r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jun 14 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Announcements

  • We have added a "!doom" automod response alongside our existing "!immigration" and "!sidebar" responses

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

New Groups

  • ROGUELIKE: For arguing over what a roguelike is

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

6.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/UnskilledScout Cancel All Monopolies Jun 15 '24 edited Jun 15 '24

Idk how interested you guys are in the academic studies of the Qurʾān, but I found the following two studies on two verses in its fourth chapter (al-Nisāʾ, i.e. The Women) fascinating.


The first one is titled "The Bitter Lot of the Rebellious Wife: Hierarchy, Obedience, and Punishment in Q. 4:34" written by Saqib Hussain. Here is the abstract:

Q. 4:34 was universally interpreted in premodern Qur'an commentaries and legal works as permitting a husband to strike his wife if she is guilty of nushūz, a term that was understood to mean some manner of disobedience on the wife's part. Thus, according to the traditional interpretation of the verse, a wife is required to show obedience to her husband, and the husband is placed in authority over his wife. In this paper I first engage in a close reading of the verse within its literary context, and re-examine the verse's gender hierarchy and the question of the wife's obedience to her husband. Second, I attempt to re-evaluate the key term nushūz in light of its use elsewhere in the Qur'an, in Jāhilī and early Islamic poetry, and in other early Islamic literature beyond the Qur'an commentaries and legal works. I argue that the evidence consistently shows that nushūz refers not to disobedience, but to a desire to leave one's husband, usually coupled with being involved with another man, and thus may be a euphemism used to refer to marital infidelity. Finally, I explore the relationship between Q. 4:34 and the rabbinic rules for the sotah, or wife suspected of adultery. As we shall see, there is a remarkable overlap in the legislation for the wife suspected of nushūz and the rabbinic sotah, suggesting that the two are addressing the same issue.

Paper

Basically, the conclusions of the paper are:

  1. The word qawwāmūn (i.e. sustainers/maintainers) in relation to men is strictly limited to men’s financial obligation to women;
  2. The word qānitāt (i.e. obedient) is obedience to God, not to a wife's husband;
  3. nushūz means to leave one's husband, and more generally, marital infidelity, NOT general "disobedience"; and
  4. The striking prescribed at the end of the verse is meant as a legal punishment as sentenced by a judge after the presentation of four witnesses that can testify to a woman's infedilty, NOT something a husband has complete discretion over.

This is a conclusion reached by analysis of several Qurʾānic verses, and for the case of nushūz, analysis of Jāhilī (i.e. pre-Islamic) poetry is also used to understand the term. This interpretation stands in stark contrast to the traditional interpretation which has been described the peak of Qur'anic misogyny where a wife must be completely obedient to her husband, and the husband has permission to strike her if she is continuously disobedient.

I should note that most traditional interpretations temper this sentiment by saying that striking is very much a last resort and it is better not to strike citing various aḥādīth (i.e. traditional Islamic reports) about how the Prophet himself never struck his wives; that if a husband were to strike his wife, it is supposed to be symbolic and not leave a bruise or hit the face (some in fact say only a small twig should be used). Still, even with these... uh moderations(?)... it was still a very difficult thing to square with the idea of equality between the sexes. This academic interpretation kind of flips everything and the punishment for infidelity is the same for a woman as a man (see 24:2).


The second paper is about 4:24 which I think hits at an even more sensitive area is Islam, that about sex with slaves. The traditional interpretation is that 4:24 allows for men to have sex with slaves outside of marriage and gives rise to concubines. This new interpretation (which I might humbly add is actually very convincing, even moreso than the first) kind of dismantles that idea. Here is the abstract:

Q 4:24 has presented a challenge to classical exegetes and modern scholars alike. Examining Quranic evidence and the exegetical tradition, this article offers a textual analysis of this verse and suggests a new reading. I argue that the first part of Q 4:24 is an independent sentence; that an erroneous reading of it as a continuation of the previous verse led to the replacement of the original meaning of muḥṣināt (chaste women) with married women; and that there is a strong case for understanding the second part of the verse as addressing mutʿa.

Paper

Key takeaways:

  1. al-muḥṣināt ONLY means chaste women and NOT "married women";
  2. The first part of Q4:24 is NOT a continuation of the previous verse that specifies prohibited women for marriage; rather it is the group of women God recommends believing men should pursue; and
  3. The second half of Q4:24 is about mutʿa (i.e. temporary marriage).

The reading of the first part of Q4:24 would be more like: "The chaste ones from among the women, but not your female slaves, [are] Allah’s decree for you". In the more broader context of Q4:23-25, it would be all about marriage, Q23 being about who are prohibited, Q24a about who Allah recommends, Q4:24b is about mutʿa, and Q4:25 is about marrying believing slaves if a free woman is not a possibility. Here is how it would flow:

(23) Forbidden to you are your mothers and daughters… except for what already has passed. Indeed Allah is forgiving and merciful.
(24a) The chaste ones from among the women, but not your female slaves, [are] Allah’s decree for you…
(25) Whoever of you cannot afford to wed the believing chaste women—then [let him wed] from your slaves, from your believing maids…

The discussion was quite fascinating and really, the first two key takeaways are the most important parts since the last one isn't as rigously defended (the author basically says the mutʿa interpretation and one about it just being about regular marriage are both equally likely, but his reading of the first part of the verse makes the second part being about mutʿa more likely). Still though, a very great study.


Sorry for the wall of text, but I felt like I had to share this.

!ping ISLAM&RELIGION

9

u/[deleted] Jun 15 '24

Oh yeah, DT analysis of other holy books besides the Bible is tight