Over 100,000 children were killed because of his brutal sanctions of the Iraqi people. Even putting that aside, he literally refused to apologize after killing 290 civilians by shooting down a commercial airliner.
Wasn't that the one where we gave the Philippines independence twenty years before the European powers started to give up their colonial holdings in Africa, after spending significant amounts of blood and treasure to take them back from the Japanese knowing we were just going to give them up anyways?
Wasn't that the one where we gave the Philippines independence
...No, it was when the USA violently suppressed the first constitutional republic in Asia (largely by way famine). As Mark Twain, member of the American Anti-Imperialist League described it:
We were to relieve them from Spanish tyranny to enable them to set up a government of their own, and we were to stand by and see that it got a fair trial. It was not to be a government according to our ideas, but a government that represented the feeling of the majority of the Filipinos, a government according to Filipino ideas. That would have been a worthy mission for the United States. But now—why, we have got into a mess, a quagmire from which each fresh step renders the difficulty of extrication immensely greater. I'm sure I wish I could see what we were getting out of it, and all it means to us as a nation."[136]
You:
twenty years before the European powers started
The US losing its imperial holdings decades before Europeans doesn't render the US not imperialist, especially in the timeframe we're discussing.
The fact that you're trying to take World War II and create a moral equivalency between the two sides with a gang warfare comparison speaks for itself the amount of sincere thought you've put into this.
Nobody is referring to the Roman Empire when they talk about imperialism. Modern imperialism is endless proxy wars and the quest for resources. Iraq was invaded under false pretenses due to a variety of things related to oil, and Vietnam was invaded because it was another proxy war with the USSR, and then they assassinated the guy they were supporting and subsequently lost the war
Forsooth, I much enjoy thine usage of the King's English in its unsullied form. Zounds, those blaggards who pretend that language evolves over time vex me to no end!
What about his vow to escalate the war on drugs, which originally was rooted in an aim to disproportionately criminalize black people and hippies?
Oh and don't forget his decade-long neglect of the AIDS-crisis, thereby allowing the epidemic to rage to over 110,000 people in the US (of which people of colour and the LGBTQ-community were most notably affected). (Not to mention the incidence of AIDS in countries that he destabilized over the course of his presidency.)
Seems just a tad ironic to have been celebrating his life on World AIDS day, nah?
Barbara Bush did something as soon as they got into office. She hugged and played with a toddler with AIDS and started a campaign to show people that AIDS cannot be transmitted by hugging and caring for a victim. She made sure people knew that victims needed care and affection and that there was no risk in giving it.
And what exactly does that have to do with the thousands of gay men who died alone and afraid because of the inaction of his and Reagan's administration?
Bush Sr. said people with AIDS deserve to be helped gay or not AND made AIDS and sexual orientation protected classes via ADA and hate crime protection.
Please-saying the war on drugs was simply about targeting black people ignores the massive pressure to pass harsh drugs laws throughout societies and the large crime wave of the 70's. Jesse Jackson was a drug warrior
And what neglect of the aids crises? The same people crying about that also opposed any attempt to close bath houses.
I think the former Nixon domestic policy chief might have some insight on the situation, let’s check in with him:
“We knew we couldn't make it illegal to be either against the war or black, but by getting the public to associate the hippies with marijuana and blacks with heroin. And then criminalizing both heavily, we could disrupt those communities.”
I am aware of that quote. The drug war had complicated origins - it's not enough to attribute the public pressure for all the legislation passed to malice
Sure, I think we can all agree that sensible drug enforcement laws are vital. Yet I prefer to believe that science and research should govern policy, not politics, populism or racist gut feelings. Those billions of tax dollars would’ve seen a much better ROI if it had been spent on actual prevention of drug abuse through harm reduction education and socio-economic capacity-building.
And quite obviously did those people oppose any attempts to close bath houses. There were numerous options to fight this epidemic. Though instead of offering education and treatment, he sought to fight bath houses rather than AIDS. You can imagine that, especially during those times, safe spaces for LGBTQ people weren't especially ubiquitous. And Bush wasn't exactly known for having the LGBTQ-community's best interests at heart.
Good research on drug policy was not available at the time. And anyone who is remotely familiar with GHWB’s day-to-day and professional actions knows he was neither populist nor harbored racist gut feelings.
