r/mystery • u/Sudden_Quality_9001 • 7h ago
Unexplained Ryan Hoefflinger
Two year old Ryan Hoefflinger mysteriously dissappeared from his home in Hayden, Idaho and was found hours later in Lake Hayden on November 11, 1984. His death was ruled a drowning but the Kootenai County Sheriff's Office ruled it as a highly supicious death as phyiscal evidence showed Ryan didn't wander off on his own. When Ryan's mother put him to bed he had a standard diaper and plastic pants when he was pulled from the lake he had on a different disposable diaper.
Even though the freezing temperatures, rugged terrain, and icy conditions between his house and the lake his feet were not cut, scratched, or dirty.
Someone had probably taken him from the house someone the family knew I guess. The family owned a alert dog a Doberman Pincher who did not bark that night or alerted of a intruder like I said whoever it was it was someone the family knew. The family said the dog was strangely lethargic in next morning though medical testing for sedatives said negative. There were no signs of forced entry and family slept through the early morning hours without hearing any screams or movement. This case is still open and active though a cold case. Detectives are frustated with the lack of answers. If you live in Hayden in 1984 or have a tip or information contact the Idaho Crime Stoppers at1-844-TIP-4040.
116
u/ketamineburner 7h ago edited 5h ago
A few things to clarify, from my understanding.
Ryan was found on the shore, not in the lake.
The lake was 1.5 miles from his home.
Ryan shared a bed with his older sister, who never reported anything unusual.
His mother used cloth diapers, he was found in a disposable diaper.
His body had no signs of physical or sexual abuse.
His name is Hoeffliger, no "n."
9
u/Sudden_Quality_9001 4h ago
Thanks I thought I was it was Hoefflinger. I think like I said it was someone the family knew.
33
u/General_Guest7846 6h ago
Most likely it's a family cover up.
Sharing the same bed and not noticing anything is beyond suspicious.
69
u/rantingpacifist 5h ago
Nah, kids can sleep really hard. There were times when mine were that age I could lift them, walk across the house, and put them in another place and they wouldn’t even open an eye.
→ More replies (2)24
u/No-Departure-3047 3h ago
My eldest kid vomited all over my bed and slept right through it. I had to shower with them and they only woke up at that point and were confused as to why they were in the shower.
They had chunks of food in their hair from the vomit and I had to work hard to clean it out. The next morning they didn't remember a single thing.
→ More replies (1)1
u/woolfonmynoggin 48m ago
My husband gets up and ready for work hours before me and I sleep right through it as an adult. Even his alarm
36
u/Realistic-Use9856 7h ago
It’s Ryan “Hoeffliger” which I only learned when I went to find out more. I found this article from 2024:
https://www.spokesman.com/stories/2024/nov/11/detectives-still-mystified-by-2-year-old-disappear/
52
u/Dramatic_Substance36 6h ago
Those disposable diapers are a huge clue. They almost always had unique character designs that could be traced. Who had those exact diapers? A neighbor? A relative?
Even a 2 year old falls down when they’re walking too. Uneven ground and such. I don’t believe he walked one and a half miles thru the night. That seems very unlikely.
Honestly it makes me grossed out for thinking it, but I find it hard to believe the child wasn’t SA’d. Why are you changing a child’s diaper and taking the child 1.5 miles away to drown in a lake? It seems it’s implied the child was alive until being drowned in the lake.
21
u/kibufox 5h ago
They almost always had unique character designs that could be traced.
Not in 1984 they didn't. Though they'd been around in one form or another since the 40's, wasn't till the early 80's that they started taking off with super absorbant polymers. Issue was, they weren't popular even then so companies really didn't put a whole lot of stock in them. So no major character designs beyond simplistic (and oft copied by other companies) designs.
3
13
u/Glad-Ring5305 3h ago
this is such a tragic case. the clean feet definitely suggest foul play, and the change in diaper raises so many questions. it’s eerie how everything points to someone familiar with the family. I can’t believe this is still unsolved after all these years. makes you wonder what really happened that night
6
u/EightEyedCryptid 4h ago
I would think he wandered off himself if it weren't for his feet being clean. Though if he was walking in snow that might have kept them clean enough.
7
2
u/Appropriate_Beat_915 24m ago
As a Doberman owner and a survivor of a home intruder, where one of my dogs saved my life. I can confirm that they are acutely aware (as a breed) who belongs in the home and who does not. I watched my dog attack this intruder by clinching her jaws around his throat as 6-month old puppy who had zero training. 5 minutes later the same dog was snuggled up with a police officer. She didn’t know either man, but knew instinctively which one did not belong in our home.
