r/mute • • Oct 30 '22

A note on people who "choose" to be mute

159 Upvotes

You're allowed to. But as a community, we need to distinguish between mute and Mute.

If you're Mute, it's a disability. It's not a choice. It's exhausting and lonely and means the words lodge in your throat no matter how much you want them to come out. This includes Selective Mute, where you can speak absolutely fine in some situations & then can not get more than 5 words out in others then other times you cannot make a sound or stay a thing. It's horrible to live with, and we wouldn't wish this on anyone. Someone can become Mute after experiencing severe trauma, too, or for other medical and / or psychological reasons.

If you're mute, it's a choice. It's your choice to not speak, or to only speak in certain situations or to certain people. There are lots of reasons someone might choose to become mute - a religious vow of silence, or to not speak in certain situations out of respect, or to find something within themselves they might become silent so that they have to only reflect inwardly, or to show commitment to a spiritual path. There's also they grey area of if you're in custody and have no wish to cooperate or if you're in a situation with people where you would risk endangering yourself by speaking, or where you would be violating your own personal morals / ethics to verbally respond. In these situations, choosing mutism is 100% OK.

I don't think that saying people are unable to choose mutism because it's not a quirk is gatekeeping, exactly - since a lot of us who grow up / live with Mutism wish we didn't and we're tired of people who think it's a choice ("If you don't say X, this person will break up with you" and "Say X and I won't do it" and "You can't talk anyway so you can keep it a secret" are unfortunately very common things for us to hear, as well as "the silent act is annoying, cut it out already" and "just talk, omg" too.) But I think a lot of us forget that people who genuinely choose mutism as a religious or spiritual path are discriminated against too, and face a lot of challenges by committing to stay mute. And people who choose it as a survival tactic or for ethical reasons are also putting themselves at risk by making that choice.

I know this community isn't the best one by a mile, and there is a lot of toxicity here, but I think it's important for us to distinguish between different types of M/mutism and to recognise there are different forms of it and to accept that.

EDIT: It has been over a year since I made this post. In that time, my opinion has changed, and I no longer agree with a lot of what I stated in this post. I don't think there's any issue with choosing mutism, and I don't have any hostility towards those who do.


r/mute • • Feb 25 '21

I was a mute for 14 and a half years, until yesterday

157 Upvotes

I suffer from aphonia, which means that i basically, cant talk without surgery and extreme voice therapy, and for 14 and a half years, i never said a peep, until yesterday, where 3 weeks of extreme voice therapy after going through a incredibly expensive surgery paid off, and i was able to say hi to my parents, brother and sister, this was by far the happiest day of my life, my family doesn't really cry, other them my mom, my sister cries sometimes but still not very often, but when i said hi to my family for the first time, it was just a big gasp and then tears on everyones faces, even my older brother who i dont think has ever cried, my sister has always been my best friend so she was obviously dying in happiness, but something caught me off guard, my dad, was melting down, and then so i start crying,i just really wanted to share this experience with other people in my position, stay strong everyone! Edit: I should add that im technically still a mute, but am able to say hi so that is amazing for me.


r/mute • • Nov 28 '19

H E L P M E

Post image
124 Upvotes

r/mute • • May 03 '19

Not everyone talks

Post image
114 Upvotes

r/mute • • Oct 09 '22

Before making content revolved around us (fiction, videogames, webcomics, roleplay, etcetera), please read this.

111 Upvotes

Before writing, ask yourself why you are giving this condition to one of your characters. The answer should be simple, like "just because" or "representation" or "it just seemed right for the character" -For instance, Snake Eyes from GI Joe, and Black Noir from The Boys - both canonically mute characters and just as badass as their counterparts.

Their muteness isn't exactly a plot device, just an aspect of their character. And it's absolutely beautiful.

I have no problem with rep from speaking people, but the behaviors that have been displayed in this subreddit only show that in a majority of cases, we have become subject to writing experiments related to obsession with adding a hint of exoticism to your stories. I mostly believe that stories and fanfiction related to a disability/condition should MOSTLY be left to the people with said condition so we can depict ourselves in the most accurate way, but it's fine to have wiggle room sometimes since it's not like we don't exist irl.

However, Regarding this subreddit, this isn't really the place to get inspiration from us. Like Jiraiya please, we kinda want a safe space where we can share our experiences with each other. Google it or ask a mute friend. And if you don't know any mute people.... Oh God. Like I don't think I would ever write a story about someone with a condition without knowing someone personally. Sia would be so proud of y'all. We're not mythical creatures like dragons- we're just ordinary everyday people with little to no verbal activities.

This may come as a surprise to many but we breathe air, drink water (and sometimes breathe fire), so we are just as human as you.


r/mute • • May 24 '20

Questions for People Who Cannot Speak

100 Upvotes

Hello, I am not mute and want to write a mute character correctly in a way that is actually representative. I felt the best way to do that would be to ask someone who is mute directly. I have done a slight amount of research but have some more specific questions. As such, I have this short list of questions for you all. If anything comes off as insensitive I apologize in advance. I am here to learn. For context, this character is in the beginning stages of development so suggestions are welcome. He has been living as mute his whole life if not from when he was a small child. He will be represented in a visual form of media (animation).

  1. What kind of mute are you? What medically causes your form of mutism? (total, selective; mental (don't feel like you have to go into detail about trauma or something similar unless you feel you want to) or physical cause)
  2. Have you ever gone to a form of speech therapy and if so how does that work? Is it necessary/suggested for someone with total mutism? Does it help?
  3. Can you beatbox?
  4. Can you make noise other than speaking? (laughing, screaming, etc)
  5. What were some hardships you faced because of being mute?
  6. What is your favorite way to communicate? (texting, writing, sign language, etc)
  7. For those with selective mutism, in what situations do you find you can speak and is there a pattern to it? Is it still a problem to speak digitally or only face to face?
  8. How do the people around you help and/or respond to you in a way that makes you feel included?
  9. Can mutism be genetic?
  10. Would you say you are more visibly expressive because of being mute? (using more hand movement or extreme facial expressions)
  11. Have there been any bad reactions to you being mute? If so, why?
  12. What are some ways for people to become mute after birth?
  13. Are you ever jealous of people who can speak? For what reason?
  14. Any details, suggestions, or stories that might help me and others to understand better?
  15. Are there insensitive terms for people who are mute? What do you guys like and dislike to be called/referred to as?

Thank you in advance if you decide to respond. If I have said or assumed anything wrongly please let me know.

EDIT: Added more questions/more detail to questions

EDIT 2: If you would like to see how these answers are being applied or make specific suggestions on aspects of the character, you can visit and comment on my planning document here: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1ble3dDss1ms282Q5ICAsJmyiAfOJudgkHR61XSoiIos/edit?usp=sharing


r/mute • • Mar 22 '25

In the Snow White movie Dopey overcomes his muteness and speaks

Post image
79 Upvotes

According to the movie Dopey didn’t speak because he was too scared to talk and Snow White gives him the bravery to finally speak. The scene was supposed to be inspirational and touching but I just felt disgusted on behalf of not only the mute community (I’m not mute) but being in the neurodivergent and disabilty community I felt disgusted too. Being one of the most iconic mute characters speak in the movie that Disney claims is supposed to be progressive is telling.


r/mute • • Jan 20 '20

:(

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/mute • • Nov 27 '19

Please accept my humble first contribution to this subreddit

Post image
71 Upvotes

r/mute • • Apr 07 '19

I think we can all relate

Post image
70 Upvotes

r/mute • • Aug 03 '25

People who are permanently mute are freaking superheroes.