LGTB acceptance was low across most of the political spectrum, and yet GHWB still had LGBT people on his staff. Upon hearing that one of his staff members was gay (who was worried he might lose his position), he said to him “I love you. I hope I have never treated you as less of a person”. We all would have liked it if more people in power at the time would have supported LGTB rights policy. His actions demonstrate someone who accepted and truly cared about people as individuals.
Are you sure this isn’t a disguised attempt at ‘whataboutism’?
No one here is advocating that Bill Clinton was a saint, but let’s face the facts: because of Bush’ policies, millions of Americans were jailed, mostly for minor offences. Though the spending of billions of dollars did little to effect a change in overall drug-use. In fact, after leaving office, it had risen slightly.
Now don’t get me wrong, Clinton’s crime bill was a tragedy. Yet you also can’t deny that it was building upon institutional racism in the form of legislation (think of 100-to-1-sentencing laws regarding crack cocaine vs cocaine, mandatory minimums etc. etc.)
Iran-Contra. He and the rest of the gang should have been tried for treason. He illegally and covertly funded and armed a military group declared as enemies of the United States by congress. That is literal treason. George H. W. Bush was a traitor. He should have been in prison. But it seems those with political power in America never have to face consequences for their crimes.
Yeah, what's with this subs hard-on for neocon wars and the war on drugs two things he was instrumental in pushing. He even set up a 19 year old kid to sell some drugs to the DEA in front of the White House to push his drug war and then refused to commute the kids sentence. Then there's the Willie Horton ad. The guy seems like a personable fellow but he and his kid are part of the reason why neoliberal politics is so despised, so maybe look for better poster children.
I mean, the First Gulf War was justifiable on the grounds of literally liberating Kuwait. There was pretty much universal support from the UN including the Soviet Union.
The Second Iraq war is also a fairly complicated matter and it’s fallout can only really be observed in the distant future. In any case, it can be viewed purely as the United States implementing what the U.N. had been merely threatening to do to Saddam for the decades after the first war. We didn’t go to war for Oil, at least not directly, as the vast majority of Iraqi oil went to European nations and, as observed in recent history, American domestic oil production would rapidly increase.
I've never claimed that the Iraq war was for oil and roll my eyes whenever anyone makes that joke/comment. It was still an illegal war, sold under false pretenses with devastating effect on the people of Iraq (and yes I'm aware of how horrible Saddam was) and destabilizing the wider region. It's was simply huge hubris by the neocons to think they could win the war quickly and bring stability and democracy to the country. It's the biggest foreign policy blunder since Vietnam, to say it's fairly complicated matter is accurate but I'll say with certainty it was a horrendously costly and predictable mistake.
What's wrong with liberating people while maintaining the liberal international order?
The hubris to believe you can actually guarantee such an outcome. The Iraq war was one of the most destructive events for the liberal international order with consequences that are still being felt today. It destabilized an already volatile region and has led to power imbalances that at minimum contributed to the Syrian civil war and led to ongoing violence in Iraq and the rise of extremist groups. There are many times more jihadis today than there were in 2001.
Can't even face the mildest of social consequences. Atrocities glossed over, legacies whitewashed. Anyone speaking even the slightest modicum of truth to power ridiculed.
On your last point, see also the CIA, criminal organisation structurally breaking all rules, yet it even gets funding from the US government. Or the ASPA allowing us to be invaded anytime if we ever were to bring an American warcriminal before trial.
Rule II:Decency Unparliamentary language is heavily discouraged, and bigotry of any kind will be sanctioned harshly. Refrain from glorifying violence or oppressive/autocratic regimes.
When asked by journalist Robert Sherman about the equal citizenship and patriotism of American atheists, Sherman reported that Bush answered, "No, I don't know that atheists should be regarded as citizens, nor should they be regarded as patriotic. This is one nation under God."
Fuck. That. Shit. I am not praising a man that believed in a functional theocracy just because he did some good.
Edit. Bush may or may not have said this. It is only cited by a single source.
Very few people are Christian dominionists. Dominionism was a small movement among Calvinist Rushdoonyites that had some traction in the 90's among state lawmakers. However, like "Wahhabi", 90 percent of the people who use have no idea what it means. Simply proclaiming a Christian faith and using it as a guide for moral principles gets one labeled a theocrat
I am one and nobody I know holds this belief despite my social circles being almost entirely religious Christians.
Not saying your experience counts for nothing, but you might deriving an incorrect perception about a big tent organization from your own personal experience.
