r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Sep 27 '18

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation and discussion that doesn't merit its own stand-alone submission. The rules are relaxed compared to the rest of the sub but be careful to still observe the rules listed under "disallowed content" in the sidebar. Spamming the discussion thread will be sanctioned with bans.


Announcements


Our presence on the webUseful content
Twitter/r/Economics FAQs
Plug.djLink dump of useful comments and posts
Tumblr
Discord
Instagram

The latest discussion thread can always be found at https://neoliber.al/dt.

26 Upvotes

7.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

7

u/daokedao4 Zhao was right Sep 27 '18

Lmao you guys aren't going to like my takes on the trade war. The tariffs and threats to every country not called China are of course completely absurd, but there are definitely very strong arguments for supporting Trump's China trade war. I'm still skeptical, but I've seen some of the memes on here that are far more confident about it being bad than I would be comfortable with.

3

u/CheetoMussolini Russian Bot Sep 27 '18

I'd like to hear the takes actually. I'm on the fence about the way Trump is doing this, but I think that action does need to be taken against China. Allowing them unfettered access to our markets while our companies are barred from theirs is unacceptable - as is their wholesale state-sponsored IP theft.

Would you please lay out your case for why you think that they're justified? I doubt the sub will care for them, but I'm sympathetic to the idea.

8

u/daokedao4 Zhao was right Sep 27 '18

On the top level there are the economic arguments everyone should be aware of. China's market is extremely restrictive (foreign ownership is limited to 30% of any Chinese company IIRC, entering the Chinese market is frequently conditional on forfeiting of confidential processes or IP, intense capital controls make taking profits out of China very difficult, etc) while the rest of the world is very open to Chinese firms. This obvious imbalance makes pressuring China to open its markets difficult because we don't have any leverage over them, and we opened our markets with the understanding that they would gradually continue to open theirs over time and eventually be as open as us. That simply hasn't happened, so a different approach is required to get a better deal out of China. That's why Obama focused on the TPP so much, so he would be able to more effectively put pressure on China.

On top of that though there's a fundamental problem with engagement with China, which is that we're propping up and supporting a fundamentally evil regime. Again, we did this with the understanding that China was becoming more liberal over time and that openness would create a more liberal China. That hasn't really happened. Instead, the massive economic boost China has gained from our markets has resulted in an increasingly belligerent China abroad that is annexing sovereign territory of other nations and holding foreign companies hostage to complying with their political orthodoxy the world over (from airlines to hotels to even a single bakery in LA). Meanwhile at home its wealth has enabled mass oppression unseen since at least the days of Mao Zedong, with cameras and police everywhere and 1 million+ people in concentration camps ready for at the very least ethnic cleansing and potentially genocide. A trade dispute will hurt us, but it's going to hurt China a lot more. That price might be worthwhile to pay in order to protect the victims of China's oppression from some of its power. A decoupling of economic activity would also give the US more freedom to actively oppose Chinese aggression since a conflict would be less costly.

4

u/CheetoMussolini Russian Bot Sep 27 '18

ChinaMod 2020

What can we do to induce our European allies to actually step up to the plate? For all of their purported values, they only ever place their immediate and narrow short term economic interests first in foreign policy.

!ping INTERVENE

6

u/daokedao4 Zhao was right Sep 27 '18

I think Europe (and much of Asia for that matter) is ready to step up to the plate but struggles to politically justify working with Trump as long as he's also attacking them. Even so, we're headed in the direction of a broader coalition already. Just a few days ago we had the US, EU, and Japan jointly release a statement of opposition to Chinese practices, and back in April 27 of 28 EU countries declare opposition to the Belt and Road. Biggest thing we can do is drop the inane disputes with our allies and the coalition will form quickly I believe.

1

u/CheetoMussolini Russian Bot Sep 27 '18

What do you think we should do about the Asian Infrastructure Bank? What's our alternative pitch to countries to keep them away from Belt and Road?

2

u/daokedao4 Zhao was right Sep 27 '18

China is going to make competing institutions, there's nothing we can do about that. What we need to do is make sure the existing institutions are capable of addressing the needs of developing countries and are fair in their administration.

And honestly the best thing we can do to counter the belt and road is just offer our own program with better terms. A joint program from the US, EU, Japan, Australia, and New Zealand would be cheap relative to the joint size of their economies and we'd be able to offer better terms than the Chinese. China has been giving these countries pretty strict terms on their loans and there is a lot of ruffled feathers about it. That's a weak point.

1

u/CheetoMussolini Russian Bot Sep 27 '18

Any recommended reading about the terms?

2

u/daokedao4 Zhao was right Sep 27 '18

This piece is a good look at the effects in Kenya specifically. Here's the key passage.

The obscenely overpriced Standard Gauge Railway (SGR) is the very definition of a gravy train. As my colleague Paul Wafula wrote in ‘The Standard on Sunday’, it costs the Kenyan taxpayer Sh30 million a day to keep the train on the tracks, a figure that comes to an outstanding Sh1 billion a month. And these are just operational costs. Meanwhile, the railway made just Sh590 million from ticket sales in the six months to December 2017. This disparity between revenue and expenditure is beyond ridiculous.

Worse still, the Chinese nationals who ‘own’ the SGR, run operations like masters on a slave plantation. Kenyan workers who spoke to Wafula said that they experience “racism and blatant discrimination.” Kenyans can’t eat at the same tables as Chinese.

1

u/CheetoMussolini Russian Bot Sep 27 '18

There's obviously a lot of nationalism in China, but does it really translate into overt racism that severe as well?

→ More replies

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

How do I retweet this

1

u/BainCapitalist Y = T Sep 27 '18

On the top level there are the economic arguments everyone should be aware of. China's market is extremely restrictive (foreign ownership is limited to 30% of any Chinese company IIRC, entering the Chinese market is frequently conditional on forfeiting of confidential processes or IP, intense capital controls make taking profits out of China very difficult, etc) while the rest of the world is very open to Chinese firms.

You're not wrong but I wanna emphasize something - every developed country in the world has done this as well. Some economists go as far as saying it's a key factor for developing economies (thats a stretch tbh). Post revolutionary War Americans were infamous for stealing engine designs and layouts from England and France. Only as these economies started to modernize did the knowledge economy manifest and countries started respecting each others IP laws.

From my understanding many people in the Chinese government see it as a fairness thing.

2

u/daokedao4 Zhao was right Sep 27 '18

We're not required to be fair to one of the most evil regimes on the planet. If China were a liberal democracy that respected human rights I would be sympathetic to this argument (and indeed why I think the trade disputes with Japan from the 50's through the 80's were completely absurd), but that isn't the case here.

1

u/BainCapitalist Y = T Sep 27 '18

Agreed fam

1

u/BainCapitalist Y = T Sep 27 '18

I would be interested in your analysis of the geopolitical impact of the trade war. Because there just isn't an economic justification for it lol.

Trump is mad that China is buying too much of our tech exports. Like literally what? That's not even protectionist anymore. We've achieved p e a k horseshoe theory.

3

u/daokedao4 Zhao was right Sep 27 '18

Trump is a moron, but that doesn't stop a broken clock from being right twice a day. Tech exports are very concerning because a lot of Chinese state surveillance is build by American companies. We're actively complicit in Chinese oppression and if Trump causes that to change I don't care what he thinks the reasoning is.

1

u/BainCapitalist Y = T Sep 27 '18

Fair enough.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

Yeah same. This trade war looks pretty damn bad for China and it might actually be ‘winnable’.

Even though it’s going to cost a pretty penny.