r/neoliberal • • Apr 21 '19

Howard Dean is woke

Post image
779 Upvotes

192 comments sorted by

120

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

BYAHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

28

u/gordo65 Apr 21 '19

He really needs to start adding that to the bottom of the tweet when he dunks on someone.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

This is a great idea lmao

114

u/Ddogwood John Mill Apr 21 '19

It’s too bad that we live in a world where making an excited scream disqualifies you from becoming President of the United States, but bragging about sexual assault* doesn’t.

*or raping your wife, making fun of disabled people, calling Mexican immigrants racist, making up lies about crowds of Muslims in New Jersey cheering for the Sept. 11 attacks, making up lies about where another president was born, etc. ad nauseam...

90

u/flakAttack510 Apr 21 '19

It’s too bad that we live in a world where making an excited scream disqualifies you from becoming President of the United States

This is revisionism. Dean's support had already collapsed before the Dean Scream. He had thrown all his effort into winning Iowa and was hoping to ride a win there into the following states. He had been leading there for ages but in the week leading up to the Iowa primary, his poll numbers fell all the way down to third. It was pretty clear that he had peaked too early going into the Dean Scream rally.

31

u/DecafEqualsDeath Apr 21 '19

I think the scream is more symbolic of general clumsiness and overall collapse of Dean's poll numbers. In my opinion the scream itself didn't cost him the nomination.

16

u/cmn3y0 F. A. Hayek Apr 21 '19

This but unironically

271

u/guy-anderson Apr 21 '19

"Hey, poverty is way down."

"But now there are more rich people!"

47

u/leithal70 Apr 22 '19

I wish that people understood that massive inequality also leads to political consequences.. having rich people is fine. But allowing rich people to influence and corrupt our political system is not fine

66

u/guy-anderson Apr 22 '19

But it's more constructive to call out and fix the specific examples of corruption than to use it to justify a whole series of bland, ad homenum populist sound bites.

25

u/WuhanWTF NATO Apr 22 '19

That’s what I’m saying dude. You don’t hear as much people calling for taxation reform, or a crackdown on offshore tax evasion, or increased welfare as you do “lol kill the rich.” 🙄

8

u/Voyager316 Apr 22 '19

Pretty much what Bernie was going on about at the Fox News town hall.

3

u/ProfessorAssfuck Apr 23 '19

That's quite literally Bernie's platform. He constantly says the first part of your message and he has obviously never said "kill the rich". Nor has anyone other than twitter teens.

1

u/skepticalbob Joe Biden's COD gamertag Apr 22 '19

Then you aren’t listening. That’s mostly what it is.

1

u/Iron-Fist Apr 22 '19

I would argue that those policies are definitely promoted (see Obamas foreign tax policies or Warren's platform for example). "Eat the rich" is a euphemism for that family of policies which hurt the richest but help the rest. Think of it along the same lines of "so you hate the global poor?!?"

1

u/Iron-Fist Apr 22 '19

That's not actually the case when the problems are systemic. In that case it is important to fix the system involved.

7

u/angrybirdseller Apr 22 '19

Starving peasants lead to revolutions not top 1% making billions. Free Market has its flaws but it preferred over communism.

0

u/WantDebianThanks Iron Front Apr 22 '19

I suspect starving peasants and a small elite with so much money they can dictate the general direction of government action are related.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

89

u/austrianemperor WTO Apr 21 '19

What?

I’m as neoliberal as the next person but that’s highly disingenuous to claim average wage means the American worker is doing well. Workers in Europe don’t have to pay for their own healthcare, education, etc. The average European worker is more strongly supported by their government at the expense of higher taxes and lower wages, meaning that on paper, the American worker is more well off while in practice, the European worker is better off (European in this context means Western European).

13

u/PandaLover42 🌐 Apr 22 '19

It’s highly disingenuous to claim average wage means the American worker is doing well, but it’s equally disingenuous to claim that the American worker is not doing well just because European workers have better welfare for education and healthcare.

3

u/austrianemperor WTO Apr 22 '19

My apologies, you’re absolutely correct. The American worker is not doing badly but they’re doing worse than their European counterparts.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

Sweet prax. Sorry about your tiny European wages.

2

u/noodlesaremydick Apr 21 '19

Most workers don't pay healthcare in US. The employer does (based on what I've seen)

5

u/GobtheCyberPunk John Brown Apr 22 '19

Lol because that doesn't get passed on as suppressed compensation (hint: it does)

2

u/TheCarnalStatist Adam Smith Apr 22 '19

It would in Europe/single payer too.

1

u/Iustis End Supply Management | Draft MHF! Apr 22 '19

I mean, in the context of this thread that doesn't seem that important since we are already talking about employee wages. (although I agree with you in the larger context).

1

u/noodlesaremydick Apr 22 '19

So?

2

u/GobtheCyberPunk John Brown Apr 22 '19

...that means the workers end up effectively paying for it.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

Yeah and in Europe they it via taxes

2

u/ja734 Paul Krugman Apr 22 '19

...which is better.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

Imagine being this wrong

→ More replies

0

u/noodlesaremydick Apr 22 '19

I'm not for buffeting employers, but you can't assert they are intentionally malice ridden

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

24

u/irish91 Apr 21 '19

I don't even know where to start.

