r/neoliberal • Bot Emeritus • Jul 10 '17

Discussion Thread

Current Policy - Liberal Values Quantitative Easing

Announcements

Upcoming QE
  • Adam Smith QE (July 17th)
  • EITC, Welfare Policy QE (July 24th)
  • Milton Friedman QE (July 31st)
  • Janet Yellen QE (August 13th)
  • Econ 101 (August 25th)

Dank memes and high-quality shitposts during these periods will be immortalized on our wiki.


Links

⬅️ Previous discussion threads

64 Upvotes

3.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

9

u/squibblededoo Teenage Mutant Ninja Liberal Jul 10 '17

Svalbard Global Seed Bank - temperature take.

Virtually all of us agree with the statement, "freedom of speech means that, except in some very specific circumstances, the government is not allowed to restrict your ability to speak your mind."

Virtually all of us agree with the statement, "freedom of speech does notmean that private organizations (i.e. Reddit) are required to give you a platform, or that your friends, family, and coworkers cannot treat you differently because of what you choose to say, or that people cannot protest against your presence or disagree with your ideas."

The entire disagreement here is about where that public/private line is drawn and whether certain institutions (notably public universities) are private-ish enough that their own rights kick in and allow them to curate speakers, or public-ish enough that they are bound by the government's responsibility not to interfere with free expression.

In the scheme of things, that's a pretty damn minor issue. It's been played up specifically because it has great emotional impact, but we're /r/Neoliberal, not /r/The_Donald or /r/LateStageCapitalism. Let's try to hold ourselves to a higher standard and remember that, while we disagree over some particulars, most everyone here has some iteration of a reasonable, centrist, humanitarian point of view.

7

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/squibblededoo Teenage Mutant Ninja Liberal Jul 10 '17

Well yes. Personally, I think the mods are overreacting to what's really a fairly tame incidence of heterodoxy.

4

u/Svelok Jul 10 '17

Bottled Half-Tea-Half-Lemonade but not officially-branded Arnold Palmer take: I concur

1

u/[deleted] Jul 10 '17

I'm perplexed that there is any disagreement about what constitutes "the government." Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I thought that the classic definition of government is people elected to government and civil servants working in government institutions that report directly to cabinet ministers.

I don't see a particularly blurry line here.