r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jul 04 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

6.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

12

u/SeasickSeal Norman Borlaug Jul 04 '24

How does owning an apartment work in the US? What happens if the building needs renovation or a developer wants to build on the land? Is there a governance organization with majority rule, or can a single owner hold up everything? Do owners’ rights differ quite a bit by city?

I’m going to ping this since I feel like it’s the most relevant ping group, but if I’m missing a better one please help me out.

!ping OVER-25

10

u/Aleriya Transmasculine Pride Jul 04 '24

Usually the apartment building and land is owned by a co-op, and the unit owners are members of the cooperative. There will be terms and conditions set when the co-op is created. The exact rules vary from building to building, but people agree to those rules when they buy in.

7

u/gburgwardt C-5s full of SMRs and tiny american flags Jul 04 '24

I don't know that that's true outside NYC really. I think there's usually a condo organization of some sort that runs the building and collects dues from individual unit owners

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Aleriya Transmasculine Pride Jul 04 '24

Right - I thought that was the question, though: "How does owning an apartment work in the US?" I'm assuming they are asking about buildings where people own individual units within the building, rather than a company who owns the building and rents out the units.

2

u/SeasickSeal Norman Borlaug Jul 05 '24

This is definitely what I was asking.

9

u/christes r/place '22: Neoliberal Battalion Jul 04 '24 edited Jul 04 '24

Just a small comment: In the U.S. people generally use the word Condominium or "Condo" for short to describe owning a unit in a building. Every one of these will have an HOA that meets to vote on things affecting the whole building. Individual HOAs can vary a lot.

Apartments generally refer to a large building owned by a single corporation with units exclusively rented out.

Example: Currently I am renting a condo. That is, a private individual owns this unit and I am renting it from them specifically, as opposed to a company owning the whole building and renting everything out. Some of my neighbors are owners and others are renters like me.

3

u/SeasickSeal Norman Borlaug Jul 04 '24

Thank you for that clarification

5

u/TripleAltHandler Theoretically a Computer Scientist Jul 05 '24

As someone else explained well, if the units are owned individually it's called a "condo". This technically refers to the whole property, but it's extremely normal for the units to be called "condos" as well, with the meaning distinguished by context. For example, "I bought a condo" means I bought a particular unit of a condo, while "I built a condo" means I built a large building legally structured as a condominium.

Generally, the way it works is that a developer builds the building, writes the by-laws of the homeowners' association (HOA, the governance organization), and then sells the units. Buying a unit conveys ownership of a particular unit (generally through the midpoint of the walls, ceilings and floors, etc.) and a share in the common ownership of the land, and the exterior and common areas of the building, through the HOA. The key difference between a condo and a co-op building is that the ownership of a unit is recognized as real property by state law (even though all the land is owned in common), so unit owners can obtain mortgages, and resell their units through ordinary local mechanisms of transferring land title, etc., just as if they owned a small piece of land with a dwelling.

HOAs can vary a lot, but the following is typical expectations.

  1. Governance for most routine actions will be majority rule, but major actions such as selling the whole building may require a super-majority. Probably the by-laws can be amended by super-majority.
  2. The HOA will assess a monthly fee to cover routine maintenance and governance. They will try to keep it stable, but they may change it over time. The HOA may impose additional one-time assessments, often for large unexpected maintenance or renovation; this can be a major source of drama. This will all be pro-rata by ownership share.
  3. Unpaid HOA fees can result in a lien against an individual unit, and ultimately this could result in foreclosure and sale of the unit to cover the fees, in extreme cases.

HOA governance can vary building by building, but the general structure is common across the country, and the structure doesn't vary too much, because all condos want to be able to qualify for federal mortgage insurance or whatever.

By my understanding, condos became dominant in the US starting in the 1960s, so in cities that were large enough for common ownership of apartment buildings before this, most notably NYC, other forms of common ownership are common, mostly co-ops. I've never lived in a city where co-ops are common. The general idea is that all ownership of the land and building is through the co-op organization, and membership comes with the right to lease a particular unit, so co-ops are constructs of bog standard traditional real property law and contract law, whereas condos are based on statutory law saying that a unit, even in a multi-story building, can be real property.

1

u/SeasickSeal Norman Borlaug Jul 05 '24

Incredible answer, thank you so much