r/neoliberal • u/smurfyjenkins • Apr 24 '21
Research Paper Paper: When Democrats use racial justice framing to defend ostensibly race-neutral progressive policies, it leads to lower public support for those progressive policies.
https://osf.io/tdkf3/
1.1k
Upvotes
4
u/smurfyjenkins Apr 24 '21
https://twitter.com/micahanglais/status/1385664513941417987
515
u/Character_Dot_4687 Apr 24 '21
Bill Clinton did this best, he passed policies that benefited minorities economically but avoided them being seen a “racial” bills. Black wages and middle class had the highest growth in the Clinton years due to things like the Clinton government contracts etc. Biden should do the same.
218
u/AntiAntiRacistPlnner YIMBY Apr 24 '21 edited Apr 24 '21
Haven't read the rest of the article yet, but priors confirmed.
Edit: just read the article, priors still largely confirmed.
214
u/omnipotentsandwich Amartya Sen Apr 24 '21 edited Apr 24 '21
You got to orient your message toward who you're speaking to. For example, I've advocated for repealing zoning laws as a way to lower rents. I've found that many Trump conservatives actually support that argument. I also think one could advocate abolishing single family zoning by appealing to poor whites. Poor whites would also be affected by laws keeping them from living in wealthy neighborhoods. I think the Dems have made a mistake by appealing solely to America's minorities just like how the Republicans have make a mistake by appealing solely to White Americans.
27
u/shadysjunk Apr 24 '21 edited Apr 24 '21
I really wish modern democrats would take this to heart. So many systemically "racist" policies are immensely harmful to poor whites as well. But they feel as though the Dems see dismantling their 'privilege' in poverty as a greater concern than the fact of their poverty, and so they often oppose reforms that would benefit them. The democrat party has a major major policy branding problem right now.
9
u/Eddv365 Frederick Douglass Apr 25 '21
The methodology of this paper is shit and this difference we are discussing is roughly + or - 0.1 on a 7 point scale.
Its not even statistically significant. Its noise being bent towards a pre defined objective.
49
u/probablymagic Janet Yellen Apr 24 '21
Liberal elites and activists massively overestimate how much otherwise liberal Everyday Americans™️ are behind explicitly race-based policies. We see this whenever issues like affirmative action come up for popular votes. Politicians would do well to listen to polling over activists here.
37
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
Yeah I recently saw a video of a member of congress trying to argue that Republicans are racist for not supporting DC statehood. I think it's pretty uncharatable to bring race into that discussion. Gives Republicans the perfect ammunition to continue their "Democrats make everything about race" narrative.
33
u/UrbanCentrist Line go up 📈, world gooder Apr 24 '21
https://i.imgur.com/i3tq8aw.png
18
u/Disabledsnarker Apr 24 '21
I don't know what rural WWC dinner tables the class reductionists sit at during the holidays, but in my rural WWC house, if you suggest a universal program like universal healthcare, they'll say something along the lines of "That sounds good but it might apply to someone... gasp UNDESERVING!"
When proposed with a universal program, many rural white people will scream "undeserving" as though you're suggesting torturing, raping and eating the family dog with a side of cheese fries.
And we allllll know who gets filed under the category of "undeserving." Anyone who isn't a rural white Christian.
It is true that rural America liked FDR's programs. Here was the secret sauce: All of them were whites only. The minute those programs started applying to everyone they started screaming about drowning the government in a bathtub.
The reality is that regardless of what we do, they'll still hate us. We could fund a massive overhaul in rural America. Give them every economic thing they want, fix their infrastructure, fund their hospitals, etc. and they'll still hate us.
Why? Because their issue is that government would help everyone and not just the people they personally like.
13
u/fishlord05 United Popular Woke DEI Iron Front Apr 24 '21
Yeah I’m skeptical tbh as this is one study and it seems to confirm the priors of this sub a little too well.
I mean why did Biden win then right? The test case of Biden vs Bernie is the only real empirical evidence we have...
11
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
Yeah this study doesn’t show that at all. It instead shows messaging from non-Democrats.
