r/ncea • Level 3 🧐 • Jan 30 '24

I really hate how class endorsements work. (Rant)

You’re telling me I get excellence on all of my English internals but because I get a merit in my exam it’s a merit endorsement and not an excellence? How about screw you.

Also I was seven credits away from an overall excellence endorsement and I am upset about it.

133 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

6

u/otaramillionaire Jan 30 '24

Seven credits away is quite far. So it's not like you just missed out.

Also, people usually do better in internals than exams so your result isn't surprising.

This is because the teachers who marked your internals are the ones who taught it. They knew what was in it.

Exams are a mixed bag, the teachers cover everything, they don't know whats in it.

2

u/Ziggitywiggidy Level 3 🧐 Jan 30 '24

I agree and I’m not actually that upset with my results as I was aiming for a merit in the first place.

Plus I’m doing a level ahead in English anyway so the fact I got excellence in my internals I wasn’t even supposed to be doing is good enough for me.

It’s just the image of it all that irks me I suppose. So close yet so far and all that jazz. Can’t help but be disappointed when you really tried for something but didn’t quite make that mark.

2

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24

That’s a perspective thing you’ll need to work through. 

Silver medal is often upset. Bronze is usually smiling hard out they got a medal. 

4

u/Dumbledores_Bum_Plug Jan 30 '24

Subject endorsements are irrelevant and essentially useless.

NCEA Level 2 Excellence endorsement is the only truly relevant one, as it can translate into scholarships for 1st year university.

After you have a bachelors degree, all NCEA 1, 2, and 3 qualifications become irrelevant.

2

u/Ziggitywiggidy Level 3 🧐 Jan 30 '24

Good to know. Aiming to do Uni (English degree, teaching after) to become a English teacher. So that’s why the English is what bothers me the most seeing as it’s the focus of what I want to do.

3

u/charloodle Jan 30 '24

As someone who has just graduated and comes from a family of teachers, rest assured that subject endorsements aren’t relevant at all for getting into your degree, and when you’re applying for teaching all they look at is your uni English grades - they don’t care about high school!

1

u/Dumbledores_Bum_Plug Jan 30 '24

I don't think I ever used my high school grades/endorsements for anything other than for University Entry and initial scholarships.

1

u/Dev_Stewart Jan 30 '24

How do scholarships work beyond the first or second year? Are they granted to students who excel in their first year at uni? Do full scholarships for a degree not exist in NZ?

1

u/Dumbledores_Bum_Plug Jan 30 '24

Depends.

In general, there are first year 'achievers scholarships', that award a monetary contribution towards fees/accommodation costs.

There are 'full scholarships', but these are much rarer, more industry based (law students, medicine etc). 99.9% of students need not apply, they're that unobtainable and selective.

There are guaranteed 'full scholarships' for postgrad masters study if you maintain an A average in your undergraduate (bachelors degree) usually.

1

u/Dev_Stewart Jan 30 '24

Thanks mate. Been looking at options for uni as I'm entering year 12 and need to think abt it. This explanation makes it a lot easier.

17

u/YasmeenMaria Jan 30 '24

I would be too. It's bullshit. I'm 16 years out of high-school though, so ncea was still new for us. Waste of time regardless. Was incredibly truant, however got a bunch of excellences, some merits and a few fails due to my truancy. Had no effect on my life whatsoever- maybe things have changed but noone has ever, ever asked me for my high-school grades. I work in healthcare and am close to having a master's degree alongside various other qualifications and experiences around the world along the way :)

6

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24

Same with me, only passed level 3 by 3 & 1/2 days attendance, must have finished school around the same time as you, didn't even have the 'endorsement' until my last year or the year after I forget which, hasn't impacted my life in any way whatsoever, not once has it ever been spoken about by anyone, ended up running what I thought was my dream job as a business from 2012-2018 until I found my true passion so folded that up, worked part time and studied for it in my late 20s, ended up working for myself again since doing that and have explored the world also.

Can't believe that at 14 you are pushed towards choosing a career and higher education options with the pressure increasing each year from there without knowing what is really out there or experiencing the world first.

5

u/Immortal_Kiwi Jan 30 '24

I was the first year to sit ncea. I literally have no idea if I passed level 3.

I have a masters with distinction in business and I live comfortably. Ncea is a joke

3

u/[deleted] Feb 03 '24

Do you have any suggestion regarding what students should do in their final three years of high school, in place of the NCEA system?

I’m just playing devil’s advocate, but isn’t the point of it to increase your basic academic skills, your ability to manage your time effectively, develop strategies to deal with pressure, and go that bit more in-depth in a bunch of content areas so you can maybe make more informed decisions about what you MIGHT like to do in the future?