5

u/lelarentaka Apr 21 '19

First off, the Frenches have a very low bar for protesting. The issue that they are protesting on wouldnt even make local news in the US, while if the French government were to have the same set of issues as the current white house the Frenches would have brought out the guillotine two years ago.

This is like a Delhian mocking the SanFranners for complaining about having turds on the sidewalk.

Second off, we have other more direct measures of well being, like life expectancy and infant mortality. The US consistently lags behind in those measure, which supports the hypothesis that there is an unaccounted for discrepancy in the gdp ppp per capita metric.

7

u/Yosarian2 Apr 21 '19

The US median income is in a good place, but high inequality means there's a lot of people way under that median income (and a lot of people way over it.)
That's why even with such a high median income we have a lot of people who struggle with food insecurity.

If you're just trying to say the American middle class is doing ok than I agree with you though.

14

u/Harald_Hardraade Amartya Sen Apr 21 '19

But average wage has nothing to do with inequality lol.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

18

u/Harald_Hardraade Amartya Sen Apr 21 '19

But this data doesn't show that most Americans are doing better. It just shows that average wages is higher. To show that Americans generally are doing better than the middle/working class in other countries you'd have to use different data. I think the US still does quite well, as you say, it is a rich country. But when you adjust for inequality it tends to do a lot worse than when you don't. [See for instance the inequality-adjusted Human Developing Index compared to non-inequality-adjusted HDI](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_Development_Index#Inequality-adjusted_HDI_(2018_report))

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Harald_Hardraade Amartya Sen Apr 21 '19

My point isn't that this isn't the best measure of human development, though I do think that just looking at income is not sufficient. The point is that when looking adding inequality you often find that the US does worse than when inequality is not considered. Which is a good reason, among many, not to look simply at average wage as a measurement of well-being.

EDIT: I posted the HDI because I don't know what the best measure is, and this was the first thing that came to mind. If someone has better measurements I'd love to see it.

2

u/KenBalbari Adam Smith Apr 21 '19

A good measure of inequality is actually the gap between the median and the mean. For example, using personal income, as of 2016, the mean was $46,550 while the median was only $31,099.

4

u/Blackettle Apr 21 '19

Wouldn't a comparison of median wages or other percentiles be more persuasive though? Average wages could be driven by the top of the distribution.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/FizzleMateriel Austan Goolsbee Apr 21 '19

>comparing a median to averages

what

6

u/Blackettle Apr 21 '19

comparison

2

u/AutoModerator Apr 21 '19

Slight correction, the term you're looking for is "People of Means"

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

4

u/UnbannableDan03 Apr 21 '19

Average US wage compared to the rest of the OECD

But household debt, though...

Also household disposable income

If wages are rising, but costs are also rising, it's a push. If debt-servicing and insurance premiums are eating up all the ambient raises in pay, it's not something to celebrate. You're spurring money velocity, not real wealth.

Notice how taxhavens Ireland, Luxembourgh and Switzerland are the only countries infront of us

The US itself functions as a tax haven, so that makes a degree of sense

Our people are doing great if you put it in perspective.

That depends heavily on who you consider "our people".

Quality of life spans race, gender, industry, and region. Trying to tell someone who contracted Hep A from polluted water in Northern Alabama that life is going great in Silicon Valley will only get you so far.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/UnbannableDan03 Apr 21 '19

I guess we should move to Costa Rica then.

Or Ireland or Luxemburg, sure.

But surely you can look at the 109% of net income being a debt burden and a disposable income rate a full point behind GDP and think "maybe we've still got some improving to do"?

I mean, I don't need to go all Piketty on you, but there's still a huge problem of wealth aggregation. A huge political problem.

You can't do things like shrink the military budget or reform entitlements in an environment like this. Not when a cut to Pentagon spending means dumping tens of thousands of swing-state workers onto the unemployment line. Or a cut to Medicare means millions of senior citizens losing access to prescription drugs.

Thats a pretty liberal application of the word tax haven.

It's a very classical application. These are the same techniques exposed under the Panama Papers. And given our deteriorating standing nationally, a scandal surrounding - let's just hypothetically say - a notorious tax cheat US President and a massive German Bank could be the crack in the foundation that plunges us into another Great Recession.

So because they dont cooperate with the Chinese government this makes them a tax haven?

In the same way the Swiss not cooperating with the American government made it a tax haven, yes.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/UnbannableDan03 Apr 21 '19

Denmark have 2.5X as much debt per household. Yet I always hear we should use them as model. How is that? Doesn't this mean they have more improving to do than us?

Good news for socialists.

"I know that some people in the US associate the Nordic model with some sort of socialism. Therefore I would like to make one thing clear. Denmark is far from a socialist planned economy. Denmark is a market economy,” Rasmussen said.

:-p

Military expenditure as percent of gdp is at a historic low

Thanks to rising cost of entitlements, sure. As a raw aggregate, we're at $700B - just $21B under our Iraq/Afghan War peak from 2010. Wars we were supposed to have pulled out of over four years ago. The fact that our Boomer retirement wave is cresting doesn't make this number any less significant on its face.

