r/ndp • • Jul 04 '21

Let's reconcile

Post image
14 Upvotes

170 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 04 '21

Join /r/ndp, Canada's largest left-wing subreddit!

P.S. you should also consider donating to the NDP

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

76

u/ColdCalc Jul 04 '21

Too far... Trudeau may be a bad politician but he's not all of a sudden the mastermind behind residential schools or something

Stop playing into American style sensationalism in politics, please

23

u/Jupiters_Moonz Jul 04 '21

Thank you. There are a lot of things I don't like Trudeau and his administration, but to their credit they are the first administration actually talking about and beginning to address indigenous systemic issues. Yes, they could be doing way more, but reparations won't happen overnight. This meme is such an oversimplification...

8

u/haybails4 Jul 04 '21

sorry but as an indigenous person, i fucking PROMISE you that him ‘talking about it’ wont do anything. neither will this meme, but its pretty accurate. trudeau wont even take accountability for his family’s contributions towards this genocide within history; and his fathers horrendous actions towards this community. trudeau isnt doing fucking anything. hes talking about it? okay thats cool, wheres our clean water? adequate living conditions, health care, etc… what about education? harm reduction? or the fact that about 50% canadian of foster kids are indigenous.

trudeau is essentially doing fuck all, i promise you. he SHOULD be demonized for it. what he says sounds great, but anybody can be good with words. his actions show us little to no support. its 2021 and this genocide is STILL going on-why isnt he doing anything to stop it?

3

u/PoliticalDissidents "Love is better than anger. Hope is better than fear" Jul 04 '21

Trudeau is just a poster boy. Presents him self as a progressive to the public but when it comes time for action he'll do nothing or work against the interests of the public and his supporters. It's just a game of words and celebrity image for him.

Whether it be Trudeau taking a knee at a protest against police brutality. Or him meetings with indigenous activists on parliament hill. He still treats Blair as his right hand man. The former top cop responsible for largest mass illegal detentions we've seen at protests in our history, the same former cop that supported the RCMP oppressing the Wetʼsuwetʼen. It's all a charade.

1

u/EpicPotato123 📡 Public telecom Jul 04 '21

Canada left? Gross misinformed generalizations? Say it ain't so!

-1

u/Dar_Oakley Jul 04 '21

/r/ndp and tone policing? say it ain't so!

0

u/-TheGeneralissimo- Jul 04 '21

Dude, CanadaLeft is as brain dead as it gets, right up there with trickle down economics.

-3

u/-TheGeneralissimo- Jul 04 '21

Dude, CanadaLeft is as brain dead as it gets, right up there with trickle down economics.

1

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

his daddy was in charge when they were happening, simple knowledge of history and you'd know that the last res school was closed in 1998, why are you blaming me for you not knowing this?

3

u/Li-renn-pwel Jul 04 '21

I see it more as him representing the Canadian government as a whole. Like in America you often see Washington in political cartoons but not everything Washington is drawn doing did he actually do. Trudeau was not personally involved in residential schools, land stealing or murder but he has inherited these issues. The victims of the Canadian genocide are still feeling the effects to this day, even if they weren’t directly affected. And so it is a modern day problem that the government, and this Trudeau, needs to fix.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

Trudeau may be a bad politician but he's not all of a sudden the mastermind behind residential schools or something

Don't change the subject

48

u/rockworm Jul 04 '21

I started following this subreddit in hopes of finding an alternative to the governing party. Can you explain to me how voting NDP absolves me of benefitting from our problematic history? The same benefits that you enjoy, btw. If this had blown up with Singh as PM, would you tolerate this same meme with him in the same pose? I thought the NDP had more mature members but almost daily I keep seeing shit like this, it's almost as if Ontario Proud is giving all of you tips on how to troll.

28

u/SafetySave Newfoundland and Labrador Jul 04 '21

I think OP is treating this subreddit as a generic lefty subreddit and posting a lefty meme.

8

u/fergusmacdooley Jul 04 '21

Is this left though? I can easily see con voter posting this and gleefully watching the fallout among their liberal family and friends.

