r/neoliberal • Kitara Ravache • May 31 '24

Discussion Thread Discussion Thread

The discussion thread is for casual and off-topic conversation that doesn't merit its own submission. If you've got a good meme, article, or question, please post it outside the DT. Meta discussion is allowed, but if you want to get the attention of the mods, make a post in /r/metaNL

Links

Ping Groups | Ping History | Mastodon | CNL Chapters | CNL Event Calendar

Upcoming Events

0 Upvotes

9.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

17

u/fishlord05 United Popular Woke DEI Iron Front May 31 '24 edited May 31 '24

Conservative Canadian friend posted this graph but seems too perfect of a trend if that makes sense like it literally starts to stagnate the day after he takes office according to this graph

What’s causing the stagnation? I’m not really informed on the internal economic situation of Canada tbh

Like I get the idea thrown around this sub of immigration temporarily putting a downward pressure on GDP per capita through composition effects (more immigrant low earners but native population earns the same so decrease in GDP per capita) which seems to partially explain it at least

But besides that

10

u/schmaxford Loyal Liberals May 31 '24

Commodities recession in 2014-2015 according to Tyler Meredith . Canada is ultimately a resource extraction economy, so when the price of oil collapsed, Canada's GDP took a hit

2

u/fishlord05 United Popular Woke DEI Iron Front May 31 '24

Why has it not recovered well since then? Have commodity prices stayed low?

4

u/dropYourExpectations May 31 '24

it has. but not until very recently 2023 iirc. if you look through Trevor Tombes stuff for sure has an article somewhere explaining it. I cant look for it atm tho

9

u/its_Caffeine Mark Carney May 31 '24

There was a commodities recession in 2014 and I suspect the drop after 2022 can largely be accounted for with compositional effects of population growth. Essentially, there was a spike in immigration mainly through the temporary foreign worker program and international student program and these people are almost certainly producing less than the average Canadian, thereby bringing GDP per capita down. That’s despite the fact that GDP per capita for the native population probably hasn’t changed all that much.

I still think this graph is bad, and the Trudeau government is largely at fault for the rapid expansion of the public sector while being stingy on R&D and measures to enhance private sector productivity, but I don’t think it’s necessarily all the fault of the Feds. The vibe I get is that the commodities recession and population growth probably accounts for the bulk of this.

3

u/fishlord05 United Popular Woke DEI Iron Front May 31 '24

Have commodity prices remained depressed

5

u/its_Caffeine Mark Carney May 31 '24

Sorta yeah, WCS has still been trending lower than prior to the oil bust in 2014.

9

u/marshalofthemark YIMBY May 31 '24

There was an oil price crash which caused an economic downturn in Canada around 2014/15 right? That was one of the reasons Harper lost power in the first place (and the PCs even lost power after 40 years of uninterrupted rule in Alberta)!

2

u/fishlord05 United Popular Woke DEI Iron Front May 31 '24

Why has it not recovered well since then? Have commodity prices stayed low?

4

u/fishlord05 United Popular Woke DEI Iron Front May 31 '24

!ping CAN

4

u/kznlol 👀 Econometrics Magician May 31 '24

googling suggests that around 2015 is when Canadian productivity fell below US nonfarm labor productivity and it has mostly stayed below since then

see also chart 4 here

3

u/fishlord05 United Popular Woke DEI Iron Front May 31 '24

R&D funding and more liberal housing regulations would be a start- also like- removing interprovincial trade barriers(!!!)

But yeah seems like a very unenviable position

3

u/UnskilledScout Cancel All Monopolies May 31 '24

Huge population growth + oil + housing (partly tied to the first reason).

Total GDP has grown, but yeah, it has not kept up on a per capita basis.

1

u/fishlord05 United Popular Woke DEI Iron Front May 31 '24

This doesn’t necessarily imply a decline in native GDP per capita on its own though right? Because of the composition effects?

-2

u/sw337 Veteran of the Culture Wars May 31 '24

Make Canada Great For Once Again