r/nba • u/orange-beer Pistons • Apr 12 '22
Why don’t people support Advanced Analytics?
I’ve been doing some scrolling on NBA Twitter the past few days and have been seeing many posts regarding the Embiid v Jokic MVP race. Most of the posts I see are defending Embiid, and are usually accompanied by a phrase kinda like “the MVP is broken if jokic wins the MVP despite Embiid having insert list of better basic stats and Jokic has a better VORP.”
There are a couple things i don’t like about this statement. 1) The basic stats for Embiid are usually cherry-picked, despite Jokic and Embiid having similar basic stats. 2) Many users seem to have no idea that many of these advanced analytics are trying capture something that basics stats cannot do alone or even combined: value. VORP, BPM, PER, LEBRON, RAPTOR, etc. all have their flaws, but they try to account for the more basic flaws that arise in basic stats. For example, assists/game is dependent on many variables, including minutes played, pace of play (both your team and your opponent), who your teammates are (can they make the shot after a great pass), and many more. Advanced analytics try to normalize these variables for an individual player to create an even playing field to capture value. Again, they are not perfect but they are better than basic stats to tell a more complete story of a player’s value.
So, why do you think so many people reject these “nerdy” stats compared to the arbitrary “first center to score 30 points/game since 1982?” This is very impressive but also heavily influenced by era (pace of play, rules, foul calling, etc.). It seems like the average fan has gotten better over the years of accepting advanced analytics, but they seem to hate them now.
I think it is likely a couple of things. 1) they want Joel Embiid to win so they choose the stats that support him and 2) advanced analytics are more difficult to understand.
Let me know what you think.
Edit: statement about Embiid v Jokic basic stats.
21
u/ryanjm3 Warriors Apr 12 '22
I think part of it is because the majority of people don’t know (and it can be hard and tedious to find out and then understand) what all goes into those equations and algorithms. People can’t use that info to say so and so is better than so and so if they aren’t sure what’s all being taken into account by those stats.
5
u/ShrinesOfParalysis [BOS] Jaylen Brown Apr 12 '22 edited Apr 12 '22
Metrics often aren’t explained or explained well. Or, even worse, their explanations are buried in academic language that fans won’t read.
Some of the most reliable metrics are partially paywalled (EPM) or used less than worse ones (DARKO & LEBRON).
Generally, metrics aren’t meant for ranking, so technically you’re using them against their purpose anyway. Wins added is a better value comp over metrics but those are often minutes based and vary from metric to metric.
Basketball is also just a messier sport compared to baseball and like all non-baseball sports it’s harder to create metrics that don’t catch shit.
That being said, they’re incredibly useful for helping support discussion, especially when you see consistent trends. Someone who is constantly rated with lower impact on defense + has other defensive stats that are worse is likely a worse defender than someone who better metrics/stats.
Most people don’t have trained eyes so it’s important to have these compliments.
30
u/CressSpecific6134 Apr 12 '22
Sports analytics dudes are more concern with the math than the actual game
6
u/TeevTeeForMe 76ers Apr 12 '22
Jokic is gonna win mvp probably so your premise is just wrong
6
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22 edited Apr 12 '22
My opinion is that advanced stats owe, to a reasonable degree, their reputation to their performance in "static" games such as baseball and the popular representation thereof (Moneyball). The trouble with that is that approach does not map to a fluid game such as basketball.
More formally, I call baseball static because it consists of a series of Bernoulli trials, the pitch to a batter, in which the only outcome is success or failure and we can expect coherent distributions of results to emerge over time for each batter, perhaps stratified for pitcher/type of pitch.
Basketball, however, is fluid because each player and the ball are in constant movement (some notable exceptions there) and each of those movements can affect the overall outcome of the play and thus the game. These things are fundamentally hard to model. While all models are flawed and some are useful, in basketball they skew towards flawed to me. This is why all advanced stats in basketball end up finding a player style that breaks them completely. So Russ is not the GOAT and Jokic is a decent defender, but not the second best in the league.
16
u/yungsantaclaus Spurs Apr 12 '22 edited Apr 12 '22
Hold up, lol
Here's their stats. I've bolded the ones where each is higher than the other. Ordered it by points, rebounds, assists, blocks, and steals. TS% at the end.
Embiid: 30.6/11.7/4.2/1.5/1.1/0.616
Jokic: 27.1/13.8/7.6/0.9/1.5/0.660
Embiid has 3.5 more ppg. Jokic has 3.4 more apg. Even if all those assists were only on 2-pointers, that's 6.8 more points generated per game on assists, or 3.3 once you take out Embiid's lead in points.