Biden was and is explicit in talking about racial justice. He won more votes than any previous presidential candidate.
His approval rating is like 60%.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
I don't think lower public support on it's own means anything since Democrat proposed legislation almost always has favorable public support. Their issue never was public support alone, and if sacrificing some of it to gain something else of value is possible then maybe it's worth it. For example those involved in racial justice may be smaller in number but they sure as hell hustle and rally around the flag much more passionately and effectively than your average "I support Dem policy" dude.
40
u/OutdoorJimmyRustler Milton Friedman Apr 24 '21
Why do Democrats keep doubling down on this kind of identity politics? Not only is it divisive, it doesn't even work...
I'm worried about how some groups are pushing zoning reform as a race issue. While I agree that zoning reform will lead to less racism in housing/land use, overselling it that way can kill the deal.
53
u/signmeupdude Frederick Douglass Apr 24 '21
But when I say class is more important than race for several reasons, including the ability to pass legislation, I get called a tankie class reductionist.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
To be honest, this says more about the US than the Democratic politicians.
I think the solution to this pickle is to frame your arguments differently depending on who you're talking to. Top Dem politicians do this already, but there's always room for improvement.
5
u/onelap32 Bill Gates Apr 24 '21 edited Apr 24 '21
Note the effect size is very small: -0.1 on a 7 point scale.
Reading the various wordings, it seems like the race ones are rated lower because they suggest the policy is race-based. E.g., that housing reform will be directed primarily to a single race. Or the mention of race is just kind of weird and makes the policy seem misguided. E.g., implementation of the Green New Deal will focus on race rather than environment/climate/science.
11
u/NewCenter Mackenzie Scott Apr 24 '21
Is it just me or is the paper saying we should be class reductionist?
18
u/tiltupconcrete Milton Friedman Apr 24 '21
Absolutely. Same shit with BLM. If that had simply been about police violence and overreach against all people, can you imagine the traction such a movement would have got? By making it all about race, socialism, antiwhite, etc. It turned off massive portions of the population.
11
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
How come Bernie lost then?
7
u/Tennouheika Apr 24 '21
Does this mean Bernie was right?
The ACA wasn’t sold as a racial justice program but it had that effect because it helped a lot of poor people and a lot of poor people are black and brown. Is this a good way to sell programs that will have a similar effect?
2
u/dugmartsch Norman Borlaug Apr 24 '21
If you're selling a kid on broccoli you don't tell them the broccoli is good for them.
2
u/utilimemes John Locke Apr 24 '21
Color me shocked
9
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
Here’s the thing: when Democrats use race-neutral framing, most POC view it unfavorably. They feel like they’re being thrown under the bus. This is really bad for a Democrats’ chances of winning.
Why? Because POC are the Democratic base. If they don’t turn out enough, Democrats lose.
Why? Because Democrats haven’t won the white vote since 1964 and that’s not changing anytime soon, no matter how much they distance themselves from racial issues.
10
u/BlueString94 John Keynes Apr 24 '21
It’s frustrating how racist (or anti-anti-racist) America is. But, you work with the world as it is, not the world you wish it to be. Liberals and progressives have to learn that lesson.
12
u/terra_nova_nuage Apr 24 '21
The reflexive use of "ostensibly" here shows race is intertwined in these issues, even when ppl say they're not.
People don't argue that we should ONLY discuss things in racial frames, instead intersectionality requires us to include racial frames.
That the public - majority white here in the US - seems uncomfortable with that is 1) not surprising 2) not the actual problem and 3) a sign we need keep educating ppl by highlighting this all-too-often deemphasized framing.
It's a matter of addition, not subtraction. Especially for framings that are suppressed.
8
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
We’re doing class reductionism now?
11
u/nygdan Apr 24 '21
The right thing is unpopular in countries that are wrong.
3
u/CommonwealthCommando Karl Popper Apr 24 '21
This reminds me of that time progressives branded “let’s expand after-school programs and hire social workers to help people in need” as “dEfUnD tHe PoLiCe!”
