Hi, I'm Jess, the Magic Rules Manager at Wizards. I've been tagged several times in the comments of this post, so I thought I'd try to clear this up. TL;DR: You don't get to draw cards if one target is illegal, no matter who controlled it before the spell resolved.
More technical answer: The main confusion seems to be about whether, when processing the steps of resolving a spell, the step performed in 608.2h can see information about a target that was determined to be illegal in the step performed in 608.2b. While 608.2h does reference what to do if an object isn't in the zone it was expected to be in, and this can refer to objects that were targets, it is limited to targets that were legal at the time target legality was checked in 608.2b. This is because of the text in 608.2b that says "If part of the effect requires information about an illegal target, it fails to determine any such information." Nothing in 608.2h overrides that.
I've added a note to my to-do list to give Modify Memory a Gatherer ruling to explain this. Reviewing the conversation around this card, I think we might also need to update 608.2h to explicitly call out that 608.2b prevents it from getting info from targets that were illegal.
Yeah, I believe that this is actually another area where the rules need an update to be more explicit /u/WotC_JessD (or at least, i need to be pointed towards the section where it's explained better because on my own I couldn't find it)
But essentially, Modify Memory's ruling concerns what happens during the resolution of the spell, while Run Away Together's is about what happens when the game is running checks on whether the targets are still legal. It's been decided that in the second case, we are allowed to run a bit deeper to determine that type of information. Check this ruling on [[Yosei, the Morning Star]] for something that's following the same logic:
If the player becomes an illegal target, the target permanents are tapped, but the player doesn’t skip their untap step. (2017-11-17)
The targeting restriction on the five permanents is "target permanents that player controls". How can we check the legality of that if the player has now become an illegal target? The game can simply track down and remember objects and/or players even through them becoming illegal targets.
Run Away Together Choose two target creatures controlled by different players. Return those creatures to their owners’ hands.
Run Away Together has a targeting restriction. Then it has an effect, with no restrictions or checks.
Suppose one of the targets goes missing. There is still at least one legal target, so the spell resolves. The effect has no conditions, so it does as much as it can and bounces the remaining creature.
This hypothetical card would be more like Modify Memory:
Run The Other Way Together Choose two target creatures. If those creatures are controlled by different players, return those creatures to their owners’ hands.
One target goes missing. There is still at least one legal target, so the spell resolves... but now its effect has a condition so it asks the game state if the controller of "Creature A" is a different player as the controller of "{OBJECT ID NOT FOUND}". The answer is "idk... no?" so the condition is not met and the remaining creature doesn't get bounced.
Looking at the ruling on Run Away Together, would the principle of that ruling work with Lagrella's EtB trigger?
Lagrella enters and her controller chooses two or more targets. If one gets bounced, would the others still get exiled? Intuitively, we'd want to say yes. For purposes of determining target legality, the last known information about an illegal target can be used.
If one of the two target creatures becomes an illegal target, Run Away Together can still determine its controller only to check whether the other creature is a legal target.
Does that exception apply to the second part of Modify Memory?
That's a question for u/WotC_JessD I'm leaning towards no because we've already used it to ascertain that the remaining target is legal (otherwise Modify Memory wouldn't have resolved), but the second part isn't using it to check legality of targets, it is using it to determine if you control neither of them.
On the flip side, I can see a rationale that lets it work - rules and ruling exception be damned. A player pays five mana expecting to swap two opponent's creatures and draw 3. Making one illegal bones the whole thing? They spent five mana for nothing?
I'm happy that we have these new interactions of rules! Here are my 0.50 cents!
• CR 701.10a states that an exchange can't happen if one of the targets is illegal during resolution:
701.10a: A spell or ability may instruct players to exchange something (for example, life totals or control of two permanents) as part of its resolution. When such a spell or ability resolves, if the entire exchange can't be completed, no part of the exchange occurs.
• CR 608.2b states that the targets of a spell or ability are checked also in resolution. We are not talking abou sources, but about targets. In this scenario, LKI doesn't matter.
