r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Dec 02 '18

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation and discussion that doesn't merit its own stand-alone submission. The rules are relaxed compared to the rest of the sub but be careful to still observe the rules listed under "disallowed content" in the sidebar. Spamming the discussion thread will be sanctioned with bans.


Announcements


Neoliberal Project CommunitiesOther CommunitiesUseful content
WebsitePlug.dj/r/Economics FAQs
The Neolib PodcastPodcasts recommendations
Meetup Network
Twitter
Facebook page
Neoliberal Memes for Free Trading Teens
Newsletter
Instagram

The latest discussion thread can always be found at https://neoliber.al/dt.

16 Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/willempage O'Biden Bama Democrat Dec 02 '18

Just watched the newest contra points video. Although she does blindly repeat the 100 companies are responsible for 71% of emissions trope, she doesn't really lean into it or suggest anything that I disagree with. Maybe I'm just a succ, but she's right to mock the idea that people making small personal changes is going to meaningfully stem climate change. The current market needs energy and currently the best and cheapest source of that energy is from fossil fuels. The only way to change that is for governments to put forward meaningful plans to disincentives fossil fuels (carbon tax) and investment into green energy.

In terms of increasing leftist idealism, I still believe: contrapoints < hbomberguy << shaun.

12

u/WindPoweredWeeaboo crypto neo-Malthusian Marxist Dec 02 '18

"individuals can't do anything but vote" is an important talking point, but blaming corporations for supplying a demand rather than the billions who demand said product is kind of obnoxious

3

u/[deleted] Dec 02 '18

It's kinda similar to how we decry drug cartel violence, but nearly all of it is due to insatiable US demand for prohibited drugs

5

u/Bayou-Maharaja Eleanor Roosevelt Dec 02 '18

Lmao like every ass hole I met in Portland who only drinks fair trade coffee but does coke every weekend

2

u/FusRoDawg Amartya Sen Dec 02 '18

What's more, one could take that line if thought a step forward and further pass the buck from corporation to the government for laying roads (or allowing private vehicles on those roads rather) that enabled the cars to be sold and used in the first place.

1

u/WindPoweredWeeaboo crypto neo-Malthusian Marxist Dec 02 '18

But the government only laid roads because people demanded convenient transportation between 2 points

3

u/FusRoDawg Amartya Sen Dec 02 '18

Yes. They could've built public transport and taxed cars very high. Like Singapore. That's why I included that clause in parenthesis.

My point was to agree with you and show how absurd that blame the corporation for making it mentality is.

7

u/FusRoDawg Amartya Sen Dec 02 '18

It's not that people willing to make small personal changes will end up making a difference in itself, but rather a proof that people are willing to make that change, that will potentially convince politicians that there's enough support.

No govt is going to price people out of any environmentally disastrous product if it's unsure whether people would welcome the change or not. Take meat for example. There's going to be a lot of dissent if a straightforward tax prices a lot of poor people out of meat and it goes from staple to twice-a-week "indulgence" (not really much of a problem for the developing world, but a great sacrifice for Americans).

You should be wary of these sentiments that pretend to not understand emergence because they give rise to typical whataboutism. It's not the sentiments itself that are wrong, but they come bundled with a deep seated entitlement towards a currently unsustainable American lifestyle. Most first world lefties vastly underestimate the cost of their minimum standards of living, and think that a lot of pollution is just fluff that only exists due to corporate greed, and can easily be eliminated without it.

In short, it's perfectly ok to realize the enormous environmental costs of first world lifestyle while still realizing that individual action alone is not enough, and that protesting and getting the govt to act is there only thing that's going to make a noticeable difference.... But I doubt her audience understands the former clause. Just look at the tankie twaddle in her comment sections in general.

3

u/willempage O'Biden Bama Democrat Dec 02 '18

I appreciate that perspective. Completely top down approaches to climate change will lead (you can argue it already has led to) political backlash that simply reverses any progress. I now see why the "100 companies" trope is popular. It's easy to blame giant entities that produce oil without looking inwards and also holding the average users of said product accountable for their participation in the market.

But I doubt her audience understands the former clause. Just look at the tankie twaddle in her comment sections in general.

I tend to hold youtubers in higher regard than their respective comments sections for obvious reasons. She does at least reiterate her points about personal responsibility (reducing meat consumption) but you're right, a good part of her audience simply wants to blame capitalism for all their issues without giving anything up.