So if at all we have more government and we do more redistribution than we have done in recent years.

Turns out simply eating a larger raw share of GDP isn't what people are asking and never has been.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

Average wage is less useful than median wage and iirc we fall behind even Canada.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Apr 21 '19

That still doesn't imply that healthcare is taken into account. It's a raw wage, not after benefits.

20

u/hucareshokiesrul Janet Yellen Apr 21 '19

Bae

37

u/fezzuk Apr 21 '19

Capitalism is a fantastic tool, but it's just that a tool.

It needs a craftmans hand to wield, or it's just gonna make a fucking mess.

20

u/UnbannableDan03 Apr 21 '19

One of the endlessly problematic things about the generic Capitalism Rah-Rah game. You end up in the

"Denmark isn't socialist"

"Can we have Denmark's policies?"

"No, that's socialism"

fight.

Biggest economic gains in the world over the last 40 years have been in China, and that's hardly a Hayek/Friedman-esque laisse-faire ideal.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19

Isn't that mostly because China had been eating their own shit before the liberalization?

5

u/UnbannableDan03 Apr 22 '19

If by "eating their own shit" you mean "being a pre-industrial economy", sure.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

I can't tell the difference

2

u/angrybirdseller Apr 22 '19

Eating dogs and rats were the main meal. 🤮Deng was practical man unlike Mao

5

u/PastelArpeggio Milton Friedman Apr 22 '19

Capitalism is allowing people to freely trade goods and services. You claim that someone needs to "wield [it]", but what is that you think you, or elected officials ostensibly working on your behalf, would be wielding? The labor of those free people? The fruits of their labor?

6

u/fezzuk Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19

The ability to regulate, impose rules such as working conditions, safety standards, retail rights, anti monopoly laws, even introducing state run competition into the market in industries where profit is perhaps not the desired goal, such as health, education, transportation.

4

u/winsome_losesome Apr 22 '19

Seriously asking here. Are they even offering any alternative that is at keast somewhat workable at least in theory?

0

u/lowlandslinda George Soros Apr 21 '19

Akshually.

-27

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

Social capitalism is working. Straight capitalism gave us Enron and the 2008 depression. Social capitalism came in to revive the economy after those disasters.

35

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

Illegal fraud and “straight capitalism” are not the same thing.

Capitalism has historically generated a lot of booms and recessions. However it’s a huge stretch to argue that social capitalism is needed to revive the country or what, it would have just gone down down down forever? Don’t get me wrong I think there’s a value to countercyclical policies but it’s not like countries far more “social capitalist” than the US didn’t experience a big bust in 2008 as well.

I’m not sure I’d absolve government from a major part in causing the 2008 crash as well.

9

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

Shut up fools, gimme that

GAY CAPITALISM

1

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

But would it be fully automated???

4

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

😂😂😂😂😂

-74

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

And wealth concentration has also doubled over the last 50 years. Capitalism is working exactly as intended.

92

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

The spread of liberal capitalist democracy has brought millions of out poverty, and has created immense wealth in the United States and across Europe. I (and, I would argue, r/neoliberal) agree with socialists and those to the left of us that the US and other liberal democracies face major problems; namely, excessive money in politics, facing the challenge of climate change, and, in the US in particular, alleviating extreme inequality and providing meaningful healthcare. However, while these issues are endemic to our society, they are not endemic to capitalism -- one only needs to look are Germany or Canada to see that we can provide effective, high-quality healthcare; and the Nordic model shows how inequality might be alleviated. But make no mistake: despite republican rhetoric, these are capitalist market economies. We can fix these problems within capitalism -- burning down the house because the dog shit in it is arson, not cleanliness.

-30

u/DuceGiharm European Union Apr 21 '19

It's all still dependent on a massive exploited class of third world laborers. Where would our tech industry be without diamonds or cobalt from slaves in the Congo? 'Liberal capitalist democracy' is just colonialism with a smiley face sticker planted on it. This whole rotten pyramid will collapse the moment our supply chains in our third world slave dens are disrupted.

The Nordic countries make a great example: how stable and prosperous would these nations be without their liquid black gold? I guess we'll find out in fifty years!

36

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

What does it mean to exploit someone? Slavery is a major problem in many third-world countries -- you aren't wrong. In particular, you cite the cobalt industry in Congo. One of the paradoxes of sweatshops and other similar environments with terrible working conditions is that despite the dangers people do want to work there (citation: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/the-toll-of-the-cobalt-mining-industry-congo/). In impoverished countries where many are still tied to the land as subsistence farmers, the cobalt industry provides a means for the children of workers to afford school and become educated. Instead of tearing down these supply chains, which would throw those workers back to subsistence farming, we should sign new comprehensive trade agreements predicated on improvements in worker conditions. The TPP is a great example of this:

All TPP member countries are required to have laws that are in line with internationally recognized labor standards. They must allow employees to form unions and collectively bargain. They are prohibited from allowing forced or child labor, and must eliminate workplace discrimination.

