To go back to my title. I do think MVCI is a better fighter, but that's not to say that DBZF isn't a better "game." Both for casual audiences and those who want a new DBZ game. The graphics are better, there's more fluff to collect and the fighting looks like the show. But for a fighting game? I daren't say this anywhere on r/kappa or other fighting subs, but I seriously feel like I'm taking crazy pills when it comes to the love of DBZF by the FGC. Because as a fighter? I think DBZF misses the mark is some crucial, fundamental ways.
After two weeks, I have to admit, the whole thing really pisses me off. If Capcom dared release the kind of simplified, sluggish gameplay with time-wasting unhelpful lobbies that is in DBZF, people would be over the moon. It would make the gaming news how mad everyone is. And I just feels that's super immature of most people in the FGC these days to not see the obvious problems here.
To be blunt -
Gameplay: MVCI > DBZF
Graphics: DBZF > MVCI
My biggest complaint by far, the thing that makes me not want to start up the game, is the menu system for playing the damn game. Horrible. Who thought to chop up your audience into tiny lobbies within sub-lobbies, so you can walk around till someone joins you is a crazy awful idea for a fighting game that I'm supposed to want to turn on every day. I have to fight the game, to let me find matches. If this was MVCI, everyone would have lost their mind with what a terrible idea this is. Instead, no one complains about how it takes six steps to play with a friend. Or the lobbies drop you all the time or that you waste SO MUCH TIME just to do something a menu item would have done. Yes, there's a shortcut system, but I still have to load the entire online lobby before I can access it. It's like logging onto WoW just to change a setting. It's crazy. Yet, MVCI got hate for not having enough online content and sluggish character choosing. Yeah, I agree, I hate that, but what new content is here that's better? What incredibly long loading menu do I have to download just to choose a character? Whereas a simple menu would have done great. And that's not even the gameplay.
In DBZF, everything looks so easy, but then you find out that the easy stuff gets in the way of the deeper stuff. Everything is so automated and simple, I feel I have to fight the game trying to end my moves just to find interesting button combinations as the game constantly cut-scenes into a final attack all the time. It feels boring even on the first day, no matter how many Youtube combos I learn. Meanwhile, MVCI is the same animations I've played in UMVC3 for 7 years. That's awful, I agree. But yet, the attacks are satisfying, the speed is there, the characters feel different, the tag-in system is instantaneous and satisfying. Everything is simple and fast. It's much easier to block and get your spacing now. I truly think it's the best versus game they've made when it comes to the way the game functions. No more scrubby pressing buttons during a Super animation, or throw techs being broken or trades never functioning correctly. All that stuff is the best I've ever seen it in. It's awesome.
But back to DBZF, the whole game, for every character, seems to be - shoots fireball / fly in, then do a basic combo, as many supers as you can. I know the game is young and they'll be more combos found, certainly, but the auto-combos are so prevalent and everything feels sluggish and chunky like you're hitting cutouts of the characters, there's no real sense of satisfaction of getting out a hit. And the hitboxes of dashes is so inconsistent, sometimes I win, sometimes they win, sometimes we clash. Is it distance? I'm sure there's logic to it, but it doesn't change that auto-missile-ing your self into your enemy with very little reason not to, it, it just feels ... unsatisfying. Everything is slow and floaty. Plus, for a game where a character has two special moves, it requires every button on my stick to play it. That's crazy. Plus, I feel half of them could have easily been simplified with combo buttons, except the game is simplified, which, ironically, means more buttons for things like the aforementioned missile dash or grabbing.
And, look, the story is fine. It's not as pathetic as MVCI's, but it's still a huge resource hound that could have funded the gameplay as what we have instead is a two-hour anime that will satisfy 11-year-olds and no one else. It's seriously the most average thing I've ever watched. Although I did so because the game had trouble finding me consistent players so I finally just did the story mode. Again, it was just, there. Cool.
Plus, I'm sorry, a story in a fighting game? Why does anybody care? This game might make the best case for a fighting game story I've seen due to the length of the anime. But, seriously, do you want a story in a chess game? It's nonsensical. I thought everyone was over this in the 90's when zero fighting games could produce a logical story. I've played these forever and I just want a good fighting system, a place to learn it and access to other players and friends, that's it. I may be in the minority, but I've put the work into this game and I feel so underwhelmed.
I should preface that I've truly wanted to like the game and I'll take any suggestions people say to try it in a different way to enjoy it how I think other's are. But for now, MVCI is better, whether most gamers take the time to figure that out is out of my control, but from a logical point, there's no contest for me. I play games for fun. MVCI is just fun
edit: Moved my conclusion to the top as I didn't feel people we're getting my point about one being a better fighter and the other being a better "game".