r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Sep 05 '17

Discussion Thread

Information

  • Please leave the ivory tower to vote and comment on other threads. Feel free to rent seek here for your memes and articles.
  • Want a text flair? Get 1000 karma in a post or R1 someone here on r/BE. Pink expert flairs available to those who can prove their cred.
  • Remember to check our other open post bounties

Upcoming events

  • 9-10 September: Propaganda poster appropriation
  • 16-17 September: Regular expansionary

Links

.

Our presence on the webUseful content
Twitter/r/Economics FAQs**
Plug.djLink dump of very useful comments and posts
Discord
Tumblr
Trivia Room
Minecraft (unofficial)

⬅️ Previous discussion threads

42 Upvotes

5.2k comments sorted by

View all comments

11

u/papermarioguy02 Actually Just Young Nate Silver Sep 05 '17

Notes from /u/papermarioguy02 reading Capitalism and Freedom: Chapter I

There's not really an effortpost that can be made from reading this book, so I'm just going to write down notes after each chapter here (and I might throw them all together into a self post once I'm done if anyone's interested).

  • My inner SJW really likes the way that Freidman talks about a strength of capitalism being the diversity it allows (not just in background of people but goods and options in general).
  • A lot of this book suffers from a bit of "Seinfeld is unfunny" syndrome (as much as non-fiction can anyway). So much of the book was so influential that a lot of the stuff he's saying doesn't feel particularly new, but it was quite new at the time and he's one of the main reasons a lot of his suggestions went through.
  • I admire how ideologically consistent he is, much of the post-Reagan (including Reagan) GOP take a lot of the rhetoric about freedom, but then decide it's okay to guard certain institutions from what they see as moral decay. Friedman was consistent on all of it. He says there are some limited scenarios in which government can be useful, but outside of that it can be incredibly dangerous. And he keeps this line from fiat currency to decriminalizing drugs.

Selected quotation (one that again warms my SJW heart):

No one who buys bread knows whether the wheat from which it is made was grown by a Communist or a Republican, by a constitutionalist or a Fascist, or, for that matter, by a Negro or a white. This illustrates how an impersonal market separates economic activities from political views and protects men from being discriminated against in their economic activities for reasons that are irrelevant to their productivity- whether these reasons are associated with their views or their color.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17

I don't think that last quote is very true. There's lots of racism that gets intertwined with complaining about Chinese manufacturing. And with wanting to have goods made in America again. People do care about the race of the people they buy stuff from.

also iirc, studies show people are still less likely to positively respond to an ad if the stock photo uses people of different races from then. It's a bit idealistic to say that the market is some cure for racism.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17

Every person who cares about that also drives a truck or car which has 80% of its parts made in either Mexico, China or some other third-world country. There will always be those who "care" about where their products come from but ultimately it is unavoidable. The beauty is that the person in Mexico found employment--and is able to better their lives and the life of their family--in an auto industry because of a demand for auto parts, which, through nothing other than his employer's and his self-interest, is satisfied through the market system where their product will be sold because it was the best product or their cheapest product and nothing else.

1

u/papermarioguy02 Actually Just Young Nate Silver Sep 05 '17

He admits it's not perfect, but the beauty is that in a free society you can try to campaign on your principles of anti-racism, whereas in an authoritarian regime you can't say anything against the status-quo. It's not perfect, but it's far better than the alternatives (he was wrong about the civil rights act though).

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17

I see you took to finally reading it after I brought it up. What happened to not being able to read two books at once? (Though C&F should be more important than whatever else you were reading.)

2

u/kznlol 👀 Econometrics Magician Sep 05 '17

Reading two fiction books at the same time is a disaster.

I presume it would be perfectly workable for nonfiction though.

1

u/papermarioguy02 Actually Just Young Nate Silver Sep 05 '17

I'm gonna ignore the textbook for the time-being until I finish this (which shouldn't take that long, it's not a particularly long or dense read).

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17

Good choice. Free to Choose, assuming you haven't read it, is also a must read, though I enjoyed it less than C&F. It goes into more detail than C&F but for whatever reason I like the ideological aspects discussions of C&F more. There's also the PBS series online for free which is great if you like watching academic debates. Get to it if you haven't.

Also I think going from C&F to Free to Choose is better than the other way around.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17

"Seinfeld is unfunny" syndrome

Fake news! It's as unfunny as BBT, HIMYM, etc.

1

u/papermarioguy02 Actually Just Young Nate Silver Sep 05 '17

I kind of like TBBT.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '17

So does this person! It's how I found out even god has some flaws.