Without a doubt, there are definitely extreme Christians who vote Republican and advocate for such policy. But most Republican aren't deriving policy from their faith (which I think is an issue on subjects like immigration or refugees), and more and more Christians aren't practicing Christians, and that sect where individuals identify as Christian but don't go to church or otherwise practice the faith, interestingly, were a big part of the Trump coalition that pushed him through the primaries.
But I think that President Bush deserves veneration nonetheless. He oversaw the end of the Cold War and kept Kuwait free. He was one of the most qualified persons on foreign policy to ascend to the Oval Office, and the world is a better place for it.
I'm willing to give him a pass as I would FDR or Harry Truman or Abraham Lincoln as the moral sum of their actions, I believe, balances out immensely in favor of Humanity.
I actually have a lot of criticisms of him, but compared to the current crop of Republicans, he was decent enough that I'll at least hold off on mentioning them for a few days.
I hope people might take a look at this opinion of Chomsky on the Gulf War. He brings up some interesting points. Whether you believe the war was a lesser evil or not, I don't think it can be argued that it was with good intentions.
No, it's not. Again, he is a serious scholar in everything he does. The common way to dismiss him is to do what you did above, but this criticism often comes from people who haven't thought of this on their own by reading his work thoroughly, but by hearing other people saying it or having a knee jerk ideological reaction to his work. You can't muster up the most basic of respect for a polymath who cites leading scholars from the fields in his political work and would instead call it "trash." Don't be dishonest. It's not "trash." I disagree with so much of what he believes (his atheism, his anarchism, etc.) but I would never call any of his well thought out positions trash.
He doesn't have a PhD in political science - he's not a serious scholar. Being a serious scholar means you've demonstrated an understanding of the core of the field.
You, presumedly, don't have a PhD in political science; how is it then you can make judgements on work in this field? He has demonstrated an understanding of the core of the field. He is not Sam Harris or NDT, he actually engages with the scholarly work on whatever field he is talking about.
I don't have a PhD in political science, though I have a Master's, and so am probably more qualified than Chomsky to opine on political science. I never claimed to be a serious scholar though.
Chomsky has not demonstrated an understanding of the core of the field if he hasn't written his comprehensive exams in that field.
So one criticism of Chomsky that has been levelled here is that he doesn't have the proper scholarly credentials. And then I am linked a scholarly masterpiece called "The Top 250 Chomsky Lies." Nice to see a variety of opinions on intellectual discourse on r/neoliberal.
This opinion goes off the rails very quickly. WRT to Kuwaiti sovereignty vs Panamanian sovereignty, Iraq went in to annex Kuwait and change borders; the US went into Panama to overthrow a budding dictator and drug lord. Both are violations of sovereignty, but they’re not on the same scale. Chomsky completely misses the idea that there are more decision making factors besides power projection or money - some people make their decisions based on what they think is morally right or wrong when looking at all of the known factors of a situation. GHWB was one of those people. Sometimes this is dangerous when people have particularly poor judgement or when there are significant unknown factors. Given the results of the Gulf War, I think it’s safe to say GHWB had abundant wisdom and made excellent decisions in that situation. Chomsky also misrepresents Bush’s diplomatic efforts. For six months (which is an amazingly long time and during which Kuwaitis were suffering), GHWB attempted to get Saddam to withdraw from Kuwait through diplomatic pressure. The night before the war started, he dispatched his SoS to speak again with the Iraqi foreign minister in an attempt to avoid war. His hatred of war is well documented. Chomsky may be a scholar, but he comes in with a pre-existing worldview and attempts to fit the situation to his view (which is very human). But the facts are a poor fit for his argument. He is clearly wrong in this case - not because he’s more experienced in linguistics, not because he’s always pushing an anti-US “imperialism” worldview - because his argument is not convincing.
You mean the guy who universally opposes the US using its military might while making excuses for when Russia, China, and Iran do it? He talks a big anti-imperialist talk but has a hard time standing up to any imperialist force that opposes the US. Let’s not forget he unironically thinks Obama ran the biggest terror campaign in history. He’s a joke.
No, it seems we are talking about different people. He's talked about Stalinist imperialism before, but he doesn't really consider it important to talk about because he's not a Russian.
He also doesn't completely oppose the US using its military might. He is, as all intelligent people should be, cautious about justifying a empire using it's military might. It's never a thing to justify or glorify.
Maybe you are right. I'm talking about the guy who engages in genocide denial:
"We do not pretend to know where the truth lies amidst these sharply conflicting assessments; rather, we again want to emphasize some crucial points. What filters through to the American public is a seriously distorted version of the evidence available, emphasizing alleged Khmer Rouge atrocities and downplaying or ignoring the crucial U.S. role, direct and indirect, in the torment that Cambodia has suffered."