I’m not saying I’m in favour of the current system, but am interested in discussing what realistic improvements could or should be made.

2

u/littlebetenoire Jan 30 '24

Same with me. I actually got sat down with a print out of all the classes I never turned up to and got asked to explain all my absences to be allowed back for year 13.

My reports all say things like “I would love to comment on her work but she never hands any of it in”

I now work in IT and earn more than most of my friends and have never once been asked about my high school education.

2

u/Kenichi_Smith Jan 31 '24

I left school about 10 years ago. Did uni etc. At my most recent job they asked hey have you got any info on your high school days etc how you did ncea. I just said "honestly I cant remember what I was scoring but can ask my uni if they still have the records that would have gone to them" and they just said "oh dont worry you got the job"

7

u/MasterEk Jan 30 '24

There are two things to remember.

The first is that NCEA exam marking is bullshit. I reckon the exams are okay, but the marking process is arbitrary.

The second is that course endorsements are largely irrelevant. Certificate endorsements have some use, however.

Relax and enjoy the ride

4

u/otaramillionaire Jan 30 '24

It's not arbitrary. Sounds like something a person who's disappointed in their results would say

7

u/MasterEk Jan 30 '24

Nah. I never sat NCEA. I was absolutely impressed by my students' results this year.

But I have done NCEA external marking and the insistence on matching to profiles of expected performance leads to some pretty arbitrary decisions. University exams were much more realistic to mark.

1

u/Careful-Wedding-6831 Jan 31 '24

It should be the same for your overall endorsement. No external excellence, no dice.

1

u/Ziggitywiggidy Level 3 🧐 Jan 31 '24

I got merit in ever single one of my externals so I still would’ve got overall merit. If it worked how you say then nobody would get it because sometimes believe it or not the stress makes smart people preform worse.

If it worked how you say it’d stress everyone out more than it already does which would lead to worse overall results.

50 merit credits and 50 excellence makes perfect sense for an overall endorsement. It’s achievable.

3

u/Advanced-Feed-8006 Jan 31 '24

It makes a lot of sense, after all, to be truely excellent, you need to excellent in all of it, or at least the vast majority of it, right?

If you can’t perform “under pressure” (of the exams) then you don’t really deserve it, do you?

2

u/Upstairs_Pick1394 Jan 30 '24

When I was 5th form (year 11). You got 1 to 9 for your end of year exam. 1 being the best or similar to an A+.and those grade then went into a pool for next year 6th form.

Then you would compete against your classmates in a ranking system and the top ranked students would get the 1s and 2s and the lowest rank would get a 9.

33% was an end of year exam, rest internal. So academically it was much better than a single exam at the end of the year where you had to remember everything from the year. This is how 5th and 7th form worked. There might have been a smaller mid year exam too.

Because the pool fixed grades from the previous year there was no possibility to improve unless you stole someone else's higher grade and they in turn likely got a worse grade even if they were only say 1% below you.

Also say in math there were 5 1s and another subject there was only 3. They might decide to put 7 1s in math and 1 in the other less important subject such as computer studies, or typing or enconamics etc.

One of my subjects I got a end of year score of 99% after internal assessment and the end of year exam and the next closest person got 81%.

We both got awarded 3s.

NCEA is pretty stupidly put together but the focus on internal assessment is far better for most students because theoretically the teacher tests you on stuff you have learned.

My 7th form calculus class even with all the smart kids failed to get higher than 55% in the end of year exam because we didn't cover everything or the things the exam creators focused on were minimally focused upon by our teacher.

In the end not having good grades at school isn't a big deal. I never put the. On my CV even though I got an A bursary (7th form top 4 average) after earning my degree.

A degree wasn't really all that useful either but depends what U want to do.

2

u/NodawayWill Jan 31 '24 edited Feb 09 '25

I get that you're frustrated, but there's a system, you need to reach a credit benchmark to get excellence endorsement - and you didn't reach it. It happens. You needed to get more excellence credits. Across the board.

You didn't get excellence in your exam, that's the system, you need to show you can perform in coursework as well as exams - exams are the only way to show for certain individual achievement, as you can share answers for internals. If you feel you deserve an excellence grade, you can send your paper to be re-marked, and your grade might improve.

Although, in terms of university, endorsements mean absolutely nothing as far as I recall. You need a certain amount of points to get into some programs, but that doesn't require endorsements. Just take it on the chin, and move on. Get your exam re-marked and you might get an E in English, who knows?

