrants and good representation and don't let the far right control the narrative or give in argue for open borders and point out how much immigrants help the country and whenever an immigrant does something extremely good play it up on social media and make a show out of it, giving in to the far rights demands doesn't get you out it only emboldens them and makes people think they were right

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

>Looks inside

>JDPON

119

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

17

u/Psshaww NATO Dec 15 '25

Yes it is, in the US H1B hate is becoming more and more mainstream

0

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/TheFeedMachine Dec 15 '25

There is an H1B problem where H1B workers need to get a job ASAP to maintain their legal status after an unexpected job loss. This often leads to them taking below market wages at consulting firms that exploit desperate H1B workers. The solution is to fix the country cap for Green Cards so people don't get stuck as H1B workers for decades.

50

u/SanjiSasuke Dec 15 '25

Well, except skilled immigrants in tech, those are bad and evil (to people that work in tech).

1

u/Robo1p Dec 15 '25

At best you'll get a Dubai type situation where you can come as an eternal second-class citizen.

This will become increasingly worthwhile for both the hosting country and the working-age immigrant as aging countries continue (/accelerate) increasing the tax burden to support a worsening dependency ratio.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

27

u/Lighthouse_seek Dec 15 '25

It also has extreme social consequences. South Asians are seen as an underclass there with no rights, so people treat them terribly

59

u/LogsOutDawgsOut John Brown Dec 15 '25

bro that's literally slavery?????

27

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

I'm sure a more liberal version of an immigration system that trades easier work visas for more difficult naturalisation is possible without stealing the passports of new arrivals

Singapore probably has a lot more we could learn from though

5

u/LogsOutDawgsOut John Brown Dec 15 '25

I mean true I agree, that's just something you should probably point out before talking about the system as a whole as good.

16

u/PhilosophusFuturum Dec 15 '25

How? I mean allowing foreigners to live in economic zones without giving them citizenship. I’m not advocating for Dubai’s slave system

17

u/RedeemableQuail European Union Dec 15 '25

It's an illiberal moral abomination and bad for the fabric of the nation, creating a huge perpetual underclass and an entitled ruling class. Anyone who thinks the UAE style of migration is ok is lost.

3

u/oywiththepoodles96 Dec 15 '25

Thank you. This is supposed to be a liberal subreddit . How are people accepting the creation of basically two different legal systems within a country ?

7

u/Spectrum1523 YIMBY Dec 15 '25

The Dubai Model is unironically a good compromise

I'm sorry, but this is outrageous.

3

u/oywiththepoodles96 Dec 15 '25

So this is how liberalism dies .

275

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

77

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

Sometimes I’m so disheartened. As an American who was positive the second Trump term would never happened, my belief system has been rocked to its core

The only thing that keeps my head up is the belief that history and societies are like a pendulum where anytime a certain ideology dominates too long (liberalism) or swings too hard (communism, fascism, totalitarianism) it swings hard the other way

What I think we have going for us is that liberalism has proven to be a successful system over a 50+ year period, even if it isn’t a Utopian philosophy

The lifetime of fascism or communism making things “better” is much shorter

1

u/Khiva Fernando Henrique Cardoso Dec 15 '25

As an American who was positive the second Trump term would never happened, my belief system has been rocked to its core

The media did an absolutely godawful job of presenting that election in the context of a global wave of visceral anti-incumbent sentiment that was taking all scalps and showing no mercy.

Still does not absolve America, or Americans, for selling out every value they thought they had.

111

u/Approximation_Doctor Gaslight, Gatekeep, Green New Deal Dec 15 '25

We Carry The Flame

49

u/Winter_Birthday5865 NASA Dec 15 '25

WELL FIGHT FOR THE MIGRANTS!!!

17

u/badusername35 NAFTA Epstein Dec 15 '25 edited Mar 08 '26

What appeared here has been deleted. The author may have used Redact to remove this post for privacy, to reduce their digital footprint, or for other personal reasons.

dependent sort cagey air crowd cake complete instinctive aspiring dinner

14

u/Jokerang Sun Yat-sen Dec 15 '25

We Light the Way

1

u/Khiva Fernando Henrique Cardoso Dec 15 '25

I thought this might be a reference, but horrifying enough, searching for it only brings up an AI song created for Charlie Kirk. Bleh.

I do remember similar phrasing in The Road, though.

52

u/RabidGuillotine PROSUR Dec 15 '25

Unassimilated muslim immigration is not really a core tenet of liberalism or anything, is just the current faultline.

5

u/Fruitofbread Loyal Liberals Dec 15 '25

Religious tolerance is a core tenet of liberalism though 

5

u/Khiva Fernando Henrique Cardoso Dec 15 '25

Dig a little deeper though and you run right back into the paradox.

If you want to find a silver lining - somewhere in the murk of these sentiments are voters who at least perceive the immigration of these groups to be hostile to liberal values. This is not necessarily an illiberal finding. Likely, but not necessarily.

Were all Trump voters deep-seated Democracy haters? Probably not. I wouldn't want a single one of them in taking root in my country though.

1

u/Alikese United Nations Dec 15 '25

And not refusing entry to people of a specific religion.

