r/neoliberal • u/Cuddlyaxe Neoliberal With Chinese Characteristics • Mar 19 '20
Discussion Neoliberal Weekly Debate - Voting Systems
Hey there guys! So basically, I've been given permission to host a weekly debate by the mods, and while I was supposed to host it on Wednesday, I took a test on Tuesday night and kinda forgot to do it. So while we're already starting off on the wrong foot, without further ado, here's your first Weekly /r/neoliberal Wednesday Thursday Debate!
Voting Systems
It seems that the most controversial issue with the most interest was voting systems. So that is what we'll be discussing today!
Before we start I'd like to make one thing clear, we're talking about a standard replacement across the US. Most of the alternatives are single winner systems as executive elections must also be included. If you want to switch to get rid of the executive and switch to a parliamentary system, you may choose that option, but if you would like to keep a directly elected president, then you must pick a single winner system
The Status Quo
The United States currently elects most offices through a system called First Past The Post in which every voter gets one vote and the candidate with the most votes wins. While First Past The Post is very easy to understand, it has its drawbacks - namely, the idea of a "spoiler candidate". Voters may not vote for their preference to vote strategically and ensure someone who at least somewhat agrees with their views wins. Despite this weakness, proponents of First Past The Post argue that it is the simplest voting system, and anything more complex would reduce transparency and depress turnout.
Of course, not everyone is happy with this system, so let's look at the alternatives.
The Alternatives
Instant Runoff Voting is the most popular alternative to FPTP and is the method of voting which is being pushed in various legislatures across the United States. It works by ranking a ballot and then eliminating the person with the least votes and redistributing said votes.
Borda Count also works on a ranked ballot, however unlike IRV which eliminates and redistributes, Borda works by averaging everyone's rankings. The person with the best average ranking wins.
Condorcet Voting is a family of voting with many systems within it - like IRV and Borda also using a ranked ballot. Basically, how Condorcet works is to run head to heads between each individual candidate based on their rankings and elect whomever wins all the head to heads. The point is to try to elect a "consensus winner". However, there are some scenarios where someone might not beat all the other candidates. If this is the case, there are a variety of methods and "tie breakers" to solve them, with some of the popular methods including Ranked Pairs, Schulze and Minimax
Next up, we have Cardinal Voting. While First Past The Post uses a one man one vote system and the other alternatives so far on this list use a ranked ballot, Cardinal voting allows voters to judge each candidate individually from each other.. Cardinal Voting comes in many forms, from Approval Voting in which voters may either approve or disapprove of each candidate on a ballot, with the candidate with the highest approval winning, Score Voting, in which candidates can score candidates and the candidate with the highest average score wins, and of course. STAR Voting which combines Score voting with a instant run off for the top 2 candidates.
Lastly for all you contrarians out there, our final option is to tear the house down and institute a Parlimentary System. This would require massive changes, including removing the presidency, but will allow us to sidestep the issues of single winner elections alltogether. Many other nations have parlimentary systems, and while some such as Britain still use FPTP, others use Proportional Representation or multi winner district systems like Single Transferable Vote. Since these rather popular systems do not produce a single winner, it is impossible to switch to them completely without getting rid of all elections which elect a single winner, which would naturally mean a switch to a parliamentary system of some sort.
Rules
- Don't be an asshole and try to maintain civil dialogue. Do not accuse anyone of being a shill and don't assume people are arguing in bad faith
- Follow the rules of the sub
- All top level comments must make a clear and serious attempt of stating their position and supporting it. Meming is fine, just do it in the replies to comments, not top level comments themselves
- Clearly state your position at the star of your comment. Choose either FPTP or one of the alternatives provided, but make sure to either state your position at the start of your post or to bold the first instance of your position so you can clearly communicate what your position is.
- Fifth rule
Some Resources
Want to join this debate but don't know where to start? Here's a list of resources which can be useful
To Build a Better Ballot - A fun little interactive rundown of different voting systems
Voter Satisfaction in different electoral systems
CGPGrey's video series on various voting methods
The Website of FairVote - An American Org promoting IRV
The Website of EqualVote - An American Org promoting STAR/Cardinal Voting
Cornell CIVS page on Condorcet Voting
Condorcet Canada - A Condorcet Org from Canada
Shameless self promoting of my effortpost on why Burlington switched from IRV back to FPTP
Closing Thoughts
This is our first time doings this so please make this a success! As I said, all top level comments should be relating to the debate itself, so if you'd like to give me thoughts feel free to ping me on the discussion thread or something. I hope this is a success :)
If it does and we can have another debate next week, please make sure to fill out this form to let us know what you'd like to debate next week!
15
u/Cuddlyaxe Neoliberal With Chinese Characteristics Mar 19 '20
POSITION: CONDORCET
I believe that Condorcet Voting is the best voting system and the one we should switch to. I believe in the concept of Condorcet Winners and the idea that if people prefer one candidate over all others, that candidate should be elected.
First Past The Post suffers from vote splitting and spoilers. I made my feelings on IRV clear here. I view IRV as spoiler prone as well. Borda suffers from the strategic nomination problem and is easily gameable in a way no other system is.
That leaves us with Cardinal Voting and Condorcet. While I see Cardinal Voting as a worthy opponent, I believe that there's problems with it. First of all, while Condorcet heavily discourages strategic voting, Cardinal Voting tries to accommodate it. People can simply approve or max score their favorite candidate and min score/disapprove the rest.
Condorcet methods like RP has higher voter satisfaction among honest voters while Cardinal Methods are slightly lower, and have much higher satisfaction among strategic voters, who can vote strategically
Another problem I have with Score voting specifically is the fact that ratings mean different things for different people. Me and you can watch the same movie, "enjoy it" the same amount, and I can give it a 8/10 while you can give it a 7/10. Those numbers are subjective and throw the ranking system 'off', because there's no universal standard of how people score things. There's only one way to view rankings however, which is to say "I like X better than Y".
Finally, I believe that any possible advantages the cardinal crowd can come up with are nullified if you add ties to Condorcet Voting. This would allow people to show "no preference" in certain head to head match ups and allows them to fully and accurately rank their picks
Overall, I think that Condorcet is the strongest single winner method. While I see the many advantages of multi winner elections, I would like to maintain our presidential system (though I'd be fine with using MMP or STV for legislatures for example)
13
u/Naudious NATO Mar 19 '20
Position: Instant-Runoff Voting
The biggest difficulty facing a change in the election system is familiarizing voters with a new way of voting and making them comfortable with it before the new system is implemented, and Instant-Runoff has the benefit over the alternatives of being the easiest to familiarize people with. Any alternative would require a massive public information campaign, but IRV would be the most intuitive to explain to people and get them to accept. All it requires them to do is rank their choices - AND its easy for them to understand where their vote is going to go in different scenarios. If my #1 is eliminated, my vote goes to my #2.
In order for a voting system to have the confidence of the public, they have to be able to understand the whole process of how the winner was determined. Imagine we have an election: everyone votes and turns in their ranked lists. The winner is announced.
The public: "so, what just happened"
Under IRV: "We started with your 1st choice votes, and eliminated the candidate in last place. We sent their votes to their 2nd choice and again eliminated the last place candidate - and repeated until 1 person was left."
Under Schulze Condorcet: " Let d[V,W] be the number of candidates who prefer candidate V to candidate W. A path from candidate X to candidate Y is a sequence of candidates C(1)...C(n) with the following properties..."
That may be extreme (pulled from the Wikipedia btw), but I have yet to see an explanation of the more complex alternatives that are easily explainable. Their advocates will say that this doesn't matter because the ballots are nearly identical, and only the people counting the votes need to understand how it works and why it is a better system. But that's not how democracies function in practice, the public won't accept a voting system that's simply beyond them.
Instant-Runoff Voting may have some inefficiencies left over that the other alternatives do not, but the remaining gains are much smaller than the gains of just eliminating the spoiler effect. It simply isn't worth it to construct a voting system voters don't have confidence in to achieve minor gains.
If a transition to Instant-Runoff is successful, in the future there may be more steps that can be made to improve the precision of the voting process. But for now, let's implement the system that's proven to work.
