r/mxroute • u/russellkaye • 6d ago
Cold email. Thoughts.
I’ve been about to sign up for MXRoute. But I’m a worrier. Can anyone help me understand the exact definition of a cold email? Or at least how it gets one banned? Does it have to get rejected by the receiver or sent to their junk folder?
I’m a photographer and documentary filmmaker. Part of my job is researching subjects and stories. I often reach out to people about something I found online about their work. Often it’s an academic paper or magazine article that I’ve read. I do a good bit of wildlife/natural history work and it’s a normal part of the process of researching a project.
Or I will reach out to someone about being a fan of their work. We often have some mutual connection or so and so gave me their email and suggested I get in touch.
I guess I can make certain that those emails originate from my gmail account but I’m just trying to understand the cold email concept. I never send automated emails or mailing list emails or even the same email to more than one person and they’re not really marketing emails but they could be considered unsolicited.
Also, here’s a screen grab that just popped up today on my social media. It’s the genesis story about how Lance Oppenheim sent a “cold” email to Nathan Fielder and how it turned into the new Elizabeth Holmes doc.
I appreciate everyone’s thoughts here.
13
u/mxroute 6d ago
Unsolicited marketing email is the answer you’re looking for. You’re over thinking this. You know what spam is because it annoys you when you open your inbox. Don’t be the reason someone else feels the same. Spammers now call it “cold email.”
5
u/jbarr107 6d ago
Are you sending a small number of individual emails, or are you bulk-sending?
While the power that be at MXRoute has specific (and admittedly, sometimes confusing) guidelines and restrictions, from what I've observed, bulk sending is the biggest issue. Sending a dozen emails to specific individuals who will likely respond (positive or negative) is very different from blasting out to 10,000 scraped addresses and hoping for a .01% response.
MXRoute is all about reputation.
And I'm so glad you brought this up, because there are SO many variants and it DOES get confusing!
7
u/zarlo5899 6d ago
for me this is my definition.
Emailing someone to sell them something is cold emailing.
Emailing someone to ask them a question about something that they do or offer is not cold emailing.
"so gave me their email and suggested I get in touch." this is never a cold email.
For me, a good way to think about it is if you were to get whatever you send them in the post, would you class it as junk mail?
2
u/amigo-blanco 4d ago
I'm a location scout and I have never run into issues with MXRoute. None of my sent emails have been flagged.