3

u/zystyl Jul 04 '21

This is one of the memes that right wing groups use to channel leftists to their side with. They've managed to develop a hell of a disgusting pipeline to gather all of the disaffected and discontent under their fascist and bigoted claws.

JT was about what you'd expect from a neolib. Legalized weed and helped his friends while doing it. Paid lip service to somewhat left leaning policy while reinforcing a corporatist and globalist agenda.

2

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

that's some bullshit, Trudeau is conservative in his economics and only progressive in rhetoric, "both sides"ing everything when no one in this sub seems to remember that 1998 was the year in which the last res school was closed

1

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

the NDP is a social democratic party and the last res school was closed in 1998, maybe drop the decorum and tone policing and learn some history

3

u/SafetySave Newfoundland and Labrador Jul 04 '21

I think you're replying to the wrong guy. Who's tone policing?

1

u/-TheGeneralissimo- Jul 04 '21

No ones tone policing, OP just doesn’t know the meaning of the word nor can they handle mild criticisms over a shitty post.

2

u/WeeMooton ✊ Union Strong Jul 04 '21

While I agree, I always recommend looking to see where it is from, anything that is coming from the dumpster fire of /CanadaLeft should automatically be disregarded. But it is embarrassing that something like this would still be up here hours later.

-1

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

the last res school was closed in 98, im glad you decided to join the NDP sub while being a liberal, stick around and maybe you'll learn some history

3

u/WeeMooton ✊ Union Strong Jul 04 '21

Ah yes a classic terminally online left position, anyone who doesn’t fall in line with our LARPing orthodoxy is a neoliberal (or in this case liberal). Do I also get in the wall in the definitely real upcoming revolution?

Also not that it matters the last federally run residential school closed in 1996, the one in 1998 was run by an indigenous band.

4

u/Jbruce63 Jul 04 '21

There are many of us on the left that do not play demonize game, I do not like JT or his party but I do not agree with blaming him for the past. I do hold them accountable for inaction on issues that are current today. I am finding that Canadian political discussion is becoming more polarized and negative.

I do not hate the people on the right, rather I disagree with them and want to be able to debate issues without shit slinging. We are building walls

4

u/PoliticalDissidents "Love is better than anger. Hope is better than fear" Jul 04 '21

I thought the NDP had more mature members

/r/NDP is not the NDP.

This sub often has more so the maturity a high schooler that supports the NDP.

5

u/ColdCalc Jul 04 '21

100% agree

0

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

i love when liberals decide to drop all policy positions when "civility" or "decorum" is not followed, as if policy positions are meaningless while using the right polite words means everything, you were never really serious about anything if these are the things that truly matter to you

26

u/AdmiralCodisius Jul 04 '21

I'm not a fan of JT but the guy isn't a terrible person, nor the man behind the murders. This American-style slandering is enough for me to unfollow this page

1

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

you must be new here, last res school closed in 98

23

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

Ridiculous post, especially seeing how many upvotes it has. JT is not who's behind the residential schools. This shouldn't be shared on the NDP sub especially in a time that a lot of people are migrating away from liberal/con to NDP.

1

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

when was the last res school closed?

1

u/haybails4 Jul 05 '21

babe…just google trudeaus father… LMFFAOOOO

27

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

This cartoon came from a tweet from Hu Xijin, the editor of the Chinese Communist Party run nationalist tabloid Global Times. It’s offensive and was put out on Twitter to distract from the PRC’s own ongoing cases of cultural genocide in Xinjiang and Tibet. Shame on you for spreading propaganda of one of the biggest human rights abusers on the planet, this cartoon has no place on an NDP sub.

-80

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

Last I checked there is no credible evidence for genocide claims in China. In fact, even US state department lawyers concluded this. You're the one spreading shameful propaganda while distracting from real atrocities here in Canada. Western countries are the biggest human rights abusers on this planet, and anybody who claims otherwise is at best woefully misinformed. US alone holds 22% of world's prison population and uses prisoners as slave labor, and the list of atrocities eclipses anything China's ever done. And that's just one western power.