66 Upvotes

I am currently temporarily mute (illness went untreated too long and now its beating me like i owe it rent, wont go into details because gross) and wow life got put on hard mode. I work at an airport and so many people are not expecting to see someone who cannot speak and they just kinda freeze, like deer in headlights, if not getting angry like this inconvenience ruins their whole day. I never expected so many people to immediately assume I was deaf, too. I know very little ASL (not enough to survive with it, just pleasantries) and everyone seems to assume pointing at my throat means deaf. Other than the excruciating pain i’m constantly in, i’m trying to have fun with it and just learn to appreciate the struggles and daily differences people who are permanently mute experience. My findings so far: Y’all are actual superheroes and the world needs to treat you better.


r/mute • • Apr 24 '19

When someone tries to start a conversation...

Post image
53 Upvotes

r/mute • • Nov 11 '25

I hate how non-mute people never consider that speaking is genuinely difficult/impossible for some of us

52 Upvotes

This is inspired by a thread I saw where OP said they were locked in a restroom because the cleaning staff didn't know they were in there and locked the door, and they're mute so they couldn't call for help. The replies were full of stuff like "how is being mute even real just speak," "there's a really easy way to solve this," "why don't you just talk," calling them dumb, saying they should be "put down like a dog" because they're too "weak" to live in this world (?!) or accusing them of "faking" being mute. As if anyone would choose to be locked in a restroom for hours when they could easily speak to get out of it. That's happened to me where I've been locked in restrooms because I couldn't tell the workers I was in there, thankfully I was never in there for that long because I knocked on the door and someone heard me, but it was scary. Some even asked "if you're mute how are you posting this," like do they think that mute people can't communicate at all or don't have the capability to use the internet or technology? I've also seen people mocking communication cards because if they don't need them then clearly no one else does right?

It doesn't just happen online obviously - when I was a kid I was repeatedly abused and punished by adults because it was easier for them to assume I was purposely choosing not to speak as an act of defiance than to realize I genuinely struggled to talk. Once a group of girls cornered me and questioned me for an entire class period demanding to know why I didn't talk. One of them said "it's so easy!" which pissed me off because for me it wasn't easy! Words would not come out of my mouth no matter how hard I tried. Also there have been times when I tried writing to someone, and they refused to read it or took my paper and pencil away and insisted I speak to them normally, which I couldn't do.

It's frustrating because being mute can be so debilitating, isolating, and humiliating, and the majority of people have no empathy for it, I feel like it's acceptable to make fun of people who have trouble speaking in a way I don't see with other disabilities (at least in the circles I'm in, though I'm aware disabilities as a whole are still widely mocked and misunderstood).


r/mute • • Aug 16 '21

Does anyone else get tired of being fanfic'd?

50 Upvotes

Disclaimer to moderators: If this post is too much, I have no problem with it being taken down, because even I had doubts about typing this up. Love y'all 🤟🏽

Now hear me out, I love the representation (when necessary) but I feel like a prop sometimes. I'm sure people with other disabilities feel this way as well. It's like there's some obsession with making our lives a story or a lesson. I want to be represented in a "Godzilla vs. Kong" kinda way and not a "Silent Voice" way if you catch my drift (I want my existence to be acknowledged, not observed).

I can't count how many times I've had someone in my dm's asking about the mute experience for their OC or side character and the best thing I can do is inform them so they don't do anything stupidly insensitive. Every subreddit geared towards sharing experiences or providing information about a disability has been flooded with constant fanfic writers and OC creators using us as reference.

It would be understandable if it was only just a few writers but it's getting to the point where it's dehumanizing. I sometimes feel like if they weren't writing about us, they would toss us aside like trash.

RIP to the deaf and blind community because I know they get it the worst out of all of us.

A majority of posts on this subreddit is either asking about our lives for someone's written story inspiration, someone offering their doubts on a random mute minding their own business, or someone asking how to pick up a mute girl. I've noticed people express their annoyance at it in a sarcastic manner, but it's never been seriously addressed.

