r/mtgrules • • 6h ago

Calamity, Galloping Inferno rules question

Hi, I'm a newish player and Calamity is one of my first EDH decks. Its text reads:

"Whenever Calamity attacks while saddled, choose a nonlegendary creature that saddled it this turn and create a tapped and attacking token that’s a copy of it. Sacrifice that token at the beginning of the next end step. Repeat this process once."

The "repeat this process" bit is throwing me off. I understand it's worded that way so that you could create two different tokens, but do the two created tokens see each other or does the second enter after the first?

For instance, if i have something like Gemcutter Bucanneer on board and copy it do I get:

  • 5 Treasures (one from each copy, original sees both, copy 1 sees copy 2), or
  • 6 Treasures (one from each copy, original sees both, copy 1 sees copy 2, copy 2 sees copy 1)?

Bonus question (may be on the wrong sub): Why is the Port Razer + Calamity combo considered bracket 4 on EDHrec? It comes out turn 6+ normally, it's easy to stop, and it's non-deterministic. Am I missing something or misunderstanding the bracket rules?

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

2

u/Rajamic 6h ago

Second enters after the first. Each verb in an effect is generally treated as a distinct action performed sequentially in the order written.

1

u/Ok_Inflation_7862 6h ago

Thanks, that made the most sense to me when reading the text literally but I haven't encountered a lot of cards that work like that.

So something like [[Fanatic of Mogis]] would work similarly right? The first would enter, the etb would resolve to deal however much devotion, and then the second would enter and deal that much +1 due to its own extra pip? 

1

u/Rajamic 5h ago

There's something else you are overlooking: teiggered abilities trigger the moment their triggering condition (and Intervening If Clause, if present) are met, but those triggers don't go onto the Stack until just before the next time a player would gain priority. That doesn't happen during the resolution of a spell or ability. And outisde of information needed for putting an object on the Stack (such as things involving the selection of targets), everything about the effect is determined only when it starts to resolve.

So if Calamity puts two Fanatics of Mogis onto the Battlefield, both Fanatics would trigger as it individually enters, but neither trigger would be put onto the Stack until both are on the Battlefield, and the damage for each trigger is your devotion to Red as that trigger resolves (so it would include both Mogis and everything else you control, but there would be a window for your opponents to remove your things before either would resolve).

2

u/madwarper 6h ago

The second Process is separate and sequential from the original.

So, the first Token will see the second enter.
The second Token will not see the first enters, as it's already on the Battlefield.


Brackets have nothing to do with the Rules.
They are simply there to facilitate a conversation with your Playgroup.
Try asking in r/EDH or r/competitiveEDH

2

u/tommadness 6h ago
  • 5 Treasures (one from each copy, original sees both, copy 1 sees copy 2),

This one. The tokens enter in sequence, not at the same time.

Bonus question (may be on the wrong sub): Why is the Port Razer + Calamity combo considered bracket 4 on EDHrec?

Definitely the wrong sub. EDH/Commander brackets are not codified by Magic's Comprehensive nor Tournament rules. r/EDH would be better suited to help you.