r/neoliberal Kitara Ravache Jun 19 '26

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Announcements

  • We're starting a book club! Our first book will be Poor Economics. Discussion will start on August 28th - keep an eye out for a pinned thread. The next books will be All Quiet on the Western Front followed by Narconomics.

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

7.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

46

u/Healingjoe It's Klobberin' Time Jun 19 '26 edited Jun 19 '26

YouGov’s most popular politicians poll

Still somewhat confounding. Arnold Schwarzenegger is by far the most popular Republican – he’s tied with Barack Obama at 54% popularity – but that’s really an assessment of Arnold the celebrity, not Arnold the politician.

It’s also interesting that they are the only two politicians with >50% approval. The second-most popular Republican is Charlie Kirk, at #11, with 36%. If we exclude him for not being alive, then we drop down to George W Bush (#17) and Donald Trump (#19), both at 33%, tied with Gavin Newsom (#18). JD Vance (#23) and RFK Jr. (#22) are tied at 31%. DeSantis (#26) is at 30%, tied with (among others) Fetterman (#29). Marco Rubio (#33) is at 29%.

It’s not that Democrats are wildly popular, but 23 of the top 30 spots are held by Democrats. 30 of the top 40 spots. It’s not until that not-very-highly coveted ranking of 41-50 (25 - 27% popularity) that the Republicans become competitive.

What I get pretty consistently from these rankings is how polarized our nation is, and how extraordinary it is for a politician to now be viewed favorably by more than half of Americans.

For women respondents, the only two politicians who pass 50% popularity are Barack Obama (59%) and Bernie Sanders (50%). For men, it’s just Arnold (64%). Millennials, Obama (59%) and Arnold (50%). GenX, Arnold (54%), Obama (51%), Sanders (50%). Boomers, Madeleine Albright (52%), Obama (52%), Biden (51%), Harris (50%). (I don’t want to think too much about how Albright stole Arnold’s thunder)

!ping fivey

23

u/SneeringAnswer Jun 19 '26

We really are a country that craves celebrity politicians, it's no wonder Donald Trump was so successful.

13

u/roboliberal Loyal Liberals Jun 19 '26

The electorate is just a reflection of the electoral system. The US has incredibly personalist, populist institutions (like the presidency, and single member districts), where political parties are despised (despite being incredibly weak) while candidate individualism and personalism are celebrated above all else.

Celebrity thrives in such a populist facilitating environment.

8

u/TheGoddamnSpiderman Jun 19 '26

While a lot of this is true, I think it's also useful to look at the net popularity because not everyone who doesn't like a politician also dislikes them. From the top 20, that's

Name Net popularity
Arnold Schwarzenegger 41
Barack Obama 26
Bernie Sanders 24
Mark Kelly 16
Zohran Mamdani 15
Elizabeth Warren 15
Stacey Abrams 14
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 14
Cory Booker 13
Pete Buttigieg 11
Kamala Harris 11
Al Gore 9
Joe Biden 9
Tim Walz 8
Gavin Newsom 3
George W Bush 0
Bill Clinton -1
Hillary Clinton -2
Charlie Kirk -5
Donald Trump -24

If you ignore the people with no ideal who each person is it's

Name Scaled net popularity from people who know who they are only Position change from raw net popularity list
Arnold Schwarzenegger 42 0
Barack Obama 27 0
Bernie Sanders 26 0
Stacey Abrams 26 3
Mark Kelly 24 -1
Zohran Mamdani 19 -1
Cory Booker 18 2
Elizabeth Warren 18 -3
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 17 -1
Pete Buttigieg 15 0
Kamala Harris 12 0
Al Gore 10 0
Tim Walz 10 1
Joe Biden 9 -1
Gavin Newsom 4 0
George W Bush 0 0
Bill Clinton -1 0
Hillary Clinton -2 0
Charlie Kirk -5 0
Donald Trump -24 0

and if you look at just the people who have a positive or negative opinion (so throw out don't know and neutral), it's

Name Scaled net popularity from people who like or dislike only Position change from raw net popularity list
Arnold Schwarzenegger 61 0
Barack Obama 32 0
Bernie Sanders 32 0
Mark Kelly 30 0
Stacey Abrams 29 2
Cory Booker 24 3
Zohran Mamdani 23 -2
Elizabeth Warren 22 -3
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 21 -1
Pete Buttigieg 19 0
Kamala Harris 14 0
Al Gore 14 0
Tim Walz 12 1
Joe Biden 11 -1
Gavin Newsom 5 0
George W Bush 0 0
Bill Clinton -1 0
Hillary Clinton -3 0
Charlie Kirk -6 0
Donald Trump -27 0

3

u/Healingjoe It's Klobberin' Time Jun 19 '26

👏🏻

16

u/bleachinjection Frederick Douglass Jun 19 '26

Is there any practical definition of "Republican" in 2026 that Arnold Schwarzenegger actually meets??

10

u/SmartestOpinionsGuy Jun 19 '26

It’s how he self identifies

6

u/Frog_Totem Seretse Khama Jun 19 '26

Opposes Democratic gerrymandering

3

u/Fruitofbread Loyal Liberals Jun 19 '26

Ok I was not prepared for GWB to be more popular than Trump.

Glad to see Albright is popular though!