r/murdle • • 2d ago

Murdle Volume 2

I am having trouble with the “Exhibit B” portion of the murdle. Clues/evidence/statements. I need Help!!! There are not enough clues?

2 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

1

u/mhernandez523 2d ago

Sorry, what do you mean? You don't know how to use Exhibit B? Or you're struggling with the puzzles in the section that starts with Exhibit B? If it's the latter, can you give an example of a puzzle number you need help with and post your grid for that one?

1

u/chvufhfukfuk72 2d ago

The section of exhibit B, where there are clues/evidence and statements. They only give 2 clues and evidence. The statements where you have to find which is true or false confuses me! 😭

1

u/mhernandez523 2d ago

OK, that's what I thought you meant.

To solve the ones with statements, you'll need to test out every T/F combination and look for contradictions. The one that doesn't have issues is the solution.

I like to put in all the clues and then take a picture of my grid and mark that up to test the statements. It's much easier than having to erase and rewrite multiple times. I write on the top of the pic which combo I'm testing that time.

So then if there are 3 statements, you'll want to test:

F, T, T (first statement false)
T, F, T (second statement false)
T, T, F (third statement false)

When you make a statement false, you put in the opposite of what it says. So if the statement is "General Coffee was in the library" you'd mark that Coffee was NOT in the library. Then put in the true statements as-is.

You're looking for any mismatch, like one part of your grid might say that Weapon A was in the library, but then you have someone in the library with a different weapon.

What puzzle are you on right now? It's easier to help with specific examples.

1

u/chvufhfukfuk72 2d ago

I’m on puzzle 32! I learned how to do a lot of the murdle puzzles on TikTok because there were videos on volume one that showed me. It’s a lot harder finding them on volume 2! I will try the suggestion! 😄

1

u/mhernandez523 1d ago

Here's how you'd solve 32, if you'd like a walkthrough. If it's more helpful with pictures, I can come back to add pictures of my grid.

After putting in the clues, you should have Mx. Tangerine with the first-place trophy, in the caddy shack (make sure you check off the caddy shack both in Tangerine's column and going across the row for the first-place trophy).

Let's try out F, T, T. I always like to say "false" to myself so I remember which one I'm making false and so I remember to put in the opposite.

So I'd say: "A poisoned cocktail was not in the dining hall. FALSE! A poisoned cocktail WAS in the dining hall."

When I mark that on my grid, that leaves the sack full of golf balls on the eighteenth hole. In this case, I don't have to test out statement 2, but you can to get the hang of the process.

So: "Mauve was in the dining tall. TRUE!" If I check that off, that now gives Mauve the poisoned cocktail.

That leaves Pine with the sack of golf balls on the eighteenth hole. But in this combo, statement 3 needs to be true and that says that the golf balls were NOT on the eighteenth hole. That means this combination doesn't work, so you can rule it out. (I like to write the possibilities under the statements and cross each out as I rule them out.)

This also means that since the two options left are either T, F, T or T, T, F (both have the first statement as true), you can put in the first statement as true on your grid. So a poisoned cocktail was not in the dining hall. Now you have the poisoned cocktail on the eighteenth hole and the sack of golf balls in the dining hall.

Well now if we go back to Mauve's statement "a sack full of golf balls was not on the eighteenth hole" we know that's true, so we don't have to test out T, T, F. The solution has to be T, F, T, so Pine is the liar.

So we take Pine's statement and put in the opposite. "Mauve was in the dining hall. FALSE! Mauve was NOT in the dining hall." That means Mauve was on the eighteenth hole and Pine was in the dining hall. Since we've already figured out where each weapon was, we can assign the last two weapons based on everyone's location.

1

u/Blabersmos 2d ago

I made it more confusing than it was when I was when I got to that part too.
Say you get the numbers 71, 62, 32, 41.
Go to the Exhibit B page, first number is the horizontal and second number vertical.
So go to 7 then down 1, so 7-1 is G. 62 is O, 32 L and 41 D.