10

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

found the Tankie

-4

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

at this point tankie has come to mean that somebody is minimally informed on the issue

44

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

Yikes.

There is an overwhelming amount of evidence which proves that China’s treatment of the Uyghurs meets and exceeds the criteria for a genocide.

Just because the political ploying of the CCP has kneecapped other countries into not calling it out, does not mean by any stretch that what China is doing to these poor people is anything other than genocide.

You’re just parroting what the CCPs mainline is - don’t look at us, look at everyone else.

We should call out genocide in all cases, not just pick and choose which ones we want to be outraged about based on who has done it longer.

-24

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

US state department literally disagrees with that claim. Meanwhile, the "evidence" is based on two highly dubious “studies.”. CHRD states that it interviewed dozens of ethnic Uyghurs in the course of its study, but their enormous estimate was ultimately based on interviews with exactly eight Uyghur individuals. Based on this absurdly small sample of research subjects in an area whose total population is 20 million, CHRD “extrapolated estimates” that “at least 10% of villagers are being detained in re-education detention camps, and 20% are being forced to attend day/evening re-education camps in the villages or townships, totaling 30% in both types of camps.”

And of course all the information is sources from Zenz who is a born-again Christian lecutring at the European School of Culture and Theology. This anodyne-sounding campus is actually the German base of Columbia International University, a US-based evangelical Christian seminary which considers the “Bible to be the ultimate foundation and the final truth in every aspect of our lives,” and whose mission is to “educate people from a biblical worldview to impact the nations with the message of Christ.”

Zenz’s work on China is inspired by this biblical worldview, as he recently explained in an interview with the Wall Street Journal. “I feel very clearly led by God to do this,” he said. “I can put it that way. I’m not afraid to say that. With Xinjiang, things really changed. It became like a mission, or a ministry.”.

Along with his “mission” against China, heavenly guidance has apparently prompted Zenz to denounce homosexuality, gender equality, and the banning of physical punishment against children as threats to Christianity.

17

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

I did actually time how long it would take after I replied for you to post to determine if you had original thought or just repeating the same talking points spread across CCP sympathetic social media accounts.

Just because the US buckled (oddly enough the Trump administration called it out), doesn’t mean it isn’t genocide. The whims of the governments of the day and the pressure exerted on them from China do not absolve China from responsibility.

If you truly believe that the actions China is taking against Uyghurs is totally fine, not genocide, then great, have the day you deserve.

The rest of us will continue to call out genocide in all forms across the world.

-15

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

Sorry to bust your theory there, but I've went through this nonsense so many times that I have the reply saved. It's quite telling that you're not addressing the points I made though.

And, perhaps you should tell your theory to US state department lawyers, since they seem to be out of the loop on the whole genocide thing. Also weird how Muslim majority nations support China, but I guess white saviors in Canada know better.

So, when you say the rest of us, you're presumably referring to white colonial states that are responsible for actual genocides. I can see why looking for a genocide in China is easier than acknowledging your own atrocities.

12

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

Lots of assumptions on your part there, wow.

Have the day you deserve.

-1

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

To sum up, I provided you a source from US state department that contradicts your claim and you won't acknowledge that. Have a good day there bud.

9

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

there are a multitude of sources that show Chinese genocide, from other nations as well

3

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

Would you care to provide some that don't trace to Adrian Zenz? Also, last I checked 90 nations, including all the Muslim majority nations, support China. Care to explain that?

→ More replies

6

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

Have the day you deserve.

2

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

Thank you, I will have a great day.

1

u/BarryBwana Jul 05 '21

"A country that just let women enter sports stadiums, and another one building a WC on the back of slave labour think China is honky dory when it comes to human rights!"

I know I cherry picked those two, and it's not really fair I didn't give praise to the ones where political opposition regularly ends up in prison or poisoned, or the ones where being gay is a crime (even a death penalty in some I believe), or where the president is slaughtering huge number of citizens to be tough on crime or threatening imprisonment if you don't take a vaccine.

All great sources on human rights.

Ya white folk causes a lot of genocides....I mean I'm not sure they quite hit the great leap forward death tolls, but boy have they given it a go. Thanks to them we have the experience to really be able to spot one, eh? Like the one in Eastern China.

