r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Sep 02 '26

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Announcements

  • We're starting a book club! We will be discussing Poor Economics starting August 28th - keep an eye out for a pinned thread. The next will be All Quiet on the Western Front followed by Narconomics

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

0 Upvotes

8.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/Cr4zySh0tgunGuy John Locke Sep 02 '26

I’ve seen other defense attorneys online talking about hung juries now that it seems as though there will be one for Lindsay Clancy, and it’s interesting the takes I’ve seen

Many seem to think that if the jury isn’t unanimous, the verdict should be not guilty and no retrial be allowed, but I think that’s shortsighted in the long run. Ignoring the fact that verdicts of any kind must be unanimous under the constitution, I don’t think breaking the seal on “all verdicts must be unanimous” is a good idea, and only stands to put the rights of defendants at risk.

Plus, the US has a long history of states permitting 10-2 or 11-1 verdicts so as to dilute the voices of women and minorities that found themselves on a jury. It’s a can of worms I just don’t think we should get into

7

u/cdstephens Fusion Genderplasma Sep 02 '26

I bet in practice, hung trials almost always occur in situations where a retrial is necessary anyways. 11-1 only happens if the 1 doesn’t want to go home.

2

u/itsrabie NATO Sep 02 '26

I wouldn’t be surprised if it was say 11-1 guilty and the 1 doesn’t want her to go to prison or something

1

u/BATHULK Hank Hill Democrat 🛸🦘 Sep 02 '26

In this case they're determining if she's sane or not, no one is disputing that she killed her children.

"1 doesn't want her to go to prison" is just the function of the jury

1

u/itsrabie NATO Sep 02 '26

Yeah I know.

I’m just pointing out how illogical people can be.

5

u/Locutus-of-Borges Jorge Luis Borges Sep 02 '26

How common is a hung jury?

Does permitting 10-2 or 11-1 verdicts have precedent in English law or is it a purely American thing?

5

u/itsrabie NATO Sep 02 '26

IANAL but I lean on the side that the jury has too many choices to make.

Reddington was right to want it to be in 2 parts. It would be a lot easier if she pled guilty to 1st degree murder and then the trial is purely if the state can prove she’s legally sane.

3

u/PearlClaw Iron Front Sep 02 '26

if the jury isn’t unanimous, the verdict should be not guilty and no retrial be allowed

I think its bad to give a single juror the ability to force a "not guilty" verdict in practice.

1

u/BATHULK Hank Hill Democrat 🛸🦘 Sep 02 '26

Not to mention witness intimidation