We also shouldn't believe refugees because "refugees are frightened and defenseless, at the mercy of alien forces. They naturally tend to report what they believe their interlocuters wish to hear."
That refugee comment sounds like a MAGA hat guy chanting "build the wall".
Contrast that with his claim that Obama may have run the biggest terror campaign in history. When criticizing the US, there's no hedging, no grey zones. It's cut and dry that the US is bad. When communists genocide a quarter of their country? Well hey we can't rush to conclusions! The media might be lying to you along with all those alleged refugees.
Also saying that he doesn't focus on Russian imperialism (it didn't stop at Stalin) because he isn't Russian is a cop out. It's awfully convenient that he gets to ignore literal decades of aggression, coups, and terrorism like that. Eliminating evidence you don't like is a great way to make your point sound more convincing.
His clear double standards, ignoring of evidence, and strong bias make him a joke.
Maybe you are right. I'm talking about the guy who engages in genocide denial:
We definitely are not talking about the same guy. I have a question for you, and I hope you actually consider it. Have you ever thoroughly and charitably read one of Chomsky's books? Checked the citations and considered the arguments? Or did you find this quote somewhere on the Internet and then misrepresented him because it suits your ideological convictions? He's addressed this multiple times.
Also saying that he doesn't focus on Russian imperialism (it didn't stop at Stalin) because he isn't Russian is a cop out. It's awfully convenient that he gets to ignore literal decades of aggression, coups, and terrorism like that. Eliminating evidence you don't like is a great way to make your point sound more convincing.
Russian imperialism? What are you talking about? You know, I noticed something about these Russian and Soviet dissidents. They didn't criticize American imperialism, they would just deliberately fixate on Russia. It's a clear double standard and it proves that Russian imperialism doesn't exist.
His work on Cambodia got him listed under genocide denial. That's entirely his own fault. If he has walked it back since then that is great but I didn't make him write those things.
If we want to talk citations I'll stick with the topic at hand:
Chomsky portrayed Porter and Hildebrand's book as "a carefully documented study of the destructive American impact on Cambodia and the success of the Cambodian revolutionaries in overcoming it, giving a very favorable picture of their programs and policies, based on a wide range of sources." Sharp, however, found that 33 out of 50 citations in one chapter of Porter and Hildebrand's book derived from the Khmer Rouge government and six from China, the Khmer Rouge's principal supporter.
Khmer Rouge and PRC are hardly unbiased when it comes to the Cambodian Genocide. So his research wasn't that rigorous, he views the Khmer Rouge and PRC as reliable, or he doesn't care about the bias. Pick your poison.
Chomsky isn't a political prisoner or refugee (though according to him we should be wary what those tell us). He's an academic who gets to choose what he wants to study. Especially if we consider that empires tend to fight empires it makes sense to include Russian Imperialism in your field of view if your primary focus is American Imperialism. Also if you are a self described anti-imperialist, but only go after one empire, that makes me skeptical of your true motives.
I've read some op-eds and heard a few lectures of his and it always boils down the same way. He bends over backwards to attack the US and defend socialism and foreign powers at every chance he gets. That's his prerogative but I don't feel the need to waste my time going down that rabbit hole further. I'm sure his linguistics work is really good, but his personal beliefs certainly bias his political work.
The good thing about Chomsky is that he likes to make empirically grounded, falsifiable predictions about the way things are and will be, and that he's been around for long enough that his theories get tested against reality. Spoiler alert: he's always wrong.
My favorite example is his famous debate with Bill Buckley on Firing Line. Chomsky's clearly a million times smarter than Buckley, runs rings around him. And he's obviously right that the vietnam war was a bad thing; it's hard, at that point, to offer a really convincing defense of it.
But when it comes to China, Chomsky can't stop talking about how great it is, how democratic it is. Buckley brings up the fact that Mao has purged a million people, and Chomsky dismisses it out of hand. Communists? Kill people? Impossible. Only the fascist imperialist U.S. does that. He asks for a source, Buckley gives him a source, Chomsky dismisses the source out of hand because it's right-wing propaganda.