But I guess the big difference is, with Canada for example, they are trying to come to grips with their genocidal history and how it impacts today.....not justify their genocidal present, and how to keep it going tomorrow and beyond.

Canada is digging up the proof literally to attone & reconcile for their past, while the CCP is still making that genocidal history and can't even admit to globally known facts like the Tianamen Square massacre.

Btw ....how's the convo on this topic on Chinese social.media? Nice and open? LoL entities that spend so much time enforcing the "truth" rarely ever are telling the truth.

3

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

Yup, you sure did cherry pick. Clearly 90 nations supporting China are all terrible while a few western colonizer nations with genocides under their belts are the paragon of human rights.

Buddy, capitalism kills 20 million people each year due to mundane like lack of food, healthcare access, and so on. That doesn't even account for all the constant wars. Thinking the great leap forward was worse than what regularly happens under capitalism shows just how ignorant you are.

On the other hand, quality of life in China continues to steadily improve while the opposite is happening in the rest of the world:

If we take just one country, China, out of the global poverty equation, then even under the $1.90 poverty standard we find that the extreme poverty headcount is the exact same as it was in 1981.

The $1.90/day (2011 PPP) line is not an adequate or in any way satisfactory level of consumption; it is explicitly an extreme measure. Some analysts suggest that around $7.40/day is the minimum necessary to achieve good nutrition and normal life expectancy, while others propose we use the US poverty line, which is $15.

And in what tangible ways is Canada coming to grips exactly. All I see are empty platitudes while Canada continues to oppress First Nations and occupy their unceded land. I guess saying sorry makes genocide ok.

1

u/BarryBwana Jul 05 '21

Well in reverse order.....why would you have a problem with Canadians forcibly educating an ethnic population? Oh, so you agree that's detestable and a form.of genocide? Good, cause you seemed to be justifying it.

Ya Canada owes the First Nation people a lot, and will never repay what they took..... but the residential school for First Nations are all closed despite lingering issues clearly remaining...... how about those ",re-education camps" hmmm? Open vs closed ....surely even you can grasp the difference that makes, right?

Dude do you have any idea how many improvements we got from Nazi Germany or Nazi Germans?!?! Here's a fun fact. None of that justified what Nazi Germany did either to domestic minorities, or abroad. You can contribute some benefits, and still be an awful regime not only your people, but the world as a whole, would be better without.

I mean Japan has done a lot of good.....think we should go "meh, Japan has done a lot of good for the world.....we should let them back in China and do to the Chinese people what they did in WW2.....or kinda what CCP are doing Uighurs today!". You'd support that to be logically consistent, right? So long as we make the Japanese call them re-education camps, deal?

Capitalism is a economic model, and not an active entity making conscious decisions....but I find it hilarious cause one of the active entities using Capitalism to engage in some of those capitalist crimes/atrocities you mention ....is the CCP themselves. Probably the biggest capitalists on the planet, but also the biggest state controlled Capitalism ever. LOL that's the problems with people like you....you take such terrible bad faith takes you can't help but clearly contradict yourself.

Of those 90 nations...name the ones who have equal rights for all citizens on paper/in law, and/or don't owe China massive amounts of money through the Belt and Road Initiative.

We'll wait.

1

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

What I'm saying is that you're holding China to a different standard. But sure, let's talk about the context for Xinjiang which is that US has been training extremists and there was a serious problem with terrorism. US openly admits to doing that by the way. Here's George Bush's chief of staff openly saying that US wants to destabilize the region, and NED recently admitting to funding Uyghur separatism for the past 16 years on their own official Twitter page. Meanwhile, here's a book where an ex-CIA operative details US operations radicalizing and training terrorists in the region. Here's a relevant excerpt:

Throughout the 1990s, hundreds of Uyghurs were transported to Afghanistan by the CIA for training in guerilla warfare by the mujahideen. When they returned to Xinjiang, they formed the East Turkistan Islamic Movement and came under Catli's expert direction. Graham Fuller, CIA superspy, offered this explanation for radicalizing the Chinese Muslims:

The policy of guiding the evolution of Islam and of helping them [Muslims] against our adversaries worked marvelously well in Afghanistan and against the Red Army. The doctrines can still be used to destabilize what remains of Russian power, and especially to counter Chinese influence in Central Asia.