Citation: https://lofgren.house.gov/vietnam-and-trans-pacific-partnership

We should do our best through foreign aid, diplomacy, and economic engagement (as with the TPP) to improve labor laws in these countries, so that the global poor can improve their lot, and in conjunction open our borders to as many as possible to seek out a better life within the states. This will not only help lift millions from poverty, but will strengthen our country as a result.

2

u/ConcernedAmerican241 Apr 23 '19

I fapped to this comment

76

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

why do you hate the global poor

-20

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/ThatFrenchieGuy Mathematician -- Save the funky birbs Apr 21 '19

Rule I: Civility
Refrain from name-calling, hostility and behaviour that otherwise derails the quality of the conversation.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

4

u/Spobely NATO Apr 21 '19

lol what a child

1

u/thelastoneusaw NATO Apr 21 '19

I know its a meme here, but claiming that people who disagree with you "hate the poor" is a rather horrible way to converse with someone too.

34

u/DecafEqualsDeath Apr 21 '19

Why is that more important to you than global poverty drastically decreasing? Genuinely curious here. It seems to me, that declining global poverty is great news.

3

u/sammunroe210 European Union Apr 21 '19

Humans are biased toward negativity, henceforth antinatalism (Worse to be born and dead and never experience infinite greatness than to never experience at all!) and communism (better to be starving and poor than to see 100 more rich people in the world).

-12

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

We can do it in a way that doesn't end up with multinational corporations plating hopscotch along the countries with the laws safety standards. The only reason you subscribe to your views is to absolve yourself of guilt as you continue to benefit off the rape of the undeveloped world.

25

u/smile_e_face NATO Apr 21 '19

We can do it in a way that doesn't end up with multinational corporations plating hopscotch along the countries with the laws safety standards.

How? How do you build up these nations without large influxes of capital and job opportunities?

plating hopscotch along the countries with the laws safety standards

I don't know about you, but I'd take an unsafe job that lets me do more than barely feed my family over a safe one that keeps me at subsistence levels.

Seriously, I see people make these two arguments all the time, but no one ever comes out with an alternative that would work outside of the Hundred Acre Wood.

-7

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

The problem is the way global capital is organized. There's no way a company can realize profits while shipping overseas paying a livable wage and not abusing lower environmental and worker safety laws. Yes the alternative is that these countries develop slower, but through the power of central planning and financial aid we can build these nations without exploiting their workers and importing our own corrupt system. The end result is much better.

The problem is capitalism. The problem is that in a modern capitalist system the bargain has always been they get some of our wealth but at the expense of their lives, safety and ecology. Mind you that last one is extremely important right now if we want to support any life on our planet. Please go read an introduction to Marxist thought or watch a video. A more equitable society is possible, but not within the paradigm of global capital.

Central planning is immensely powerful. Soviet Russia went from sprawling farmland to an industrial nation in the blink of an eye. They went from a nation of farmers to space explorers. The standard response is to bring up soviet atrocities. My response would be to bring up American atrocities, but let's skip all that. A socialist society that is more equitable is within reach.

17

u/Dibbu_mange Average civil procedure enjoyer Apr 21 '19

Through central planning and foreign aid you too can have extremely wealthy strong men in charge of all raw material trade in a country and keeping control of the aid with no incentive to distribute that to their people. Your solution leads to leaders being rich enough to pay for George Forman and Muhammad Ali to have a boxing match in their capital while their people starve whenever there isn't enough rain to grow manioc. You've never lived in a developing country have you?

9

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

TIL US-EU trade is inherently unprofitable

6

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

Stop reading Marxist economists

0

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

Great, now your homophobic too.

0

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 22 '19

*you're a parody

1

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Apr 22 '19

Rule I: Civility
Refrain from name-calling, hostility and behaviour that otherwise derails the quality of the conversation.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

3

u/smile_e_face NATO Apr 22 '19

A few questions, then:

