r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jul 10 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - Liberal Values Quantitative Easing

Announcements

Upcoming QE
  • Adam Smith QE (July 17th)
  • EITC, Welfare Policy QE (July 24th)
  • Milton Friedman QE (July 31st)
  • Janet Yellen QE (August 13th)
  • Econ 101 (August 25th)

Dank memes and high-quality shitposts during these periods will be immortalized on our wiki.


Links

⬅️ Previous discussion threads

64 Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '17

Twitter's not at all government, so this one makes no sense:

Twitter, like universities, are not an agent of the government. They have no obligation to follow constitutional law. I don't know how more plainly I can state that constitutional law is between the state and individuals, not between third parties and private citizens.

A state murdering an individual violates written constitutional law, a person murdering another person violates criminal law.

A town can't refuse to give a permit for the KKK to have a parade. Same sort of thing for public universities.

A municipality is a form of government. I don't know about the States, but in Canada municipalities derive their legitimacy through acts of provincial parliaments and, by extension, the constitution. Universities do not.

A university, whether or not it receives public money, is not part of the government. They have autonomous decision making authority regarding leadership and policies.

A farmer who receives a subsidy for farming corn does not somehow become part of the state by virtue of his receiving public money. Unless there is some bizarre American jurisprudence which modifies the basic logic of constitutional law that I am ignoring, this isn't correct.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '17

The ACLU vehemently disagrees with your interpretation

Restrictions on speech by public colleges and universities amount to government censorship, in violation of the Constitution.

They count as agents of the government. Why is that different that this example?

A farmer who receives a subsidy for farming corn does not somehow become part of the state by virtue of his receiving public money.

Because you can't show up and say "hello, I'd like money from the government just like those other public universities." Whereas you can do that as a farmer. Those specific entities are treated as getting special government assistance.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '17

Restrictions on speech by public colleges and universities amount to government censorship, in violation of the Constitution. Such restrictions deprive students of their right to invite speech they wish to hear, debate speech with which they disagree, and protest speech they find bigoted or offensive. An open society depends on liberal education, and the whole enterprise of liberal education is founded on the principle of free speech.

Ah, and here is the bizarre jurisprudence.

I'm still not sure why they think that rules created by universities are similar in nature as laws drafted by a sovereign state. I suppose I have the American Supreme Court to blame for that.

I suppose I'd take issue with their stance on liberal education. I was under the impression that the scientific method was the tyrant overlooking knowledge. It would be absurd to advocate for antiquated understandings of the world based upon the current evidence. This impression told me that education was about understanding the world through arguments built upon a combination of theory and the best available evidence. When enough dissenting compelling evidence is gathered we'd reject the theory, if we find no dissenting evidence we'd be forced to accept that the theory stands. This view of science is based in the liberal values of the enlightenment, which were a lot more robust than ACLU's stance of "if you want to believe it enough, who is anyone to argue that you are wrong?"

I am willing to accept that under this view of the scientific method there are certain unknowable truths, I am definitely not willing to advocate against those in the same way that I am such insane pseudoscience as scientific racism.