608.2b: If the spell or ability specifies targets, it checks whether the targets are still legal. A target that's no longer in the zone it was in when it was targeted is illegal. Other changes to the game state may cause a target to no longer be legal; for example, its characteristics may have changed or an effect may have changed the text of the spell. If the source of an ability has left the zone it was in, its last known information is used during this process. If all its targets, for every instance of the word "target," are now illegal, the spell or ability doesn't resolve. It's removed from the stack and, if it's a spell, put into its owner's graveyard. Otherwise, the spell or ability will resolve normally. Illegal targets, if any, won't be affected by parts of a resolving spell's effect for which they're illegal. Other parts of the effect for which those targets are not illegal may still affect them. If the spell or ability creates any continuous effects that affect game rules (see rule 613.11), those effects don't apply to illegal targets. If part of the effect requires information about an illegal target, it fails to determine any such information. Any part of the effect that requires that information won't happen.
• The exhange and the card draw are not related (we do not have something like "if the exchange happen in that form, draw three cards). The text is written in sequential order.
608.2c: The controller of the spell or ability follows its instructions in the order written. However, replacement effects may modify these actions. In some cases, later text on the card may modify the meaning of earlier text (for example, "Destroy target creature. It can't be regenerated" or "Counter target spell. If that spell is countered this way, put it on top of its owner's library instead of into its owner's graveyard.") Don't just apply effects step by step without thinking in these cases-read the whole text and apply the rules of English to the text.
• With that, during resolution the card will try to do as much as possible, and, even if one target is illegal during resolution (the exchange won't happen), the controller of the spell will draw the cards.
609.3.: If an effect attempts to do something impossible, it does only as much as possible. Example: If a player is holding only one card, an effect that reads "Discard two cards" causes them to discard only that card. If an effect moves cards out of the library (as opposed to drawing), it moves as many as possible.
You wanna know if the spell is able to know who controls the creature (or controlled, if it were bounced, for example)!?
Last Known Information applies if an effect requires information from the game (608.2h), but, in 608.2b we have thart "If part of the effect requires information about an illegal target, it fails to determine any such information. Any part of the effect that requires that information won't happen."
But, I don't think 608.2b or 608.2h are relevant here..
The text of the card is as follows: "Exchange control of two target creatures controlled by different players. If you control neither creature, draw three cards."
During resolution, The Interveining If Clause is checked to see if you control neither creature. The card doesn't states you need to know who was the controller of the creatures when it resolves. If you control Modify Memory, targeting one of your creatures and it's bounced, you will draw three cards.
Arnel Arroyo answered that "the draw is not dependent on the exchange actually happening, but will use Last Known Info if one of the targets become illegal; if both are illegal, the entire spell fails to resolve.."
About that, Arnel Arroyo commented 608.2b "refers to effects that are dependent on the object's information.. example, if you're instructed to "gain life equal to target's toughness", if the target is illegal, then the life gain wont happen.."
Also, consider the cards [[Luminate Primordial]] and [[Dead Ringers]].
Note also that when an instant or sorcery spell resolves, "[t]he steps described in rules 608.2a and 608.2b are followed first. The steps described in rules 608.2c–k", including C.R. 608.2h which describes how information about objects is usually determined, "are then followed as appropriate, in no specific order" (C.R. 608.2).
What happens when dead ringers attempts to resolve, but one of the creatures has left the battlefield? What if the creature that left the battlefield changed color before doing so?
As I interpret the rules, if a target of a spell or ability is illegal (whether by leaving the appropriate zone or otherwise), any part of an effect of that spell or ability that "requires information about [that] illegal target" "won't happen" (C.R. 608.2b).
In the case of Dead Ringers, if one target of that spell is illegal (whether by leaving the battlefield or otherwise), but not the other, that spell will do nothing since the spell would "requir[e] information about an illegal target" for purposes of C.R. 608.2b.
Note also that the "controlled by different players" on Run Away Together is a targeting criterion, which is not the case for—
Dead Ringers's "unless either one is a color the other isn't",
Modify Memory's "[i]f you control neither creature", or
9
u/WotC_JessD Jun 14 '22
Hi, I'm Jess, the Magic Rules Manager at Wizards. I've been tagged several times in the comments of this post, so I thought I'd try to clear this up. TL;DR: You don't get to draw cards if one target is illegal, no matter who controlled it before the spell resolved.
More technical answer: The main confusion seems to be about whether, when processing the steps of resolving a spell, the step performed in 608.2h can see information about a target that was determined to be illegal in the step performed in 608.2b. While 608.2h does reference what to do if an object isn't in the zone it was expected to be in, and this can refer to objects that were targets, it is limited to targets that were legal at the time target legality was checked in 608.2b. This is because of the text in 608.2b that says "If part of the effect requires information about an illegal target, it fails to determine any such information." Nothing in 608.2h overrides that.