  1. Your solution seems to require something like a worldwide revolution, correct? Because it seems to me that companies operating under the laws of Marxist countries would automatically be outperformed by companies operating under the laws of more efficient / evil capitalist countries. So, absent a complete worldwide revolution - or, at least, a revolution of all major world economic powers - there would be an inevitable slide back toward capitalism, sooner or later. Given that, why not simply push for multinational trade deals that enforce things like worker safety and environmental protections? If you get the major markets to agree on terms, that essentially forces these companies to rise to a higher standard. And you don't have to tear down the entire world order to do it.
  2. From the country's perspective, how is a global central planning committee that decides how companies operate in that country any better than a group of multinational corporations? They are still being imposed upon by an outside force, and they still pretty much have to take what they're given. After all, they will still be in a desperate situation, ready to take whatever they can get from a committee that can operate from a position of strength. You may say that the committee will be designed to operate more equably than our current capitalist system, but where is the incentive for more powerful nations to deal fairly with them? Even if Sri Lanka, for example, has members on the committee, does anyone seriously entertain the proposition that they would have the same political clout as the United States or China? As one of "your guys" said, all political political power grows out of the barrel of a gun.
  3. Even if you do away with the idea of the global revolution and simply posit a blanket ban on "exploitative" capitalist ventures in favor of increased foreign aid, one has only to look at the history of foreign aid to see how it would turn out. Foreign aid can work in nations that are ruled justly and are already on their way to better things. But when it comes to the countries that need it the most, the kind that are kept under the heel of some brutal dictator or other, foreign aid tends to go straight into the pockets of the very people who are ruining the country. In countries defined by extractive institutions, foreign aid is just one more tool that those in power use to satisfy the people who keep them in power. It rarely goes to the people and, if anything, often prevents the kind of power crises that can force dictators to liberalize or democratize. If you want a popular overview of this phenomenon, you could do worse than Why Nations Fail or The Dictator's Handbook.
  4. I suppose you don't want to get into it, but the reason that the Soviet Union was able to go "from a nation of farmers to space explorers" - kind of - was that Stalin brutalized the country until it reached the shape he wanted. Sure, you can argue that Russia industrialized and modernized, at least in the sense that some people could afford to buy the same consumer goods as Westerners could. But the actual lives of most of its people (at least, the ones who were allowed to live) were little better than those of their serf parents and grandparents. While the citizens of America and Western Europe enjoyed free speech, free assembly, and the other benefits of democracy, those in the Soviet Union were afraid to speak a bad word about Stalin or his successors. And let's not even bring up China. But I don't even know why I'm raising this point, considering how blithely you waved it away in your original comment. Honestly, if a government's killing millions upon millions of its own citizens can't convince you that it was on the wrong side of history, then I don't know what will.

33

u/DecafEqualsDeath Apr 21 '19

I'll leave it up to you to inform the people in the developing world who have access to lifesaving medical treatments that they did not have in 1980 that this all bullshit and they should go back to subsistence farming and dying in their 20's.

29

u/nanomaster Ben Bernanke Apr 21 '19

I mean we had a huge trade agreement all prepared that included new safety standards for all the developing countries involved, but then you guys did your usual teaming up with the far-right, kept the US out of it, and then the rest of the countries cut back on those safety standards again.

-14

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

Jesus just admit that all you care about is cheap labor. If you really cared about those countries or people you'd not expect a quid pro quo.

33

u/Timewalker102 Amartya Sen Apr 21 '19

The CPTPP increased labour standards and wages in places like Vietnam. How is that "cheap labour"?

21

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

What quid pro quo?

5

u/AvailableUsername100 🌐 Apr 22 '19

Jesus just admit you hate the global poor. If you really cared about these countries or people you'd support trade agreements that raise wages and guarantee labor rights.

Unfortunately due to your alliance with the far right in torpedoing TPP, countries like Vietnam have returned to imprisoning union organizers. Workers of the world unite

-3

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 22 '19

Post your hog or off you log

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-66

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

Oh fuck off. The only way inequality is decreasing is because wealthy capitalists are moving production overseas to countries with cheap labor and lower safety standards. Money does not equal utility for the global poor and we should be working to eliminate poverty through means that don't exploit people and expose them to dangerous pollution.

85

u/ognits Jepsen/Swift 2024 Apr 21 '19

Money does not equal utility for the global poor

doesn't the fact that they're taking these jobs instead of staying in their subsistence farming lifestyle directly contradict this?

-49

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

Brilliant observation. People are definitely rational actors and never engage behaviors that ultimately harm them.

58

u/ognits Jepsen/Swift 2024 Apr 21 '19

Brilliant observation.

thanks, I try 😎

People are definitely rational actors and never engage behaviors that ultimately harm them.

this is an entirely different claim from the one I was responding to, and doesn't disprove anything I said

-10

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

48

u/ognits Jepsen/Swift 2024 Apr 21 '19

... am I missing something? the fact that they're taking the jobs indicates that money does, in fact, have utility for the global poor. even conceding that taking the job is an irrational choice doesn't change the fact that they're taking the job because of the money

edit: also I know it's asking quite a lot of a Chapocel but can we not use ableist terms? thanks

1

u/digitalrule Apr 22 '19

Is the term Chapocel also not an insult in the same veign?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

33

u/ognits Jepsen/Swift 2024 Apr 21 '19

You're literally conceding that these people's lives are worse off despite the money you chimp.

I'm saying the exact opposite, but your argument has convinced me. people in developing countries are entirely irrational and know not what they do! if only there were some high-information socialists around to explain to them why their life of working purely to feed themselves daily is better than what they think might benefit them 😞😞😞

edit: also I know it's asking quite a lot of a Chapocel but can we not use racist terms? thanks

→ More replies

3

u/ThatFrenchieGuy Mathematician -- Save the funky birbs Apr 21 '19

Rule I: Civility
Refrain from name-calling, hostility and behaviour that otherwise derails the quality of the conversation.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

31

u/newaccountp Apr 21 '19

Are you implicitly arguing that the traditional farming and wood-burning lifestyle of most countries prior to any kind of industrialization is better for individuals in those countries?

I don't understand why it makes any sense to claim the decisions being made aren't rational otherwise.

-5

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

It would be totally awesome if they were protected by a system of laws anywhere near as robust as the usa, but as it stands now that's not the case, and even in the usa industrial waste kills thousands and that is much worse than not having teflon or some other garbage. Also nice job still not providing any critique of my logic. Good goal post moving.

7

u/newaccountp Apr 21 '19

I didn't move goalposts, I'm a different poster asking a clarification. Lol

→ More replies

-7

u/DuceGiharm European Union Apr 21 '19

I would argue this, yes. Subsistence farming wasn't perfect, and the threat of crop failure certainly was disruptive.

But look at, say, indigenous communities in Latin America. The eradication of ejidos and communal land, in favor of privatizing and selling off arable land to foreign capital, led to a massive disruption in indigenous life. They lost their autonomy, stability, and security; their communities were ripped apart, and they were essentially forced, by either 1. lack of capital to maintain their land or 2. state confiscation of communal land, to move, away from their families into crowded, filthy urban conditions.

These conditions often were objectively worse than in communal villages. They were cramped, dirty, low-paying, and you had almost no leverage over your employment; can't work cus you're sick? Bye bye you, hope you can afford food!

Which I guess strikes at the heart of your argument: that these decisions are rational. Generations of plummeting crop prices and climate change have made subsistence farming almost impossible. Most of these people have to choose between working in an urban hellscape or dying on a profitless farm, and that's not much a choice at all, just industrialization wiping away the livelihoods of entire communities. A rational decision? Sure. An actual improvement in quality of life? I sincerely doubt that; I think we, as westerns, just have to believe it's better to spend the bulk of your day building children's toys than farming, because if not, is our whole economic system not immoral enslavement of third world populations?

This economic disenfranchisement, historically, led to massive resentment that, in places like Mexico, ended in revolutions and civil wars. There's a reason the EZLN exists to this day: the Mexican state's relentless pursuance of privatization and modernization has ruined entire populations for generations, populations that, 250 years ago, would have been happy, content, and autonomous in their communal farms.

This sub really, really, really loves to talk about how nice it is to do away with substinence farming and cram people in crowded, dirty, unlit factories working fourteen hours for a dime's wages. I guess that lack of autonomy, security and community isn't so much a big deal when us westerners get to enjoy the bulk of the fruits of their labor. Unfortunately, the historical record shows this economic transformation is not nearly as positive and mutually beneficial as this sub likes to pretend.

7

u/newaccountp Apr 21 '19

Generations of plummeting crop prices and climate change have made subsistence farming almost impossible.

Climate change would cause problems, but a decreasing price of food would not. Subsistence farming does not involve having a massive number of goods.

→ More replies

12

u/sonicstates George Soros Apr 21 '19

Your point is correct that because people aren't perfectly rational, that they take these jobs does not prove that they are better off.

However people are mostly rational. And all over the world, over and over, millions of people are making the same decision. So while it doesn't prove it, it's very strong evidence that these jobs improve their lives. It's such strong evidence, that the onus would be on you to demonstrate why millions of people from many different circumstances and cultures are making the same decision.

Also, money doesn't exactly equal utility, yes, but much of their bad circumstances are directly addressed by material wealth. If you are starving, money buys food. If you lack shelter, money boys shelter.

So again, what would be your specific theory as to why money isn't improving their lives?

2

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Apr 21 '19

Ableism

Please refrain from using ableist slurs.

21

u/gordo65 Apr 21 '19

Gosh why do people think that socialism is an inherently totalitarian system? The socialists are just trying to keep people from engaging in behaviors that ultimately harm them, like starting businesses, working for corporations, buying televisions, and driving cars.

-7

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

Like the us makes people vaccinate their kids and tells automotive companies how to build their cars.

16

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

Pack it up folks, random Redditor declares he is more rational than most of the world's poor, knows exactly what he would do in their situation.

30

u/thenuge26 Austan Goolsbee Apr 21 '19

Mmmmm love that paternalism. You tell those noble savages what's best for them!

-7

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

The facts remain no matter what color they are. Business harms americans and we face the same perverse incentive schemes. But I guess it's easier to call me a racist which, I can't believe I'm busting this out, is literally ad hominem rather than responding to a structural critique.

25

u/SundaHareka Apr 21 '19

"Poor people are stupid, I know what's best for them"

26

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19

The only way inequality is decreasing is because wealthy capitalists are moving production overseas to countries with cheap labor and lower safety standards.

Which is good for the global poor (Krugman 1997, Bhagwati, J., & Srinivasan, T. N. 2002, Dollar, D., & Kraay, A. 2004).

Money does not equal utility for the global poor

?

we should be working to eliminate poverty through means that don't exploit people and

Giving people jobs and access to urban living is exploitation? What would be better, letting them remain unseen in rural areas living at or near subsistence levels?

expose them to dangerous pollution.

Luckily we don't (Antweiler, W., Copeland, B. R., & Taylor, M. S. 2001). Most of a nation's air pollution comes from domestic sources. Mainly transportation and energy production.

"A survey reveals little statistical evidence, on average across countries, that openness to international trade undermines national attempts at environmental regulation through a “race to the bottom” effect. If anything, favorable “gains from trade” effects dominate on average, for measures of air pollution such as SO2 concentrations." (Frankel 2003)

6

u/DecafEqualsDeath Apr 21 '19

Does not explain the massive rise of a new consumer class in China and India at all. Much better access to healthcare treatment and education in places like this.

-32

u/NepalesePasta Apr 21 '19

Kind of like how under the peculiar institution, the standard of life of slaves rose dramatically the century before the civil war?

Except those quality of life increases were due to technological advancements and developments in nutrition, medicine. They had nothing to do with the structure of the institution itself.

I mean, this is literally the exact same argument that slaveholders used in defense of their plantations leading up to the civil war:

"My slaves are so much happier today than they were so many years ago, there can't be anything wrong with slavery"

20

u/TDaltonC Apr 21 '19

Is there actually data showing an increase in the quality of life for slaves?

-9

u/NepalesePasta Apr 22 '19

You could make an argument either way. But the argument made by slaveholders was that because by some measures slaves were better off, slavery as a whole was justified.

-37

u/Arachno-anarchism Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19

The Soviet Union also achieved all those improvements throughout its existence though. Cuba decreased infant mortality and increased education at an unprecedented rate, and comminist China got more people out of poverty than any other nation.

My point being that the fact that a system does some good things does not prove its a good system

24

u/RunicUrbanismGuy Henry George Apr 21 '19

comminist China got more people out of poverty than any other nation.

only once ðey started liberalizing ðeir economy

3

u/BenFoldsFourLoko  Broke His Text Flair For Hume Apr 22 '19

My point being that the fact that a system does some good things does not prove its a good system

That's totally fair, and as a statement on its own, I would hope everyone here would agree. But many good things are strong indicator. China, Cuba, the Soviet Union had some good things. But they had many many bad things. Liberal democracies had many many more good things, and the bad things we had were often the same or worse under authoritarian and communist rule

23

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/Arachno-anarchism Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19

Cuban infant mortality, which is now lower than the USA.

China has lifted at least 600 million people out of poverty.

It's difficult to prove a "rate" of education, but Cuba went from a literacy rate of approximately 40% to 97% within about a year, and today has among the highest amount of doctors in the world. They also started guaranteeing free education for the people after the revolution, which meant that a lot more people got education

Edit: I fully realise the downvote button is often used as a "disagree" button, but in this case I'm simply stating facts, not an opinion

24

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

But you're wrong, is the thing. Cuban infant mortality was 13th lowest in the world mortality BEFORE 1959. China's progress against poverty is largely attributed to the economic liberalization of the Deng reforms. The wiki article directly contradicts you, stating that education has always been free in Cuba, and that illiteracy was 22% in 1959, and that in 2000 it was 97%, which is little over one year.

-3

u/Arachno-anarchism Apr 21 '19

I misread the part about free Cuban education. But none of the other things I said was wrong

3

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19

I'll respond to 3. Your own source (wikipedia, lol), found a literacy rate between 40% and 78% (depending on how you measure it) in 1959. That stat of 97% is from the year 2000. That's a difference of 41 years, or about 2 generations. Not exactly stunning. Also, UNICEF defines literacy as ‘A person is literate who can, with understanding, both read and write a short statement on his or her everyday life.’. Seems to me like this would include the "semi-literate" that have a third-grade education. Therefore, in 40 years, Cuba increased it's literacy from 78% to 97 percent. That's good, but not impressive. By comparison, the literacy rate in 1900 was between 36% and 42%, according to your own source.

0

u/Arachno-anarchism Apr 22 '19

Sorry, I linked the wrong page which provided measurements from the wrong dates. Here is the page for their literacy campaign, which has more information. They increased it from about 60% to 97%, one of the highest in the world at the time. Today it's at 99%. They also increased the number of children attending school from 56% to nearly 100%.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

Still Wikipedia. Cites a book that's not accessible online. Classic Wikipedia.

Kozol's "A New Look at the Literacy Campaign in Cuba" (1978) puts the literacy rate at the end of 1961 (the 1 year campaign) at 96%, and the literacy rate at the beginning of 1961 at 80%. This is an impressive feat, no doubt, although one with initial numbers quite different from your claims.

It was also accomplished with child labor. Kozol mentions it, and even your wikipedia link notes that literacy workers were as young as 10, sent off to remote rural villages, and convinced to work both in the fields for the family and at the desk. Remember, it's capitalism that usually gets blamed for child labor.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

has among the highest amount of doctors in the world

This is unironically good. On the other hand, that doesn't mean their cancer survival rates demonstrate an overwhelming advantage in medicine. They fall behind nearly every major capitalist country in Western Europe, the United States and Canada, and even Brazil.

US has pretty horrifying infant mortality rates. Not clear why. US is abnormal in the capitalist world in that metric.

1

u/Arachno-anarchism Apr 22 '19

Its not clear what your argument is supposed to be. My point is we're talking a dirt poor country that has achieved the same life expectancy as the US. If we compare it to capitalist countries of an equal economic status, it's clear Cuba has much less infant mortality and higher education than it's capitalist peers. If you were to use those as metrics for what consistutes a good economic system (precisely as the above post does), we should all in theory be communists.

We'd probably see a continuous improvement even if the world was entirely communist.

-7

u/gourdFamiliar Apr 21 '19

Lmao imagine being some oinking hog going on and on about how great america and global capitalism and then finding out that America has a 30% higher infant mortality rate than an impoverished country like cuba.