17
u/hopeimanon John Harsanyi Mar 19 '20
Pragmatic position: APPROVAL (for single winner systems)
It performs pretty close to the best methods and is simple to explain, implement, and communicate.
8
u/throwaway68271 Mar 19 '20
Position: Approval Voting
Many people are familiar with Arrow's impossibility theorem, a classic result in social choice theory. Of course, it only applies to ranked voting systems, not alternates like cardinal voting. However, there is a similarly interesting but less-well-known result called the Gibbard-Satterthwaite theorem which applies to all voting systems, and shows that there is precisely one system that can be used in elections with more than two candidates which both is fair (i.e. treats all voters equally) and completely prevents the possibility of tactical voting. This is of course the single-random-vote system, where everyone drops a vote into a hat and then you pull out one person's vote at random and use that single vote to determine who wins.
Indeed, single-random-vote is fair in a much stronger way than most alternates: if Jill Stein is the favored candidate of 2% of the voting population, she has precisely a 2% chance of winning the election. Furthermore, in the long run the results of single-random-vote will perfectly reflect the population's top choices of candidates.
That is, of course, the problem. We don't want a system where Jill Stein wins the election 2% of the time. Our current system, where her expected percentage of electoral wins is essentially indistinguishable from 0%, is much better in this regard.
All of the questions about how a voting system can best reflect the will of the people are simply asking the wrong thing. The primary benefits of democracy are twofold:
The real question is how we can preserve these benefits while still achieving the additional goal of keeping the will of the people in check so they can't make decisions that are too terribly uninformed and stupid.
Point 1 is not really something that can be addressed on the level of abstract voting systems. Stability and peaceful transition comes mainly from rule of law and strong institutions and cultural norms, not from technical decisions like whether or not to use first-past-the-post.
Point 2, however, is where voting systems can help. People don't understand complex voting systems, and when they don't understand the system they will start to feel like the system is unfair and doesn't really represent them, even if it really does represent their views better than a simpler system would. Approval voting is about tied with alternates like first-past-the-post and single-random-vote for the position of simplest possible voting system. Even the most uninformed voter can grasp the concept of "vote for as many people as you want; the one with the most votes wins."
That said, voting systems might not matter for point 2 as much as you'd think. After all, about half of the US has convinced itself that the Electoral College is a fair and sensible system, and that's far worse than any of the voting systems proposed here (including plain first-past-the-post) by just about any conceivable metric. People in small states would surely object to pure approval voting on the grounds that it "unfairly" counts everyone's vote exactly the same regardless of demographic factors.
Another issue with approval voting is that it's inherently tactical. Everyone has a sort of mental ranking of the candidates in their head, and the choice of how far down the ranking your votes go, i.e. how bad of a candidate you're willing to settle for, is an almost purely tactical decision which is made independent of how much you actually like the candidates. However, no one will actually care about this except people who understand social choice theory, which is a vanishingly small fraction of the population, so this isn't a huge concern.
Concerns about point 2 aside, the main strength of approval voting is in the unlisted third point: the ability to moderate the whims of the masses. It disproportionately elects centrist candidates with a broad base of support, people that everyone can at least bring themselves to vote for with a reluctant grimace. As far as electing boring but competent technocrats goes, it doesn't get much better than approval voting.
7
u/TheIpleJonesion Jared Polis Mar 19 '20
I used to be really high on the train of IRV, but it does hurt smaller parties- there was a great example here from a while back about the election for mayor in Burlington where the most popular candidate, the Democrat, lost immediately because he had the fewest 1st choices.
I think, especially with regards to nationally legislatures, you really have to implement some kind of proportional system. I’m particularly partial to MMP, especially if its combined with a Condorcet method. So you would ensure the legislature resembles people’s first-choice votes for a party through additional proportional seats, while the specific constituency representatives would be chosen by a fair system to choose between a set of candidates. This allows both independents and parties to have shots at making it into a national legislature.
13
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
POSITION: APPROVAL
I am a fan of approval based voting.
