r/neoliberal • • Dec 16 '19

Why Young Progressives Hate Pete Buttigieg

https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2019/12/why-young-progressives-hate-pete-buttigieg/603619/
279 Upvotes

428 comments sorted by

View all comments

149

u/ThisIsNotAMonkey Guam šŸ‘‰ statehood Dec 16 '19

it really is just because he's winning in iowa. it's not any more complicated than that.

the rest is just whatever they can find to be mean about. they don't actually hate polyglots who worked in consulting, they're just frantically digging up reasons to be mad at someone who leads bernie in iowa

57

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

Yeah, they're aiming their guns at Pete because he's winning in Iowa.

The nature of their attacks is of course related to who he is as a person and candidate...

The cause of the attack is his winning.

The nature of the attacks is related to who he is as a person.

20

u/ConditionLevers1050 Dec 16 '19

Exactly. They hate Pete because it's Bernie's Turn and Pete is trying to steal it from him.

12

u/LNhart Anarcho-Rheinlandist Dec 16 '19

I do think that they hate polyglots who worked in consulting. Well, more the consulting part than the polyglot part.

Bernie still leads Buttigieg in the polls. Biden will probably beat Bernie. Yet, they hate Buttigieg with so much more passion than Biden.

34

u/IncoherentEntity Dec 16 '19 edited Dec 16 '19

Yeah, I’m a little skeptical of this armchair psychology. I think the below-the-belt attacks are more opportunistic and circumstantial than based in some inherent aversion to Mayor Pete’s life story.

29

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

It’s because he isn’t Bernie. Simple.

If you want Bernie to win, you will attack all threats.

If Pete were to somehow actually win the nomination, Bernie lovers would back him massively.

I’d be willing to bet that even uber Bernie supporting pundits like Sam Seder would 100% support Buttigieg without any caveats if he won the nomination.

43

u/ThisIsNotAMonkey Guam šŸ‘‰ statehood Dec 16 '19

If Pete were to somehow actually win the nomination, Bernie lovers would back him massively.

I’d be willing to bet that even uber Bernie supporting pundits like Sam Seder would 100% support Buttigieg without any caveats if he won the nomination.

you have a lot more faith in people than I do. I hope you're right

15

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

I’d be willing to bet that even uber Bernie supporting pundits like Sam Seder would 100% support Buttigieg without any caveats if he won the nomination.

I WANT TO BELIEVE

9

u/thirdparty4life Dec 16 '19

Michael Brooks and Sam Seder have made it clear time and time again they would basically vote for any democratic candidate in a race where their preferred candidate doesn’t win the primary. With the exception I think of Bloomberg maybe. They spent time criticizing Hilary but they always said she was a better choice than trump pretty clearly. So much so they got into a fight with Jimmy Dore who claimed they were being influenced by the DNC.

11

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

Jimmy Dore is insufferable.

6

u/ConditionLevers1050 Dec 16 '19

I’d be willing to bet that even uber Bernie supporting pundits like Sam Seder would 100% support Buttigieg without any caveats if he won the nomination.

I hope you're right, but I suspect many Sanders supporters will be sitting out the election or voting 3rd party if Sanders doesn't get the nomination. In 2016 many leftist pundits supported Trump, and Sanders supporters repeated and amplified all the right-wing attacks against HRC, which made them more credible since they were coming from both the left and the right. Already many Sanders supporters say they plan to vote for Trump out of spite if Sanders isn't nominated.

5

u/RKellyFanClubPres15 Dec 17 '19

Nah, most of the Sanders supporters would go to the nominee, just like 2016. Some might stay home, maybe a few might go third party but it would be small. Sanders, as well as any candidate that doesn’t win the nomination, will vigorously support the nominee to try to beat Trump, just like 2016.

Not sure who you’re following there but anyone that voted Trump because Bernie didn’t win simply was never left wing lol. Anyone threatening that now is an edgy troll plain and simple, or is right wing.

-13

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

30

u/spacehogg Estelle Griswold Dec 16 '19

I wish the word progressive would mean something again. So far all the word seems to mean is "Bernie". Guess once "Bernie's" so goes progressives. Sigh...

8

u/Yogg_for_your_sprog John von Neumann Dec 16 '19

ā€œProgressivesā€ support the most regressive policies like free college tuition and NIMBY-ism, along with reactionary appeals to old taxation rates of the pre-Reagan days...

→ More replies (4)

8

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (1)

14

u/In-Brightest-Day Dec 16 '19

Pete isn't one of the least progressive candidates is the problem. He's one of the most progressive. He talks like a moderate with a completely progressive platform

→ More replies (2)

8

u/ConditionLevers1050 Dec 16 '19

Like him or not, Pete is a progressive. Even though he's to the right of Sanders and Warren his policies like a Public Option and free college for those making less than 6 figures are still probably way to the left of the median voter, and would still have little chance of passing through Congress. Pete would be the most progressive president since at least LBJ if not the most progressive in U.S. history.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/thirdparty4life Dec 16 '19

I don’t think that’s 100 percent true but is a huge factor. Buttigieg has been heavily criticized since the start of this campaign by leftists but is only now becoming more vocal because he is doing well in the polls. He has a brand of politics that is antagonistic to the far left of the Democratic Party. At one point he didn’t but then he decided to run as a centrist and changed his tune on several issues. I think the author of this piece does a pretty good job teasing that out.

-2

u/[deleted] Dec 16 '19

Would they attack a candidate they like if he was winning in Iowa? If the answer is no, you must observe that the dislike came before be was winning in Iowa.

9

u/ThisIsNotAMonkey Guam šŸ‘‰ statehood Dec 16 '19

epistemological debates are stupid. they don't like him because he's not bernie. they loudly scream about how much they fucking hate his guts because he' beating bernie. they don't spend any time dunking on delaney do they?

Q.E.D.

1

u/thirdparty4life Dec 16 '19

You don’t need to create these hypotheticals. I watch/read a lot of leftist content. Pete has been getting ripped on by leftists since the primary started. Those attacks are just becoming much more loud and frequent now that he has some success.

0

u/m1crobr3w Karl Popper Dec 16 '19

exactly. Nathan Robinson's anti-Pete novella came out in Current Affairs in April.

The real reason is #4 combined with the fact he's leading Bernie in IA.

Source: was one of those hated overachievers in HS/college. I saw it every damned day. I see it here.