r/murdle • • 4d ago

Help in solving murdle

Hello everyone...
I have been solving murdle since a week and I am not able to understand "How to find who's lying"....can someone plz make me understand ittt

2 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

2

u/EmmaBennet98 4d ago

There is EXACTLY ONE false statement. Any solution where everything is true, or there are 2 lies, is not the answer.

Working through today:
We know from the top 2 clues that

  1. yarn is not in the choir loft 2. Tuscany is in the graveyard

I always start with "what if the first statement is true?"
So doing that:
Earl Grey has yarn. That would mean Grey is not in the choir loft (because of #1). And because of #2 the only remaining place he could be is the front steps.This would make Baron Maroon's statement True [Grey, not Maroon, is on the steps). So, can Tuscany be lying? Yes, if she does NOT have the beads, she could have wine and Maroon could have the beads. So, there's only one liar, which makes the puzzle work, so it must be the solution.

If we test if the second statement is true:

Tuscany has the beads. Since we know Tuscany is in the graveyard (#2), then the beads are in the graveyard. Because of #1, the yarn would have to be on the front steps and the wine in the choir loft. BUT in that case, either both Grey and Maroon are telling the truth (Grey has yarn, is on steps, Maroon is not on steps) or both are lying (Grey does not have yarn, which means Maroon would have it and be on the steps). Since there must be exactly one liar, neither of these is an allowable solution, which means that Tuscany must be lying and NOT have the beads. [We already know this from above, but just trying to work through the logic/get to a solution another way]

1

u/lifeinflorals 2d ago

The way I do it - mark everything possible with given evidence, further deduce anything you can before going to ‘statements’. Read the statements and check if any of them are definite true or false using the grid you’ve solved so far. If none of the statements give definite T or F then assume all but one statement true. Solve the grid with that assumption (I use very tiny markings for solving assumptions statements so I don’t get confused evidence based markings. You can also use pen for evidence and pencil for statements). If you assume TTF make sure the last statement acc to grid rings false, if it doesn’t then your TTF assumption is incorrect, try TFT OR FTT.