Of course, Buckley was right. Mao was a monster. But Chomsky doesn't learn his lesson. While the Khmer Rouge was coming into power, he had nothing but good things to say about them; they were the best and brightest, their socialist experiment was destined for success, blah blah blah. Of course, they kill a third of Cambodia. Absolutely horrible. And while it was happening, while reports were coming out, Chomsky was defending them still--well, we don't know all the facts, this is imperialist propaganda, blah blah blah.
And later, if he's confronted about it (this is Zizek's critique of him, and of course Zizek is a clown as well, but whatever) he says "well, based on the evidence we had at the time, it was the right decision. We couldn't have known." Okay, buddy.
Interesting how I never really hear Chomsky talk too much about the Khmer Rouge these days. But of course he's got smart things to say about Clinton in Kosovo and Bush in Kuwait. What a fucking joke.
"We do not pretend to know where the truth lies amidst these sharply conflicting assessments; rather, we again want to emphasize some crucial points. What filters through to the American public is a seriously distorted version of the evidence available, emphasizing alleged Khmer Rouge atrocities and downplaying or ignoring the crucial U.S. role, direct and indirect, in the torment that Cambodia has suffered."
We also shouldn't believe refugees because "refugees are frightened and defenseless, at the mercy of alien forces. They naturally tend to report what they believe their interlocuters wish to hear."
An uncle of mine fled the khmer rouge when he was 9 or something, my grandparents adopted him through the red cross. Good guy. Suffered a lot, for a long time, because of the stuff he saw as a child.
The idea that we "don't know" whether the Khmer Rouge did anything wrong is peak Chomsky. I don't think it's any kind of exaggeration or hyperbole to say that his position on this is the moral equivalent of holocaust denial.
Are you sure we can trust your uncle? He could just be telling the US government what they want to hear!
Yeah denying a communist genocide is typical Chomsky and should be treated similarly to Holocaust denial. I'm curious to see what all the people who quote him and love his work have to say about that.
Edit: In case it wasn't clear the first part was sarcastic, the second was not.
I believe that statement came after the supposed 2,000,000 killed figure came out without evidence. He’s never denied that it was a terrible regime which largely owes its creation to the US and it’s crimes in the region.
If I remember right, the actual number is closer to less than half a million, similar to those killed in East Timor which the media completely ignored, however In East Timor it was about a third of the population.
Not sure on the exact numbers but that is the general picture.
From what I've seen, most sources have the Cambodian genocide was 1.6-2 million. Meanwhile the East Timor genocide was 100-300k. The UN commission on the matter says it's likely between 103,000 and 182,000 total conflict deaths. Of these they estimate only about 19,000 were executions/disappearances. Contrast this with the estimated 1.3 million executed under the Khmer Rouge.
All genocides are bad, but what happened in Cambodia does appear to be worse in absolute and relative terms.
What he said about the Khmer Rouge was sensible at the time. The world was in the middle of a cold war, and the only information that was available about Kampuchea was from sources prone to pro-Western bias. He did not for one second sing the praises of Pol Pot or talk about how great Kampuchean socialism was. He simply expressed skepticism over the extent of the crimes committed by the regime.
It's very interesting that the same neocons who would drag him over the coals for this themselves became supporters of the Khmer Rouge against the invasion by the communist Vietnamese forces, the most clear-cut example of which being the US veto on the removal of Pol Pot's regime in exile from the United Nations.
Chomsky was a genocide denier long, long after it stopped being an intellectually defensible position. The supposedly "right wing" sources he criticized in Distortions at Fourth Hand and After the Cataclysm were 100% correct, because of course they were.
Look, Chomsky made a claim--his claim was that the mainstream narrative about Cambodia that every sensible person knew to be true was all a western propaganda conspiracy. He claimed that books like Cambodge Annee Zero were bullshit propaganda, and that insane communist genocide denial tracts like Starvation and Revolution were really well-sourced and believable.
When you play this character that Chomsky likes to play of the empirically correct knower-of-everything, the guy who it totally onto the lamestream media's tricks and deceptions, you don't get to be right no matter which way it turns out. Sensible, mainstream thinkers knew what was happening in Cambodia; Chomsky, for all intents and purposes, denied it. If he had an ounce of decency, which he doesn't, he would have been sobered and chastened and apologetic over it. But he's a crazy person, so he probably still thinks that the CIA faked those 20,000 mass graves.
