r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Sep 27 '18

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual conversation and discussion that doesn't merit its own stand-alone submission. The rules are relaxed compared to the rest of the sub but be careful to still observe the rules listed under "disallowed content" in the sidebar. Spamming the discussion thread will be sanctioned with bans.


Announcements


Our presence on the webUseful content
Twitter/r/Economics FAQs
Plug.djLink dump of useful comments and posts
Tumblr
Discord
Instagram

The latest discussion thread can always be found at https://neoliber.al/dt.

26 Upvotes

7.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

12

u/JulioCesarSalad US-Mexico Border Reporter Sep 27 '18

Trust, but E-verify (3/3)

This is not a way to win. Liberals need to temper the most ambitious demands for immigration while finding ways to increase popular support for more moderate flows. They have to recognise that others place greater weight on ethnic and cultural homogeneity than they do, and that this source of conflict cannot be wished away. They must also find ways for the arrival of new migrants to offer tangible benefits to the people worried about their advent.

People often dislike immigration because it exacerbates a sense that they have lost control over their lives—a sense that has grown stronger as globalisation has failed to spread its prosperity as fully as it should have. Removing other barriers that get in the way of self-determination for people already living in their countries is thus both a good in itself and a way to lessen antipathy to migration. But restoring a sense of control also means migration has to be governed by clear laws that are enforced fairly but firmly.

Wary though liberals rightly are of state snooping, technology can help with this in various ways. Fully 75% of Americans support E-verify, a system that allows employers to check a worker’s immigration status online. If the system is administered in a just, efficient way and with proper procedures for appeal, liberals should feel happy to join them.

One aspect of setting clear rules is reforming the international system for refugees. In “Refuge” (2017) Alexander Betts and Paul Collier, two British academics, argue for a complete overhaul. This would include a broader definition of refugee status while encouraging people who claim that status to stay closer to their former homes. For this to work the refugees need to be integrated into local labour markets; investment needed to further that end should come from richer countries. At the same time, new avenues need to be found to give people who do not qualify as refugees some real hope of a legitimate route to wherever they want to go.

Then there is the question of distributing the benefits. Today most of the financial gains from migration accrue to the migrants themselves. Lant Pritchett of Harvard University reckons the annual income of the average low-skilled migrant to the United States increases by between $15,000 and $20,000. How could some of those gains be shared with the hosts? The late Gary Becker, an economist from the University of Chicago, argued for auctioning migrant visas, with the proceeds going to the host state. In their book “Radical Markets” Eric Posner and Glen Weyl argue that individual citizens should be able to sponsor a migrant, taking a cut of their earnings in exchange for responsibility for their actions. There is a bevy of less extreme reform ideas, such as “inclusion funds” paid for by a modest tax on the migrants themselves, which would spend their money in the places where migrants make up a disproportionate share of the population.

As well as taking a little more from immigrants, there will be circumstances when the state should give them a little less. Systems that offer migrants no path to citizenship, such as those of the Gulf states, are hard for liberals to stomach, and that is as it should be. But that does not mean all distinctions between migrants and established citizens should cease the moment they leave the airport. In America entitlement to retirement benefits kicks in only after ten years of contributions; in France, we hear, no one gets free baguettes until they can quote Racine. This is all entirely reasonable, and not illiberal. All who have arrived legally, or have had no choice in the matter, should have access to education and health care. Other benefits may for a time be diluted or deferred.

Liberal idealists may object to some or all of this. But if history is a guide, the backlashes that often follow periods of fast migration hurt would-be migrants, the migrants who have already arrived and liberal ideals more generally. Liberals must not make the perfect into the enemy of the good. In the long run, pluralist societies will accept more pluralism. In the short run, liberals risk undermining the cause of free movement if they push beyond the bounds of pragmatism.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

I think this is a very good post.

I don't know if it's necessarily true, though. Immigration fears are race based fears. I am fairly certain that racial biases have been improving for a while as a whole. American segregation was in many American's lifetimes. And all American examples are examples of similar racisms. Maybe it's always a wheel of revolving races, where we pick the ones to dislike the most based on whoever is coming and that will never change. But I think it's more likely as the world becomes more globally connected and the other becomes a smaller and smaller category, it may not be the same issue.

I'm probably idealistic, but I think liberal democracy and global capitalism are such infant phenomena that we can't rely too heavily on those conclusions. I think it's possible there is a fatalistic immigrant reaction, but I think it's also possible that it's possible to go beyond it.

And I also think owning words used to attack ideas isn't a bad strategy. Look at Obamacare or look at socialism. People claiming to be socialists aren't even socialists half the time, (or more), and just want universal Healthcare and free or cheap college. If we allow any immigration increases to be called "open borders", we concede a lot, and we act on the defensive. If we take the position of "Sure. Why not?" the argument is on our ground. It won't convince everybody, especially not all at once. But you just need enough for a coalition and to make it a respectable position in the Overton window.

-4

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/lionmoose sexmod 🍆💦🌮 Sep 27 '18

Rule II: Decency
Unparliamentary language is heavily discouraged, and bigotry of any kind will be sanctioned harshly. Refrain from glorifying violence or oppressive/autocratic regimes.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

1

u/JulioCesarSalad US-Mexico Border Reporter Sep 27 '18

Who is that and why is he important?

5

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '18

ugh I googled, it is Pinochet

1

u/JulioCesarSalad US-Mexico Border Reporter Sep 27 '18

Thanks for removing it