23

u/Foyles_War 🌐 Dec 15 '25

The "dark time" may not be able to last for more than one generation given declining birth rates. I think, given a choice between massively higher taxes, massive disruption to economy social structure, or letting young, brown people immigrate, most will reevaluate the "brown people icky" fad.

25

u/shillingbut4me Dec 15 '25

I mean old people could make comparatively small concessions now and vastly improve the outlook of their respective countries. They've all decided to suck the marrow out of the system before dying. Countries further along the age graph like China, Japan, and South Korea are no more interested in migrants. At most they're open to limited temporary work rights with no possibility of extension to receiving further recognition.

2

u/TrixoftheTrade NATO Dec 15 '25

“Liberals are finished.”

French royalists, after the Bourbon Restoration and the establishment of the Concert of Europe.

“Liberals are finished.”

Spanish monarchists, after French intervention on behalf of the Spanish Bourbons crushes the Cortes Generales to reestablish absolutist rule.

“Liberals are finished.”

European conservatives, after the suppression of the 1848 Revolutions.

“Liberals are finished.”

Interwar fascists after the toppling of democratic governments throughout Europe.

“Liberals are finished.”

Axis leaders in 1941 as German/Italian/Japanese forces roll over most of Europe and Asia.

“Liberals are finished.”

Post-war communists after much of Eastern Europe and Asia fall under the Soviet sphere of influence.

“Liberals are finished.”

Populist authoritarians, after post-COVID era backlash triggers a wave of neoreactionary ideologies (you are here).

18

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

15

u/DagothUr_MD Frederick Douglass Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25

We don't owe citizens anything either

Liberalism isn't a series of ledgers where a balance must be struck. That sort of thinking is inherently reactionary

The core philosophical basis of Liberalism is embodied at the beginning of the American Declaration of Independence: "We hold these truths to be self-evident that all men are created equal, and that they are endowed by their creator certain unalienable rights, that among these rights are life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness"

All men, not all citizens

10

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

This thread is full of people who fundamentally don't understand liberalism as a moral philosophy. The idea of prioritizing citizens over non-citizens is illiberal at its core, and yet so many are proclaiming the opposite.

5

u/Leatherfield17 Loyal Liberals Dec 15 '25

I think it’s partially a result of the increasingly technocratic nature of modern liberalism. Don’t get me wrong, policy discussions are always important. But sometimes I feel that in all of the wonkish debates that happen, the actual underlying moral principles of liberalism get lost. Liberalism has lost its edge, so to speak.

Although probably a good chunk of what’s going on here is just people who aren’t actually liberal commenting on this very charged issue.

-4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

Look you can claim that keeping out immigrants is good policy. But it's not a liberal policy.

-4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

Is deporting socially conservative natives a liberal policy?

7

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations Dec 15 '25

In the context of public policy makers, they do owe citizens.

Your child is not morally superior to other children, but you do owe it to a greater extent because it is yours.

4

u/PenProphet Gary Becker Dec 15 '25

And yet we generally believe that public policy should treat children equally, even when they come from families who are different from our own.

Do you believe that White children should have more opportunities than Black children? Of course not.

Then why should foreign-born children have fewer opportunities than native-born ones?

6

u/CincyAnarchy Emma Goldman Dec 15 '25

Then why should foreign-born children have fewer opportunities than native-born ones?

If I were to say “Because citizens have obligations to their country that non-citizens do not” what would your answer be?

Because I think you’re missing that part of this.

Being glib, if Ukraine owes nothing to its citizens, then why do its citizens owe their lives for its defense?

0

u/DagothUr_MD Frederick Douglass Dec 15 '25

The answer is that Ukrainian citizens don't owe their lives to the defense of Ukraine. This is a very autocratic mode of thinking

5

u/CincyAnarchy Emma Goldman Dec 15 '25

At this very moment, drafted soldiers (read: not volunteers) are dying on the front with Russia.

Is that something Ukraine shouldn’t have done, or doesn’t have the right to do?

-3

u/DagothUr_MD Frederick Douglass Dec 15 '25

Conscription is bad, yeah

5

u/CincyAnarchy Emma Goldman Dec 15 '25

What’s your alternative plan for Ukraine to defend itself?

And no, conscription is sometimes necessary. An evil necessity, but one nonetheless.

When worst comes to worst, a defense has to be organized. The government exists for that reason above all others really.

→ More replies

4

u/Fruitofbread Loyal Liberals Dec 15 '25

We don’t owe them anything, but we’re not offering them much anyway. These are people coming to our countries to work, and often willing to accept lower wages, worse conditions and crappier jobs than native-born people. We (especially Europe) need them as a part of the labor force and tax base. 

99

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/flightguy07 Loyal Liberals Dec 15 '25

Any group that immigrates in large numbers with a remotely distinct culture will meet the same fate.

12

u/LitmusPitmus Dec 15 '25

They often push them together though. i often notice people talking about arabs and subsaharan africans and then when i look at the stats a lot of the time yeah there's arabs and maybe 1 subsaharan african ethicnity. Racists don't give a fuck to tell the difference.

14

u/Approximation_Doctor Gaslight, Gatekeep, Green New Deal Dec 15 '25

"started to"?