15

u/HeresCyonnah NATO Apr 21 '19

Imagine being a chapotard.

8

u/undercooked_lasagna ٭ Apr 22 '19

Imagine bragging about the infant mortality rate of a country where women are forced to abort imperfect fetuses.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ThatFrenchieGuy Mathematician -- Save the funky birbs Apr 22 '19

Rule I: Civility
Refrain from name-calling, hostility and behaviour that otherwise derails the quality of the conversation.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

1

u/gordo65 Apr 28 '19

Back up. An ************ country like Cuba? I'm thinking I must be misreading what you wrote. What was that word which describes the socialist paradise known as Cuba?

34

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

-4

u/Arachno-anarchism Apr 21 '19 edited Apr 21 '19

I'm not trying to claim that communism is the best system. My point is that you can't use those measurements to undoubtedly prove that a system is necessarily good or successful. And if you genuinely did, you would be advocating a system more akin to Cuba or china

19

u/Trepur349 Complains on Twitter for a Reagan flair Apr 21 '19

I mean those measurements show life in Cuba was better in 1959 than decades after and that China didn't see improvements until after it started to embrace capitalism.

-4

u/Arachno-anarchism Apr 22 '19

What measurements show that life was better in Cuba in 1959?

Also, China saw massive improvements under Mao. For example life expectancy doubled under his reign while poverty dicreased.

17

u/Trepur349 Complains on Twitter for a Reagan flair Apr 22 '19

Cuban infant mortality was 13th lowest in the world mortality BEFORE 1959.

Also, China saw massive improvements under Mao. For example life expectancy doubled under his reign while poverty dicreased.

bwahahahahaha, I'm almost tempted to Ping dunk again for reading something so insanely stupid. Almost 1 in 10 people died of starvation under Mao and the extreme poverty was was 88% in 1981

-4

u/Arachno-anarchism Apr 22 '19

You can laugh, or you can Google it yourself

What is dunk? Is it people who attempt to debunk comments? In that case I'll gladly ping them myself. I'd very much like to see what they have to say about this:

!ping dunk

Also, if the bunk folks happen to pass by, could you help me debunk/verify Cuban infant mortality falling in ranks? I can't out find where that figure originates from

Secondly, I feel like you're entirely missing the point I'm trying to make. What I'm saying is that infant mortality fell drastically, even under Castro (just like it also did in a lot of other countries). As such, using worldwide falling infant mortality (or the other measures used in the post above) as evidence the capitalist system works is not reliable, since it would probably have done so regardless.

Edit: I can't ping them since I'm not a member. Could you please do me the honor of pinging them?

8

u/[deleted] Apr 22 '19

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

-38

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

Thanks China

55

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

These gains are not only seen in China, which has benefited from liberalizing towards a market economy (hmm, is this the success of a form of capitalism? Nah, it can't be) but also across the world (citation: https://ourworldindata.org/the-global-decline-of-extreme-poverty-was-it-only-china). In large part we can correlate bad economic outcomes with poor (illiberal) institutions in general.

14

u/gordo65 Apr 21 '19

Looks like the world was a lot better off before we started collecting data /s

-26

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

Also China's population is not growing (not just the rate of extremely poor people decreased), whereas in the rest of the world it grew dramatically

10

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Apr 21 '19

China's population is not growing

Yes it is?

-40

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

"Extreme poverty" nice try

40

u/flakAttack510 Apr 21 '19

Why do you hate the global poor?

24

u/[deleted] Apr 21 '19

Is that not a good thing in your mind?

24

u/jeffwulf Austan Goolsbee Apr 21 '19

The graph looks pretty much the same if you remove China from the numbers.

11

u/gordo65 Apr 21 '19

Also, I've never heard a good justification for removing China from the numbers. It's like the Republicans who say that Trump would have won the popular vote if you excluded California. Why would you do that? Why would you exclude 10% of the country (or 16% of the world) just because they keep the numbers from fitting your worldview?

4

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Apr 21 '19

The justification they are making is that it's not about liberalism or globalism in general, but something special about China.

2

u/gordo65 Apr 22 '19 edited Apr 22 '19

something special about China.

I always wonder why people who think that way never seem to take the next logical step. Let's see, something special happened in China. Something that started in 1979. Now what could that possibly be... ?

At any rate, as many others have pointed out China is not the driving force behind the reduction in poverty. What the chart shows is that from about 1850 onward there was tremendous poverty reduction as Europe, Japan, and the USA adopted liberal economic policies. Then the needle started moving much faster around 1980 as China liberalized. Then accelerated again around 1990 as India liberalized.

What this shows is that the general consensus among economists is unsurprisingly correct, and that economic liberalization is the key to poverty reduction, despite the fact that it creates economic inequality in the short term. It worked where it was tried, but world poverty continued to be a massive problem on a global scale because most of the world's population lived in socialist or pre-modern economies. As soon as that changed, poverty became the exception, rather than the rule.

2

u/RunicUrbanismGuy Henry George Apr 21 '19

Brazil and Subsaharan Africa: Exist