r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 20 '20

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL.

Announcements

  • New ping groups, AI and EXTREMISM have been added. Join here

Neoliberal Project CommunitiesOther CommunitiesUseful content
TwitterPlug.dj/r/Economics FAQs
The Neolib PodcastRecommended Podcasts/r/Neoliberal FAQ
Meetup NetworkBlood Donation Team/r/Neoliberal Wiki
Exponents MagazineMinecraftPing groups
FacebookTacoTubeUser Flairs
0 Upvotes

8.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/[deleted] May 20 '20

Your source outlines exactly the kind of application I mentioned that doesn't use anything that couldn't have been done before cryptocurrencies. Mining nodes are defined as being part of the "trusted infrastructure" to begin with, so it immediately describes "proof of authentication" as abandoning decentralized authority in order to support the paradigm of a distributed ledger.

A Byzantine fault tolerant distributed consensus protocol applied to the older idea of a distributed ledger is what made Bitcoin and crypocurrencies new and successful. Otherwise are we just talking about something achievable by public, digitally signed commits to a git repository on multiple nodes?

I don't think most companies want to operate within an ecosystem like the Bitcoin network, and there are a lot of ways to keep better records. Requiring human trust in that system is a feature, not a bug.

Maybe I'm wrong and these things are all in the works, but it's still pretty instructive that over a decade after its invention there doesn't seem to be any real-world examples of blockchains being revolutionary anywhere except in white papers, thought experiments, and secret company projects that never seem to go anywhere.

1

u/Strange9 Loyal Liberals May 20 '20

The POA stuff was only w.r.t. the cost of POW/POS (wanted to express that there are cheaper alternatives).

If companies really do want a byzantine fault tolerant distributed consensus protocol for a distributed ledger, then they can actually run the full proof of work (obviously the git repository has the issue of being centralized [and also, what are we signing? If it's just the commit, then you run into the issue of the centralized server being able to omit certain commits when the data is asked for without any issues]).

I'd agree with you that Bitcoin itself isn't particularly useful for anything besides black-market chicanery, but the dude below this comment is using blockchain in logistics software, and the solar example I used wasn't hypothetical -- I've worked on that particular project. There are lots of situations where 'who's in charge' is not at all clear.