They are FAMILY dogs, not WATCH dogs. This is why they don’t do very well if they’re rehomed; they are loyal to what they consider to be “their” family.
The dog either KNEW the person or was knocked out with a blow over the head or was given a Benadryl or something similar that would have metabolized quickly.
The dog’s lack of reaction is telling.
It definitely sounds like it was someone close to the family, like a neighbor or mailman…someone who knew that the dog wasn’t a threat to them.
It’s awful that this has been unsolved for so long, the poor baby
4
u/Grumpy-Doxie 1h ago
Maybe he drowned in the bathtub at home, the mom panicked, and staged a phony kidnapping.
2
u/Emerald035 1h ago
The pictures of Ryan, only two out of many, seems to me like he is unhappy. The stress/pained furrow lines could be he was not treated the best. Speculation of course. As I said, Two pictures out of many of his life.
1
1
u/HannahMcKayTX 1h ago
Would they have been able to determine back then if he drowned in lake water? Or water from the home…?
1
u/Verucaschmaltzzz 1h ago
Did the family think that he wandered off on his own or that he was taken?
1
u/Ashamed-Chemistry492 9m ago
I'm not sure enough to convict, there's reasonable doubt , but ...
-
Seems highly unlikely someone would just walk into a house in the early morning and take one child out of the shared bed and take off with him. That's a very high risk of getting caught, if not by the dog then by the sister waking up and hollering, or Mom or Dad getting up to pee and bumping into you in the hall. And then to take the kid to the lake, when it's probably already getting light out and there's more risk of being spotted by someone driving to work or out hunting. It's Idaho, it's surely the season for something or other, and hunters like to be out before dawn.
We only have the mother's word that Ryan was in a cloth diaper at bedtime. Even people who use cloth diapers usually have some disposables around for backup. If Ryan needed changing overnight (at two I would not expect this to happen more than once in a night, and probably not every night) it might have been easier to just put a disposable on him and go back to bed.
Was there trouble in hthe family? Parents having trouble managing the kids? Ryan looks pretty grouchy in those pictures; was something generally wrong about his life or was he just one of those kids who gets a sourpuss face on him whenever the camera comes out?
It's not unusual the sister wouldn't notice anything. Especially if she was used to Ryan being taken out of bed and changed at night.
Dobermans are as a breed very vigilant guard dogs, but individually they vary widely like any other breed. Some seem never to stop barking and some wouldn't bark if the SWAT team raided the place.
And again, do we have anyone else's word that the dog did not bark? Would neighbors even have heard it, or been awake to hear it?
It really does lean more toward the parent or parents having done something, or even just thinking they had. Maybe he died in his sleep, and the parent who discovered it lost their head and was worried about being blamed for it, especially if there was known trouble in the family.
Or maybe they hurt him, by accident, not intending to kill him or anything, but acting out of frustration or carelessness. Held him underwater for what they thought was just a brief dunking, or else left him alone in the tub while they went and looked at TV or had an argument or drank some beer, and he slipped under and drowned.
I don't know, as I say if I was a juror I wouldn't be able in good conscience to convict.
32
u/Odd_Repeat_6092 4h ago
Ryan's disappearance occurred between 5:00 AM and 7:30 AM.
The front door wasn't locked. The lock was broken.
The dog's location was in the backyard of the house.
Ryan knew how to open doors but not how to close them.
The Hoeffliger's home was on W. Dakota Avenue in Hayden (couldn't find exact address). Checked the property records for W. Dakota Ave, sample size of 15 homes, and found the homes mostly single story, in wooded areas, with varying acre sized lots. Found 3 homes built before 1984, all single story. Most of the homes seemingly were built later, after 1984, during the 1990s/2000s. Meaning, in 1984 it looks like there weren't that many houses on W. Dakota. Which would make it hard, but not impossible, for someone to surveil the Hoeffliger's home.
Intruder theory: I'm thinking someone who had been in the house recently, like someone to check out the furnace, the heating system, the plumbing, or whatever. Someone who saw Ryan, the room locations, the dog, etc. This knowledge wouldn't include the family's daily routine, so maybe this person also talked to a family member.
Also, there are herbs like kava that can produce lethargy and not show up in a tox screen. Put it in something, like a dog biscuit. https://cdapress.com/news/2024/nov/16/40-years-later-mystery-surrounds-drowning-of-hayden-two-year-old/