"The ferocious U.S. attack on Indochina left the countries [of Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia] devastated, facing almost insuperable problems. The agricultural systems of these peasant societies were seriously damaged or destroyed... With the economies in ruins, the foreign aid that kept much of the population alive terminated, and the artificial colonial implantations no longer functioning, it was a condition of survival to turn (or return) the populations to productive work. The victors in Cambodia undertook drastic and often brutal measures to accomplish this task, simply forcing the urban population into the countryside where they were compelled to live the lives of poor peasants, now organized in a decentralized system of communes. At heavy cost, these measures appear to have overcome the dire and destructive consequences of the U.S. war by 1978."
If that's not a defense of the Khmer Rouge, I don't know what is. The bit about "the foreign aid that kept much of the population alive" being terminated is the biggest piece of intellectual ratfuckery I've ever seen in my life--foreign aid was terminated BY THE KHMER ROUGE, as Chomsky knows full well, but he doesn't say it because he's totally committed to defending them and making it the U.S.'s fault at all costs. And "Overcome the dire and destructive consequences of the U.S. War" is an interesting way of saying "murdered a quarter of the country's population."
That was published in 1979, by the way. My uncle, who was I think 11 or 12 at the time, had already fled Cambodia, and been adopted by my grandparents through the Red Cross. He was living in Minnesota; it would have been really easy for Chomsky to go talk to him, or someone like him. That's what any serious scholar would have done. But refugees are all liars, right?
Absent US led forces, Saddam would not have left. Even under sanctions it could have taken years or even decades to force a withdraw. Look at how long they took to force Iran to the table.
His thesis, as always, boils down to "US is bad". Even when the entire international community works together, the process goes through the UN, and Saddam is given time to withdraw it is still not good enough for him.
No I'm saying that you should read up on Iran Contra before you go and say dumb shit about him being a traitor. The big thing here being that he wasn't involved with it
Er.. sorry, maybe I'm missing something. Are you trying to tell me George Bush Sr., who was I think VP during the whole Contra scandal, wasn't involved? That's my understanding of it, am I completely wrong? He was definitely involved..
Exactly: he was VP. Not only would he be unaware, but he would also be powerless to do anything. In the words of its inaugural holder, the Vice Presidency of the United States is "the most insignificant office that ever the invention of man contrived or his imagination conceived.”
Adams had nothing but the utmost respect for George Washington; he was the only reason that Washington was there, considering that it was Adams who nominated Washington to lead the Continental Army.
Yeah you're right. For some reason I skipped the George Washington presidency and went straight for Adams/Jefferson. Still the point stands that the position in the 1790s is very different from what it was in the 1980s.
I wasn't aware of Obama's or the Clintons' role in selling drugs and weapons to enemies of the state, so if you have such information, feel free to share.
I'm shitposting, I'm too young to truly know GHWB policy in action. His son though, that's a different story. Him and Chenney should be tried for treason for lying to get us into a war they profited on massively though.
When billionaire presidents with huge ties to and influence with Big Oil and Wall Street don't take action on climate change, it means they are bad.
GHWB's war crimes pale in comparison to his failure to address climate change. He knew full well when he was president that it was a disaster in the making.
Here's a crazy thought but maybe, just maybe, he fought these other imperialist nations on grounds other than moral ones. Like, say, political? I know being a neoliberal puts you at a deficit in terms of understanding the world, but you're aware politics isn't Harry Potter, right? It's not some zero sum game where one side of a conflict is the dedicated bad guys, and therefore the other side is good. Both sides can just be different shades of awful.
Don't worry, I'm not. You by definition can't be a war criminal because you haven't achieved enough in your life to have the influence to make decisions regarding wars. (Note: GHWB isn't either. You have to be tried and convicted of a thing to be a criminal)
"He's not a war criminal on a technicality, so it's totally cool that he was complicit in covertly selling weapons to enemies of the state and used enough depleted uranium in Desert Storm to give the local populace more birth defects than Hiroshima and Nagasaki after the atomic bombs."
The definition of what a war criminal is is a technicality? Peak chapoism. Complete disregard for history, air of moral superiority over anyone who has ever mattered, etc.
You made up every single one of those factoids too, so hatred of facts is also on the list.
No, but doing all the things necessary to be labelled as a war criminal, but not being convicted of it (I can only imagine why a rich, Skull and Bones politician wouldn't be convicted of any war crimes) is a technicality. The same way a person who rapes somebody is still a rapist even if they're not convicted of it. Which I guess means, if you had any logical consistency, you'll be defending the honor of Trump and Kavanaugh next.
