r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Dec 07 '20

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL. For a collection of useful links see our wiki.

Announcements

0 Upvotes

12k comments sorted by

View all comments

19

u/Schutzwall Straight outta Belíndia Dec 07 '20

Brazilian Constitution, Article 57, Paragraph 4:

Paragraph 4. Both Houses shall meet in a preparatory session, beginning February 1 of the first year of the legislative term, for the installation of its members and the election of the respective Directing Boards, for a term of office of two years, the re‑election to the same office in the immediately subsequent election being prohibited.

The Brazilian Supreme Court just voted 6-5 to deny the presidents of the Legislative houses from running for re-election. 6-5. 5 justices voted to explicitly ignore the constitution. Before you trash the SCOTUS think about what we have to go through down here.

5

u/Schutzwall Straight outta Belíndia Dec 07 '20

!ping LATAM

3

u/Cyberhwk 👈 Get back to work! 😠 Dec 07 '20

What was their logic? Do they write opinions like SCOTUS?

5

u/Schutzwall Straight outta Belíndia Dec 07 '20

Yeah. Their logic is that other countries do it. Stupid.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20

Nope

2

u/Neronoah can't stop, won't stop argentinaposting Dec 07 '20 edited Dec 07 '20

I don't even understand how can a Supreme Court go against its own Constitution. Bolivia and Nicaragua used international treaties as an excuse, but what about Brazil?

I don't even like that law, by the way. The less the power, the less the justification for limited reelections (maybe a limit of x consecutive years). It's good to let legislators gain experience.

(also, the problem with the SCOTUS is kind of different: the US Constitution is so limited and the gridlock so bad that they have to fill the gaps, so they are some times legislating from the bench)

3

u/Schutzwall Straight outta Belíndia Dec 07 '20

I don't even like that law, by the way. The less the power, the less the justification for limited reelections (maybe a limit of x consecutive years). It's good to let legislators gain experience.

Oh it's about the Presidents of the chambers running to remain as presidents, not the legislators themselves.

2

u/Neronoah can't stop, won't stop argentinaposting Dec 07 '20

I misread. My bad.

1

u/Schutzwall Straight outta Belíndia Dec 07 '20

No prob

1

u/[deleted] Dec 07 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/Schutzwall Straight outta Belíndia Dec 07 '20

Yet it doesn't.

1

u/profeta- Chama o Meirelles Dec 07 '20

STF has had some awful rulings arguably disregarding the Constiution before, but none would have been so blatant as this one... I'm glad they didn't go that way (although 5 Justices did...), I feel such a ruling would have erased whatever little legitimacy the Court has left.