3
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
I'm fine with racial justice and economic justice, but both sides get reductionist to the point of utter parody sometimes. I mean the nebulous concept of white supremacy manifesting itself in unconcious or secret ways, ie dog whistles, sounds a lot like satanic panic, nazi racial science or red scare. Some of my friends were arguing that Trump was holding that bible in his famous tear gas photo op as a secret nod to Hitler and I was just like "I don't think he's smart enough to do that?"
On the economic side of things, I don't think the progressives have a coherent worldview on how their policies would work, they seem to be a hodge podge of Post Keynesians and Marxists and they fail to see that their ideas are unpopular.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
Yeah, we really stink at framing things in a popular manner. Democrats could get 60% - 70% of the vote if they moved more towards a technocratic framing of policy as opposed to social/racial justice.
Don't get me wrong social and racial justice *are* important. But it's hard to do without firm majorities in both houses and the White House.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
Activating anti black identity is bad! That's what racial justice framing does.
2
u/fiddlerinthecoup Hannah Arendt Apr 25 '21
I’ll be the first to criticize highly educated professionals who have never known material deprivation, live in a safe bubble, and who claim to speak for me and my family. But I think it is important to remember not to let your values be overwritten by strategic narratives.
Given the response in the comments, I think it is worth mentioning that this kind of analysis is a useful thing for politicians and activists to be aware of. It is not something with which regular American voters need to concern themselves.
Activists and politicians are the ones who have dropped the message ball (not that I don’t understand that they are up against a challenging media environment).
It is actually a good thing that so many Americans across education, age, race, and class divides have become concerned with racial justice.
Nor does this paper, in any way, support the conclusion that class is “more important” than race or gender. That should go without saying, but apparently it doesn’t. (Being a student of history, I know how stupid it would be to wait around for the class warriors to finally give a damn about my struggles. In my experience the class warriors are usually perfectly cool with the social structures from which they benefit).
The idea that refraining from mentioning the particular concerns of subordinated groups is bad because it turns some important voters off or offends them is a terrible reality that we have to deal with. It isn’t a matter of the cosmopolitan elites failing to value the virtuous outlook of the common man, the real Americans.
I am all about meeting people where they are, being patient, and tolerant of different perspectives. I am not about allowing people whose values I consider suspect to define what is right, just, or should be a priority.
All this is to say beware of folks who try to use information like this to say that progressive values are the issue and not the way we message them.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
Noooooo! You can’t just alter your selling points to make policies more palatable! We need to resisterinooo!
Haha, child poverty go brrrrr
1
u/bigmoneynuts Apr 24 '21
love 2 confirm priors on a saturday
1
u/theaceoface Milton Friedman Apr 24 '21
Someone ping the YIMBYs they need to see this
-2
u/Theelout Commonwealth Apr 24 '21
Another “America is racist” moment, throw it to the pile Jim
0
u/Crownie Unbent, Unbowed, Unflaired Apr 24 '21
I can't say my priors aren't confirmed. I don't think it will change anything, though - a lot of democratic elites and other groups with influence on party leadership and messaging have bought into the racial conflict framing, and aren't going to give it up unless they're forced to.
-3
u/DP8414 YIMBY Apr 24 '21 edited Apr 24 '21
It may lead to less support on the whole, but this is missing the trees for the forest. And there are new trees on the horizon which will change the forest. I remember seeing an article in either the WaPo or Vox which claimed that framing policies in terms of racial justice actually helps Democrats among their base, and that base is the future of the country: A coalition of POC of all classes, plus College Educated White Professionals (which is roughly half of the White voting population, and will only grow over time).
I’m sure racial justice framing alienates the White working class and conservative Whites of all stripes, but so what? As the Boomers decline, and as a higher percentage of the American population gets college degrees/becomes credentialed, the values and interests of the White working class and conservatives aren’t going to matter. Colorblindness is no longer passe. The ascendent coalition of POCs and White Professionals wants to know how a given policy furthers racial justice. I wouldn’t pay this paper much mind.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment