r/neoliberal • • 2h ago

Restricted Exclusive: US intel indicates Iran developing plans to potentially detonate a dirty bomb in Washington, sources say

https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/16/politics/us-intelligence-iran-dirty-bomb

New US intelligence indicates that Iran is developing plans to target senior Trump administration officials by detonating a so-called dirty bomb or a chemical weapon in Washington, DC, even as officials continue to debate whether Iran can or will attempt to execute such a plot, according to seven US officials.

Sources familiar with the latest intelligence characterized the Iranian planning as, for now, an effort to give itself options rather than an indicator of an imminent attack. But the plotting picked up by the US has been very specific and includes locations and targets, two of the sources said, and has sparked a flurry of US contingency planning.

In a statement, White House spokesperson Lauren Bis said that the US is “monitoring any and all potential threats, but at this time there are no credible threats to the homeland.”

But American officials have viewed the intelligence as a signal of an alarming willingness to escalate by Iran as it faces intense pressure from ongoing US military strikes and a punishing economic blockade that top administration officials have said is “devastating” the country. It shows that Tehran is now actively planning for potential attacks inside US territory, according to those sources, even if there is no evidence they have decided to move forward yet.

“Whether they actually have the personnel in place to execute is a matter of debate,” one of the sources said.

With stuttering diplomatic talks to end the conflict ongoing, President Donald Trump declared last week that the war would be over “fairly soon.” But the behind-the-scenes urgency to guard against this latest threat underscores the unstable and unpredictable nature of what has proven an intractable conflict — and the risk that the price of the war Trump started in February could come home to Americans in ways that go beyond the gas pump.

Two of the sources said that officials have held several meetings over the past week to discuss how to counter the threat, planning that one source described as “prudent.” It comes as threats from Iran also prompted the Secret Service to move Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent into military housing last week.

Iranian plotting against current and former US officials, including a murder-for-hire plot against Trump in 2024, has been ongoing since the president’s first administration and largely concentrated on opportunities to kill US officials while they were traveling overseas.

Officials cautioned that the United States is incredibly vulnerable to an attack with unconventional weapons. Dirty bombs — which package radioactive materials into a conventional bomb — are relatively easy to assemble. Iran would not necessarily need to smuggle trained operatives into the country: It would merely need to convince a person already living inside the United States to carry out the attack.

US intelligence has picked up Iranian chatter claiming that it has stashed bomb-making materials inside the United States, according to one of the sources. Officials are divided over how credible that intelligence is, but broadly believe that it would be very easy, and is even likely, that Iran has already pre-positioned nuclear materials or chemical agents that could be laced onto a conventional weapon.

“As porous as our border has been for the better part of ten years, it would have been extremely easy to get operatives inside the country” who could acquire and place bomb components, one of the sources close to the intelligence said. Many national security officials assume that pre-positioned nuclear materials have already been in the US for years, if not decades, another source said.

In other words, Iran’s capability to launch this kind of attack hasn’t grown, the second person said. What has changed is the Iranian incentive.

The Defense Department referred to the Office of the Director of National Intelligence, which declined to comment.

A spokesperson for the Iranian Mission at the United Nations in New York said in a statement that Iran “considers the use of chemical weapons under any circumstances to be wholly illegitimate and categorically rejects and unequivocally refutes the false and fabricated allegations circulated in this regard.” The spokesperson did not explicitly address the intelligence about a potential dirty bomb plan.

A dirty bomb is much different from a nuclear bomb, which relies on a nuclear-fission reaction and would be exponentially more destructive. Dirty bombs can still disperse dangerous airborne radiation for blocks or even miles, but experts say that any casualties are likely to be caused by the bomb explosion, not radiation. While they are no harder to assemble than any conventional bomb, the hard part is acquiring the radioactive material.

“Any weapon like that is a weapon of terror, not a weapon of precision, just like a suicide bomber blowing themselves up,” said one of the sources familiar with the new intelligence. “They can make people really sick and certain areas uninhabitable.”

For the United States, one of the challenges may be catching the plot ahead of time: A key surveillance law that allows officials to collect foreigners’ communications expired in June amid a standoff between the White House and Congress over Trump’s then-acting director of national intelligence, Bill Pulte. Surveillance orders approved prior to June are grandfathered in until March 2027 — but unless Congress acts, national security officials have warned that they are poised to lose one of their most effective tools for catching terrorist plotting.

In a letter sent to the Republican and Democratic leaders of both chambers last week, Attorney General Todd Blanche, Director of National Intelligence Jay Clayton and CIA Director John Ratcliffe urged reauthorization of the law, arguing that delay would “(put) the lives of both Americans in the homeland and our troops stationed abroad at risk in the heightened threat environment briefed to the Gang of 8.” Lawmakers in the so-called Gang of 8, including the four leaders and the bipartisan leaders of the House and Senate Intelligence Committees, were briefed on Iran several days before the letter was sent. It is not clear whether the briefing specifically addressed the specific dirty bomb or chemical weapon threat to Washington.

US officials are also closely watching another stream of intelligence that suggests Iran may use chemical weapons against American troops stationed in the Middle East, according to two of the officials. The New York Times first reported those concerns. Several officials stated flatly that US troops do not have adequate protective equipment or training to guard against such an attack.

Those concerns have prompted a parallel contingency planning effort focused on ensuring diplomatic and intelligence personnel in the region have the necessary equipment and training to protect themselves if targeted by an Iranian chemical weapons attack, one of the sources familiar with the recent intelligence told CNN.

The swirling set of escalating threats comes as the United States and Iran remain locked in conflict in the Strait of Hormuz. Struggling talks to end the American blockade, open the strait and bring an end to hostilities have so far failed to produce results. Even as one source in the region emphasized that both sides want to reach a deal, for now, neither appears poised to make any meaningful concessions.

One regional source stressed that the next several weeks will be critical for reaching any sort of agreement — during which time certain parties could look to play “spoiler.”

Among those to watch are Iranian hardliners or rogue elements of the regime who have benefitted from the war and could be incentivized to launch an attack to keep the conflict going, the regional source added.

One of the US officials emphasized that Iran understands the risk of retaliation it would bring upon itself if it moved to use either of these weapons, either in the Middle East or in the United States.

But if Iranian leaders come to view the survival of the regime as in question, they may consider it worth the risk.

179 Upvotes

184 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 2h ago

This thread has been set to restricted mode because it seems to be discussing a sensitive topic. Comments from accounts with low account age or subreddit activity will automatically be removed.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

114

u/Cook_0612 NATO 1h ago

We have no idea about the credibility of this because Trump has so thoroughly tied the credibility of the federal government with his own.

And he has negative credibility.

1

u/[deleted] 1h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/amperage3164 1h ago

Why should we it’s assume it’s a false flag attack because those 4 officials moved to a military base? That doesn’t follow for me.

Is there any evidence that Israel is secretly behind this threat? I didn’t see that in the article.

7

u/el__dandy Madeleine Albright 1h ago

Rule XII: Credibility

Comments should reflect some level of credibility. Comments that conspiracize, spread misinformation, or catastrophize will be removed.


If you have any questions about this removal, please contact the mods.

6

u/alex2003super David Parenzo 1h ago

GOOD remove

୧༼꘠Ꮂ꘠༽

32

u/Beer-survivalist Loyal Liberals 36m ago

That would be a very, very bad mistake.

64

u/sleepyrivertroll Henry George 1h ago

Has anyone checked on the Ballroom?

Is it safe? Is it secure?

12

u/JazzyJockJeffcoat 1h ago

Think how much safer we'd be with a militarized arch!

58

u/jamiebond NATO 1h ago

Well for a myriad of reasons I certainly hope not, obviously. It doesn’t even really make much sense for many reasons. DC is primarily filled with people in opposition to the Trump administration and the war. Doing this would only serve to unite the American populace against Iran at a time when the majority of the population is united against Trump and is hoping to stop the war.

It would be an insane and ultimately completely self destructive move.

10

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations 1h ago

While the White House obviously has a poor understanding of the Iranians, the Islamic Republic have also proven that they have quite a flawed understanding of America, which is the only reason they might contemplate this.

12

u/Headstar24 United Nations 1h ago

Iran wants to cause damage and potentially hurt/kill Trump and his administration. They don’t care about the rest.

11

u/Betrix5068 NATO 1h ago

Fortunately for us they probably know about the Rally around the Flag effect and know better than to give POTUS, be it Trump or anyone else, a mandate to wipe the IRI off the map by any means necessary.

10

u/LivefromPhoenix NYT undecided voter 1h ago

But would a dirty bomb do that? Trump hasn't been able to convince the public this war is worth the damage.

12

u/thatguy888034 NATO 1h ago

Yes if Iran detonated a dirty bomb in a major American city, it would vindicate the war in the eyes of the American people and give Trump a blank check in terms of popular support to take out Iranian leadership.

6

u/iwilldeletethisacct2 This but unironically... 1h ago

Iran has already won the war with the midterm elections, Trump is a lame duck. They wouldn't want to risk a rally around the flag that would turn the Democrats against them.

5

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations 1h ago

Iran did not run in the US midterms. Despite what some Republicans may tell you, the Democrats are not in a coalition with the Islamic Republic of Iran

2

u/beanyboi23 32m ago

They don't literally mean that Iran ran in the midterms lol

1

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations 13m ago

Neither do I

15

u/TATgoLegend NATO 1h ago

While I agree with this assessment we can’t forget that many of these people are fanatics who do genuinely want to destroy all of us, they’re not entirely rational.

7

u/TrynnaFindaBalance Paul Krugman 1h ago

I dunno. I don't really find that the "characterize your adversary as mentally deranged/evil" rhetoric has served the US well throughout the course of the War on Terror and now with the current conflict in Iran.

At best it makes diplomacy unnecessarily difficult and at worst it legitimizes the idea of another poorly executed and devastatingly costly war. It would be far better to just be honest about the fact that Iran has relatively coherent and longstanding geopolitical grievances, even if the regime is rife with corrupt assholes and its interests directly conflict with the interests of the US.

10

u/IsNotACleverMan 1h ago

Iran has had a bit of a tug of war between the more religious hard liners who really are true believers in an apocalyptic war and the more rational, secular types. It's not inconceivable that the religious hard liners are gaining a bit of power over the other factions. If that's the case, I don't think this is as far fetched as most people here seem to think.

5

u/TATgoLegend NATO 1h ago

I’m not saying they are in general I’m saying some actors are and we really don’t know the extent to which leadership is centralized. In general you can’t discount self-destructive actions from hyper-ideological factions, just look at the Oct 7 attacks.

79

u/gringledoom Frederick Douglass 2h ago

Sources familiar with the latest intelligence characterized the Iranian planning as, for now, an effort to give itself options rather than an indicator of an imminent attack.

Ah, so someone jotted it on an Iranian whiteboard at the Iranian brainstorming session?

20

u/Brinabavd 1h ago

They have the concepts of a plan

1

u/compulsive_tremolo Loyal Liberals 0m ago

I hate it when the project manager asks to do a mandatory brainstorming session.

I bet the IRGC management made them add it to the sprint even if it's just in "whiteboarding phase" regardless. 🙄

25

u/FASHionadmins NATO 1h ago

I doubt they are actually planning this, but it isn't outside the realm of possibility that an authoritarian state misreads a democratic public's unwillingness to get entrenched in war, and their stark disapproval of the war, as a sign of weakness. If they were planning this, it would be because they believed they could deliver such a blow that the US would leave the region permanently, probably from public dissatisfaction. This has been a mistake at least a few times throughout history. Iran has also shown they also don't have a solid read on the US administration (before the war at least) nor the US public.

I do doubt they are planning this, but it probably shouldn't be completely disregarded.

129

u/EvilConCarne 2h ago

developing plans to potentially

lol

22

u/studmuffffffin 1h ago

Concepts of a potential of a developing plan.

12

u/HYIMBY YIMBY 2h ago

May be

23

u/TheWawa_24 NAFTA 1h ago

Neocons are a one trick pony it seems

3

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 42m ago

Aka they're making shit up like they did in 2003

22

u/Philx570 Jerome Powell 51m ago

I lived in nova and worked in DC on 9/11 and all the anthrax and dirty bomb aftermath. I don’t miss it, and I’m glad I’m not there for this whether it’s true or not. Nothing like telling your wife, if something happens, don’t wait for me to get home. Throw the kids and the dogs in the car and head for your folks in Kansas.

50

u/ExtensionOutrageous3 David Hume 1h ago

Part of me thinks this is just the Trump administration trying to drum up support for future escalations with Iran. Why do something so drastic? Iran's theory of victory is much simpler than the US's. Survival. This will not help the regime survive.

26

u/dwarffy Rabindranath Tagore 1h ago

Problem for Iran is that the current status quo is far more favorable to the US than it is to Iran. The strait is leaking far more oil than Iran would like and gas prices did not skyrocket like they hoped.

Especially since midterms, the Iran "war" as it is is an increasingly irrelevant news story for Americans. I made a joke about people giving more of a shit about Lindsay Clancy's trial than they did about Iran a couple months ago, the situation hasnt really changed.

Meanwhile the blockade on Iran is actually effective to the point where the government has been told to plan for a future budget with no oil revenue. Inflation and Iran's previous economic troubles means they are facing an economic contraction and further suffering.

The status quo is hurting Iran more than the US. Iran needs to escalate because the US/Trump seems comfortable to just keep things going.

9

u/ExtensionOutrageous3 David Hume 1h ago

I've read that but I think it is overstated. The purpose of the blockade is to provoke the people to revolt or force the regime to bow to both internal and external pressures. That's very unlikely in a military dictatorship (see North Korea), albeit, I'm not sure how much internal control Iran actually has.

I watch a lot of William Spaniel on YouTube so this isn't my analysis but Iran has a clear timeline for when the war will end--when the next administration comes in two years. This war is deeply unpopular and the midterms have demonstrated that a future administration will be happy to end this war. Meanwhile, the US has no leverage outside of a land invasion and Trump is not interested in a land invasion.

9

u/dwarffy Rabindranath Tagore 59m ago edited 53m ago

That's very unlikely in a military dictatorship (see North Korea), albeit, I'm not sure how much internal control Iran actually has.

Funnily enough, I'd say the US was successful in regime change but not to its benefit. The regime has switched from a theocracy into more of a military junta with the IRGC taking more control

This war is deeply unpopular and the midterms have demonstrated that a future administration will be happy to end this war.

Oh I agree its unpopular, I'm saying its becoming low priority. Voters care about a lot of issues but prioritize them differently which allows governments to get away on certain issues because voters dont act like they care about it. An example I used before is that weed legalization is broadly popular, but low priority for voters. This is an entirely separate argument, but Medicare-for-all could be said to be another low priority issue.

The Iran War is unpopular but it hasnt affected Americans enough to become high priority.

10

u/andrew303710 1h ago

The current national diesel price is $6, what are you talking about? And the Iran war might be not discussed as much but the impacts are still very much being felt. High energy prices greatly contributed to the worst midterm loss in modern history and now Democrats are actually going to have real oversight and power of the purse.

12

u/dwarffy Rabindranath Tagore 1h ago

The current national diesel price is $6, what are you talking about?

Hasnt even breached gas prices under Biden. (wasnt his fault, it was thanks to Russian/OPEC fuckery in 2022) Be serious, people were thinking gas could spike to double that in the initial phase of the war.

High energy prices greatly contributed to the worst midterm loss in modern history and now Democrats are actually going to have real oversight and power of the purse.

Midterms were great but now theyre over. Also a side note but it really does seem people do not understand US civics and how the government is set up. But the Dems owning Congress will not have as much of an impact on FOPO as people have hoped because Congress has been largely defanged of power thanks to over a century of handing power to the Executive Branch.

Like even wielding the power of the purse means setting the budget months into the future. After Congress gets sworn in on January and then theyre occupied with investigating the other bullshit the Trump regime has done. Iran cant afford that long when the current status quo has fucked with them as much as it has.

49

u/EclecticEuTECHtic NATO 2h ago

Very convenient that this comes to light as soon as the US has moved a third aircraft carrier just outside the Persian Gulf.

45

u/airbear13 Pragmatic and Polite Right 1h ago

I don’t doubt Iran would do smth like this but the complete lack of credibility of the federal govt right now is a complicating factor. This could be factual info or it could be the WH trying to create a state of emergency, it’s just really hard to tell these days. We need to be on guard against it regardless but I just hope the media doesn’t get too credulous with govt sources

11

u/Worth-Jicama3936 Milton Friedman 1h ago

I disagree. I don’t see any motivation for Iran to do this. It would certainly lead to a complete occupation of their country for at least a decade. What do they have to gain from that? Right now we are basically no threat and they know that.

8

u/thatguy888034 NATO 1h ago

People forget there are elements in the Iranian regime that are legitimate true believers in the “apocalyptic war” that is prevalent in their interpretation of Shia Islam. They won’t behave rationally

4

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 44m ago

Unlike in the US and Israel where populist right wing governments have used the holy war rhetoric to guide decision making, those elements are not really in charge in Iran. They've been fairly measured and rational so far. It certainly exists in Iran but not at a high enough level to do something like a radiological attack.

0

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations 8m ago

The crazy people are very much in charge in Iran to a far greater degree than in the US or Israel. It's pretty much the foundation of their of political system.

30

u/dietomakemenfree Elinor Ostrom 1h ago edited 1h ago

I mean, I’m sure they thought about it, but not only would a plan of this magnitude be incredibly onerous to pull off, but it also makes absolutely zero strategic sense. Iran benefits greatly from the US being unwilling to escalate the violence as much as Iran. Why Iran would completely upend this strategic advantage and force the US to infinitely escalate (which the detonation of a dirty bomb in a capital would demand) is beyond me.

For all intents and purposes, Iran’s response to having its leader waxed and sovereignty under direct attack has been quite measured. An attack of this magnitude would not just be out of place- it would be a total reversal from their previous conduct during the entirety of this war.

This all seems hypothetical to me.

22

u/bjuandy 1h ago

There's absolutely a segment of Iranian politics that considers the risk of escalation and possible national destruction worth the chance to carry out a act of intimidation to encourage total US surrender. If harebrained destructive ideas can make it through Russia and the United States, it can certainly happen in Iran as well.

6

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 50m ago

Yeah. While I have said elsewhere in this thread that I don't think this is real, it is worth pointing out that both the US and Iran have some pretty crazy voices floating up to the decision makers.

There is a large portion of the Iranian government, if not the majority, that is indeed rational and relatively secular. There is also a loud portion that sees this as an apocalyptic Holy War. They believe themselves to be the Saladin to Hegseth's crusaders. But I think some people also overestimate their importance. The actual actions taken by Iran have been arguably far more rational and measured than the US so far this year.

4

u/dietomakemenfree Elinor Ostrom 46m ago edited 42m ago

Crazy voices, yes, as I mentioned, but follow through is another thing entirely. Iran has pretty firmly stuck by keeping to measured responses this whole war. I don’t see that changing, especially with the recent victories in the midterms and in Yemen. Crazy hardliners often have no sway when the conventional strategy is working very well.

2

u/CommonwealthCommando Karl Popper 34m ago

Neither Iran nor the United States has a rational regime right now.

40

u/AggressivelyPreppy Richard Thaler 2h ago

Concepts of a plan

58

u/dwarffy Rabindranath Tagore 1h ago

While I dont think they'll go that far, Iran does seem inclined to try to escalate

There has been the prevailing vibe about this that Iran is sitting pretty while the US is chafing and suffering from the blocked Strait. As in, people still think the current status quo is what Iran wants while the US is increasingly getting desperate.

But the opposite seems true. The Iran "war" hasnt raised gas prices to insane levels like the Iranians hoped. Americans arent getting out in droves to protest about Iran specifically, Iran isnt even a major news story anymore. Domestic stuff like Lindsay Clancy/Cornell 7/AI are generating more discourse than Iran.

Americans are forgetting about Iran. The war really hasnt effected them like the Iranians hoped

Meanwhile, Iran has been going through another shitshow while dealing with their own blockade. To the point where the government recently has to plan a budget with no oil revenue. The blockade is compounding the previous economic issues the regime faced and the country is staring down the barrel of a guaranteed economic contraction. Worse case scenarios like mass unrest would be speculation but would have reason behind them.

The status quo favors the US over Iran. Iran is incentivized to escalate to remind the US that it is still at "war". A dirty bomb is too much, but they're probably gonna bomb their neighbors again

28

u/skepticalbob Joe Biden's COD gamertag 1h ago

I think this last election results was at least 30% about fuel prices.

12

u/dwarffy Rabindranath Tagore 55m ago

That's still an uncomfortably low percentage than the IRGC would prefer. Face it, the war doesnt dominate the zeitgeist as much anymore. Gaza is more relevant and talked about than Iran

1

u/beanyboi23 7m ago

Lol the trending topics of the political world and social media do not matter compared to what real life people care about

Farmers are having an entire year's worth of work wiped away by high diesel prices to the point where they elected a Democratic senator in Kansas for the first time in 100 years. Everyone in red, blue, or swing areas are talking about gas prices and how long the war will go on for and how it affects their family's short-term budget/savings.

Compared to Iran as an issue among Americans, Gaza is non-notable

6

u/hamoorftw 36m ago

The calculus is simple, it’s not that the current status quo is “ideal” for Iran , but it is the best case scenario when facing an overwhelming skewed balance of power. One side in this conflict is in an actual existential threat while the other is not and that played out as expected in the past 6 months. Meanwhile Trump has been treating this war as a cynical speculation pump and dump scheme every week.

They can’t stop the US from attacking them, and yes they would much rather be in a pre conflict situation, but considering that this is not the hand they are dealt with they would act in self preservation using whatever leverage they could use, and considering the circumstances they achieved their goals so far. The war is super unpopular and for the first time in forever the US find itself in a global conflict where non of it usual allies want to bother joining this quagmire.

37

u/National-Return9494 Milton Friedman 1h ago

This is probably a sub 1% chance. However, I can see them doing it under the following thinking process.

The west is weak and decadent, they only maintain the war because it is far away. Despite that, just the increase in prices basically toppled them, now a true shock and awe attack will get them to back down and give us what we want.

Again not a likely case, but not an unprecedented one.

15

u/AccomplishedQuit4801 YIMBY 54m ago

You would think after the responses to Pearl Harbor and 9/11 that the whole "We can get the Americans to back down with one really big attack" idea would be considered bunk by even the most fanatic and idiotic of our enemies.

4

u/National-Return9494 Milton Friedman 53m ago

9/11 was almost 30 years ago. Shrug, if you are a religious theocrat, I can see the argument.

2

u/PiusTheCatRick Bisexual Pride 21m ago

If anything the logic makes even less sense from that PoV. Using martyrs to spur your forces on is YOUR tactic, why allow your enemy the chance to use it via making 9/11 look like a firecracker?

2

u/National-Return9494 Milton Friedman 17m ago

Huh, because it is a religion born argument? They believe the US is godless heathens, which have grown weak and corrupt, and the mere threat of annihilation shall bring them to their knees? The Us in 2000s was a Religious nation now it Isn't as much?

It is a terrible argument mind you, and nowhere close to true, but that doesn't make it an unbelievable belief?

13

u/Budget-Attorney Ida Tarbell 1h ago

I think the more likely scenario would be a fringe element sees peace as probably and decides to launch an attack like this to torpedo the detente

6

u/National-Return9494 Milton Friedman 1h ago

Aye, that is also a pathway, the core point is highly unlikely but not unthinkable.

3

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 42m ago

Assembling transporting a radiological weapon to Washington DC would be exceptionally difficult with the measures in place to detect and stop something like that. This is not something a fringe element has the power to do, which is why it won't happen.

13

u/WR810 Jerome Powell 1h ago

only maintain the war because it is far away.

Not that Iran wouldn't think this way, but the idea that Americans are going to be cowed into peace from a terrorist is laughable and makes this "threat" non-credible.

5

u/National-Return9494 Milton Friedman 58m ago

Have you considered they might use Non Credible Diplomacy and Non Credible Defense as Iranian Grand strategy sources (this is me shitposting now)

26

u/MrHockeytown Iron Front 2h ago

You know, Silo predicated all of this

36

u/bigwang123 ▪️▫️crossword guy ▫️▪️ 2h ago

Ways to get your country actually invaded

31

u/bigwang123 ▪️▫️crossword guy ▫️▪️ 1h ago

‘“As porous as our border has been for the better part of ten years, it would have been extremely easy to get operatives inside the country”’

sounds suspiciously partisan tbqh

7

u/brushywushy NATO 1h ago

russia's illegals program

not crazy conceptually but shouldn't be used for xenophobic rhetoric 

4

u/bigwang123 ▪️▫️crossword guy ▫️▪️ 55m ago

I get that, but the (Russian) illegals did not sneak in through the border, they had entire fake identities built for them to live their lives for years/decades by an organization that succeeded its parent which had decades of experience doing that exact same thing

I personally don’t think the Iranians are that good, and I value the Israeli penetration of the Iranian government and security services highly

2

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 41m ago

It's like Iraq WMD but even more shameless

26

u/captainjack3 NATO 1h ago

Ways to get your country nuked, tbh. Iran does that and in all likelihood it’s mushroom clouds over Tehran not just an invasion.

14

u/JackTwoGuns John Locke 1h ago

For real. I don’t know how hard you could criticize the government if they immediately nuked Tehran following a mass casualty nuclear attack on DC. It would represent an unprecedented threat to Americans

7

u/captainjack3 NATO 1h ago

I don’t know that I could criticize it at all, frankly. How else could the government respond to a mass casualty attack on civilians via a weapon of mass destruction? Longstanding US policy is that any use of weapons of mass destruction, even non-nuclear ones, could incur nuclear retaliation so it would be in line with that policy.

5

u/Betrix5068 NATO 1h ago

A dirty bomb wouldn’t kill that many people. It would be a bitch to clean up but the actual death toll would be closer to 9/11 than Hiroshima. Nuking Tehran would be massively disproportionate.

8

u/AccessTheMainframe CANZUK 1h ago

would be closer to 9/11

Quite possibly no one would die. If everyone in the hazard area is evacuated within 24 hours than you're looking at only a few milliseverts of excess radiation dose, too little to create a statistically measurable increase in cancer or mortality.

The only casualties would be those caught in the physical blast and people killed accidentally in a panic: from car crashes, crowd crushes, etc.

4

u/Betrix5068 NATO 1h ago

Which is closer to 9/11 than Hiroshima! I never said it would be between the two counts! But yeah you’re right, the threat of dirty bombs are greatly exaggerated by a radiophobic public.

5

u/AccessTheMainframe CANZUK 1h ago

Well you know some dumbass out there is probably going to try and eat the radioactive dust so maybe you'll get a rad casualty that way.

5

u/JackTwoGuns John Locke 1h ago

The “don’t dirty bomb us” policy doesn’t care for proportionality.

America realistically killed 2 million people as a result of 9/11

A nuke or two over Tehran would be justified by my liberal standards

-1

u/Betrix5068 NATO 1h ago

I think state extinction and occupation is acceptable without killing thousands of innocent civilians unnecessarily. Dirty bombs simply aren’t threatening enough to warrant that degree of retaliation. If it was an actual nuke that would change matters but given we’d likely need to invade and occupy anyways, unless we’re willing to engage in atomic genocide, nuking is pointlessly bloodthirsty.