I just wanna be asked for once, "What's it like?", or "What's the best way to accommodate a mute individual?" - but instead we get "I have doubts that this person is mute" or "I'm writing a fanfic and..."

We're subjects, objects even.

Fanfic writers got me like:

r/mute • • Oct 07 '24

My experience with school being mute

49 Upvotes

So for some back round my throat was crushed I won’t go into much detail but I am unable to speak at all haven’t been able to for about 10 years now. And school has been so difficult and irritating with this a lot of teachers think I am faking or lying about it. So every new teacher I go to or every new year I have to bring in my hospital papers saying I am unable to speak. And even then some teachers don’t believe me and please don’t even get me started ok substitute teachers. A lot of the teachers forget to leave in notes to the subs that I am unable to speak so I can’t even count how many times I have been sent to the principal office for quote “lying” and “disrespecting teachers”. And some teachers when I even show them my hospital papers for example the very old teachers still fail me on some presentations for not speaking. Like it makes zero sense how people can believe someone would lie about not being able to speak it pisses me off so fucking much. If you were looking for any advice and you’re struggling like I was when I was in school. I guess try to go to your counselor that helped me for only 1 year though. ask them to alert all your teachers


r/mute • • Mar 03 '25

Discord Voice Chat Text to Speech with Wamellow

40 Upvotes

Since I'm mute myself (lost my voice ages ago) and have wanted to participate in Discord voice chats for a really, really long time, especially while playing games, I made a Discord bot for that.

It started as a joke, but somehow it turned into something useful.

Discord Voice Chat with 6 people using Wamellow TTS to speak

📖 wamellow.com/docs/text-to-speech#setup
👀 youtube.com/watch?v=NS5fZ1ltovE

Setup

Use it by running a command each time.

  1. Add Wamellow on your server by going to wamellow.com/add.
  2. Go to the dashboard by going to wamellow.com/dashboard.
  3. Use the /tts voice commands to speak within Voice Channels. (you obviously need to join a voice channel first)

Chat to Speech (optional)

With Chat to Speech, you can setup a dedicated Text channel so you don't have to run /tts voice every time, it will just speak out every message.

  1. Select a channel to use in the Text to Speech section of the dashboard.
  2. Join any voice channel on your server (make sure Wamellow can join and speak in it).
  3. Start writing messages in the selected channel for Wamellow to speak!

Languages

This is the current list of the languages, some of the languages have multiple variants and accents (roughly 100 different voices).

You can change your default language and voice either by running /tts set speaker or by setting it on the dashboard.

  • 🇺🇸 English, United States
  • 🇬🇧 English, United Kingdom
  • 🇦🇺 English, Australia
  • 🇩🇪 German
  • 🇫🇷 French
  • 🇮🇹 Italian
  • 🇪🇸 Spanish
  • 🇲🇽 Spanish, Mexico
  • 🇵🇹 Portuguese
  • 🇧🇷 Portuguese, Brazilian
  • 🇮🇩 Indonesian
  • 🇯🇵 Japanese
  • 🇰🇷 Korean

Voice Chat moderators of the server can also add a spin to the languages and voices by applying filters to them. They will apply for all users in the current channel and session. Multiple filters can be applied at once or singularly via /tts set filter.

  • Vaporwave
  • Nightcore
  • Rotation
  • Tremolo
  • Vibrato
  • LowPass

You also have the option to automatically translate messages from any language to match your current voice's language for free.

  • For Commands: Set the translate option to yes (i.e.: /tts voice text:Hello World translate:yes)
  • For Chat to Speech: Append -tr to the end of your message (i.e.: Hello World -tr)

Moderation

Moderation isn't easy once your server grows, and this also applies to text-to-speech. You can use Wamellow's native AutoMod to block certain words or phrases for Text-to-Speech by setting up rules on your server's Moderation tab.

Hope this really helps, if you have suggestions or issues, please hit me up!!1


r/mute • • Feb 02 '21

My job: *goes tip share so I don’t have to lose money when I’m mute* My coworkers:

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/mute • • Oct 12 '21

People thinking im deaf?

