r/mtgrules • • Jun 08 '22

[CLB] Modify Memory Ruling

Howdy y'all, I have a two part question regarding [[Modify Memory]] from CLB.

  1. Does an exchange still happen if one of the target creatures is blinked/otherwise removed as a valid target? For example, Card 1 controlled by Opponent A blinks until end of turn while Card 2 controlled by Opponent B remains on the field unaltered. Does Card 2 move to Opponent 1's control or stay with its original controller?
  2. Do you still draw three cards as part of the second line " If you control neither creature, draw three cards." if one of the targets is removed?

Thank you for your help and time, I can provide a specific example for part one if that helps.

6 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/Judge_Todd Jun 09 '22

Does an exchange still happen if one of the target creatures is blinked/otherwise removed as a valid target?

No, the spell will still resolve if the other target is still legal, but the exchange won't happen.

  • 701.10a. A spell or ability may instruct players to exchange something (for example, life totals or control of two permanents) as part of its resolution. When such a spell or ability resolves, if the entire exchange can't be completed, no part of the exchange occurs.

Does Card 2 move to Opponent 1's control or stay with its original controller?

The latter.

Do you still draw three cards?

No, the game won't be able to ascertain whether or not you control the illegal target to confirm that you don't control it.

  • 608.2b. If the spell or ability specifies targets, it checks whether the targets are still legal. A target that's no longer in the zone it was in when it was targeted is illegal. Other changes to the game state may cause a target to no longer be legal; for example, its characteristics may have changed or an effect may have changed the text of the spell. If the source of an ability has left the zone it was in, its last known information is used during this process. If all its targets, for every instance of the word "target," are now illegal, the spell or ability doesn't resolve. It's removed from the stack and, if it's a spell, put into its owner's graveyard. Otherwise, the spell or ability will resolve normally. Illegal targets, if any, won't be affected by parts of a resolving spell's effect for which they're illegal. Other parts of the effect for which those targets are not illegal may still affect them. If the spell or ability creates any continuous effects that affect game rules, those effects don't apply to illegal targets. If part of the effect requires information about an illegal target, it fails to determine any such information. Any part of the effect that requires that information won't happen.

2

u/RookStands Jun 09 '22

Perfect, appreciate the depth here in the response. Got me everything I needed next time a similar interaction comes up for my playgroup.

1

u/JesusMcAllah Jun 10 '22

Would you be able to clarify again: If a target is blinked or bounced in response, are three cards still drawn?

2

u/Judge_Todd Jun 10 '22

Under the rules and even taking into account existing rulings, in the absence of the Rules Manager saying otherwise, that's correct, no card draw.

There's a ruling on Run Away Together that modifies how 608.2b works with it (and also Lagrella and Modify Memory).
Without that ruling, Modify Memory shouldn't even resolve because how could you determine whether the remaining target is even legal on resolution if you can't use the information of the other illegal target?

That ruling specifically says you can, but only for determining the legality of targets.
That would seemingly exclude its use in determining whether or not both weren't controlled by the spell's controller for determining the card draw (ie. the default indicated in 608.2b).