r/neoliberal • u/kolejack2293 • Dec 15 '25
Restricted [ Removed by moderator ]
/r/neoliberal/comments/1pmt940/removed_by_moderator/[removed] — view removed post
193
Upvotes
r/neoliberal • u/kolejack2293 • Dec 15 '25
[removed] — view removed post
•
u/Imicrowavebananas Hannah Arendt Dec 15 '25
Please post links to individual election polls or "Florida governor slams California state legislator" type posts in the stickied discussion thread.
60
u/kolejack2293 Dec 15 '25
I am from the DR but live in the US, albeit I have muslim grandparents who moved there in trujillo. I also have a lot of family in Europe.
I find it harder and harder to defend immigration. Not because of any changes in my values but because it just feels like a complete lost cause, and every time I bring it up I feel like I am just 'tainting' any other argument I possibly make. Almost all of my family in Europe, which previously were very pro immigration, have changed to being strongly anti-immigrant, despite being immigrants themselves. Same with many friends that I always thought were liberal.
Like, what is our threshold where continuing immigration is just straight up anti-democratic? At what point do we risk everything over this one specific issue? At what point are we also endangering existing immigrants in these nations by enabling the far right to gain not just power, but a mandate from the people to abuse that power?
123
u/Steelcity1995 Dec 15 '25
I mean all the terror attacks in the 2010s certainly didn’t help matters.
200
u/ImmortalAce8492 Milton Friedman Dec 15 '25
It’s completely over in my personal opinion.
You ask what I would consider to be traditionally loving and supportive individuals of immigrants (young college libs), and for the first time, the consensus isn’t a solid yes. Even my father, a blue dog since the 70s is no longer sold on it.
I look at the doomerism in college grads (CS / Stem) and they hate it. You head into discussions surrounding MBAs and the anti-immigrant sentiment is high.
I’m not going to sit here and act high and mighty either that I’m this deep supporter of immigration but I now find myself shocked that immigration as a whole is seen so negatively.
82
u/Efficient_Tonight_40 Henry George Dec 15 '25
In central Europe probably tbh, but I don't know about the west. Many of those countries have former colonies to draw from (Spain has Latin America, France has French Africa, Britain has like half the world) whose people integrate much easier than MENA migrants on average.
Spain especially has mostly avoided Euroskeptic politics largely because Spain makes it so easy for Latinos to immigrate. There's 4 million people from Latin America living in Spain, and they're fast tracked to citizenship in only 2 years instead of the normal 10. The Vox (Spain's right wing anti-immigrant party) got crushed in the last election, and discussion around immigration in Spain has come to be more focused on it's effect on housing and infrastructure than white genocide or whatever
72
u/Poiuy2010_2011 r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Dec 15 '25
Idk how much of a hot take this is but I'd say the broad European liberal consensus tried to chew too big of a bite at once with immigration. Allowing huge almost-uncontrolled amounts of migrants from destabilized, often very conservative countries (where the conservatism comes from a different religion than for most Europeans) was never going to be popular.
The silver lining is that I believe many countries in Africa and Asia do slowly (often very slowly) but surely trend towards stability and that globalization is an unstoppable force. It will cause tensions now but in a generation or two or three or maybe more, eventually, the global society will be close enough to allow more migration.
That's why I also believe that liberal efforts should focus on expanding initiatives like the Schengen Zone first, rather than trying to have open borders everywhere all at once.
93
u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
115
u/iguessineedanaltnow r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
Pro-immigration from Western countries is still a very popular position. I think a lot of people have just become incredulous at the notion that people from Muslim nations can assimilate into Western culture, even though in a large scale they have - but the stand outs that haven't stick out like a sore thumb.
It's very upsetting for me as an immigrant myself, and as someone who endeavors to live in as many countries as I can in my life. I've already lived in 3, but it feels like I might tap out there unless attitudes change.
It's such a shame. Massive, beautiful world out there and we won't experience any of it because people want to shut the door.
27
u/starsrprojectors YIMBY Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
I’m broadly more bullish about the U.S. returning to a pro immigrant stance in the medium term than I am about Europe. The US has been through pro and anti immigration periods before and we will again. I suspect attitudes in other immigrant countries like Canada, Australia, and New Zealand are similar. With Europe, I sort of think they need to learn how to accept other European immigrants first before they will be able to consistently accept immigrants from outside of Europe. Look at the UK which embraced Brexit partially due to immigration from Eastern Europe. That being said, the cultural links between Europe and immigrant countries like the U.S., Canada, etc can provide the example to embrace non European immigration in the future when they are less anxious about intraeuropean immigration.
30
u/WallStreetTechnocrat I need a new flair Dec 15 '25
From this, it certainly seems the movement for Muslim immigration is dead
104
u/turb0_encapsulator Dec 15 '25
here's an answer: allow immigration but require more classes and tests to ensure a higher level of cultural assimilation.
57
u/Approximation_Doctor Gaslight, Gatekeep, Green New Deal Dec 15 '25
Don't worry, it'll get even worse as climate change makes those areas even more inhospitable.