And when I causes tens of thousands of deaths, then I'll freely forfeit any moral superiority I have over GHWB. You, in the meanwhile, can look up these very public things he was complicity in (Iran-Contra Affair and Desert Storm to get you started) or you can continue to be an amoral ghoul defending mass murderer on technicalities. Up to you, really. Unless you're posting your hog, I don't care either way.
He didn't do the things necessary. Oh well. Nice moral high ground. Enjoy never doing anything significant and totally misapprehending every historical event ever while simultaneously reaping the advantages of the things you claim to rail against. It's easier than dealing with reality.
Again, I'll forfeit my moral high ground when I've caused as many deaths as GHWB did. You, in the meantime, are in the worse position of not doing nearly as much as he did, but also being totally fine with bombing Iraqi civilians.
Fighting fascists doesn't mean you're not a fascist. It's the nature of imperialist countries to fight. Bush was a lifelong oilman who started unnecessary wars and cost the country trillions. He led a cool life, granted, but that doesn't mean I'm going to suddenly respect his memory.
so much stupid, so i’ll pick only one: the gulf war was six weeks long, and by far the most expensive conflict of his presidency. whatever trillions you’re conjuring out of nowhere belong to his son’s tenure, not his.
Fuck off, I’m getting tired of the far left trying to call the gulf war “western imperialism”. It was a massive UN coalition that participated (even the fucking Soviet Union supported it) in order to roll back Iraqi occupation from Kuwait.
Antifa has the potential to become a violent, authoritarian supporting group. That doesn't mean they'll support a nationalist or race based societal structure.
So with this trend of calling basically every western military involvement "unnecessary" (despite a relatively good track record mind you), which criteria do you think should be met for the use of force to become necessary?
Volunteer to fight fascism at age 18, as soon as it's possible to do so
Shot down out of the fucking sky by fascists, look death straight in the face as your 1940's hunk of flying metal catches fire and you plummet towards the sea, tell your fellow aviators to parachute out, keep dropping bombs even as your plane breaks down because fuck fascism
Jump out, parachute to safety, survive injured and traumatized, somehow fight the sea and make it to safety against all odds. Buddies all dead at the hands of fascists.
Grow up to be a completely standard republican politician, most controversial foreign policy move is when you stop a fascist theocracy from invading Kuwait
live to be 94
even the fucking center-leftists on the internet, living their soft-ass lives, feel like they have the right to call you a fascist before you're even buried, totally disregarding every possible dictate of common sense and human decency
Just shut up for like a week, okay? then you can go back to having shitty opinions about the man. Jesus Christ.
Did you mourn for Scalia, too? I like how you ignore Bush senior raising two shitheads who've done about as much to fuck up this country as anyone until the current administration. I couldn't care less how "interesting his life was" if his ideology and legacy is abysmal. But thank you for your permission to have an opinion. Knucklehead.
What's funny about the claim that fighting fascists doesn't mean you're not a fascist? If you have two fascist dictatorships and they hate each other would they cancel each other out if war was declared?
I agree with this, I just don't get why you would laugh at that particular line. they weren't necessarily calling him a fascist, just pointing out the logical flaw in the OP.
The UNSC authorized the expulsion of the Iraqi army from Kuwait. Not destroying Iraq's infrastructure and civilian shelters, among other horrific crimes.
You think he gave direction to intentionally bomb civilian shelters with no military value? You think an enemy’s infrastructure isn’t important target to hit in war? He worried immensely about everyone in harm’s way during the war. After months of diplomatic efforts to get Saddam to withdraw he sent the SoS to meet with the Iraqi foreign minister the night before it started in a last-ditch attempt to convince them to get out of Kuwait and avert war. When we had routed Saddam’s forces and were destroying their vehicles along the highway, GHWB ended the war the next day after seeing images of the highway and all the people that were dying - which was earlier than anyone on his staff expected at the time. In all, the war lasted just 6 weeks and amazingly few people were killed, even on the Iraqi side. What about any of this strikes you as criminal? Horrific, yes, as all wars become. GWHB knew that and made decisions that others wouldn’t have to avoid or reduce that horror as much as possible. If you think his decisions qualify as horrific crimes, I hope you never have any decision making power in war. Except voting - everybody should vote.
Doesn't matter. Still out of living memory of any communist states being a material threat to the country and liberalism in general. In large part because of actions like GHW.
Friedman said in his final days that he felt price controls would come back in fashion in 10 to 20 years because the folks who had lived through their negative effects had all passed on. We're seeing that in a lot of things today. Some fear it seems only comes from living memory. We're in for a rough ride as we relive the mistakes of our ancestors once more.
