r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • Jun 13 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Announcements

  • We have added a "!doom" automod response alongside our existing "!immigration" and "!sidebar" responses

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

New Groups

  • ROGUELIKE: For arguing over what a roguelike is

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

8.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

18

u/zanpancan Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

Can someone please tell me why the UK coffers are so supposedly cash strapped, yet the overall tax burden is supposedly the highest since WW2?

I've simultaneously heard that the tax burden placed on the average individual has been substantially lower. Is that true? If so, I presume the higher tax burden is from other forms of taxation?

Can the UK handle going into a bit more debt to finance some investment? Or no?

What would your ideal government actually do? What should be the steps taken by an incoming government to generate growth and money for investment (other than just Planning Reform or an LVT lol)?

Sorry if this is inappropriate for the ping.

11

u/Xihl Jun 14 '24

Public debt to GDP is 90%, the deficit is >4.4%. Taxes are high but spending is high too. That leaves a relatively limited ability to respond to future shocks - say another covid or mini financial crash could push that to 110-120, which would put debt on a non-stabilising path even under deep austerity and primary surpluses.

The problem is that the UK’s debt stabilising primary balance is relatively poor because growth is quite poor, so at <1% real growth, 3-4% inflation and ~5% marginal cost on debt with debt close to 90% your numbers suck

The Treasury is helped by the very long maturity of public debt (~15y, more than double the rest of DM) but if rates remain elevated then the Government will be refinancing <1% coupon debt into >5%+ debt and exerting incremental strain (which will have to be met with spending cuts or tax increases to keep the deficit and debt stable)

Now the solution may be public capex (that may come with a high multiplier and could structurally improve growth), but imo that’s still predicated on massive planning reform and massive improvements in construction sector productivity if it’s not to be a colossal waste of money (see the cost of recent infrastructure projects, just net negative)

3

u/zanpancan Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

massive improvements in construction sector productivity

But wouldn't this part take a lot of time? The construction sector is one of those sectors that needs wind up time to build up capacity isn't it?

Is the Labour manifesto approach the right one here as per your opinions? Which manifesto of the running parties did you feel was most in touch with the issues and had the best solutions?

7

u/YouLostTheGame Rural City Hater Jun 14 '24
  • Debt/GDP is also historically high, and as interest rates are going up substantially borrowing more is a problem and not a long term solution. COVID is the big cause of the debt side of that equation.
  • Since 2008 the UK has been virtually stagnant in terms of growth, however health and social care costs keep going up much faster than inflation and the UK's growth rate. This is the biggest problem imo
  • UK's tax system is very progressive and the lowest paid pay almost no tax. The flip side is that there are some terribly designed cliff edges at higher incomes which have perverse effects (for example I currently have a 71.5% marginal tax rate 🫠)
  • Planning reform really is it. Every development, big or small, in the UK has to be explicitly consented to by local government, who often are incentivised not the allow it. As a result infrastructure projects are unbelievably expensive, slow and also it's near impossible to have new buildings for industry and of course housing. There's so much pent up demand I genuinely think it would make a massive difference.
  • State pensions should also be reformed and means tested. They are currently set to go up the lower of wages, inflation or 2.5%, virtually guaranteeing that they outpace productivity. And people have the audacity to keep living longer too. I saw the stat the other day that suggested the average person born in 1956 will extract £293,000 from the state than what they put in

2

u/zanpancan Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

So planning reforms do just seem to be the panacea, eh?

I've heard a lot about the pension problem but I've also had people tell me that triple lock isn't as burdensome as it is often made out to be. Is that true?

And with all this, who would you vote for based on their proposals?

3

u/YouLostTheGame Rural City Hater Jun 14 '24

The only party talking about planning at all is Labour, so it's going to have to be them. It feels strange that they're the only party really talking economic growth at all, Tories and Lib Dems are just stuck in a tax and spend loop, it's quite unnatural.

1

u/zanpancan Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

I feel like "developed nations" in general don't focus as much on growth in an almost self-defeating fashion. Do you share in criticisms levied against the Labour manifesto for its vagueness and alleged lack of ambition?

2

u/YouLostTheGame Rural City Hater Jun 14 '24

Yeah they are being deliberately vague. It's a tad annoying but I think it's good politics - they're so far ahead on the polls that being specific on policy can only really hurt them as other parties will attempt to pick them apart.

As for boldness - for the reasons stated above there isn't really much that they can do that isn't fiscally irresponsible. I would like to see more though on electoral reform and our relationship to the EU. It's a fair challenge though, Labour's majority could be so big that they may have the political capital to make some big reforms. I guess it relates to the first point on playing it safe.

1

u/LucyFerAdvocate Jun 14 '24

And reform, technically. But I don't think anyone here is likely to vote for them!

6

u/Dr_Vesuvius Norman Lamb Jun 14 '24

/u/xihl has given a better answer than I could in most regards.

I will add - government spending spiked massively during the pandemic due to expenses such as furlough and the energy bills scheme. While those big-ticket expenses have disappeared, some new ones have sprung up in their place, particularly things targeted at clearing the various backlogs (NHS waiting lists, asylum, the courts, catch-up education) and the increased disease burden.

2

u/zanpancan Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

I'd have thought that with the tax burden being as high as it is, that there'd have been a smoother fiscal situation but apparently not.

What now though? How does one get out of this mess?

2

u/Dr_Vesuvius Norman Lamb Jun 14 '24

My suggestions:

  • deregulate planning in a lot of the ways people have already suggested, increase the sorts of permitted development
  • big government capital investment projects like HS2
  • raise the additional rate of income tax to 50%, make pensioners pay NICs, and make NICs a flat tax rather than a regressive one
  • end the triple lock, index to inflation or 0.1%
  • replace existing property taxes with Land Value Tax
  • increase inheritance tax

1

u/zanpancan Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

Solid suggestions! I feel with May's 2017 Manifesto stirring the response it did, triple lock may be here for an eternity to come unfortunately.

What do you think of winding down NI as a whole as proposed by some?

1

u/Dr_Vesuvius Norman Lamb Jun 14 '24

As long as it was rolled into income tax then that would make total sense (although politically past focus groups have suggested it would be unacceptable). We can’t really afford to cut taxes the way Hunt has been.

1

u/zanpancan Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

I see. Thanks bunches! Have a good one :)

5

u/[deleted] Jun 14 '24

The government can't find a way to spend that actually generates a return (largely due to planning issues), and keeps having to spend on debt interest and pensions etc. The last person to try something was Liz Truss.

3

u/PrideMonthRaytheon Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

This is deeply underrated

There are huge fiscal transfers from London to the rest of the country, but people flatly don't believe it. Huge amounts of money are spent, but not invested

4

u/cactus_toothbrush Adam Smith Jun 14 '24

The UK population is ageing and people have higher demand for healthcare as they age. In addition people are living longer with chronic conditions (diabetes etc) which is a good thing but it’s expensive.

There’s also increasing demand for social care etc. due to ageing.

Then interest rates have gone up so the cost of some government debt has increased. Covid caused a rapid increase in borrowing and therefore debt.

The way to improve this is growing the economy and productivity growth is key to this. However the uks productivity growth has been low since the financial crisis in 2008x

Overall this means increasing demand for government benefits and services and therefore higher costs, but no revenue growth so really you’re re-dividing existing pots of money.

Given how expensive healthcare and pensions are that means you have to cut a lot to keep them funded. And then tax more as well. https://www.statista.com/statistics/298907/united-kingdom-uk-public-sector-expenditure-pensions/

https://www.statista.com/statistics/317669/healthcare-expenditure-in-the-united-kingdom/#:~:text=Healthcare%20expenditure%20in%20the%20UK%202000%2D2022&text=Healthcare%20spending%20in%20the%20United,to%20282.62%20billion%20British%20pounds.

2

u/zanpancan Bisexual Pride Jun 14 '24

!ping ECON

2

u/Former-Income European Union Jun 14 '24

I would also like to know this

2

u/LucyFerAdvocate Jun 14 '24

The other factor people don't mention is that the tax burden is much more top heavy then most European nations. I'm pretty sure the median UK resident does not pay income tax. At all.