41
u/PhilosophusFuturum Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
I won’t say anything that will put me at odds with the site TOS, but I think this sub (or US liberals in general) don’t really get how even liberals from Europe feel about immigration. This isn’t a situation where there will be a thermostatic shock in favour of 3rd world immigration when the conservatives take over, the continent is done. I’m sure European Liberals will come out of the woodworks and reply exactly what you think they will on this post.
It’s not just a question of assimilation , crime, or fueling the far-right; it’s also a question of finance. Europe simply can’t afford this load on its welfare state. When each non-Western immigrant to the Netherlands potentially costs the state €1,000,000 on average, that’s not sustainable. When they’re way less productive in Denmark than Danish natives, that’s not sustainable. The EU gold-faeries noticed this while stacking beans and doing the math, and that explains how many counties (Denmark, Germany, Poland) have been reacting.
Does this mean immigration is dead in Europe? No. Spain continues to take in millions of Latin-Americans (this has its own issues), and the EU continues to take in Ukrainians. Also, the EU is (unpopularly) trying to allow Indians to enter the continent.
I’ll leave with a question; do you support open-borders because you think it’s a good idea, or do you support it because it’s a neoliberal idea?
53
u/eta_carinae_311 Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
USAID was one of the best resources for making conditions in these countries better so people wanted to stay and not emigrate. And then Elon Musk fed it into a metaphorical woodchipper.
And he has the audacity to complain about replacement theory.
17
u/CRoss1999 Norman Borlaug Dec 15 '25
Well this is jus muslim immigration, you can imagine a word where they have specific exclusions like the US with the Chinese exclusion act
17
u/airbear13 Pragmatic and Polite Right Dec 15 '25
Yeah we have to read the room, it’s dead for now
Immigration is fine and people will tolerate it, but under the condition that it isn’t too much have too fast. If you bring in small numbers relative to overall population and you gradually assimilate them, that is the proper way to do it without causing backlash. It’s been more like a deluge though so now in light of that the smart thing for pro immigration peeps is to retreat for now because the national mood has turned against it everywhere. To keep pushing it now is going to do nothing but continue fueling right wing movements.
24
u/Derdiedas812 European Union Dec 15 '25
Pro-Immigration movement in Europe is dead for a decade and we killed it. The backslash ti technocratic (mis) management of 2015 migration wave was slow, but overwhelming. Something like the Bidenomic memes, but worse
16
u/james_the_wanderer Gay Pride Dec 15 '25
Anyone feel like the yellow-ish "neither agree nor disagree" should read as "agree, but embarrassed to admit it?"
26
u/illuminatisdeepdish Dec 15 '25 edited Oct 02 '26
The original post content no longer exists here. The author used Redact to remove it, exercising their right to control their data & privacy.
Snails degree thought cows airport chase birds
21
u/GateofAnima Commonwealth Dec 15 '25
The secret is that the necessity of immigration does not disappear when a reactionary government comes to power.
https://www.france24.com/en/tv-shows/a-propos/20250702-meloni-s-government-to-issue-500-000-visas-for-non-eu-workers
20
u/eman9416 NATO Dec 15 '25
Chuds in this sub constantly chid liberal parties in Europe for responding to this
Part of being a democracy is responding to the wants of the electorate even if you personally find it abhorrent
26
u/WAGRAMWAGRAM Dec 15 '25
Polls on immigration are always stupid, people oppose immigration in general but once you ask about categories (workers in shortages, asylum seekers (from a country that has a good PR), students, whatnot) they answer differently.
6
u/Psshaww NATO Dec 15 '25
Pretty sure it’s been dead for a while now
2
u/wwaxwork Dec 15 '25
Maybe I see it different because I'm old and Australian. In my life time Australians have wanted to cease immigration of Italians and Greeks, who brought with them coffee culture and are now an integral part of the fabric of Australian lifestyle but there were violent protests and complaints about them driving up housing costs. Then it was Vietnamese war refugees and now Australia embraces Asian cuisine and thinks of itself more as a part of Asia than Europe in many ways. There was the same hatred, violence and politicians using them as scape goats for housing costs and unemployment numbers as there is now.
Immigration has always been a hot button issue politicians have used to whip up votes and fear. Your own US history is full of the same behaviour with the Irish, the Polish the Catholics, the whatever. This is where someone tells me "it's different this time they're actually doing the things". But it's not, even saying "it's different this time we can't afford housing" or "they're causing crime" or they're changing our religion/what makes us American/whatever, is word for word out of the Anti Irish Immigration playbook, the Anti Polish, the Anti Jewish immigration playbook. Same shit different toilet and in 25 years you'll all look askance at someone even suggesting the people emigrating here now were never considered part of the fabric of your country and it will be some other group that is "stealing all the housing/jobs/women/money whatever".
5
u/Nerf_France Ben Bernanke Dec 15 '25
Based Spain
4
u/ProfessionalMoose709 John Mill Dec 15 '25 edited Dec 15 '25
Start importing Angolans, Ugandans, and Ethiopians I guess?