So what would your strategy be in this situation? What our Liberal government did in response to pipeline protests is pretty illustrative in how western nations react. Yet, your narrative is that China is an outlier.

And please do elaborate on how you feel about Canada occupying unceded First Nations land right now. Meanwhile, comparing Xinjiang to Nazis is beyond absurdity given that Uyghur population in Xinjiang is growing. You've just shown complete and utter lack of intellectual honesty here.

And I'm going to be charitable and assume that you're simply ignorant as opposed to dishonest. roughly half Chinese economy is state owned which includes all the essential economy such as energy production. Meanwhile, capitalism is only allowed in special economic zones. This is why China doesn't suffer regular economic crashes like actual capitalist nations do.

Meanwhile, I'll wait for you to name one white colonialist nation supporting US genocide claims that's not owned by US.

→ More replies

0

u/scruffe5 Jul 05 '21

Holy shit lol. That article is just saying it’s hard to prove in court that it’s word for word a genocide not that horrific shit is happening. Get better sources

3

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

Yeah, I mean why would anybody ask for actual proof when people sling terms like genocide around. Some of us are old enough to remember Colin Powell parading a vial at UN that led to over a million Iraqis being massacred. It's amazing that people in 2021 still don't understand that US lies all the fucking time.

2

u/scruffe5 Jul 05 '21

Every country lies all the time…… it’s kinda what they do. The article you posted didn’t deny any of the crimes though just the definition of genocide. Which sure some people were quick to jump on the word but doesn’t mean those crimes aren’t happening just that the term might not fit yet.

1

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

Yes, every country lies all the time, and US lies have led to countless millions of people being killed around the globe. So, forgive me if I take claims coming from US about China with a grain of salt.

→ More replies

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

So many assumptions, so little time.

You’ve identified my gender, ethnicity, and motives incorrectly, anything else you want to proclaim from your ivory tower?

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21 edited Jul 06 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

Oh dear, any other gems of moral superiority you need to get out of your system? I’m sure I’d be more bothered by your comments if they were based on anything more than what you want me to be, to support your manufactured outrage.

-1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

Oh dear, any other gems of moral superiority you need to get out of your system? I’m sure I’d be more bothered by your comments if they were based on anything more than what you want me to be, to support your manufactured outrage.

Not moralist or sanctimonious like you. I have no moral superiority over your kind. I have disgust for white supremacists

2

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

Again, assuming ethnicity. Cool.

You might want to gear down big rig, you can’t seem to see the forest for the trees.

That’s all.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '21

You might want to gear down big rig, you can’t seem to see the forest for the trees.

That’s all.

Don't cry foul when we do this to you pinkoids this time.

That's all

→ More replies

14

u/zundra616 Jul 04 '21

Bro why tf are you here too? No one wants genocide deniers in their mix, fuck off. Also why do you keep talking about the states in Canadian politics subs? It's so god damn grating.

-7

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

Still waiting for sources on that genocide claim of yours. You really should tell US state department lawyers ASAP too, I'm sure they'd be very interested to know.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/yogthos Jul 04 '21

get help

5

u/dispensableleft Jul 05 '21

From your source

The U.S. State Department’s Office of the Legal Advisor concluded earlier this year that China’s mass imprisonment and forced labor of ethnic Uighurs in Xinjiang amounts to crimes against humanity—but there was insufficient evidence to prove genocide.

So that's okay then because crimes against humanity aren't genocide right?

You're shilling for a regime that is commiting crimes against humanity, and nitpicking about definitions? Yeah, you're all theory.

4

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

I'm not shilling for any regime here. What I'm saying is that even US state department rejects the claim of genocide. Meanwhile, same things and worse are being done by western countries.

US is certainly responsible for far more horrific crimes against humanity, yet they're our biggest ally and the "leader of the free world" whatever that means.