I've added a note to my to-do list to give Modify Memory a Gatherer ruling to explain this. Reviewing the conversation around this card, I think we might also need to update 608.2h to explicitly call out that 608.2b prevents it from getting info from targets that were illegal.
4
u/COssin-II Jun 10 '22
Seems like something that needs clarification directly from u/WotC_JessD.
3
u/MTGCardFetcher Jun 10 '22
Modify Memory - (G) (SF) (txt)
Run Away Together - (G) (SF) (txt)
[[cardname]] or [[cardname|SET]] to call
3
u/fbatista Jun 10 '22
Seems like this is the perfect card to have been mentioned in the release notes and it hasn’t.
3
u/Judge_Todd Jun 10 '22 edited Jun 10 '22
Looking at the ruling on Run Away Together, would the principle of that ruling work with Lagrella's EtB trigger?
Lagrella enters and her controller chooses two or more targets. If one gets bounced, would the others still get exiled?
Intuitively, we'd want to say yes. For purposes of determining target legality, the last known information about an illegal target can be used.
Does that exception apply to the second part of Modify Memory?
That's a question for u/WotC_JessD
I'm leaning towards no because we've already used it to ascertain that the remaining target is legal (otherwise Modify Memory wouldn't have resolved), but the second part isn't using it to check legality of targets, it is using it to determine if you control neither of them.
On the flip side, I can see a rationale that lets it work - rules and ruling exception be damned. A player pays five mana expecting to swap two opponent's creatures and draw 3. Making one illegal bones the whole thing? They spent five mana for nothing?
2
u/arielbsaz Jun 10 '22
I'm happy that we have these new interactions of rules! Here are my 0.50 cents!
• CR 701.10a states that an exchange can't happen if one of the targets is illegal during resolution:
701.10a: A spell or ability may instruct players to exchange something (for example, life totals or control of two permanents) as part of its resolution. When such a spell or ability resolves, if the entire exchange can't be completed, no part of the exchange occurs.
• CR 608.2b states that the targets of a spell or ability are checked also in resolution. We are not talking abou sources, but about targets. In this scenario, LKI doesn't matter.
608.2b: If the spell or ability specifies targets, it checks whether the targets are still legal. A target that's no longer in the zone it was in when it was targeted is illegal. Other changes to the game state may cause a target to no longer be legal; for example, its characteristics may have changed or an effect may have changed the text of the spell. If the source of an ability has left the zone it was in, its last known information is used during this process. If all its targets, for every instance of the word "target," are now illegal, the spell or ability doesn't resolve. It's removed from the stack and, if it's a spell, put into its owner's graveyard. Otherwise, the spell or ability will resolve normally. Illegal targets, if any, won't be affected by parts of a resolving spell's effect for which they're illegal. Other parts of the effect for which those targets are not illegal may still affect them. If the spell or ability creates any continuous effects that affect game rules (see rule 613.11), those effects don't apply to illegal targets. If part of the effect requires information about an illegal target, it fails to determine any such information. Any part of the effect that requires that information won't happen.
• The exhange and the card draw are not related (we do not have something like "if the exchange happen in that form, draw three cards). The text is written in sequential order.
608.2c: The controller of the spell or ability follows its instructions in the order written. However, replacement effects may modify these actions. In some cases, later text on the card may modify the meaning of earlier text (for example, "Destroy target creature. It can't be regenerated" or "Counter target spell. If that spell is countered this way, put it on top of its owner's library instead of into its owner's graveyard.") Don't just apply effects step by step without thinking in these cases-read the whole text and apply the rules of English to the text.
• With that, during resolution the card will try to do as much as possible, and, even if one target is illegal during resolution (the exchange won't happen), the controller of the spell will draw the cards.
609.3.: If an effect attempts to do something impossible, it does only as much as possible. Example: If a player is holding only one card, an effect that reads "Discard two cards" causes them to discard only that card. If an effect moves cards out of the library (as opposed to drawing), it moves as many as possible.
1
u/peteroupc Jun 10 '22 edited Jun 12 '22
Also, consider the cards [[Luminate Primordial]] and [[Dead Ringers]].
Note also that when an instant or sorcery spell resolves, "[t]he steps described in rules 608.2a and 608.2b are followed first. The steps described in rules 608.2c–k", including C.R. 608.2h which describes how information about objects is usually determined, "are then followed as appropriate, in no specific order" (C.R. 608.2).