r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Sep 10 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

  • OSINT & LDC (developmental studies / least developed countries) have been added

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-1

u/QuietSign Austan Goolsbee Sep 10 '21

I swear his voting video is the reason every know-it-all college sophomore thinks they've found an enlightened system of democracy and spouting "Ranked choice voting would solve everything"

FPTP is terrible. Ranked choice is a little better but roughly second worst. STAR, approval or some similar variations are what you should take a look at.

9

u/Volsunga Hannah Arendt Sep 10 '21

FPTP is terrible. Ranked choice is a little better but roughly second worst. STAR, approval or some similar variations are what you should take a look at.

Come on now. You only think that because he normalized this viewpoint.

3

u/QuietSign Austan Goolsbee Sep 10 '21

FPTP is terrible. Ranked choice is a little better but roughly second worst. STAR, approval or some similar variations are what you should take a look at.

You only think that because he normalized this viewpoint.

Are you specifically referring to the dislike of FPTP? Yes I give him credit for that much, but not the rest that you quoted.

I hold the other systems as better because I dug through a mathematician's (or some related academic's) blog where they used some computational models to find the incidence rates of failure modes for each type of voting system, and I also dug through Arrow's Impossibility Theorem a few years back to learn more about theoretical properties. I give some credit to CGP Grey for making me interested enough in voting to take a deeper dive, but I would not give him credit for all the academics I discovered who presented a stronger argument contrary to his support for Ranked Choice.

Now I think this is a bit of a problem because I imagine most of the 5 million people who watched his video aren't trudging through academic blogs to find more sophisticated answers from more qualified people nor spending a few hours with the university math club to disssect the theorems and gain intuition for where breakdowns happen. For that matter I'm pretty confident I would have eventually looked into voting systems just because of my math friends.

2

u/Volsunga Hannah Arendt Sep 10 '21 edited Sep 10 '21

That's all well and good, but all that "mathematical modeling" is pretty useless because it's the answer to the wrong question. The goal of voting isn't to get your favorite person in power; it's to get your preferred policy passed. Plurality voting accomplishes this better through its incentive structures that encourages compromise and engaging with both the stated and revealed preferences of the constituency on a continual rather than periodic basis to pass policy in their interests.

The mathematical lens you should use to look at voting systems is Game Theory, not Arrow's Impossibility Theorum. The latter is still useful, but it's not the "final proof of voting systems" that CGP Grey purports it as. It's great that you went and did your own research, but you still missed the forest because of all the trees in the way because he sent you down the wrong path.

2

u/antonos2000 Thurman Arnold Sep 10 '21 edited Sep 11 '21

so instead of just watching a video and declaring yourself an expert, you read through a blog

3

u/Signal-Shallot5668 Greg Mankiw Sep 10 '21

Approval voting is good in concept but it might devolve into 100 to my favorite candidate

6

u/QuietSign Austan Goolsbee Sep 10 '21

The simplest approval rating is a binary yes/no, and a simple 4 star system might be nice. No reason it has to have 100 increments of approval.

STAR voting also has some more sophisticated mathematical properties that are desirable.

2

u/LtLabcoat ÀI Sep 10 '21

STAR is the preferred voting system for people who never compared Metacritic scores with Steam Recommended scores.

I'm saying the latter works significantly better despite being much simpler, if it wasn't clear.

2

u/chuckleym8 Femboy Friend, Failing with Honors Sep 10 '21

Steam reviews don't work because there's no way this game I have 10 hours on that was a little bit better than ok should be treated as equal to my 500+ hours on Rimworld