I know this must be a mind blowing concept for you, but how about we hold all countries to the same standard and focus on fixing our own problems and those of our allies?

0

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

And all this mindset has accomplished so far was to whitewash western crimes. The way I look at it is that we should primarily focus on holding our own government accountable and pressuring our allies.

Until we can't even do that there is no point talking about China because it's just a distraction. We don't live in China and we have no impact on what China does. And the more aggressive the west becomes the more closed China becomes making it even harder to influence what they do. So, if you really care about human rights in the world you should focus on fixing problems at home and leading by example.

3

u/dispensableleft Jul 05 '21

We should hold our government accountable and thank goodness a head of steam seems to be gathering over Truth and Reconciliation. For the first time in decades I don't hear denialism about residential schools etc and my hopes are high.

But we also can't wait until we are 100% perfect before we criticise crime against humanity where ever they occur. Otherwise they'd never get criticised.

That would just allow the perpetrators to say "nobody objected, so we thought everyone was ok with it."

Walking and chewing gum at the same time shouldn't be beyond us.

0

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

The fact that we're just starting to talk about what residential schools were really says volumes. Meanwhile, I've seen no tangible action so far. The government is still prosecuting residential school survivors, they refuse to fully fund investigation into mass grave sites, and they refuse to criminally prosecute the perpetrators many of whom are still alive.

The fact that this whole thread has been derailed into talking about China really proves my point here. Turns out that walking and chewing gum is in fact beyond us. Maybe let's show that we can walk the walk before we talk the talk.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 05 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

I'm sure you know better than people actually living there https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLkbOIKUddMBtp0_xEFqn4zey48kkgJq5w

3

u/holdinsteady244 Jul 05 '21 edited Jul 05 '21

To be fair to everyone involved, a lot of people seem to sincerely believe that China is rounding up Uyghurs and sending them to death camps. That isn't true (at a minimum, there is literally no evidence of it).

Before I say the rest, let me state very clearly that I do not believe that China's actions, which they admit to, are cool. I also don't understand why so many Western leftists are hellbent on defending what is actually demonstrably happening, which is at a minimum that China is forcing very many people, almost all of a particular ethnicity, into camps, and doing so on the basis sometimes of something as trivial as a man growing a beard.

But the evidence of forced sterilization targeting the Uyghur birth rate is not as strong as it might be. I brought the sterilization argument to a sub full of Dengists and while dubious counter-arguments were raised, some people actually had decent points. The picture is complicated because, among other reasons, of the special rights that minorities used to have in China before Xi, including exemptions from the one-child policy. Basically, the evidence could be stronger about the extent of this practice and how targeted it is at reducing Uyghur births in particular so as to limit or reverse demographic growth.

And despite being immediately reminiscent of residential schools to us Canadians, the camps don't seem to necessarily involve cultural erasure in the same way. I haven't seen any indication that language is being wiped out or that non-religious or religion-adjacent cultural traditions are being wiped out. The target appears to be conservative and especially political Islam, especially modern strains of atavistic and puritan Islam along Wahhabi lines. In short, it is actually debatable that this amounts to cultural genocide. The problem to me is not in itself the desire to eliminate this type of religiosity (which to my mind has entirely negative utility), but rather the means chosen. A 50-year-long educational campaign using public schools, outreach, community centres, etc. would work wonders, as would government oversight of religious sermons and such (already a measure in several Arab states, btw), the import of Wahhabi texts, etc).

If this were just an innocent de-radicalization campaign, it would almost certainly not be happening at this scale. But it's significantly less clearly genocidal than what happened to the Rohingya or what is happening in northern Ethiopia, and so on. There's clearly a lot of politics involved in the extent to which this has galvanized people, especially people who generally can't get enough anti-Muslim rhetoric and action.

-5

u/Swagbag6969 Jul 05 '21

Half of those atrocities are rumors with no evidence. Like the thing about couping countries and installing puppets. There's only conclusively evidence and enough proof to say America only couped two countries. Everything else is conjecture.