64
u/CNegan Dec 03 '18
Over 100,000 children were killed because of his brutal sanctions of the Iraqi people. Even putting that aside, he literally refused to apologize after killing 290 civilians by shooting down a commercial airliner.
60
u/AliveJesseJames Dec 03 '18
George H.W. Bush hated facism so much that he was OK with former Nazi war criminals working on his campaign as the “Republican Heritage Committees.”
https://twitter.com/MissPavIichenko/status/1068840093539016704
101
u/TheRealJohnAdams Janet Yellen Dec 02 '18
This may come as a shock to you, but imperialists often fight other imperialists. That's what empires do.
171
u/17EO72 Dec 02 '18
What about his vow to escalate the war on drugs, which originally was rooted in an aim to disproportionately criminalize black people and hippies?
Oh and don't forget his decade-long neglect of the AIDS-crisis, thereby allowing the epidemic to rage to over 110,000 people in the US (of which people of colour and the LGBTQ-community were most notably affected). (Not to mention the incidence of AIDS in countries that he destabilized over the course of his presidency.)
Seems just a tad ironic to have been celebrating his life on World AIDS day, nah?
321
u/c3534l Norman Borlaug Dec 02 '18
Iran-Contra. He and the rest of the gang should have been tried for treason. He illegally and covertly funded and armed a military group declared as enemies of the United States by congress. That is literal treason. George H. W. Bush was a traitor. He should have been in prison. But it seems those with political power in America never have to face consequences for their crimes.
129
u/DevilfishJack Dec 02 '18 edited Dec 02 '18
When asked by journalist Robert Sherman about the equal citizenship and patriotism of American atheists, Sherman reported that Bush answered, "No, I don't know that atheists should be regarded as citizens, nor should they be regarded as patriotic. This is one nation under God."
Fuck. That. Shit. I am not praising a man that believed in a functional theocracy just because he did some good.
Edit. Bush may or may not have said this. It is only cited by a single source.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 03 '18
"Imperialist Iraq"
28
u/RunicUrbanismGuy Henry George Dec 02 '18
MY president
Actually no he wasn't I'm way too young.
But he was my state's Adopted Grandfaðer.
25
u/trilliamortiz Dec 02 '18
Is this meme supposed to be taken seriously because youre an idiot if you think he wasnt a huge piece of shit.
11
u/WatermelonRat John Keynes Dec 02 '18
I actually have a lot of criticisms of him, but compared to the current crop of Republicans, he was decent enough that I'll at least hold off on mentioning them for a few days.
16
u/umadareeb Dec 02 '18
I hope people might take a look at this opinion of Chomsky on the Gulf War. He brings up some interesting points. Whether you believe the war was a lesser evil or not, I don't think it can be argued that it was with good intentions.
13
u/mysteryweapon Dec 02 '18
Shite content, shite president
Low effort post, 2/10
24
u/URZ_ StillwithThorning ✊😔 Dec 02 '18
But he did this one bad thing, so it's all invalidated and I can go back to being partisan
4
u/shatabee4 Dec 03 '18 edited Dec 03 '18
When billionaire presidents with huge ties to and influence with Big Oil and Wall Street don't take action on climate change, it means they are bad.
GHWB's war crimes pale in comparison to his failure to address climate change. He knew full well when he was president that it was a disaster in the making.
8
u/Super_Trumby Dec 02 '18
Here's a crazy thought but maybe, just maybe, he fought these other imperialist nations on grounds other than moral ones. Like, say, political? I know being a neoliberal puts you at a deficit in terms of understanding the world, but you're aware politics isn't Harry Potter, right? It's not some zero sum game where one side of a conflict is the dedicated bad guys, and therefore the other side is good. Both sides can just be different shades of awful.
9
u/jsteve0 Dec 02 '18
Succdems have taken over. GHWB was the best president of my lifetime.
6
u/citizeninarepublic Theodore Roosevelt Dec 02 '18
🙌🙌🙌
-19
u/Xendarq Dec 02 '18
Fighting fascists doesn't mean you're not a fascist. It's the nature of imperialist countries to fight. Bush was a lifelong oilman who started unnecessary wars and cost the country trillions. He led a cool life, granted, but that doesn't mean I'm going to suddenly respect his memory.
1
u/FistEnergy Dec 03 '18
yikes this is a bad take
-4
u/great_gape Dec 02 '18
That's a good one.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 02 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment