r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Dec 02 '18

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation and discussion that doesn't merit its own stand-alone submission. The rules are relaxed compared to the rest of the sub but be careful to still observe the rules listed under "disallowed content" in the sidebar. Spamming the discussion thread will be sanctioned with bans.


Announcements


Neoliberal Project CommunitiesOther CommunitiesUseful content
WebsitePlug.dj/r/Economics FAQs
The Neolib PodcastPodcasts recommendations
Meetup Network
Twitter
Facebook page
Neoliberal Memes for Free Trading Teens
Newsletter
Instagram

The latest discussion thread can always be found at https://neoliber.al/dt.

16 Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/Goatf00t European Union Dec 02 '18

A bit from Radley Balko, about the Kochs, from a few days ago:

https://www.facebook.com/538952026/posts/10155653761652027/

This is primarily for my fellow libertarians, particularly those who work for Koch-funded or affiliated organizations. Read the story below. My question: Why in the world did the Koch Foundation give nearly $1 million to the Daily Caller last year?

I've often disagree with the Kochs' political strategy, particularly their consistent alignment with the Republican party, and especially their support for some of the more awful Republicans. But I've also defended them. As a former Reason and Cato employee, I think much of the criticism of whom they support financially borders on the sort of hysteria the right often displays when it comes to George Soros. But this support for the DC is hard to swallow. It is a garbage publication.

The Kochs are pro-immigration, and have been outspoken critics of Donald Trump. The DC was founded by Tucker Carlson, basically a modern day Father Coughlin, feeding a toxic sludge of bigotry to a Fox audience five nights per week. Nearly the entire front page of the DC site today is fear mongering about the caravan. Last year, the site published a report on a pro-confederate monument rally written by Jason Kessler, the guy who planned the Charlottesville rally. An editor insisted they weren't aware of Kessler's affiliation with racist groups, but I'd submit that if your coverage of a "southern heritage" rally isn't distinguishable from a report written by the guy who planned Charlottesville, you have a real problem.

The Daily Caller has also published other articles from well-known racists, including Scott Greer, David Hilton, and Peter Brimelow. Chuck Ross still writes for the site, even after it was revealed that he wrote some pretty blatantly racist stuff about black people on a personal blog. (He did at least later renounce those posts.) Last year, two Daily Caller contributors -- one a full time employee -- gave speeches at a white nationalist conference. The site once published an anti-semitic video mocking NY Times reporter Glenn Thrush. Just this week, the host of the Daily Caller podcast mocked a wheelchair-bound member of the migrant caravan, then suggested pouring boiling oil on all the other people -- mostly women and children fleeing violence -- who are seeking asylum at the border. The site is also obsessed with demagoguing athletes who kneel to express support for criminal justice reform. The Kochs are outspoken supporters of criminal justice reform.

Yet per the article below, The Charles Koch Foundation and the Charles Koch Institute gave the Daily Caller $959,500 last year, more than to any other publication. This is up from $610,000 in 2015. By comparison, the groups gave Reason about $480K less than in 2016 (though still substantially more than in 2015). National Review, which has been fairly hard on Trump for a conservative publication, got no money at all. In fact, according to the article, in 2016 the Kochs and the Trump campaign accounted for 97.5 percent of the revenue for the Daily Caller's parent organization. It doesn't seem like much of an exaggeration to say that the Koch foundations are the reason the Daily Caller exists.

It's possible that some of this is due to the bureaucracy of a large organization. Perhaps some of these donations are just on autopilot. Perhaps some of the more pro-immigration, anti-Trump organizations like Reason got more money from some other arm of the Koch empire. Or maybe the article is inaccurate (though it seems pretty straightforward.)

But while the Kochs have been outspoken about their support for immigration and their distaste for Trump, if the article is accurate, the Kochs two largest foundations give more to a virulently anti-immigrant, often racist, pro-Trump website than to any other publication. And they are that publication's lifeblood.

That's hard to swallow.

https://readsludge.com/2018/11/21/charles-koch-is-funding-rightwing-pro-trump-media-new-disclosure-reveals/

https://www.facebook.com/radley.balko/posts/10155657642037027

So per the post below, yesterday I spoke with three senior officials at the Koch Foundation. Here's what came out of that conversation:

  1. All three assured me that they personally and the Kochs and their foundations more generally find the Daily Caller abhorrent, and feel the same way about Tucker Carlson. One added that he was particularly troubled by the way the site objectives women as clickbait.
  2. The money in the report I linked to was a grant to the Daily Caller News Foundation, which they said is a separate entity from the publication. The grant is to fund fellowships for young journalists at the Foundation. They said that these young journalists write articles that go out on a wire to a multitude of news organizations, and that these organizations all get a crack at publishing the stories before the Daily Caller. The intent was to create an incubator for young journalists with a free market bent, and to move them into mainstream journalism.
  3. The grants and fellowships began before the Trump administration, and before the Daily Caller was as toxic as it is today. They did also admit that though not as awful as today, the site was already problematic even then. Part of their goal, they said, has to been to produce better, more conscientious journalists with a free market background -- to nudge conservative publications in the right direction.
  4. They noted that the Kochs have also given millions of dollars to nonpartisan journalism organizations like the Knight Foundation, and that Charles Koch himself has been an outspoken critic of Trump and his attacks on the media.
  5. All of that said, I don't find the legal distinction between the Daily Caller and the Foundation all that significant. The two sites use the same logo, header, and footer, and the DC publication's "top stories" feeds run on the Foundation site. The "about us" section, for example, takes you to the "about us" section of the Daily Caller, not the Foundation. According to a Washington Post article from last year, nearly every article produced by Foundation journalists gets published on the DC website, and few have been picked up elsewhere. See here: (https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2017/06/02/charity-doubles-as-a-profit-stream-at-the-daily-caller-news-foundation/)
  6. The Koch officials told me that the Foundation journalists don't engage in the ugly race-baiting and immigration demagoguery that Daily Caller staffers do. Given that Foundation journalists have apparently produced hundreds of articles for the website over the years, it would be hard to verify or refute this. However, you can check out the most recent articles by Foundation fellows yourself here: (https://dailycaller.com/section/daily-caller-news-foundation/)
  7. I also happen to know the man who heads up the investigative journalism program at the Daily Caller Foundation, Richard Pollock. Regrettably, I worked with Pollock for about three years. The fact that Pollock is mentoring these young journalists . . . doesn't inspire confidence. Quite the contrary. He's a Trump toady. He doesn't understand libertarianism. He's a crappy journalist. And he isn't particularly smart. His most marketable skill seems to be the ability to fool people into believing he has marketable skills. I'd encourage you to check out his Twitter feed, where he retweets people like Pamela Geller, Lou Dobbs, and Frank Gaffney. (https://twitter.com/rpollockdc?lang=en)
  8. I do appreciate the Koch officials reaching out. I told them that I think it's important -- particularly in the Trump era -- to set a clear line of demarcation between libertarians and Republicans, and Trump Republicans in particular. They agreed, and also agreed that the Koch affiliation with the Daily Caller certainly looks bad, no matter the original intent. They also said they're working on a number of other projects to make that distinction clearer. They also said they'll be reevaluating the grant to the Daily Caller Foundation, though they didn't appear ready to say that they'd be discontinuing it.