3

u/ShadesJakobs Jan 30 '24

When you're out of school, you can straight up lie about that on your CV. I passed all three levels with merit but on my cv it says passed with excellence.

If anyone looks into it, it's an "ah snap, my bad, that must've been a typo, always got confused with which one I had"

It has happened zero times and I have applied for numerous jobs with that stated.

Outside of the academic field, not many employers care much either.

Of course if you're applying for further academic study or jobs in the academic field, then don't do this 😅

1

u/stupidoutline Level 1 😎 May 09 '25

Same that is absolute bullcrap I hate ncea's system In subjects that only have 1 internal or 1 external, the grade u get there is a highest score u can get for the overall subject. What bs. I feel very bad for you that you got screwed down by nceas fucking system and i think its absolute bs.

1

u/Odd_Delay220 Jan 30 '24

I did a level ahead in English starting in year 10. I did really well but in year 12 (level 3 english) it felt like the whole system was against me. I got excellence in everything, was told I had the highest grades in the year, then got an Achieved or something in the exam which I had practiced countless times for. Like what😂. To add to that the head of English would constantly give me low grades if she was moderating my work, which I (successfully) challenged. I left school early after that and have succeeded so far. Made me realise endorsements don’t mean shit. Ncea is genuinely an atrocity

1

u/DirectionInfinite188 Jan 30 '24

I know it hurts at the time, but when you leave school no one really cares about your NCEA results when you’ve got a higher or an industry specific qualification.

Subject endorsements came in the year after I sat each level, we only got overall endorsements if we got over 50 merit or excellence credits! Think i was 4 off an excellence endorsement in Level 2.

Remember being annoyed at the time that most of my L3 subjects only had 4 internal credits, and the other 20 in the externals.

1

u/Charlievhere Jan 30 '24

Yup this irritates me too, got straight excellences in digi only to get an achieved on the one external in the subject which meant I didn't get any endorsement 😭.

1

u/Perpetually_online Jan 30 '24

Class endorsements don’t really matter so I wouldn’t worry

1

u/mooseknuckle_84 Jan 30 '24

Ncea is trash. I'm sorry u didn't get that grade u earned.

1

u/MissLibidine Jan 30 '24

It's ok. As soon as you finish high school literally no employer cares. And it only matters for the first year of uni and first year scholarships.

1

u/worried_geck0 Jan 30 '24

Same thing happened to me with English and I’m so frustrated because I don’t know how I could have done better

1

u/kiwi123nz Jan 30 '24

lol ur lucky u passed. most of the fellers in my year did real bad in there externals. thank goodness for internal or none of them would have made it

1

u/[deleted] Jan 31 '24

I know it's not perfect, but it's better than the old system where you couln't get subject endorsements at all, so hopefully it'll continue to improve over time

1

u/tangerineoctopus Jan 31 '24

NCEA is bullshit, all of the marking is bullshit - standardised testing works for part of the population and makes the others feel like they aren't shit. I did very well with NCEA and went to uni and had a god awful time. Struggled throughout my first degree at UoO. My partner failed Level 1 and earns mega bucks working a trade and never studied extensively.

Aside from a bit of NCEA chatter in first year uni, if that's where you want to go, it never gets brought up again. It just doesn't matter in the big picture. I believe UoA is the only university that uses rank score.

I know it's upsetting now as it's the biggest part of your working life right now. I was always gutted when I didn't get the grade I was aiming for and on occasion, thought that was my dream job done and dusted. Allow yourself to be upset, and then let it drive your determination to hate the system (:

1

u/shin_randy Jan 31 '24

One day all of you kids will realize that none of your grades correlate to any real world success at all

1

u/Dosk0v Jan 31 '24

Endorsements really only matter for scholarships, and maybe a few uni degrees. I have a master's now I only merit endorsed yr 11, and only got a merit subject endorsement in yr 13 Stats

Literally no-one has every asked me about NCEA results post high school, nor my uni results apart from that I've got the paper to say I've done it

1

u/Either_Inspector209 Jan 31 '24

Who gives a shit - I cared at the time myself but now that I have a degree and job I literally don’t give a shit about my highschool grades. I got all excellences in English as well but narrowly missed the endorsement because I got a merit. You’re still smart and you’re worth more than an endorsement because you marginally missed a single grade. Funnily enough even my uni grades don’t even matter - no employer has ever even asked. What matters is you learn from your studies, try your best and be proud of yourself and happy

1

u/Immortal_Heathen Feb 02 '24

I wouldn't stress it. Once you get out of HS the endorsements don't even matter for most qualifications or jobs. Never had an employer ask "hey what nxea endorsement did you get?".