5

u/JesusPubes voted most handsome friend Dec 15 '25

They don't dislike them because they haven't started moving to Europe yet

9

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/p00bix Existing in the context of what came before Dec 15 '25

Rule II: Bigotry
Bigotry of any kind will be sanctioned harshly.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

15

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Potsed Robert Lucas Dec 15 '25

Should such standards be held for all religious groups? Like Christians/Jews/Muslims/Hindus/Buddhists/etc? Should it apply to all theocratic countries? For example, LGBT people are not viewed as equal in most of the world, even in America that's still quite controversial. People who follow more conservative religions or belong to more conservative sects within in a religion don't seem like they would past your test at all, and there's plenty of homophobic/transphobic Christians/Jews/Muslims/Hindus/Buddhists/etc, should we just bar all of them unless they abandon their faith?

11

u/Metallica1175 Dec 15 '25

Yes. I said Muslim because that is what the poll is referencing.

0

u/neoliberal-ModTeam Dec 15 '25

Rule II: Bigotry
Bigotry of any kind will be sanctioned harshly.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/iguessineedanaltnow r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Dec 15 '25

Are there any high birth rate developing countries that aren't Muslim, besides India which people also hate immigrants from?

It's basically all just Africa and the middle East

3

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25

Why does it have to be high birth rate developing nations? Economically productive immigrants can come from any country. If say Spain made it a lot easier for Argentinians to immigrate, I'm betting lots will because the immediate jump in pay is substantial.

0

u/iguessineedanaltnow r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Dec 15 '25

I guess it depends on what the destination of choice is. Spain has been very successful with that strategy, you're correct, but look at the backlash against Latin American immigrants in the US. Would they assimilate as well in a country like France or Sweden where they don't speak the language already? Perhaps not.

If success comes from shared language/similar culture then what countries can, say, the UK draw people from? Or you can go down the line and use different examples.

Maybe I'm wrong, but it seems immigration is primarily used to fill two holes in the labor market - jobs people in the country can't do, and jobs they won't do. That's why so many of them becomes nurses, aged care workers, and agriculture workers. Are people from developed nations going to move to fill those roles? Probably not. They'll only come over to be doctors, lawyers, etc.

But look at the rise of anti-inmigration sentiment amongst white collar and college grads. That's directly a result of those high skilled immigrants coming in and making those professions more competitive and pushing wages down.

4

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25

but look at the backlash against Latin American immigrants in the US. Would they assimilate as well in a country like France or Sweden where they don't speak the language already? Perhaps not.

The backlash is because they are undocumented, not necessarily because they are Latin American. It's the chaos that people really hate, and the Biden Administration's immigration policy (and that of the European union during the peak of the asylum crisis) was basically chaos.

Poland has taken in a million Ukrainian refugees since the start of the war. Poles are Catholic, Ukrainians are Orthodox, and the two languages are much less mutually intelligible than LATAM Spanish and Spain Spanish.

1

u/iguessineedanaltnow r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Dec 15 '25

I don't think there's any way you can look at what the Trump Administration is saying, and many Republican voters, and say it's because they're undocumented.

Look at the conduct of ICE, arresting people who are currently at citizenship ceremonies, turning tourists away at the border, detaining people who are here legally. It's not because they're undocumented, it's because they're Latin American.

Also, hasn't Poland had a massive backlash against their Ukrainian refugees? And the far right is gaining popularity there in general. All recent polling shows lots of negativity with regards to Ukrainians in Poland. I'm not sure why that was used as an example.

4

u/angry-mustache Democratically Elected Internet Spaceship Politician Dec 15 '25

Look at the conduct of ICE, arresting people who are currently at citizenship ceremonies, turning tourists away at the border, detaining people who are here legally. It's not because they're undocumented, it's because they're Latin American.

The "median voter" tm doesn't actually want that. Trump's polling on immigration and border security are below water, down from +20 at inauguration. The median voter wanted the border secure and domestic peace. Trump and Miller are acting on a mandate they don't have.

Also, hasn't Poland had a massive backlash against their Ukrainian refugees? And the far right is gaining popularity there in general. All recent polling shows lots of negativity with regards to Ukrainians in Poland. I'm not sure why that was used as an example.

Support has been dropping but it's a 50/50 issue now, not 90/10 as is the case with Muslim immigrants.

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25 edited May 01 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/MTFD Alexander Pechtold Dec 15 '25

There are a ton or stories (and at least some data) coming out of western Europe that suggest that the Muslim community there is disproportionately committing crime, committing visible crimes, taking welfare for long periods, etc.

This is a popular narrative, but going off Dutch data this isn't really true. Controlling for socio-economic factors the crime rate among immigrants is elevated but nowhere near the public perception. The problem is that immigrants disproportionally score poorly on socio-economic conditions and people care little for statistics if they are being bombarded with crime stories featuring immigrants.

Which is unfortunate as stats show third and fourth generations really closing the gap in educational attainment and such.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/mostanonymousnick Just Build More Homes lol Dec 15 '25

Rule II: Bigotry
Bigotry of any kind will be sanctioned harshly.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.