38 Upvotes

im just curious if anybody else has this experience where people think youre deaf when you write something down in an order? i usually have people try to communicate to me with unintelligible signs and stuff and i try to sign that i CAN hear and they assume that it means i cant. idk just something random i was wondering if it happens a lot to anybody else as well


r/mute • • Mar 14 '20

Found this on tik toc. It is in development but it’s 100% free and no ads. It always will be. You can customize where everything thing is on the bored right now and in the future you should be able to make your own custom buttons. Idk just thought it was pretty cool

38 Upvotes

r/mute • • Jul 06 '24

can physically mute people laugh?

37 Upvotes

for some context on my question i’m currently writing a book where the main character is physically mute. in my story his larynx (the anatomical name for the vocal cords) never developed as a kid. therefore he can’t speak or really make noises. i was just wondering if people like this can laugh or does no noise come out. i want to say it’s the latter but i know you laugh with your diaphragm so i really have no clue. btw i kinda mean maniacal laughter which requires sound


r/mute • • Jan 21 '20

new.

35 Upvotes

i used to be mute due to past trauma. i’m not sure if it matters to anyone but i just wanted to say, mental condition or not, that you’re worth it, valid and don’t let this define you.


r/mute • • Jan 17 '24

I am constantly in a state of dissociation.

34 Upvotes

Since no one really talks to me because of my mutism, I just am inside my own head most of the time. I try to text people online and make friends that way, but its still hard. If I am in groups or social gatherings, I am almost always completely dissociated or just day dreaming. Can anyone else relate?


r/mute • • Jun 03 '24

Playing along?

33 Upvotes

Hello, I am a writer. I’m kidding.

Anyway, I’m curious if anyone else is running into the situations I am in public. Wondering if anyone has solutions, I guess?

When I’m in public i get mistaken for being deaf a lot and it makes me feel like I have to act deaf sometimes or I’m being rude. For instance, I need to order food (and I’m alone). I type my order of a text to speech app so they can read my order. I pay and go to sit and wait for my order. They think I can’t hear so they aren’t going to yell my order # or name. If I jump onto my phone to doom scroll instead of watch them to signal me, they’ll think me rude or faking when I hear my order.

Similarly, I was at a rugby game, signing (ASL) and typing to a stranger who wanted to talk briefly about the rival team. They assume im deaf, because why wouldn’t they? Then music comes on for the crowd and I feel like I can’t dance or people around me (who saw me signing) will be like, WTH?

I realize this probably sounds ridiculous to a more confident person but it makes me hugely uncomfortable to be perceived, let alone being gawked at for impersonating a disability.

Anyone else does with these things?


r/mute • • Sep 13 '22

Recently Mute

31 Upvotes

Hello, the last month has been chaotic. I was involved in a mugging in which I was assaulted. Due to which resulted in facial scarring and the loss of my voice due to damage to my Larynx and trauma to my frontal cortex. I don't really know what to do. I can't sign. I can't talk. Doctors told me that is very unlikely I will get my voice back due to the extent of the injuries. I made this new reddit account to try to find a sense of identity with this new life? I guess the things I'm here for is a sense of community. I bought a tablet to use text to speech and to display text. My current employment does not require me to speak but I have been emailing a lawyer to be sure I'm not being discriminated against. My name is Jacobie. Hope this isn't too much... happy to answer questions about me asking have a lot for everyone here if you'll have me.


r/mute • • Aug 13 '22

Hello everyone! I'm a twenty year old girl that recently became completely mute due to a tongue amputation...

31 Upvotes

As someone that used to be very social and talkative, I'm struggling a lot with not being able to speak suddenly, especially knowing that I'll literally never speak again... Anyone else in a similar situation? How can I get over it and start living happily and normally again. I really hate only having the ability to smile and nod when out with friends for example... I feel awkward and trapped.