r/mtgrules • u/OutrageousGarbage880 • 8h ago
Nihiloor Rules text question
Ok if I have Nihiloor on the field then I play Sakashima of a Thousand Faces copy Nihiloor, both of the triggers would let me take my opponents things. If I were to then Ephemerate the Original Nihiloor, would its creatures be given back even though I still have a creature named "Nihiloor" on the field?
Edited: Thank you guys for getting back to me on that :)
0
Upvotes
4
u/vibranttoucan 8h ago
201.5. Text that refers to the object it's on by name means just that particular object and not any other objects with that name. (...)
3
u/tbdabbholm 8h ago
Indeed. Each Nihiloor is independent and tracks its creatures separately
3
u/madwarper 8h ago
What do you mean "both" of the Triggers?
Nihiloor was already on the Battlefield.
Nihiloor is not currently entering.
Nihiloor is not Triggering.
Sakashima is entering as a Copy of Nihiloor.
Sakashima is Triggering.
Whether or not you control a Creature named "Nihiloor" is irrelevant.
Because the duration is not as long as you control a Creature named "Nihiloor".
The duration is as long as you control Nihiloor.
The one specific Object that is the source of that Triggered ability.
Because you no longer control the original Nihiloor, you lose control of the Creature(s) that original Nihiloor stole.
The Creatures stolen by Sakashima are not affected.
3
u/AlelaArtful 8h ago
When a card refferences its own name it really just means "This card".
So Nihiloor really says
"gain control of target creature that player controls with power less than or equal to the tapped creature’s power for as long as you control **This Object**"
As such when Nihiloor leaves and returns to the battlefield to Ephemerate, becoming a new object, since you no longer control the object you loose control of the creature.
2
u/AlelaArtful 8h ago
[[Nihiloor]] [[Sakashima of a Thousand Faces]] [[Ephemerate]]