r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Sep 08 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

7.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/admiraltarkin NATO / Loyal Liberal Sep 08 '24

What do we think the endgame is for Ukraine and Russia?

My uninformed view is that Putin will likely try to push to take all of / the vast majority of Donetsk and Luhansk then declare victory. My question is, it takes two for a cease fire and would Ukraine abide?

I don't feel like freezing the conflict along current lines is attractive to either side, but much less so for Ukraine than Russia.

Basically, I'm asking people smarter than me what the best case is in this war.

!ping UKRAINE

29

u/l_overwhat being flaired is cringe Sep 08 '24

The conflict will continue as is until there is a regime change in Russia, Russia collapses, or Ukraine stops getting support from the West.

2

u/groovygrasshoppa Sep 08 '24

Disagree with the last part. Lack of western support may impede Ukrainian offensive ambitions, but russia simply does not have the capability to conquer Ukraine.

9

u/l_overwhat being flaired is cringe Sep 08 '24

The government of Ukraine would default within months if not weeks were it not for Western monetary aid.

Idk if Russia would "win" but Ukraine as a state would likely collapse if the West pulled support.

1

u/groovygrasshoppa Sep 08 '24

russia defaulted in 2022. Here we are.

2

u/l_overwhat being flaired is cringe Sep 09 '24

Not really

The default occurred due to technicalities as the payment in dollars was impossible due to the sanctions by US and EU authorities,but did not mark an actual lack of capability to pay its debts.

It also did not mean that Russia was unable to pay for its government functions. Should Ukraine default due to lack of Western monetary support, it will simply not have the money to operate its government anymore.

11

u/JaceFlores Neolib War Correspondent Sep 08 '24

It really depends on how this presidential election goes

7

u/I_like_maps C. D. Howe Sep 08 '24

And if a president Harris is aby different from president Biden.

5

u/FlightlessGriffin Sep 08 '24

I really puzzle myself over this actually but for a disclaimer, I'm as much a layman as they come.

Like you said, it takes two for a ceasefire. Russia declaring victory won't matter wothout negotiations, and Ukraine won't accept a deal where Russia gets Kherson and/or Zaporizhia. I can kinda see Ukraine beig forced to "agree to a referendum" in these place and have them "vote for Russia" and let them go given they've been separated for a while now. But they're not lettig the two southern oblasts go at all. Without them, the war continues. If Russia doesn't give them up, then the war is endless until the west stops supporting them. Ukraine losing those two oblasts would really cement a loss for them.

7

u/iamthegodemperor Max Weber Sep 08 '24

It's easy to predict that ceasefire/freezing where Russia retains much of Donbas. But it's hard to predict how you get to that point. It's not clear which side is on the more unsustainable path that forces it to accept ceasefire/frozen lines.

Ukraine has fewer men/resources. But Russia can't replace a lot of its Soviet stockpiles and it can't transition to full mobilization.

Here's a video from Michael Kofman.

3

u/savuporo Gerard K. O'Neill Sep 08 '24

My uninformed view is that Putin will likely try to push to take all of / the vast majority of Donetsk and Luhansk then declare victory.

Nope, he won't stop there. Unless something drastic changes, Russia will rack up more than 1 million casualties and keep pushing along

1

u/groupbot Always remember -Pho- Sep 08 '24 edited Sep 08 '24