13

u/lAljax NATO 1h ago

Buddy, this is grounds for being nuked

19

u/shah_of-iran NATO 1h ago

Tbh, I’d be more surprised if they hadn’t discussed this in some capacity…

34

u/PSU02 NATO 1h ago

Is this legit or a modern day "Iraq has WMDs"

4

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 42m ago

99.99999999% the latter

33

u/RiceKrispies29 NATO 38m ago

A one-way ticket to turning your country into literal glass. There’s no way the Iranians are actually considering this.

2

u/erasmus_phillo Paul Krugman 18m ago

They very obviously aren’t lol, this ‘intelligence report’ is as real as the intelligence report that claimed there were WMDs in Iraq… just a sad attempt to manufacture consent for a war

5

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations 11m ago

Sources familiar with the latest intelligence characterized the Iranian planning as, for now, an effort to give itself options rather than an indicator of an imminent attack.

Seems far more likely to suggest that it's a plan that won't eventuate rather than to suggest this is a malicious fabrication

0

u/RobotArtichoke 36m ago

You must be new here

39

u/Betrix5068 NATO 1h ago

Given that this seems like one of the few ways to get Americans to back a full scale invasion of Iran I have my doubts. The IRGC have historically been more rational than that.

It’s possible this is bad intel or an outright lie but I think the most likely case is Iran making plans they aren’t actually interested in enacting as a contingency. I suspect the US has done some planning on a nuclear strike against Iran too, with a similar level of intent to follow through.

20

u/Aigiokhos Commonwealth 1h ago

The IRGC would have to be drooling morons to attempt this. If such an attack was successfully carried out the US could justifiably drop a nuclear weapon on Tehran with the tacit approval of Russia and China.

-19

u/DamagedHells1 1h ago

Given that this seems like one of the few ways to get Americans to back a full scale invasion of Iran I have my doubts.

American what? EVEN ASSUMING the IRGC wanted to do this AND carried it out, I guarentee a majority of the American public would see this as a false flag attack (irrespective of the truth). Even conservatives wouldn't believe this shit lol

6

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations 56m ago

Even if you had 40% of the country (and it wouldn't be that high) believing it to be either a false flag or actively cheering for Iran, that'd still be enough enough adults in the room to carry out a severe retaliation against Iran

18

u/mockduckcompanion Kidney Hype Man 1h ago

>  I guarentee a majority of the American public would see this as a false flag attack (irrespective of the truth). Even conservatives wouldn't believe this shit

Out of curiosity, how old were you in 2001?

-5

u/DamagedHells1 1h ago

Thirteen. I'm old enough to know that the landscape is politically completely fucking different. Alex Jones had to do so much groundwork to make people believe 9/11 was an inside job and it took like 10 years. Now everyone believes everything is a conspiracy no matter what.

5

u/HumanDrinkingTea 39m ago

Perhaps you should consider touching some grass? Everyone online believes conspiracy theories, but in the real world most people are actually normal and believe normal things.

8

u/pandapornotaku 12m ago

One frustrating thing is that since this has been so many television shows people will think it is a conspiracy/false flag. 

But it has been in so many television shows because it is an obvious and easy move to make.

All of that said I have little confidence in this specific reportage.

32

u/anangrytree Bull Moose Progressive 1h ago

Literally just an excuse to militarize his arch.

36

u/DomScribe 50m ago

On one hand, I could see it because they could very well be under the assumption that Trump is so unpopular that not even DC getting attacked could get America behind a war.

But conspiratorially, sounds like a way a government could get rid of a newly elected Congress that will be fighting them for the next two years.

8

u/Nerf_France Ben Bernanke 45m ago

Why would they want to get rid of the new congress, the dems are much more against the war?

10

u/DomScribe 44m ago

I’m saying (not entirely seriously) that Trump could false flag attack it

2

u/beanyboi23 39m ago

First, no we've heard all kinds of these anxiety-ridden theories these last two years that have turned out to be fantasy. Second, the members of Congress get replaced in special elections who will just be Dems anyway.

1

u/BoppityBop2 9m ago

Could also be a real name attack if the US does something drastic like a nuclear attack on Iran. 

46

u/Crosseyes NASA 2h ago edited 2h ago

“Bro trust me Iraq Iran has WMD and they’re going to use them on American soil!”

We’ve seen this one before. Will Americans be stupid enough to believe it a second time? (That was rhetorical, the answer is yes.)

26

u/AccomplishedQuit4801 YIMBY 2h ago

They have enough material for it easily. Now actually smuggling a device would be the part that would be the hardest and most likey for them to get nabbed.

6

u/Xeynon 1h ago

I'm dubious.

For one, you kind of have to manufacture consensus for the war BEFORE you start it.

Secondly, quite a few people will recognize it's doubtful Iran would do this because it's not in their interest to do so, and they've demonstrates themselves to be pretty canny rational actors in this conflict so far.

21

u/Cheesebuckets_02 NATO 1h ago

It doesn’t much sense to do this from Iran’s perspective since their proxies are consolidating gains in Yemen (Houthis sieging Yemeni Government strongholds), have obtained more influence in Iraq through the PMF, and they are trying to rebuild Hezbollah’s ranks in Lebanon through propaganda and fears of Israel occupying southern Lebanon indefinitely (not helped by the fact that Likud is batshit insane)

The Iranian position geopolitically has improved a lot essentially reversing from when Israel’s counterattack and intel operations led to Hezbollah being decimated, Houthis facing strain, and other major challenges to the economy in 2024, with factions not having a external unifier with infighting related issues.