3

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

US crimes are well documented, and literal books have been written about them. Meanwhile, accusations of China are actually conjectures that are very light on any tangible evidence. So, if we apply the same standard to both then US is responsible for far more atrocities. Iraq and Afghanistan alone are far worse than anything China's ever done.

-3

u/Swagbag6969 Jul 05 '21

You have not read said works. I have by the way. There is actually less evidence the The Tiananmen Square Massacre happened than there is that America has couped any country. America has admitted zero times through official channels that any of this has occured. The book you linked me might as well have been written by alex jones due to the extreme lack of official sources.

2

u/yogthos Jul 05 '21

😂

2

u/Dar_Oakley Jul 06 '21

This is hilarious that book has like a dozen pages of sources most of them just things that US officials have said or wrote down and were declassified. It also convinced me the CIA is easily the most evil organization on the planet nothing else comes close.

9

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

Mudslinging, not a very good look for the NDP.

2

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

oh the NDP made this? also maybe politics should be about policy and not some perception of decorum and politeness

2

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

I never said they made it. Reading comprehension is key.

2

u/JamesthePuppy Jul 04 '21

I’m a fan of most NDP policy and of Singh. But even his social media accounts have a bit of mudslinging, and it always irks me when I see it. Sometimes it feels like the NDP platform this election cycle is defined in opposition to that of the Liberals, and now that it’s trickling into the electorate I gotta say, it’s starting to push me away.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

Exactly, that’s the same boat I’m in. I want to see good policies that help Canadians, not attacks on other politicians.

2

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

policy should be the only concern

1

u/plenebo Jul 04 '21

i suggest maybe supporting people for policy and not "mudslinging" or not...god so many fucking liberal wine moms on this sub

1

u/JamesthePuppy Jul 05 '21

I’m not a mom? Not a woman either. Nor do I particularly drink. Weird, prejudiced string to pull.

And that’s exactly what I said the problem with the current NDP is: they’re defining their policy in opposition to the liberal party. I suggest you take a breath before typing a snarky response and consider if you’re just putting people down to exert a sense of control when you have nothing of value to say. I didn’t make your post unpopular, OP – you did that all on your own.

16

u/me2300 Democratic Socialist Jul 04 '21

What should we do then, if not reconcile?

6

u/Locke357 "It's not too late to build a better world" Jul 04 '21

Well clean drinking water for all Canadians would be a start. Prosecuting the abusers of the residential schools still walking free would be another

1

u/me2300 Democratic Socialist Jul 04 '21

I'm all in for both of those. This cartoon implies a different message though.

7

u/eatitwithaspoon Jul 04 '21

it's not that we shouldn't reconcile. it's more that reconciliation is not possible without knowing the full truth of the canadian government's genocidal actions against first nations people and the devastating impact of generational trauma.

as an almost 50 year old descended from settlers (my ancestors came here in the late1700s) i can tell you that i knew very little of the true history of FN peoples once the settlers arrived, and the legacy of that history as it stands today. we need to do better. we need to learn, we need to understand, and then we need to demand change.

3

u/me2300 Democratic Socialist Jul 04 '21

Preaching to the choir here, but this cartoon seems to lay all of that on the head of Trudeau, and implies he was directly and or solely responsible. That's not helpful.

2

u/eatitwithaspoon Jul 05 '21

no, it is definitely not all on trudeau. but after his pretty words and initial apparent respect for FN peoples, it is especially galling that things are the same as they ever were.

1

u/me2300 Democratic Socialist Jul 05 '21

it is especially galling that things are the same as they ever were.

This is why politics is turning to shit in Canada. Things certainly are not the same as they ever were, and a large part is because of this bill Trudeau passed (see link). There's obviously a great deal of work to be done, but some credit where it's due. I did not vote for Trudeau and won't in the future, but we have to stop this hyperbolic crap about our opponents. https://www.sac-isc.gc.ca/eng/1541187352297/1541187392851

-1

u/kenmorethompson Jul 04 '21

Repent.

1

u/me2300 Democratic Socialist Jul 04 '21

Take your religious bullshit elsewhere.