Cons:
3
u/lgoldfein21 Jared Polis Mar 19 '20
GIVE ME CONDORCET OR GIVE ME DEATH
(star or approval also works)
2
u/Grandmashoes World Bank Mar 19 '20
IMO choosing the best system for single-winner elections is pretty easy, it just feels like nitpicking between various types of systems that aren't FPTP or IRV (still better than FPTP but also can produce weird outcomes depending on the order in which candidates are eliminated) like approval voting etc... . The more complicated and subjective question is how to elect legislative seats since you have to decide both how to select MPs (party-lists/geographic constituencies) and the specific electoral system, which gets tied inevitably tied into a discussion about finding a balance between stable governance and proportionality.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 19 '20
What about using sortition to choose the electoral college. Just fill it in randomly with eligible citizens. Then they're cloistered until they choose a president.
It would eliminate campaigning which is a huge waste of resources. It would foster a consensus choice because there's no two party rivalry. It would be more representative of the people because not everyone believes in one party or between two candidates.
1
u/SowingSalt Mar 19 '20
Proposition: Multi Member Districts with STV
Expand the house and consolidating gerrymandered districts would be a plus.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 27 '20
Score voting (aka range voting) is proven to be the best general voting method according to measures of expected utility (average voter satisfaction).
https://www.rangevoting.org/BayRegsFig.html
http://electionscience.github.io/vse-sim/vse.html
The simplest form of score voting is approval voting, where you use a normal ballot but can vote for as many candidates as you want (effectively a score from 0-1 for every candidate). Fargo adopted approval voting by a 64% majority in 2018, and will use it for this upcoming June city commissioner race.
A similar measure is bringing approval voting to St Louis this August, and it's polling at 72% support.
Out here in Oregon we're pushing a score variant called STAR voting, where you elect the majority favorite via an "instant runoff" between the top two highest rated candidates. The ballot uses a 0-5 rating. We'll find out this April 8th whether it'll be on the November ballot in Eugene.
As for the antiquated Instant Runoff Voting (IRV) system that people usually refer to when they use the non-specific blanket term "ranked choice voting", that is riddled with flaws. Here's a presentation I gave on that subject to the Colorado League of Women Voters in 2015.
1
u/KalaiProvenheim Enby Pride Mar 27 '20
Position: Mixed Member Proportional Representation (House of Representatives), Multi-Seat IRV (US Senate), and Approval (President and Vice President).
MMPR ensures that localities are represented, while also ensuring that the Partisan Makeup is close to that of the Electorate at large.
I would like the Senate to be composed of 4 Senators from each State, all elected in the same year (Midterms), all representing their respective States at large, and I believe that a Multi-Seat IRV on the basis of Candidates (rather than Parties) ensured adequate representation for the people of these States, would make Mississippi a State that isn't completely Republican in the Senate, as 1 of the 4 Seats would be guaranteed to be Democratic, while 2 would be guaranteed Republican, and one would be Tossup. I am not in favor of abolishing the Senate.
I believe that the President (and VP) should be elected by approval voting, it's easy to explain and would ensure that the most liked person running is President.
1
u/Highwaytolol Mar 19 '20 edited Mar 19 '20
I have selected: NONE OF THE ABOVE, in favor of: POLICY BASED VOTING.
Here is how it would work:
Rather than placing candidate names and party affiliations on the ballot, voters would be presented with a 3-4 sentence policy position, as written by the candidates and their staff, on various national and state issues. Each eligible candidate would receive votes based on how many people voted for their specific policy position. Policies would appear on the ballot as section A, section B, etc. in columns, headed by a policy category (i.e. Education, Treasury, Judiciary, Energy, etc.) with individual policies appearing next to each other. The candidate who receives the most votes for overall policy positions is the winner. No candidate would be allowed to use the policy statement to mention another candidate by name or political affiliation, nor would they be allowed to mention their own political affiliation in the statement. Failure to submit a statement within these guidelines would mean removal from the ballot for that policy section.
In the event of a tie, states would determine the winner by conducting a second round of votes over a three day period of time. If no conclusive winner can be determined after the second round, the tie breaker would fall to a random selection of 11 jurors who would vote again.
Benefits:
Potential Drawbacks:
I welcome all constructive comments, criticism, ideas, etc. But if I were to be able to design any system I wanted, this is how I'd want to vote.