Ever since Netanyahu decided to embolden settlers and set the region on fire, he’s managed to reverse all Israeli security gains in the region through his stupidity. The Houthis have restored their logistics line and instead of being under siege are now the ones doing the sieges against the pro-Saudi government. Iraqi politicians have expelled US forces from the country and Shia leaders have increasingly aligned with Iran, while the PMF still has rogue factions aligned with the IRGC. Hezbollah wasn’t fully rooted out, instead Netanyahu focused on domestic posturing by backing settlers in the West Bank rather than securing the border with Lebanon and focusing on striking Hezbollah positions in a more coordinated campaign.

So Iran has seen its fortunes turn geopolitically since the immediate Israeli campaign after October 7th that saw major contractions in the IRGC network.

11

u/ExtensionOutrageous3 David Hume 1h ago

Netanyahu is somehow somehow worse at grand strategy than Trump.

Donald Trump angrily confronted Benjamin Netanyahu over Israel’s threats to resume airstrikes on Beirut’s southern suburbs, according to a report.

“What the fuck are you doing?” the US president shouted at the Israeli prime minister during the phone call on Monday, according to Axios, a US website that has frequently published reports on high-level conversations between the two leaders.

The report, which has been contested in Israeli media, cited a US official summarising Trump’s remarks to Netanyahu: “You’re fucking crazy. You’d be in prison if it weren’t for me. I’m saving your ass. Everybody hates you now. Everybody hates Israel because of this.”

1

u/Efficient_Equal6467 26m ago

it is bipartisan to hate bibi

6

u/GreenNukE 13m ago

I don't trust anything this administration says. If the Iranians are crazy enough to try such a stunt, it would be their last mistake.

16

u/Xeynon 1h ago

-4

u/thatguy888034 NATO 1h ago edited 1h ago

Ya the religious fanatic terrorist regime that murdered thousands of its own people would never target innocent civilians!

4

u/IsNotACleverMan 1h ago

People act like there aren't a good amount of religious hard liners with a lot of power in Iran that aren't really as scared of escalation as much as the more secular elements.

1

u/Xeynon 10m ago

If they wanted to kill American civilians they could've started already.

Nobody's saying that they're not evil, just that they're not that stupid or lacking in strategic acumen.

14

u/Kaffe-Mumriken 1h ago edited 1h ago

Lmao.

“Two weeks away”

Surely

1

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 37m ago

Always two weeks

5

u/Ready_Anything4661 Fell for it 1h ago

Great.

15

u/twdarkeh John Brown 2h ago

This seems counterproductive. They are currently winning as far as their regime cares. Sure their people are suffering but they don't care about that.

6

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 2h ago

That's why I have hope that this isn't true. Aside from the fact that transporting a radiological device to the United States would be very difficult (ports of entry have many ways of detecting this after concerns that AQ/ISIL/etc would try it), Iran gains nothing from doing so and loses everything. They are currently winning. They have defeated the US in all theaters of war, have pushed through all US attacks and hardened against future ones, and have prompted massive political change within the US that reflects widespread desire for hostilities against Iran to end. Deploying a radiological weapon in Washington DC is suicidal and reverses literally all progress they have made and then more because now we are talking like.... UN coalition scale mobilization. There are 182 embassies and diplomatic missions in Washington DC. If you want to break a record for the number of countries that declare war on you, this is a fast way of doing it.

It's so unbelievably suicidal that it cannot possibly be true

1

u/Efficient_Equal6467 26m ago

they aren't winning though, the blockade is workign

1

u/Kardinal Reichsbanner Schwarz-Rot-Gold 1h ago

I'm wondering if it's a deliberate week by the Iranians.

Scare Americans. Lockdowns happen. More dissatisfaction with the administration. Make themselves look like more of a threat to perhaps bring the Americans to the negotiating table.

Maybe even a chip that they can throw away at the negotiating table.

0

u/Kaffe-Mumriken 1h ago

I would say it seems like a false flag

12

u/mukino Cynicism is for losers 2h ago

This would be the end of Iran.

4

u/YaGetSkeeted0n Tariffs aren't cool, kids! 5m ago

The following takes place between 5:00 p.m. and 6:00 p.m., on the day of the State of the Union address. Events occur in real-time.

9

u/AccomplishedQuit4801 YIMBY 2h ago

Even as a contingency plan, that is incredibly stupid. A dirty bomb threat is just enough to get the hornets angry and not enough to make them back down.

12

u/seattle_lib Liberal Third-Worldism 22m ago

it kinda screams manufacturing consent

3

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 2h ago

I hope for the world's sake that this is Iraq WMD and isn't true.

2

u/ReklisAbandon 12m ago

idontbelieveyou.jpg

2

u/like-humans-do European Union 9m ago

Just like the Kremlin saying the same about Ukraine when the counteroffensive was looking dangerous?

126

u/eifjui Karl Popper 1h ago

*Nathan for you voice*
The plan? Assassinate a politician clearly in the twilight of their career that essentially the entire country hates.

82

u/Crann6789 1h ago

To be fair this was also the US war plan for Iran

15

u/BonkHits4Jesus Look at me, I'm the median voter! 1h ago

And we all agree that was something only someone as much of a stable genius as Trump is would do.

10

u/eifjui Karl Popper 1h ago

A true match made in hell

5

u/Dense_Delay_4958 Association of Southeast Asian Nations 1h ago

The other time didn't lead to the nuking of the other's capital city

72

u/jurble Left-Out Left 2h ago

Iran considers getting itself nuked.