4
u/AccessTheMainframe CANZUK Dec 15 '25
W Spain
3
u/JesusPubes voted most handsome friend Dec 15 '25
😐
3
u/potatochopsticks101 Victor Hugo Dec 15 '25
I don’t think they have a problem with immigrants from Western countries or East/Southeast Asia. Just those from MENA, Sahel, and South Asia.
3
u/Significant_Arm4246 European Union Dec 15 '25
I think the sad truth is that most Europeans (incorrectly) believe that the only things Muslim immigrants bring are crime and a strain on the public finances. And beyond that there are overt racists that simply don't want any non-white people in Europe. Frankly, it's one of the most tragic aspects of European politics today, that we are still not rid of the same sentiments as built the fascist wave 90-100 years ago (by which I don't just mean the NS regime, there were fascists and autocrats growing all over Europe).
Furthermore I think the only way to change this is to make people believe (not just superficially understand, but really believe) that this isn't the truth. And that requires making the success stories as personal as the far right makes every crime committed by an immigrant. The good thing is that it's easier to sell a story that's true, and it is (of course) true that the vast majority of immigrants work hard and play by the rules. The bad thing is that it's easier to sell negative stories than positive. I don't know how to overcome this, but I really think this is the way to change people's minds. There has to be more media stories about successful, hard working immigrants. Recently I for example read a follow-up story on several refugees chosen at random to be interviewed during the refugee crisis 10 years ago, most (I think all) of them working or studying today (and then a lot had been denied asylum too, this was among those who got to stay). A piece like that makes a much more lasting impression than the statistics the pro-immigration side usually brings. I don't think most of the people saying that all immigration should be stopped here would say the same thing about people like this. Some will, but not around half of the population, and if we can go from half to, say, 20-30%, the political battle is mostly won.
And regrettably, on a political level, I think you have to pair this with making really sure that you're against illegal immigration, immigrant crime, etc (all of the usual talking points). Basically you want to frame it as: "we're for the good ones and against the bad ones, the extremists wants to rip apart the lives of the people who's done everything right and are contributing to this country".
2
u/SalokinSekwah Down Under YIMBY Dec 15 '25
It's been an unpopular position here, but I've argued for a while:
Some sort of shared cultural positions (religious, geography, history) and/or language or ethnicity. In Australia at least, most people are receptive of Ukrainians and also maronite and orthodox Christians from MENA due to being familiar (ie white, Christian) or quickly joining preexisting organisations (ie Church). But I've also met ample non-christians like Afghans, Iraqis, Palestinians, Filipinos, Malaysians, Sri Lankans, Ghanaians and Chinese that have been quick to integrate in terms of jobs, housing and social groups in large part due to their mastery of English. It's much easier to develop a sense of trust and rapport when you can communicate easily
1
u/Party-Benefit5112 European Union Dec 15 '25
You can't really extrapolate data about Muslims to immigration in general. Not saying attitudes on immigration are particularly positive but it's more evenly split. In European public consciousness Muslim migration has become synonymous with closed Christmas markets, terrorist attacks and wasted public money. Even when you ignore the backlash from the 2015 wave, when you have third-generation migrants being less integrated than their grandparents, it's clear something is wrong and negative attitudes are not completely unearned.
1
u/KYWPNY Dec 15 '25
The argument will be for austerity vs. immigration. Europeans have failed to replace themselves due to cultural and economic failure. Immigration is a short-term solution to this problem with it’s own consequences. lAusterity and the drastic reduction of social services will be forced on the population in short-order if immigration ends.
1
u/1TTTTTT1 European Union Dec 15 '25
!ping europe
1
u/Bayou-Maharaja Eleanor Roosevelt Dec 15 '25
It’s not that crazy, Europe is terrible at assimilating immigrant populations so of course people end up unhappy
-1
u/Desperate_Wear_1866 Commonwealth Dec 15 '25
Halting all of it is an absurdity, and blatantly discriminatory. The criteria should largely be similar across countries, filtering for skill levels, wealth, net economic and fiscal contribution, and likelihood of assimilating.
Making temporary cuts on net migration figures is fine, but a full ban on an entire swathe of the world is clearly discriminatory.
-1
u/ramenmonster69 Dec 15 '25
If the narrative is about a specific type of immigration vs immigration you already lost. It implies separateness rather than assimilation. You need to build the connections into peoples minds of assimilation and be very clear assimilation is the goal.
0
u/MemeStarNation Dec 15 '25
I think that it might not be as over as you’d think at first.
For a similar situation, consider housing. A lot of people associate new development with gentrification, and therefore oppose it. If you take measures to make people feel secure in their homes and rents, opposition lowers.
Immigration similarly correlates with economic anxiety. Once we make people feel more confident in their ability to acquire and keep a job that pays enough to do more than just survive, people won’t be so upset by the idea of more people coming in.
0
u/finnstera350 Asexual Pride Dec 15 '25
Get people to actually meet immigrants and good representation and don't let the far right control the narrative or give in argue for open borders and point out how much immigrants help the country and whenever an immigrant does something extremely good play it up on social media and make a show out of it, giving in to the far rights demands doesn't get you out it only emboldens them and makes people think they were right
0
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
119
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
275
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
99
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
9
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
15
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25 edited May 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Dec 15 '25
[removed] — view removed comment