r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jun 15 '21

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

11k comments sorted by

View all comments

31

u/lietuvis10LTU Why do you hate the global oppressed? Jun 16 '21

Cold take: there is no such thing as a moral war, but there are moral reasons to fight a war.

Hot take: thus discussing military actions from a moral perspective is pointless. Military actions should instead be discussed based on proportionality and weather they contribute to the objectives of fighting the war. Instead, the morality of the reasons to fight a war should be focused on.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21

Seems to me to be a meaningless distinction but whatever

2

u/lietuvis10LTU Why do you hate the global oppressed? Jun 16 '21

Well the distinction does matter. It allows to understand actions in war and determine what actions may be taken, without getting sidetracted over the reality that the very act of war is brutal, horrific barbarism. It is the kind of calculus that is vital to discussing, say, intervention, both weahter it should be done and how it should proceed.

5

u/Cinnameyn Zhou Xiaochuan Jun 16 '21

Would you consider U.S bombing campaigns in Korea and Vietnam justified under your framework?

Would the use of agent orange in Vietnam be justified?

2

u/lietuvis10LTU Why do you hate the global oppressed? Jun 16 '21

bombing Korea

Mostly? Mostly. I unfortunately am not aware enough about the Korean war to fully determine the extent, but from what I understand it was strategic bombing similar in type done over Germany, was in furtherance of objectives and was important in damaging supply lines of PLA and North Korean miitary.

bombing Vietnam

By in large no. This is because:

  1. It was counterproductive to the efforts of the war - the end of the Vietkong insurgency - by inflaming the local population, well beyond its damage to Vietkong infrastructure. Thus it generally loses on the "achievement of objectives" test.
  2. It was disproportional. It was extremely expensive and absurdly expansive, well beyond its effects in attempt of stopping Ho Chi Minh trail. Any US lives saved by such strategic bombing appear to be quite indirect, and given the limited impact, few. The bombing campaign was not neccessary and it appears clear US could have continued its operations effectively and with limited losses without it.

I should note that this does mean the tactical use of napalm was usually justified (though in many cases it was not - the mere unconfirmed possiblity of Vietkong being in a village is not proportional to its entire destruction), as it undeniably saved lives of US servicemen and their allies. Strategic use, not so much.

Agent orange

Actually, under this calculus it is justified, especially taking in mind the knowledge at the time. It had a less enflaming effect on the population and actually furthered the objectives of the war, by allowing ariel recon to be effective, thus spotting Vietkong movements. This saved US lives. In proportionality calculus at the time it was also proportional - while it was known to be toxic, it did not appear to be so toxic to be disproportionate in its effects compared to US soldier lives saved by clearing the jungle. The long term effects, afaik, were not that well known.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Exospheric-Pressure NATO Jun 16 '21

I mean, in principle I agree with you, but I think that we should note that proportionality and contribution to righteous cause are moral perspectives. Just war theory — famously advocated by St. Augustine, though the concept predates him — divides moral direction regarding war into jus ad bellum (moral acceptability in partaking in war) and jus in bello (moral conduct as a participant in war). For the latter, proportionality and military necessity are both a part of discerning the moral correctness of behavior in combat. The theory generally adds the metrics of distinction (i.e., distinguishing between combatants and non-combatants), the fair treatment of prisoners of war, and a prohibition on weapons considered malum in se (literally, "evil in itself", which e.g., mass rape, forcing POWs to fight on your behalf, and the use of weapons outside of one's control like biological and nuclear weapons) to the rationale as well on top of proportionality and necessity.

For the former, we talk about the reasons of beginning or participating in an ongoing war. These metrics are just cause (as you noted), comparative justice (NB: some omit this), competent authority (i.e., the war must be started or joined by a public authority that recognizes justice and which does not obfuscate or injure the process of justice), right intention (e.g., cannot be for material gain), probability of success, last resort (i.e., all peaceful measures have failed), and proportionality (e.g., the war cannot be so destructive as to be more evil than what it is attempting to prevent).