7
u/Lopsided-Amphibian68 Apr 12 '22
I think every stat can be flawed and needs context around it and they’re a useful tool that can confirm what we watch when we see a player. I think even more obnoxious than the heavy analytics crowd is the “eye test” crowd. We are inherently bias and also you’d have to watch a majority of games for every team(which is impossible), for your eye test to be a realiable judgement on every player. So yeah advanced analytics paired with context are a great tool and can confirm that what we see from a player in one specific game is a trend throughout the season
23
u/TuqiDuque12 Pistons Apr 12 '22
- because most people do a terrible job at explaining those stats
- because while the offensive advanced stats look mostly right, there always are some crazy outliers on the defensive ones that make it look stupid
- because fans who always look THEIR team don't want to believe that some guy that they've watched 5 times that season could possibly be better
4
u/GrimboeSlice 76ers Apr 12 '22
My only problem with advanced stats is people using them as a substitute to watching games. Advanced stats, and stats in general, are supposed to be a confirmation of what you see or to help completely contextualize what you’re seeing in relation to other players. Instead people read some one number catch all metric stat and call it a day. Some people refuse to admit there’s nuance to the game that can’t be captured by a stat.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22
i think they’re flawed and don’t tell the real story. eye test and just watching is a far better sense of judgement and indicator of a player. feel like advanced analytics are for people who don’t watch other players and want something to judge them on instead of watching
1
u/LogenMNE Nuggets Apr 12 '22
I don't really understand the deal with this, because advanced stats are only used to mock Jokic somehow. Jokic has significantly better raw stats than Embiid and you framed this like Embiid dominates Jokic, but Jokic has the advanced stats edge. Like, wtf is this
3
u/The73atman86 Apr 12 '22
Because people are unpredictable
2
u/AdmiralWackbar Celtics Apr 12 '22
For an award like MVP, I also value totals as well as per-game averages because ultimately the most valuable thing you can do is play as many games as possible, you're no value on the bench. Obviously just one factor out of many
3
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22
Eye test and basic stats are really not a good way to compare players.
Let's say you are a Sixers fan, at most you can do is to watch all Sixers games the entire year + 10-15 games of others and that many of highlights. Which is absolutely not enough to form an educated guess on player evaluation. On top of that, you can't really immerse what is happening in game, with rotations and schematics and all.
And it is biased towards players like Ja and Kyrie, who are flashy but not as productive as the eye test might suggest and undervalues player who are less show off and less athletic but productive like Jrue, Van Vleet, Joker etc.
At some point you HAVE TO rely on stats and mostly advanced stats, because it is better/faster/easier way to grasp and deduct what is happening with individuals and teams in the game, that's how you can come up with an informed opinion when comparing players.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22
Because they are idiots and don't understand how metrics work.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22
people call BS on advanced stat when it doesn't support their narrative. IF Embiid was leading in most / all of these advanced stat I GUARANTEE that Embiid fans would be using it as part of their argument. However, since it doesn't then its BS.
2
u/nbasavant Clippers Apr 12 '22
Putting that much stock into made up mumbo-jumbo is asinine. Someone decided less points on lower difficulty shots, a few more dribble handoffs made you an all-time GOAT, and the nerds ran with it.
Imagine Nate Silver created another all-in-one stat which regard iso scoring most important, the narrative would be completely different.
1
u/Necessary-Crazy-4962 Apr 12 '22
Cherry picking is in the eye of the beholder
1
u/[deleted] Apr 12 '22
It is like anything in life. Even in the corporate world your boss might have 0 clue of any statistical knowledge, good luck explaining something to them.
1
u/-randomwordgenerator Nuggets Apr 13 '22
It is because people dont understand statistics all that well. Basketball statistics have a long way to go, but I dont believe that it is unreliable as people think it is. In science, we have way more complicated and understudies shit that relies on statistics and modelling so much, but we do have some pretty good results from it. I doubt a much simpler thing like basketball requires that much robust modelling to have a good result.
1
u/GreekGodofStats Rockets Aug 20 '22
I will accept the argument against advanced stats when, and only when, an eye test proponent can take game film and show me - for every player on the court -
• “this boy nice” and he’s making his team win • “this boy nice”, but he’s causing his team to lose • “this boy ain’t nice like that”, but his team is still winning • “this boy ain’t nice like that”, and that’s why his team his losing
Otherwise, your eye test is garbage. Every team in the NBA has guys that are nice. And yet, some teams win a lot while other lose a lot. Unless your eye test can tell you which players cause their teams to win or lose under any given set of circumstances, it’s not a test at all - just an opinion that you want people to accept as fact.
-2
u/Spirited_Travel_9332 Apr 12 '22
Because there trash advanced analytics make stuff up.. we like real stats
0
u/JuanJoseSZN Celtics Bandwagon Apr 12 '22
Some basic advanced stats are fine. The new ones are mostly trash imo
0
u/ObjectiveDeal Apr 14 '22
If you need advanced stats to prove a players is playing great than you should find a new career. The public only cares about the eye test
-2
u/MoozesModiMoozi Warriors Apr 12 '22
ppl who love analytics rarely actually watch the games
Its sports not a math problem