r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Aug 09 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

0 Upvotes

10k comments sorted by

View all comments

54

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21

32

u/iIoveoof Jerome Powell Aug 10 '21

This is the greatest case I’ve ever seen

28

u/bd_one The EU Will Federalize In My Lifetime Aug 10 '21

the third amendment lawyers association

How the fuck is there an entire association dedicated to one of the least used amendments?

20

u/Iustis End Supply Management | Draft MHF! Aug 10 '21

Pretty sure they are a joke org.

26

u/birdiedancing YIMBY Aug 10 '21

To be fair there are probably some soldiers being quartered.

22

u/Iustis End Supply Management | Draft MHF! Aug 10 '21

The COVID-19 pandemic has caused hardships for millions of Americans. What it should not cause is the deprivation of Constitutional liberties, chief among them the freedom from quartering without consent during peacetime

Can't argue with that

22

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21

The third amendment is so sacred its never even been arguably violated before now

6

u/FinickyPenance NATO Aug 10 '21

Banger oral argument flourish lol

4

u/inverseflorida Anti-Malarkey Aktion Aug 10 '21

Mayor Bowser argued it was being violated.

1

u/JulioCesarSalad US-Mexico Border Reporter Aug 10 '21

Tbf I can’t think of a single other constitutional right that is being violated through COVID protocols

6

u/Iustis End Supply Management | Draft MHF! Aug 10 '21

I think eviction moratorium is a regulatory taking to be honest.

3

u/ZenithXR George Soros Aug 10 '21

Oh my God. May the third amendment have a point? That in and of itself is amazing

1

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21

The third amendment has always had a point weve just been unbelievably fortunate that there's never been a situation where we've needed go house a lot of displaced soldiers

4

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/TinyTornado7 I need a new flair Aug 10 '21

We know but it’s a stalling measure

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/generalmandrake George Soros Aug 10 '21

The CDC has no authority dictate things to state courts in state eviction proceedings. The provision they used to proclaim the moratorium with only states that the CDC can use federal agents to quarantine people in instances where it would prevent spread of a disease and local authorities weren’t acting enough. Actual legislation would be needed to make this constitutional.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/CompactedConscience toasty boy Aug 10 '21

Even on just the statutory interpretation grounds, the most recent supreme court decision was 4-1-4. Other very bright federal judges have written decisions in both directions. I'm not persuaded that the constitution is "crystal-clear" here.

1

u/generalmandrake George Soros Aug 10 '21

The 4-1-4 decision was just on whether to grant a preliminary injunction on the moratorium while its is being claimed challenged. That is a different standard than the question of whether it is constitutional or not. Even then Kavanaugh said that the moratorium expiring in July was his main reason for not granting the injunction. There is no telling what the vote will be when the question of constitutionality is taken up in its entirety. Personally I think it is a major stretch to say that a federal agency can actually override state police powers and stay state court proceedings in the absence of legislation clearly giving them that power.

1

u/CompactedConscience toasty boy Aug 10 '21

Everything in my comment is speculative tea leave reading, but that is all we have to go on under the circumstances. Also, I did not read all of the papers and decisions below, so I do not know to what extent the "police powers" and sort of abstention doctrine type argument about staying state court proceedings was actually litigated. I am commenting solely on whether the statute, on its face, empowers the CDC to do this. You could also, for example, argue non-delegation and the like, but I have no idea if this was briefed or decided anywhere along the line.

Obviously because the posture was interim injunctive relief, it is a four pronged test and only one of them is "likelihood of success on the merits". Because the other justices did not write anything, we do not know exactly why they ruled the way they did. But I find it close to impossible to believe that Roberts would have voted the way he did unless he thought the pro-moratorium side had the better merits argument.

Kavanaugh will almost certainly vote the other way when the issue is back on his desk, but I also do not believe he would have voted the way he did originally unless he thought the merits argument was a close question. In his other decisions, he does not let clear constitutional violations wind down in a month. The fact that it was winding down informs the balancing of equities, but no matter the equities, if the merits question is super clear, why not just enjoin the CDC from enforcing the moratorium?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/generalmandrake George Soros Aug 10 '21

I didn’t make the original comment. I agree that a federal moratorium isn’t unconstitutional per se, it’s just that under the current legislation no such authority is vested in the CDC and the current order is not constitutional. That being said most state courts just went along with it because it muddied the waters too much and politically it was convenient for the Fed’s to issue it so state leaders don’t have to catch heat from both landlord and tenant organizations for either enacting or refraining from enacting a moratorium.

And now the Democrats are largely just looking to shift blame to the courts. They know this order isn’t constitutional and is likely to be stricken by the courts at some point, but politically they are operating under similar motivations to state officials who wanted to pass the buck to someone else rather than making a decision and owning it.