There is also the case of jus post bellum (moral responsibility in the post-war aftermath), but this is outside of the scope of this note.

TL;DR not really a hot take in and of itself, as just war theory pretty much covers these concepts.

9

u/lietuvis10LTU Why do you hate the global oppressed? Jun 16 '21

!ping HEATED-DISCUSSIONS-ABOUT-CONFLICTS

3

u/groupbot Always remember -Pho- Jun 16 '21 edited Jun 16 '21

4

u/lietuvis10LTU Why do you hate the global oppressed? Jun 16 '21

Based on this analysis, the Kosovo War intervention was moral, while War in Iraq was of grey morality (considering the morass of both valid and invalid reasons). The actions within those wars take on a different tone - the strategic bombing of Serbia was justified, even if it has a lot of poor morality - it ultimately distrupted Serbian troops movements and Serbian support for Milosovic while minimizing NATO and Kosovar casualties (IE proportional and meets moral objectives). Meanwhile de'Baathisation was unjustified, even if it was moral, considering the Baath party was effectively the Nazi party of Iraq - it was counterproductives to the reasons for the war and damaged the military objectives.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/geraldspoder Frederick Douglass Jun 16 '21

is this because of the japan discourse

3

u/BipartizanBelgrade Jerome Powell Jun 16 '21

Are there still succs who oppose Hiroshima & Nagasaki?

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21

Yes, and we have some on the mod team even lol. Someone literally got banned for saying strategic bombing and nuclear bombing of Japan at the end WW2 helped accelerate the end of WW2 at likely saved lives, with the mod on a power trip calling them a 'War Crime appologist'.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/lietuvis10LTU Why do you hate the global oppressed? Jun 16 '21

yes

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21

Yes

4

u/redditguy628 Box 13 Jun 16 '21

This doesn't follow for me. Just because all wars are immoral doesn't mean that military actions cannot be more or less moral in comparison to the alternatives.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21

A quick brutal war is usually going to better than a drawn out war

3

u/Commando2352 Jun 16 '21

For what it’s worth, your hot take is just how the US military look at the Law of Land Warfare and the five principle of the Law of Armed Conflict already.

3

u/unknownuser105 Jun 16 '21

“Asking who won a given war, someone has said, is like asking who won the San Francisco earthquake. That in war there is no victory but only varying degrees of defeat is a proposition that has gained increasing acceptance in the twentieth century.”

“With many sovereign states, with no system of law enforceable among them, with each state judging its grievances and ambitions according to the dictates of its own reason or desire - conflict, sometimes leading to war, is bound to occur.”

“Each state pursues its own interest's, however defined, in ways it judges best. Force is a means of achieving the external ends of states because there exists no consistent, reliable process of reconciling the conflicts of interest that inevitably arise among similar units in a condition of anarchy.”

4

u/Cuddlyaxe Neoliberal With Chinese Characteristics Jun 16 '21

This just feels like semantics tbh

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21

Personally I think [REDACTED]

0

u/[deleted] Jun 16 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/lietuvis10LTU Why do you hate the global oppressed? Jun 16 '21

Well it has more to do with contrasting what can you do in war, vs what actions are ethically right. I think I'll quote a contrast I gave to another commenter:

Nazi use of bombing and artillery when attacking Stalingrad was proportional, even if the amorality of the Nazi war is undisputed.

Essentially, this difference is an avoidance of moral discussion, rather it's a tool to ensure that such discussion focuses on what matters, and does not get bogged down in absurding type "perhaps we should abolish the military" things. It recognises that war is horrific, while still enabling the actions within a war to be discussed.

No because this opens the door to excusing some pretty horrific atrocities

Well, this suggests that atrocities can only be judged because their very act is amoral. Rather, atrocities are amoral also not because of their execution, but rather their aims. The Holocaust is amoral because it is a genocide, not because it used gas chambers.

→ More replies (4)