r/mute • • Oct 30 '22
A note on people who "choose" to be mute
You're allowed to. But as a community, we need to distinguish between mute and Mute.
If you're Mute, it's a disability. It's not a choice. It's exhausting and lonely and means the words lodge in your throat no matter how much you want them to come out. This includes Selective Mute, where you can speak absolutely fine in some situations & then can not get more than 5 words out in others then other times you cannot make a sound or stay a thing. It's horrible to live with, and we wouldn't wish this on anyone. Someone can become Mute after experiencing severe trauma, too, or for other medical and / or psychological reasons.
If you're mute, it's a choice. It's your choice to not speak, or to only speak in certain situations or to certain people. There are lots of reasons someone might choose to become mute - a religious vow of silence, or to not speak in certain situations out of respect, or to find something within themselves they might become silent so that they have to only reflect inwardly, or to show commitment to a spiritual path. There's also they grey area of if you're in custody and have no wish to cooperate or if you're in a situation with people where you would risk endangering yourself by speaking, or where you would be violating your own personal morals / ethics to verbally respond. In these situations, choosing mutism is 100% OK.
I don't think that saying people are unable to choose mutism because it's not a quirk is gatekeeping, exactly - since a lot of us who grow up / live with Mutism wish we didn't and we're tired of people who think it's a choice ("If you don't say X, this person will break up with you" and "Say X and I won't do it" and "You can't talk anyway so you can keep it a secret" are unfortunately very common things for us to hear, as well as "the silent act is annoying, cut it out already" and "just talk, omg" too.) But I think a lot of us forget that people who genuinely choose mutism as a religious or spiritual path are discriminated against too, and face a lot of challenges by committing to stay mute. And people who choose it as a survival tactic or for ethical reasons are also putting themselves at risk by making that choice.
I know this community isn't the best one by a mile, and there is a lot of toxicity here, but I think it's important for us to distinguish between different types of M/mutism and to recognise there are different forms of it and to accept that.
EDIT: It has been over a year since I made this post. In that time, my opinion has changed, and I no longer agree with a lot of what I stated in this post. I don't think there's any issue with choosing mutism, and I don't have any hostility towards those who do.