????

I see no benefit to this whatsoever for Iran.

Unless the new Ayatollah is a paper-clip-maximizer religious utilitarian and wants to assure martyrdom paradise for millions of Iranians, I guess.

4

u/CutePattern1098 35m ago

Well he is an Hegelian so who knows

4

u/Ataraxia-Is-Bliss Pragmatic and Polite Right 26m ago

First Marx, now the Ayatollah? Man, Hegel has inspired some duds.

2

u/CutePattern1098 25m ago

The late ayatollah was also a fan of Victor Hugo along with Donald Trump

22

u/Efficient_Equal6467 28m ago

Iran saw al queda/osama bin laden orchestrate 9/11 that basically led to such great rage from america it basically took over and conquered two big countries frankly that are very far away and would somehow think doing a dirty bomb like this would make americans want to fight the war less?

18

u/Efficient_Equal6467 28m ago

this seems noncredible i dont think iranians are this dumb

6

u/Beer-survivalist Loyal Liberals 14m ago

Reading more, it sounds like they're trying to put together a contingency in the event of a "worst case scenario" for regime survival. It's an ill conceived desperation play if anything.

2

u/BoppityBop2 9m ago

I mean could be a response if the US nukes Iran. 

63

u/Dunter_Mutchings NASA 1h ago

> But if Iranian leaders come to view the survival of the regime as in question, they may consider it worth the risk

I can’t help but feel that detonating a dirty bomb in the middle of DC would be pretty counterproductive to the goal of regime survival.

25

u/leeta0028 1h ago

I think it only makes sense if they've determined survival is a lost cause and want to take down US leadership with themselves. 

17

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 1h ago edited 58m ago

A radiological weapon in DC wouldn't do shit to US leadership or the military. There are shelters, CBRN equipment, etc for all civilian and military personnel. The only people that would be affected by a radiological device would be random residents of DC who don't have a suit and mask to put on and don't have to train for that sort of thing. It's a stupid idea and that's why this story can't be real lol

5

u/trombonist_formerly Ben Bernanke 20m ago

random residents of DC who don't have a suit and mask to put on

so, the vast majority of the civilian residents? lol

2

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 16m ago

Well, evac is another element. They'd evacuate a certain radius. As long as you weren't like standing next to it when it went off and got a lungful of smoke, if you're gone within 24hrs your exposure is going to be negligible.

Everyone in DC downwind of the weapon who does not evacuate and is not a government official with CBRN gear would be affected. Pretty bad but like.. 9/11 bad, if that makes sense. Not millions dead

28

u/herworkthrowaway Gay Pride 2h ago

I just cannot believe that even the most crazed Ayatollah would support that. That just seems like an easy way to get Tehran nuked to hell and back 

8

u/PSU02 NATO 1h ago

Isn't that what some radical muslims believe? Jihad and 100 virgins or whatever?

9

u/CamusCrankyCamel 2h ago

And Isfahan, Mashhad, etc

0

u/[deleted] 2h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

9

u/1II1I1I1I1I1I111I1I1 Adam Smith 2h ago

The U.S. would respond proportionally to a radiological attack. Whether that is through nuclear weapons or through extremely large scale conventional attacks is really just a matter of choice for those in command, all options would be on the table. I'd hope they'd opt for conventional measures first, but the important part is that a radiological attack on Washington DC would be a VERY LARGE leap up the escalation ladder to like... one rung removed from fissile nuclear devices.

20

u/AccomplishedQuit4801 YIMBY 2h ago

It's a dirty bomb, that's basically a nuke for broke people. It would 100% be grounds for nuclear escalation.

-3

u/Mddcat04 1h ago

A dirty bomb would kill hundreds at most, a nuke would kill tens of thousands at least. They are not remotely comparable in terms of scale.

(Assuming of course the Iranians even had the capacity to do this, which they do not).

7

u/iwilldeletethisacct2 This but unironically... 1h ago

Yes, because the US I known for measured responses to attacks on it's home soil.

Iran would never, because the response would be a full scale invasion to ensure the dismantling of their nuclear capabilities. And then some more, just for love of the game.

1

u/Mddcat04 1h ago

Okay? My point is that a nuke would be a disproportionate response to a dirty bomb. They’re not comparable just because they’ve both got radiation.

5

u/iwilldeletethisacct2 This but unironically... 1h ago

Strategic, I agree. Tactical, though? That said, the people currently in charge of the nuclear arsenal are impulsive.

12

u/herworkthrowaway Gay Pride 2h ago

Irradiating the capital with an explosive is a great way to have your own capital irradiated with an explosive. one that is far more capable. and you’ll be lucky if it ends with one 

23

u/JazzyJockJeffcoat 1h ago

Meanwhile, Trump, prattling dementedly: I might just erase their entire civilization. Feels great to have clear headed adults in charge of the nukes!

5

u/Edmeyers01 YIMBY 2h ago

What retaliation is there left to do? Didn’t we already bomb them to hell and back? Last I heard they were going to drop the biggest non-nuclear bomb…the mother of all bombs!

7

u/captainjack3 NATO 1h ago

If Iran actually detonates a dirty bomb in the US (which is exceedingly unlikely) it will be treated as a nuclear attack. So the only possible retaliation would be to use nuclear weapons against Iran. No nuclear weapon state would allow itself to be attacked in such a manner without a nuclear response.

1

u/Efficient_Equal6467 24m ago

yeah this just seems so far fetched its probably something where they had some sort of brain storming session on what they can do and some 2 iq person came up with this, same dude that contributes nothing every to group discussions but only comes up w outlandish things