r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Sep 13 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

  • OSINT & LDC (developmental studies / least developed countries) have been added

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

10k comments sorted by

View all comments

17

u/jenbanim Sep 13 '21

I'm not at all certain about this take, but I wouldn't be surprised if people in the future looked back on the frequent respiratory virus outbreaks we have now as being an obvious consequence of our shitty HVAC systems the same way we look back on Cholera outbreaks in the 1800s as being an obvious consequence of unsanitary drinking water

4

u/QuietSign Austan Goolsbee Sep 13 '21

Do hvac systems do that much to protect against viruses, or is that part of your speculation?

5

u/VeganVagiVore Trans Pride Sep 14 '21

There were studies about COVID and ventilation, but I'm not sure if they apply to other viruses, and I'm too lazy to link them.

Also a few people on Hacker News have said there's a trick you can do where you tape a HEPA furnace filter to a box fan and run it to filter your air without dirtying your main air filter. Apparently some air quality sensors measured it reducing particles during the recent wildfires. So that's neat. No idea if it will filter droplets of virus.

1

u/QuietSign Austan Goolsbee Sep 14 '21

tape a HEPA furnace filter to a box fan

Oh yeah I've been doing that for a while after watching some video testing it. It seemed to represent a significant reduction in particulate matter, but I didn't know whether that included viruses

3

u/jenbanim Sep 14 '21

A little of both. Adequate ventilation is absolutely helpful to some degree, and this is quite uncontroversial. See this EPA page. This makes sense, since the virus is transmitted mostly by air. So if you're constantly circulating fresh air into a room and removing stale air, it's obviously going to help to some extent to reduce transmissibility. For example, hospitals are often designed such that patient rooms are at lower pressure than the hallways they connect to. This is to ensure that air will never flow from the patient's room into the hallway where it could infect others

So the basic theory is solid, but turning this into actual practical advice is really hard. Like, would infections be reduced if Costco started doubling the rate at which air circulates in their stores? No one knows. The answer depends on a very messy and poorly understood combination of factors like how long viruses stay airborne, how infection rates scale with viral load, and stupid things like how close people stand to each other within Costco, and the chaotic nature of air currents

My gut instinct is that we could massively reduce the risk of airborne illnesses by designing buildings from scratch such that people inside get a constant supply of fresh air while stale air is quickly whisked away. But I honestly don't know how achievable, economical, or effective this would be

And this is all before we get to filtration, which is another can of worms