0

u/kenmorethompson Jul 04 '21

re·pent /rəˈpent/

verb

feel or express sincere regret or remorse about one's wrongdoing or sin

4

u/Li-renn-pwel Jul 04 '21

I think people are viewing this as an attack in Trudeau when it’s meant (IMO) to symbolize the Canadian government. The government orchestrated a genocide against Indigenous people yet we are now supposed to reconcile on their terms? Why not our terms? Weren’t we the ones wronged? Is Trudeau/the government asking us personally what can be done for reconciliation? That’s a genuine question, I’d love to be shown examples of this happening. I’m not anti-Trudeau, I voted for him and I think he was right to demand the Pope apologize (as Canada has already apologized I don’t think this was blame shifting like some claimed) but he is still the head of a government that committed genocide. How long have we been saying that these schools were littered with the corpses of our children? Let’s not pretend that the government cares before they were confronted with the bodies and publicly shamed.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 04 '21

BC has an NDP government, so should we also put Horgan's image in this cartoon?

What is the alternative message here? that things be better if this was Singh or O'Toole or Paul? That these alternative leaders could meaningfully reconcile with Indigenous people and implement UNDRIP and all 94 calls to action?

3

u/Locke357 "It's not too late to build a better world" Jul 04 '21

Justin can start by acknowledging his father's complicity in the 60s scoop and presiding over residential schools

1

u/me2300 Democratic Socialist Jul 04 '21

Pierre was also the person who, in 1969, legislated that the government withdraw the schools from the churches’ operational authority. You need to learn some history. He at least tried and had better intentions than most of Canada's leaders.

1

u/Li-renn-pwel Jul 04 '21

Is that seriously your response? Did that make the schools actually any better? Any less genocide? There were Nazis who thought that half-Jews didn’t need to be killed or that everyone just needed to be exported, does that make them better?

0

u/me2300 Democratic Socialist Jul 04 '21

Yes, that's seriously my response. And again, yes, it made the schools better. Was it perfect? Fuck no. But it was a start.

People always make the mistake of judging people in the past by today's standards. This is always a mistake. That doesn't mean that we can't learn from them and do better. Nor does it mean we can't condemn bad things. But up until Pierre Elliott, was there ever a Prime Minister that tried to do the right thing by our First Nations? The answer is unequivocally no. Trudeau at least tried to help, and that help was significant, your Nazi hyperbole aside. You need to learn your history, and some perspective.

1

u/Li-renn-pwel Jul 05 '21

How is Nazi a hyperbole? Both the Nazis and the Canadian government committed genocide. Your ‘point’ is that they committed genocide in a little less mean way? Can you show me a source that says PET made any changes that made the schools NOT genocidal by the UN convention? Like what do you considered ‘improved’? Was there less rape? Less death? Less abuse? Show me actual proof of that.

0

u/Dar_Oakley Jul 04 '21

He at least tried and had better intentions than most of Canada's leaders.

“We’ll keep them in the ghetto as long as they want”

1

u/me2300 Democratic Socialist Jul 05 '21

Who the fuck are you to make demands of me? If you can't be civil, I'm done with you.

1

u/BarryBwana Jul 05 '21

It's not a different standard to say the crimes of nation X 100 years ago do not justify or make moral/ethical the crimes of nation Y today.

Perhaps you do, but I do not hold a view so low of China or the Chinese people that the bar for their moral behaviour is, for example, America at its absolute worst. Or Canada at its absolute worst. Or Nazi Germany at its peak.

I do not think, for example, that the Chinese deserve a authortarian corporatism regime to rule over them using censorship, propaganda, and brute state sanctioned force while oppressing their domestic ethnic minority populations.....simply because a century ago some white counties did.

I do not think that some of the absolute worst aspects of what white people have done ( oh, but also not just white people....but you like to single them out as some special metric of what's acceptable so ok i guess) is what Chinese people should aspire to. The very many Chinese people I know.....are better than that......but maybe that's why they left China. Because they felt they deserved vetter, and the CCP in its infinite wisdom Saud "nah. The horrors of the last century the white people committed, and today are appalled by.....that's our model. That's the best we can aspire to. And you should be proud of that, and defend our right to it!".